Fix vote #1792

Tommo-L · 2020-07-23T07:30:12Z

Close #1790

cloud8little · 2020-07-23T08:08:14Z

Test passed:

send wallet a.json with 100 neo/100 gas.
vote for himself.
send neo to another account successfully.
register for himself to be a candidate.
vote successful and get candidates.

src/neo/SmartContract/Native/Tokens/NeoToken.cs

superboyiii · 2020-07-24T06:09:59Z

@shargon Ready for merge?

erikzhang

If state_account.VoteTo keeps the original value, then other changes should also be rolled back, otherwise transaction consistency cannot be guaranteed. Maybe Vote() shouldn't return bool, but should throw an exception when something goes wrong.

cloud8little · 2020-07-24T08:37:01Z

Retesting.

cloud8little · 2020-07-24T09:41:07Z

Test passed:

Register a candidate not exist in the wallet.

NEO-CLI v3.0.0-preview2  -  NEO v3.0.0-preview2  -  NEO-VM v3.0.0-preview2

neo> open wallet wallet_1.json
password: ********
neo> list asset
Nc56Zrq72VN9Xr6wo3HyFn3oFZUvoYQJtj
NEO: 0
GAS: 0

Ncu47NyTJLJPEFi859gmuqQ8fPPt1AVwHX
NEO: 100000000
GAS: 30000000

----------------------------------------------------
Total:   NEO: 100000000    GAS: 30000000

NEO hash: 0xde5f57d430d3dece511cf975a8d37848cb9e0525
GAS hash: 0x668e0c1f9d7b70a99dd9e06eadd4c784d641afbc
neo> register candidate Ncu47NyTJLJPEFi859gmuqQ8fPPt1AVwHX
Error: Missing the signature of 026a59b03f981a5dfded185472f4f19409cd229b5cfd11721e70f2b1d16079376a

Register candidate

neo> list key
  Address: Nc56Zrq72VN9Xr6wo3HyFn3oFZUvoYQJtj
PublicKey: 026a59b03f981a5dfded185472f4f19409cd229b5cfd11721e70f2b1d16079376a

  Address: Nc56Zrq72VN9Xr6wo3HyFn3oFZUvoYQJtj
PublicKey: 026a59b03f981a5dfded185472f4f19409cd229b5cfd11721e70f2b1d16079376a

neo> send neo NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB 100
password: ********
TXID: 0x2c045472e8de39fe3d36101f2f98b0d2c94d6c47a4546d03bd2372243b2b6a3a
neo> send gas NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB 100
password: ********
TXID: 0xdca11fa586665dd4dd2bdb403414a59bee8bb5b1a8ea89f7b68212d3fd6f50e0
neo> open wallet a.json
password: *
neo> list asset
NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
NEO: 100
GAS: 100

----------------------------------------------------
Total:   NEO: 100    GAS: 100

NEO hash: 0xde5f57d430d3dece511cf975a8d37848cb9e0525
GAS hash: 0x668e0c1f9d7b70a99dd9e06eadd4c784d641afbc
neo> list key
  Address: NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
PublicKey: 02ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a03

neo> register candidate NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
Invoking script with: '0c2102ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a0311c00c11726567697374657243616e6469646174650c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 0.0600775
Evaluation Stack: [{"type":"Any"}]

relay tx(no|yes): no
neo> register candidate NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
Invoking script with: '0c2102ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a0311c00c11726567697374657243616e6469646174650c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 0.0600775
Evaluation Stack: [{"type":"Any"}]

relay tx(no|yes): yes
Signed and relayed transaction with hash=0x02d47d1558cd78280ddd7120558b69dd02900122a61443944d27926e5a46a470
neo> get candidates
Invoking script with: '10c00c0d67657443616e646964617465730c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 1.0100757

Candidates:
02ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a03      0
neo> list key
  Address: NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
PublicKey: 02ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a03

Unregister candidate and get candidates

neo> unregister candidate Nc56Zrq72VN9Xr6wo3HyFn3oFZUvoYQJtj
error: The address 0x7646c5c571b77ab316815d05d1c2ede2e9ea3bb1 was not found in the wallet
neo> unregister candidate NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
Invoking script with: '0c2102ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a0311c00c13756e726567697374657243616e6469646174650c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 0.0600775
Evaluation Stack: [{"type":"Any"}]

relay tx(no|yes): yes
Signed and relayed transaction with hash=0x0ae9442300662e26530ae0f6051d4181747f12f68dbd7345e972f11e22028875
neo> get candidate
error: Command not found
neo> get candidates
Invoking script with: '10c00c0d67657443616e646964617465730c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 1.0100757

Unregister a non-candidate

neo> unregister candidate NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
Error: The candidate does not exist

Vote a non-candidate and send neo to other account.

neo> vote NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB 02ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a03
Error: The candidate does not exist
neo> send neo Nc56Zrq72VN9Xr6wo3HyFn3oFZUvoYQJtj 1
password: *
TXID: 0x0606e732e534474d1a3949dde42304612b1cf8081cfe923957b783b41c2cdc94
neo> list asset
NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
NEO: 99
GAS: 99.7525614

----------------------------------------------------
Total:   NEO: 99    GAS: 99.7525614

NEO hash: 0xde5f57d430d3dece511cf975a8d37848cb9e0525
GAS hash: 0x668e0c1f9d7b70a99dd9e06eadd4c784d641afbc

Then register candidate and vote to the candidate; get candidates and check the votes.

neo> register candidate NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB
Invoking script with: '0c2102ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a0311c00c11726567697374657243616e6469646174650c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 0.0600775
Evaluation Stack: [{"type":"Any"}]

relay tx(no|yes): yes
Signed and relayed transaction with hash=0x9deab808316d09794e1f33f0c25d142787b0f850aebb52403b52005fabe55fd5

neo> vote NUzy2y33pa7DvUgnihxdqSPUTZi3Hb3DnB 02ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a03
Invoking script with: '0c2102ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a030c1463ab15dab11bfa8ebc0b3ca0e2bec6300b45e35d12c00c04766f74650c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 5.0100793
Evaluation Stack: [{"type":"Any"}]

relay tx(no|yes): yes
Signed and relayed transaction with hash=0x5e737b6b0d9864823abaccd57812b6106a7ad3cb6773fb4e001d7b7d1659d081
neo> get candidates
Invoking script with: '10c00c0d67657443616e646964617465730c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 1.0100757

Candidates:
02ae840030e1e58d3c8b08568e13075372fb17c111fb5690fc3c26a7342abc2a03      99

superboyiii · 2020-07-27T03:51:06Z

@erikzhang Could you review it again?

cloud8little · 2020-07-27T08:03:11Z

src/neo/SmartContract/Native/Tokens/NeoToken.cs

+                validator_new = engine.Snapshot.Storages.GetAndChange(CreateStorageKey(Prefix_Candidate).Add(voteTo))?.GetInteroperable<CandidateState>();
+                if (validator_new is null) return false;
+                if (!validator_new.Registered) return false;
+            }


why not throw an exception?

Returning false can give the contract a chance to recover from the exception. Throwing an exception will directly terminate the virtual machine. we should try not to throw exceptions if the consistency can be guaranteed.

cloud8little · 2020-07-27T09:03:46Z

Retest passed.

vote when pubkey register

neo> vote Nb4z5KTAqgavWKZ7RemRS73RGkY8Qc68mm 0358c84fee21b68e568b1a43d1cf6bddf74cce08ad5f3b301f3ad6d3ad75a9a6dc
Invoking script with: '0c210358c84fee21b68e568b1a43d1cf6bddf74cce08ad5f3b301f3ad6d3ad75a9a6dc0c14a63e5f5deb760927fed26f64e40cabff2309329312c00c04766f74650c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 5.0100793
Evaluation Stack: [{"type":"Boolean","value":true}]

relay tx(no|yes): yes
Signed and relayed transaction with hash=0x590578ebe8242810f28552a02d339ec9b5e54b3a553ed602df80fe49b9ea2be4

vote before register, then send neo successfully to other accounts.

neo> vote Nb4z5KTAqgavWKZ7RemRS73RGkY8Qc68mm 027a4c687d168044dfb37ad32a51830f0c86b068084914f2373702393b1923ae5e
Invoking script with: '0c21027a4c687d168044dfb37ad32a51830f0c86b068084914f2373702393b1923ae5e0c14a63e5f5deb760927fed26f64e40cabff2309329312c00c04766f74650c1425059ecb4878d3a875f91c51ceded330d4575fde41627d5b52'
VM State: HALT
Gas Consumed: 5.0100793
Evaluation Stack: [{"type":"Boolean","value":false}]

relay tx(no|yes): yes
Signed and relayed transaction with hash=0xdc4c34f6f537c5b11389425584269288f97eb04f2d69f52372833944b60ca85d

superboyiii · 2020-07-27T09:48:46Z

Looks good now.

superboyiii · 2020-07-27T10:28:24Z

@erikzhang Shall we merge?

superboyiii · 2020-07-28T06:26:22Z

@shargon Need your merge.

* Classes related to Neo.SmartContract types should not be internal (#1785) * Classes related to Neo.SmartContract types should not be internal Fixes #1782 * public callbacks + protected internal service methods * Add AsReadOnly() Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Shargon <[email protected]> * Add AppEngine.ValidateCallFlags to be callable by subclasses (#1784) * Update ApplicationEngine.cs separate call flag validation into separate function so it can be called by ApplicationEngine subclasses. This is needed for the debugger, which overrides a few of the standard service implementations * fix whitespace * protected internal addGas Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> * Fix vote (#1792) * fix vote * add ut * throw exception * fix * fix ut Co-authored-by: Tommo-L <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: erikzhang <[email protected]> * preview3 * Update dependency Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Shargon <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Luchuan <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Tommo-L <[email protected]>

* Classes related to Neo.SmartContract types should not be internal (neo-project#1785) * Classes related to Neo.SmartContract types should not be internal Fixes neo-project#1782 * public callbacks + protected internal service methods * Add AsReadOnly() Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Shargon <[email protected]> * Add AppEngine.ValidateCallFlags to be callable by subclasses (neo-project#1784) * Update ApplicationEngine.cs separate call flag validation into separate function so it can be called by ApplicationEngine subclasses. This is needed for the debugger, which overrides a few of the standard service implementations * fix whitespace * protected internal addGas Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> * Fix vote (neo-project#1792) * fix vote * add ut * throw exception * fix * fix ut Co-authored-by: Tommo-L <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: erikzhang <[email protected]> * preview3 * Update dependency Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Harry Pierson <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Shargon <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Luchuan <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Tommo-L <[email protected]>

fix vote

14d93aa

shargon reviewed Jul 23, 2020

View reviewed changes

src/neo/SmartContract/Native/Tokens/NeoToken.cs Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved

add ut

7a51143

shargon approved these changes Jul 23, 2020

View reviewed changes

vncoelho approved these changes Jul 23, 2020

View reviewed changes

superboyiii mentioned this pull request Jul 24, 2020

Neo3-Preview3 release checklist #1731

Closed

16 tasks

erikzhang requested changes Jul 24, 2020

View reviewed changes

throw exception

6c80d0c

shargon approved these changes Jul 24, 2020

View reviewed changes

fix

ce37957

cloud8little reviewed Jul 27, 2020

View reviewed changes

fix ut

a84b071

erikzhang approved these changes Jul 28, 2020

View reviewed changes

shargon merged commit 90105ef into neo-project:preview3 Jul 28, 2020

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Fix vote #1792

Fix vote #1792

Tommo-L commented Jul 23, 2020 •

edited

Loading

cloud8little commented Jul 23, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 24, 2020

erikzhang left a comment

cloud8little commented Jul 24, 2020

cloud8little commented Jul 24, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 27, 2020

cloud8little Jul 27, 2020

erikzhang Jul 27, 2020

cloud8little commented Jul 27, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 27, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 27, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 28, 2020

Fix vote #1792

Fix vote #1792

Conversation

Tommo-L commented Jul 23, 2020 • edited Loading

cloud8little commented Jul 23, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 24, 2020

erikzhang left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

cloud8little commented Jul 24, 2020

cloud8little commented Jul 24, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 27, 2020

cloud8little Jul 27, 2020

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

erikzhang Jul 27, 2020

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

cloud8little commented Jul 27, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 27, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 27, 2020

superboyiii commented Jul 28, 2020

Tommo-L commented Jul 23, 2020 •

edited

Loading