Subway stations popup as housenumber-tasks

[RubenKelevra]

I'm currently not entirely sure how to fix this, but it feels wrong that SC create a task to add a house number to a subway station.

Do subway-stations have house numbers?

Example:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/378955812

[ENT8R]

IMO this is related or even a duplicate of #351...

[RubenKelevra]

Well, this ticket mentions a tag called noaddress=yes, which SC sets if the user selects, that this building has no house number. But this option was obviously removed from SC.

So, maybe it's worth discussing how often buildings with layer=-2 and level=-2 do have house numbers and if it's safe to assume that they do not need to popup as a task?

Currently, we show this task all users and each of them can hide this task once per subway station... this doesn't sound like the right solution here.

EDIT: oh well, I'm tired. Yeah you're right, this might be just another shade of the same grey color and to be fair. But since there are many subway-stations it's still worth a discussion if there's a need for a special filter to block them from this quest. :)

EDIT2: fixed layer & layer error

[ENT8R]

But this option was obviously removed from SC.

No. It was never added. But will be added if this issue is resolved...

[westnordost]

Hmm, it is tagged as "train station". I wouldn't tag a building there at all, just the platform, but one could argue that it is correct correct to tag a building and maybe even correct to tag it as a "train station".

So, perhaps I can exclude buildings with negative layers from the quest? Though, a negative layer does not mean that something is underground.

[goldfndr]

Reuben typed layer=-2 and layer=-2 but one of those should be level=-2 and negative level(s) could be a better exclusion than negative layer.

[matkoniecz]

So, perhaps I can exclude buildings with negative layers from the quest? Though, a negative layer does not mean that something is underground.

Yes, object in question is missing location=underground (it it really is underground). negative layer and level tag may appear on objects that are not underground (though while OK it happens really rarely).

[matkoniecz]

I added location=underground per streetcomplete/streetcomplete-mapstyle#54 (comment)

[RubenKelevra]

So maybe we should make a quest from that? "Is this building underground"? If underground-tag is not attached but level-tag is below 0? :)

[ENT8R]

And setting location=overground if the building is over ground?

[matkoniecz]

@RubenKelevra @ENT8R location=surface is not used and was not documented, so it would be impossible to tag anything for "normal" buildings - I added it on Wiki for now.

[RubenKelevra]

@matkoniecz ah okay, I see the problem here.