Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

update apm index pattern #86739

Merged
merged 1 commit into from
Dec 22, 2020
Merged

Conversation

simitt
Copy link
Contributor

@simitt simitt commented Dec 22, 2020

Summary

APM Server Index Pattern creation was broken since pulling in the change where beats switched to wildcards. elastic/apm-server#4577 fixes the issue.
With the fix there are a couple of changes to the index pattern:

  • change type from keyword to wildcards in alignment with ECS 1.7 leads to removing the string type
  • add new ECS fields.
See list of Index Pattern changes
---- Comparing Generated Index Pattern with https://raw.githubusercontent.com/elastic/kibana/master/src/plugins/apm_oss/server/tutorial/index_pattern.json
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=agent.build.original.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=as.organization.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.as.organization.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.geo.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.registered_domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.subdomain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "client.subdomain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'client.subdomain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.user.email.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.user.full_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=client.user.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.as.organization.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.geo.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.registered_domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.subdomain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "destination.subdomain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'destination.subdomain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.user.email.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.user.full_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=destination.user.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=dll.pe.original_file_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=dns.answers.data.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=dns.question.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=error.stack_trace.indexed'
[
    true,
    false
]
Value in APM Server: True
Value in Kibana: False
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=error.stack_trace.text.indexed'
[
    true,
    false
]
Value in APM Server: True
Value in Kibana: False
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=error.type.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=file.directory.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=file.path.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=file.pe.original_file_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=file.target_path.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=file.x509.issuer.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=file.x509.subject.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=geo.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=host.geo.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=host.hostname.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=host.os.full.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=host.os.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=host.user.email.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=host.user.full_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=host.user.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=http.request.body.content.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=http.request.mime_type'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "http.request.mime_type",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'http.request.mime_type', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=http.request.referrer.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=http.response.body.content.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=http.response.mime_type'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "http.response.mime_type",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'http.response.mime_type', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=log.file.path.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=log.logger.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=observer.geo.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=observer.os.full.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=observer.os.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=organization.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=os.full.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=os.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=pe.original_file_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.command_line.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.executable.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.parent.command_line.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.parent.executable.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.parent.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.parent.pe.original_file_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.parent.thread.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.parent.title.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.parent.working_directory.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.pe.original_file_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.thread.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.title.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=process.working_directory.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=registry.data.strings.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=registry.key.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=registry.path.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.as.organization.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.geo.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.registered_domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.subdomain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "server.subdomain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'server.subdomain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.user.email.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.user.full_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=server.user.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.as.organization.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.geo.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.registered_domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.subdomain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "source.subdomain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'source.subdomain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.user.email.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.user.full_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=source.user.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=threat.technique.subtechnique.id'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "threat.technique.subtechnique.id",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'threat.technique.subtechnique.id', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=threat.technique.subtechnique.name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "threat.technique.subtechnique.name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'threat.technique.subtechnique.name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=threat.technique.subtechnique.name.text'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": false,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "threat.technique.subtechnique.name.text",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': False, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'threat.technique.subtechnique.name.text', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=threat.technique.subtechnique.reference'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "threat.technique.subtechnique.reference",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'threat.technique.subtechnique.reference', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.client.issuer.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.client.subject.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.client.x509.issuer.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.client.x509.subject.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.server.issuer.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.server.subject.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.server.x509.issuer.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=tls.server.x509.subject.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=url.domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=url.full.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=url.original.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=url.path.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=url.registered_domain.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=url.subdomain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "url.subdomain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'url.subdomain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.domain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.domain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.domain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.email'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.email",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.email', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.full_name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.full_name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.full_name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.full_name.text'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": false,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.full_name.text",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': False, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.full_name.text', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.group.domain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.group.domain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.group.domain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.group.id'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.group.id",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.group.id', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.group.name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.group.name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.group.name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.hash'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.hash",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.hash', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.id'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.id",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.id', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.name.text'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": false,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.name.text",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': False, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.name.text', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.changes.roles'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.changes.roles",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.changes.roles', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.domain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.domain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.domain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.email'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.email",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.email', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.full_name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.full_name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.full_name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.full_name.text'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": false,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.full_name.text",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': False, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.full_name.text', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.group.domain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.group.domain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.group.domain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.group.id'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.group.id",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.group.id', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.group.name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.group.name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.group.name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.hash'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.hash",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.hash', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.id'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.id",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.id', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.name.text'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": false,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.name.text",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': False, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.name.text', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.effective.roles'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.effective.roles",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.effective.roles', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.email.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.full_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.domain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.domain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.domain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.email'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.email",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.email', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.full_name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.full_name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.full_name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.full_name.text'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": false,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.full_name.text",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': False, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.full_name.text', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.group.domain'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.group.domain",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.group.domain', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.group.id'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.group.id",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.group.id', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.group.name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.group.name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.group.name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.hash'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.hash",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.hash', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.id'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.id",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.id', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.name'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.name",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.name', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.name.text'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": false,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.name.text",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': False, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.name.text', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user.target.roles'
[
    {
        "aggregatable": true,
        "analyzed": false,
        "count": 0,
        "doc_values": true,
        "indexed": true,
        "name": "user.target.roles",
        "scripted": false,
        "searchable": true,
        "type": "string"
    },
    ""
]
Value in APM Server: {'aggregatable': True, 'analyzed': False, 'count': 0, 'doc_values': True, 'indexed': True, 'name': 'user.target.roles', 'scripted': False, 'searchable': True, 'type': 'string'}
Value in Kibana: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user_agent.original.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user_agent.os.full.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=user_agent.os.name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=x509.issuer.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---
Difference for id 'apm-*' for key 'attributes.fields.name=x509.subject.distinguished_name.type'
[
    "string",
    ""
]
Value in Kibana: 'string'
Value in APM Server: ''
---

@simitt simitt added bug Fixes for quality problems that affect the customer experience Team:APM All issues that need APM UI Team support release_note:skip Skip the PR/issue when compiling release notes v7.11.0 labels Dec 22, 2020
@simitt simitt requested a review from a team December 22, 2020 09:58
@elasticmachine
Copy link
Contributor

Pinging @elastic/apm-ui (Team:apm)

@kibanamachine
Copy link
Contributor

💚 Build Succeeded

Metrics [docs]

Distributable file count

id before after diff
default 47144 47904 +760

To update your PR or re-run it, just comment with:
@elasticmachine merge upstream

@simitt simitt merged commit 3b5bf69 into elastic:master Dec 22, 2020
simitt added a commit to simitt/kibana that referenced this pull request Dec 22, 2020
simitt added a commit to simitt/kibana that referenced this pull request Dec 22, 2020
gmmorris added a commit to gmmorris/kibana that referenced this pull request Dec 22, 2020
* master: (36 commits)
  update apm index pattern (elastic#86739)
  [Visualizations] Remove vis_default_editor - visualize plugins cyclic dependencies (elastic#85422)
  [ML] Fix alignment of values in data frame analytics results view badges (elastic#86621)
  [Visualizations] Remove charts - editor plugins cyclic dependencies (elastic#84887)
  fixing blank page (elastic#86640)
  Update dependency vega to ^5.17.1 (elastic#86715)
  [Monitoring] Convert Kibana-related server files that read from _source to typescript (elastic#86364)
  Uses @elastic/elasticsearch-canary (elastic#86398)
  [CI] Removes script previously used for Karma (elastic#86412)
  [build] Remove grunt checkPlugins task (elastic#85852)
  [build] Remove grunt docker:docs task (elastic#85848)
  [ML] Add doc link for classification AUC ROC evaluation (elastic#86660)
  [ML] Edits saved object synchronization message (elastic#86664)
  Uses the new es client in canvas usage collector's fetch methods (elastic#86668)
  [ML] Support legacy watcher URL (elastic#86661)
  [ML] Fix Single Metric Viewer y domain extending beyond the visible focus area (elastic#86655)
  Migrates search telemetry usage collector es client from legacy to new (elastic#86597)
  [Alerting] Encourage type safe usage of Alerting (elastic#86623)
  Migrates kql_telemetry usage collector es client (elastic#86585)
  [ML] Fix time range adjustment for the swim lane causing the infinite loop update (elastic#86461)
  ...
@kibanamachine kibanamachine added the backport missing Added to PRs automatically when the are determined to be missing a backport. label Dec 24, 2020
@kibanamachine
Copy link
Contributor

Looks like this PR has backport PRs but they still haven't been merged. Please merge them ASAP to keep the branches relatively in sync.

1 similar comment
@kibanamachine
Copy link
Contributor

Looks like this PR has backport PRs but they still haven't been merged. Please merge them ASAP to keep the branches relatively in sync.

simitt added a commit that referenced this pull request Dec 28, 2020
@kibanamachine kibanamachine removed the backport missing Added to PRs automatically when the are determined to be missing a backport. label Dec 28, 2020
simitt added a commit that referenced this pull request Dec 28, 2020
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
bug Fixes for quality problems that affect the customer experience release_note:skip Skip the PR/issue when compiling release notes Team:APM All issues that need APM UI Team support v7.11.0
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

4 participants