Remove row-reverse errata #42251
Closed
Remove row-reverse errata #42251
Conversation
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
facebook-github-bot
added
the
CLA Signed
|
This pull request was exported from Phabricator. Differential Revision: D52698130 |
NickGerleman
added a commit
to NickGerleman/yoga
that referenced
this pull request
Jan 11, 2024
Summary: X-link: facebook/react-native#42251 Yoga has an odd behavior, where `start`/`end` edges under row-reverse are relative to flex-direction, instead of writing direction. While Yoga doesn't actually document what this behavior is supposed to be, it goes against CK documentation, historic RN documentation, and the behavior valid on the web. It is also applied inconsistently (e.g. sometimes only on container, sometimes on child). It really is a bug, instead of an intended behavior. We changed the default behavior for Yoga, but left the existing one behind an errata (so existing fbsource users got old behavior). We have previously seen this behavior show up in product code, including CK when running on FlexLayout. `row-reverse` is surprisingly uncommon though: 1. Litho has <40 usages 2. RN has ~40 usages in `RKJSModules`,~30 in `arvr/js`, ~6 in `xplat/archon` 3. CK has ~80 usages 4. NT has ~40 usages These components are pretty static, and few enough that we can do this style of refactor, where we just fix everything we find. But there is some risk of missing complonents. CK accounts for 17/20 usages that I could tell would trigger the issue, since it only exposes start/end edge, and not left/right. It might make sense to make it preserve behavior instead, to reduce risk a bit. FlexLayout is now separately powering Bloks, which wasn't surveryed, do I didn't touch CK behavior under Bloks. There could also be other usages in other frameworks/bespoke usages, and this has implications for OSS users. But based on our own usage, of many, many components, this seems rare. Changelog: [General][Breaking] - Make `start/end` in styles always refer to writing direction Differential Revision: D52698130
NickGerleman
added a commit
to NickGerleman/react-native
that referenced
this pull request
Jan 11, 2024
Summary: Yoga has an odd behavior, where `start`/`end` edges under row-reverse are relative to flex-direction, instead of writing direction. While Yoga doesn't actually document what this behavior is supposed to be, it goes against CK documentation, historic RN documentation, and the behavior valid on the web. It is also applied inconsistently (e.g. sometimes only on container, sometimes on child). It really is a bug, instead of an intended behavior. We changed the default behavior for Yoga, but left the existing one behind an errata (so existing fbsource users got old behavior). We have previously seen this behavior show up in product code, including CK when running on FlexLayout. `row-reverse` is surprisingly uncommon though: 1. Litho has <40 usages 2. RN has ~40 usages in `RKJSModules`,~30 in `arvr/js`, ~6 in `xplat/archon` 3. CK has ~80 usages 4. NT has ~40 usages These components are pretty static, and few enough that we can do this style of refactor, where we just fix everything we find. But there is some risk of missing complonents. CK accounts for 17/20 usages that I could tell would trigger the issue, since it only exposes start/end edge, and not left/right. It might make sense to make it preserve behavior instead, to reduce risk a bit. FlexLayout is now separately powering Bloks, which wasn't surveryed, do I didn't touch CK behavior under Bloks. There could also be other usages in other frameworks/bespoke usages, and this has implications for OSS users. But based on our own usage, of many, many components, this seems rare. Changelog: [General][Breaking] - Make `start/end` in styles always refer to writing direction Differential Revision: D52698130
NickGerleman
force-pushed
the
export-D52698130
branch
from
66e236d to
97a52e8
Compare
|
This pull request was exported from Phabricator. Differential Revision: D52698130 |
Base commit: 3630138 |
Summary: X-link: facebook/yoga#1547 Yoga has an odd behavior, where `start`/`end` edges under row-reverse are relative to flex-direction, instead of writing direction. While Yoga doesn't actually document what this behavior is supposed to be, it goes against CK documentation, historic RN documentation, and the behavior valid on the web. It is also applied inconsistently (e.g. sometimes only on container, sometimes on child). It really is a bug, instead of an intended behavior. We changed the default behavior for Yoga, but left the existing one behind an errata (so existing fbsource users got old behavior). We have previously seen this behavior show up in product code, including CK when running on FlexLayout. `row-reverse` is surprisingly uncommon though: 1. Litho has <40 usages 2. RN has ~40 usages in `RKJSModules`,~30 in `arvr/js`, ~6 in `xplat/archon` 3. CK has ~80 usages 4. NT has ~40 usages These components are pretty static, and few enough that we can do this style of refactor, where we just fix everything we find. But there is some risk of missing complonents. CK accounts for 10/13 usages that I could tell would trigger the issue, since it only exposes start/end edge, and not left/right. It might make sense to make it preserve behavior instead, to reduce risk a bit. FlexLayout is now separately powering Bloks, which wasn't surveryed, do I didn't touch CK behavior under Bloks. There could also be other usages in other frameworks/bespoke usages, and this has implications for OSS users. But based on our own usage, of many, many components, this seems rare. Changelog: [General][Breaking] - Make `start/end` in styles always refer to writing direction Reviewed By: joevilches Differential Revision: D52698130
NickGerleman
added a commit
to NickGerleman/yoga
that referenced
this pull request
Jan 11, 2024
Summary: X-link: facebook/react-native#42251 Yoga has an odd behavior, where `start`/`end` edges under row-reverse are relative to flex-direction, instead of writing direction. While Yoga doesn't actually document what this behavior is supposed to be, it goes against CK documentation, historic RN documentation, and the behavior valid on the web. It is also applied inconsistently (e.g. sometimes only on container, sometimes on child). It really is a bug, instead of an intended behavior. We changed the default behavior for Yoga, but left the existing one behind an errata (so existing fbsource users got old behavior). We have previously seen this behavior show up in product code, including CK when running on FlexLayout. `row-reverse` is surprisingly uncommon though: 1. Litho has <40 usages 2. RN has ~40 usages in `RKJSModules`,~30 in `arvr/js`, ~6 in `xplat/archon` 3. CK has ~80 usages 4. NT has ~40 usages These components are pretty static, and few enough that we can do this style of refactor, where we just fix everything we find. But there is some risk of missing complonents. CK accounts for 10/13 usages that I could tell would trigger the issue, since it only exposes start/end edge, and not left/right. It might make sense to make it preserve behavior instead, to reduce risk a bit. FlexLayout is now separately powering Bloks, which wasn't surveryed, do I didn't touch CK behavior under Bloks. There could also be other usages in other frameworks/bespoke usages, and this has implications for OSS users. But based on our own usage, of many, many components, this seems rare. Changelog: [General][Breaking] - Make `start/end` in styles always refer to writing direction Reviewed By: joevilches Differential Revision: D52698130
NickGerleman
force-pushed
the
export-D52698130
branch
from
97a52e8 to
6f54e66
Compare
|
This pull request was exported from Phabricator. Differential Revision: D52698130 |
facebook-github-bot
pushed a commit
to facebook/yoga
that referenced
this pull request
Jan 12, 2024
Summary: Pull Request resolved: #1547 X-link: facebook/react-native#42251 Yoga has an odd behavior, where `start`/`end` edges under row-reverse are relative to flex-direction, instead of writing direction. While Yoga doesn't actually document what this behavior is supposed to be, it goes against CK documentation, historic RN documentation, and the behavior valid on the web. It is also applied inconsistently (e.g. sometimes only on container, sometimes on child). It really is a bug, instead of an intended behavior. We changed the default behavior for Yoga, but left the existing one behind an errata (so existing fbsource users got old behavior). We have previously seen this behavior show up in product code, including CK when running on FlexLayout. `row-reverse` is surprisingly uncommon though: 1. Litho has <40 usages 2. RN has ~40 usages in `RKJSModules`,~30 in `arvr/js`, ~6 in `xplat/archon` 3. CK has ~80 usages 4. NT has ~40 usages There are few enough, mostly simple components, that we can inspect through each of them, looking for signs they will hit the issue (at the potential chance of missing some). CK accounts for 10/14 usages that I could tell would trigger the issue, since it only exposes start/end edge, and not left/right. It might make sense to make it preserve behavior instead, to reduce risk a bit. FlexLayout is now separately powering Bloks, which wasn't surveyed, so I didn't touch CK behavior under Bloks. There could also be other usages in other frameworks/bespoke usages, and this has implications for OSS users. But based on our own usage, of many, many components, this seems rare. Changelog: [General][Breaking] - Make `start/end` in styles always refer to writing direction Reviewed By: pentiumao, joevilches Differential Revision: D52698130 fbshipit-source-id: 2a9ac47e177469f30dc988d916b6c0ad95d53461
|
This pull request has been merged in e859f6c. |
facebook-github-bot
pushed a commit
to facebook/litho
that referenced
this pull request
Jan 12, 2024
Summary: X-link: facebook/yoga#1547 X-link: facebook/react-native#42251 Yoga has an odd behavior, where `start`/`end` edges under row-reverse are relative to flex-direction, instead of writing direction. While Yoga doesn't actually document what this behavior is supposed to be, it goes against CK documentation, historic RN documentation, and the behavior valid on the web. It is also applied inconsistently (e.g. sometimes only on container, sometimes on child). It really is a bug, instead of an intended behavior. We changed the default behavior for Yoga, but left the existing one behind an errata (so existing fbsource users got old behavior). We have previously seen this behavior show up in product code, including CK when running on FlexLayout. `row-reverse` is surprisingly uncommon though: 1. Litho has <40 usages 2. RN has ~40 usages in `RKJSModules`,~30 in `arvr/js`, ~6 in `xplat/archon` 3. CK has ~80 usages 4. NT has ~40 usages There are few enough, mostly simple components, that we can inspect through each of them, looking for signs they will hit the issue (at the potential chance of missing some). CK accounts for 10/14 usages that I could tell would trigger the issue, since it only exposes start/end edge, and not left/right. It might make sense to make it preserve behavior instead, to reduce risk a bit. FlexLayout is now separately powering Bloks, which wasn't surveyed, so I didn't touch CK behavior under Bloks. There could also be other usages in other frameworks/bespoke usages, and this has implications for OSS users. But based on our own usage, of many, many components, this seems rare. Changelog: [General][Breaking] - Make `start/end` in styles always refer to writing direction Reviewed By: pentiumao, joevilches Differential Revision: D52698130 fbshipit-source-id: 2a9ac47e177469f30dc988d916b6c0ad95d53461
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Summary:
Yoga has an odd behavior, where
start/endedges under row-reverse are relative to flex-direction, instead of writing direction.While Yoga doesn't actually document what this behavior is supposed to be, it goes against CK documentation, historic RN documentation, and the behavior valid on the web. It is also applied inconsistently (e.g. sometimes only on container, sometimes on child). It really is a bug, instead of an intended behavior.
We changed the default behavior for Yoga, but left the existing one behind an errata (so existing fbsource users got old behavior). We have previously seen this behavior show up in product code, including CK when running on FlexLayout.
row-reverseis surprisingly uncommon though:RKJSModules,~30 inarvr/js, ~6 inxplat/archonThese components are pretty static, and few enough that we can do this style of refactor, where we just fix everything we find. But there is some risk of missing complonents.
CK accounts for 17/20 usages that I could tell would trigger the issue, since it only exposes start/end edge, and not left/right. It might make sense to make it preserve behavior instead, to reduce risk a bit.
FlexLayout is now separately powering Bloks, which wasn't surveryed, do I didn't touch CK behavior under Bloks.
There could also be other usages in other frameworks/bespoke usages, and this has implications for OSS users. But based on our own usage, of many, many components, this seems rare.
Changelog:
[General][Breaking] - Make
start/endin styles always refer to writing directionDifferential Revision: D52698130