Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Duplicate 2-oxoadipate dehydrogenase reactions #719

Closed
4 tasks done
Devlin-Moyer opened this issue Nov 3, 2023 · 14 comments
Closed
4 tasks done

Duplicate 2-oxoadipate dehydrogenase reactions #719

Devlin-Moyer opened this issue Nov 3, 2023 · 14 comments
Labels

Comments

@Devlin-Moyer
Copy link
Collaborator

Devlin-Moyer commented Nov 3, 2023

Current behavior:

MAR04239: 2-oxoadipate + CoA + NAD+ --> CO2 + glutaryl-CoA + NADH, GPR: DLD and OGDH and DLST
is the same as the net reaction of the following three reactions:
MAR04599: 2-oxoadipate + H+ + lipoamide --> CO2 + S-glutaryldihydrolipoamide, GPR: OGDH or DHTKD1 or OGDHL
MAR06415: CoA + S-glutaryldihydrolipoamide --> dihydrolipoamide + glutaryl-CoA, GPR: DLST
MAR06409: H+ + lipoamide + NADH <=> dihydrolipoamide + NAD+, GPR: DLD

Expected feature/value/output:

Following the same rationale as #524, #529, and #660:

  • MAR04239 should be removed for being a duplicate of MAR04599 + MAR06415
  • The GPR of MAR04599 should be changed to (OGDH and DLST) or (DHTKD1 and DLST), since the lipoamide it uses is bound to DLST (source) and OGDHL doesn't appear to catalyze this reaction (source)
    • Add PMID:28757203 to the list of references for MAR04599
  • Remove OGDHL from the GPR of MAR04209 and MAR06413, since OGDHL doesn't appear to catalyze these reactions (source)
@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

yes, it seems reasonable to remove MAR04239

regarding the change to GPR of MAR04599, can you please paste the direct evidence from that source

@Devlin-Moyer
Copy link
Collaborator Author

So that paper I cited in the original comment never super directly states that DLST is lipoylated, but this one does, right at the beginning:

Lipoic acid (LA) is an essential cofactor of major mitochondrial enzyme complexes (Figure S1), including the glycine cleavage system (GCS) and four 2-oxoacid dehydrogenases, namely [...] 2-oxoadipate dehydrogenase (2-OADH, lysine catabolism). This cofactor is covalently bound to a conserved lysine residue of the E2 subunits of PDHc, BCKDHc, 2-OADH, and α-KGDHc as well as the H protein of GCS.

Figure S1:
image

I just updated my proposed changes to include adding this paper as a reference for MAR04599

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

2-oxoadipate dehydrogenase (2-OADH, lysine catabolism). This cofactor is covalently bound to a conserved lysine residue of the E2 subunits of PDHc, BCKDHc, 2-OADH, and α-KGDHc as well as the H protein of GCS

maybe there are multiple aliases names, just to be sure, which of these is DLST?

@Devlin-Moyer
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Devlin-Moyer commented Nov 10, 2023

DLST is the E2 subunit of both the 2-OADH (2-OxoAdipate DeHydrogenase) and α-KGDHc (α-KetoGlutarate DeHydrogenase) complexes

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Nov 13, 2023

This cofactor is covalently bound to a conserved lysine residue of the E2 subunits of PDHc, BCKDHc, 2-OADH, and α-KGDHc as well as the H protein of GCS

according this description, DLST (E2 subunit of both the 2-OADH) should be part of the GPR of MAR04599.

Now the proposed GPR (OGDH or DHTKD1 or OGDHL) and DLST reflects that MAR04599 is catalyzed by a complex with E1 and E2 subunits, this seems fine. For the three paralogues of E1, please double check if OGDHL should be included or not.

@Devlin-Moyer
Copy link
Collaborator Author

From this paper:

The activity with OG increased only upon transfection of OGDH, while the activity with OA increased upon transfection of DHTKD1 and/or OGDH (Fig. 3A and Supplementary Material, Fig. S3B and C). [...] Transient transfection of OGDHL or MRPS36 did not increase 2-oxo acid dehydrogenase activity in HEK-293 cell lysates using either OA or OG substrates.

So perhaps OGDHL should be removed from MAR04599 as well as MAR04209 and MAR06413, since it seems to have no measurable impact on catalysis of either reaction. I noticed that Uniprot only associates OGDHL with the dehydrogenation of 2-oxoglutarate "by similarity", and the above paper is the only one I can find that directly assess catalytic activity of OGDHL independently of OGDH; most of the others I can find that mention OGDHL implicitly treat it as functionally equivalent to OGDH.

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Nov 13, 2023

thanks for the investigation - yes, OGDHL can only be associated with the dehydrogenation of 2-oxoglutarate "By similarity", according to Uniprot. No evidence for MAR04599, MAR04209, and MAR06413, even "By similarity"

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Nov 15, 2023

it might worth revisiting the removal of OGDHL altogether from MAR04599, MAR04209 and MAR06413; such an implementation in #725 led to its removal from Human-GEM completely and this might be an overkill

it appears that OGDHL should still be kept for MAR04209 and MAR06413, given the Uniprot annotation as 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase-like with matched substrate (2-oxoglutarate) and cofactor (thiamine diphosphate).

sorry for the mistake I made before

@Devlin-Moyer
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Devlin-Moyer commented Nov 16, 2023

As I mentioned earlier, this paper found that

Transient transfection of OGDHL or MRPS36 did not increase 2-oxo acid dehydrogenase activity in HEK-293 cell lysates using either OA or OG substrates.

where OA = 2-oxoadipate and OG = 2-oxoglutarate
and once again, Uniprot's only references for associating OGDHL with the OGDH reaction is "by similarity" (the two papers it cites at the very beginning only establish OGDHL's role in signalling pathways, not as an enzyme)

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Nov 16, 2023

So the Uniprot assignment of OGDHL "by similarity" is actually overridden by the experimental validation in this paper. Then probably it's fine to remove OGDHL entirely now

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

Transient transfection of OGDHL or MRPS36 did not increase 2-oxo acid dehydrogenase activity in HEK-293 cell lysates using either OA or OG substrates.

The paper is relatively new, maybe this info should be updated to Uniprot somehow. How did you trace to it specifically @Devlin-Moyer ?

@Devlin-Moyer
Copy link
Collaborator Author

pretty sure I just searched for something along the lines of "OGDHL catalytic activity" on Google Scholar; nothing fancy

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

haowang-bioinfo commented Nov 16, 2023

pretty sure this should be turned into routines processed regularly by bots

@haowang-bioinfo
Copy link
Member

fixed by #725

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants