Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Semantic error: Function pointer #565

Closed
lars-reimann opened this issue Sep 20, 2023 · 1 comment · Fixed by #629
Closed

Semantic error: Function pointer #565

lars-reimann opened this issue Sep 20, 2023 · 1 comment · Fixed by #629
Assignees
@lars-reimann
Labels
enhancement 💡 New feature or request released Included in a release validation ✔️ Improved or new static checks

Comments

@lars-reimann
Copy link
Member

Is your feature request related to a problem?

To provide a clean graphical view, we should prohibit function pointers, like in

fun f()

fun g(p: () -> ())

// ...

g(f)

Desired solution

Add a validation check for this. Code that has this error might also have an alias error (#564), e.g.

fun f()

// ...

val a = f;

We need to decide whether to show both errors or only one of them.

Possible alternatives (optional)

No response

Screenshots (optional)

No response

Additional Context (optional)

No response
@lars-reimann lars-reimann added the enhancement 💡 New feature or request label Sep 20, 2023
@lars-reimann lars-reimann added this to DSL Sep 20, 2023
@github-project-automation github-project-automation bot moved this to Backlog in DSL Sep 20, 2023
@lars-reimann lars-reimann added the validation ✔️ Improved or new static checks label Sep 20, 2023
@lars-reimann lars-reimann linked a pull request Oct 10, 2023 that will close this issue
feat: error if function pointers are used #629
Merged
@lars-reimann lars-reimann mentioned this issue Oct 10, 2023
Merged
lars-reimann added a commit that referenced this issue Oct 10, 2023
@lars-reimann @megalinter-bot
feat: error if function pointers are used (#629)
01933b9 
Closes #565
Closes partially #543

### Summary of Changes

To provide a cleaner graphical view, this PR makes the use of function
pointers (to functions/segments) an error. Lambdas can be used instead.

---------

Co-authored-by: megalinter-bot <[email protected]>
@github-project-automation github-project-automation bot moved this from Backlog to ✔️ Done in DSL Oct 10, 2023
lars-reimann pushed a commit that referenced this issue Oct 25, 2023
@semantic-release-bot
chore(release): 0.2.0 [skip ci]
1eae9e7 
## [0.2.0](v0.1.0...v0.2.0) (2023-10-25)

### Features

* `const` modifier to replace `@Constant` annotation ([#618](#618)) ([ea4a9ba](ea4a9ba)), closes [#558](#558)
* allow instance and static members of classes to have the same name ([#583](#583)) ([1b04905](1b04905))
* automatic formatting in Langium ([#526](#526)) ([922af22](922af22)), closes [#31](#31) [#33](#33) [#513](#513) [#433](#433)
* basic implementation of partial evaluator service ([#649](#649)) ([10ed8bf](10ed8bf)), closes [#603](#603)
* built-in library ([#557](#557)) ([7998eb1](7998eb1)), closes [#433](#433)
* check `@PythonName` and `@PythonModule` ([#641](#641)) ([5a9dcbb](5a9dcbb)), closes [#543](#543)
* check context of union types ([#677](#677)) ([e846b59](e846b59)), closes [#675](#675)
* check template expressions inside `@PythonCall` ([#686](#686)) ([09bfb38](09bfb38))
* comment provider ([#688](#688)) ([e4a1b35](e4a1b35)), closes [#669](#669)
* compute types of lambdas that are passed as arguments ([#604](#604)) ([25c8707](25c8707)), closes [#541](#541)
* document symbol provider ([#659](#659)) ([fe0c8d5](fe0c8d5))
* documentation provider ([#689](#689)) ([ff70b07](ff70b07)), closes [#669](#669)
* ensure that all assignees get a value ([#630](#630)) ([e8e2bf6](e8e2bf6)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if @pythonName and @PythonCall are set on a function ([#685](#685)) ([d22c446](d22c446))
* error if argument lists are missing ([#642](#642)) ([f5ee1bd](f5ee1bd)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if class or enum are statically referenced ([#643](#643)) ([8b076e7](8b076e7)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if divisor is zero ([#644](#644)) ([9af3b81](9af3b81)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if function pointers are used ([#629](#629)) ([01933b9](01933b9)), closes [#565](#565) [#543](#543)
* error if lambda is used in wrong context ([#647](#647)) ([2d2ccc6](2d2ccc6)), closes [#409](#409) [#543](#543)
* error if left operand of type parameter constraint does not belong to declaration with constraint ([#571](#571)) ([cba3abf](cba3abf)), closes [#562](#562)
* error if member access must be null safe but isn't ([#626](#626)) ([077daff](077daff)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if names are not unique (part 2) ([#640](#640)) ([38d1181](38d1181)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if pipeline file is in a `safeds.xy` package ([#673](#673)) ([867bae3](867bae3)), closes [#671](#671)
* error if placeholder is alias for parameter or placeholder ([#628](#628)) ([b99ab25](b99ab25)), closes [#564](#564) [#543](#543)
* error if simple names of builtin declarations collide ([#678](#678)) ([275ad5e](275ad5e)), closes [#672](#672)
* error if single use annotations are used multiple times ([#631](#631)) ([17a5b7a](17a5b7a)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if type parameters don't have sufficient context ([#687](#687)) ([ea8fe29](ea8fe29))
* error if value assigned to constant parameters is not constant ([#646](#646)) ([097764d](097764d)), closes [#543](#543)
* error if wildcard import has alias ([#574](#574)) ([4ba7873](4ba7873)), closes [#543](#543)
* extensions for the `NodeMapper` ([#606](#606)) ([4fd8d86](4fd8d86))
* generation ([#634](#634)) ([c52b5e6](c52b5e6)), closes [#542](#542)
* handle backticks surrounding IDs ([#622](#622)) ([608e470](608e470)), closes [#579](#579)
* improved TextMate grammar ([#623](#623)) ([d7ff0e2](d7ff0e2))
* info if elvis operator is unnecessary ([#645](#645)) ([dcc05ce](dcc05ce)), closes [#543](#543)
* info if import alias can be removed ([#637](#637)) ([83936b8](83936b8)), closes [#636](#636)
* inlay hint provider ([#683](#683)) ([f23fa29](f23fa29)), closes [#679](#679)
* intermediate type computer ([#600](#600)) ([8d68a42](8d68a42)), closes [#541](#541)
* Langium grammar ([#470](#470)) ([c439c19](c439c19)), closes [#433](#433)
* list & map literals ([#619](#619)) ([e3b2870](e3b2870)), closes [#615](#615) [#616](#616)
* mark union types as experimental ([#676](#676)) ([4656c25](4656c25)), closes [#674](#674)
* node mapper ([#602](#602)) ([a13e5b5](a13e5b5))
* port additional checks ([#567](#567)) ([2803305](2803305)), closes [#543](#543)
* port additional validation checks to `Langium ([#576](#576)) ([8f5d57a](8f5d57a)), closes [#543](#543)
* port remaining validation infos that don't need partial evaluation ([#607](#607)) ([d53bda3](d53bda3)), closes [#543](#543)
* port validation of parameter lists ([#573](#573)) ([bd73bc5](bd73bc5)), closes [#543](#543)
* Python-like import syntax ([#598](#598)) ([4c61b8c](4c61b8c))
* PythonCall annotation ([#684](#684)) ([15114df](15114df)), closes [#617](#617)
* remove star projection and use-site variance ([#597](#597)) ([928f487](928f487))
* remove type arguments from calls ([#581](#581)) ([3e88f02](3e88f02))
* resolve references to declarations in other files ([#586](#586)) ([6b30de5](6b30de5)), closes [#540](#540)
* scoping for named types ([#563](#563)) ([a877f4c](a877f4c)), closes [#540](#540)
* scoping for own members ([#611](#611)) ([43b276f](43b276f)), closes [#540](#540)
* scoping for references to own static members ([#582](#582)) ([38afc07](38afc07)), closes [#540](#540)
* scoping for type arguments ([#585](#585)) ([3da8dd0](3da8dd0)), closes [#540](#540)
* scoping of annotation calls, type parameter constraints & yields ([#561](#561)) ([a510f2b](a510f2b)), closes [#540](#540)
* scoping of arguments ([#601](#601)) ([6b486cd](6b486cd)), closes [#540](#540)
* scoping of direct references to declarations in same file ([#580](#580)) ([491d7b0](491d7b0)), closes [#540](#540)
* semantic highlighting ([#653](#653)) ([fe8c602](fe8c602)), closes [#27](#27)
* show info if unnecessary syntax is used ([#566](#566)) ([c26d33a](c26d33a)), closes [#543](#543)
* show info that empty constraint lists can be removed ([#572](#572)) ([af13e28](af13e28)), closes [#570](#570)
* stop validation after lexing/parsing errors ([#662](#662)) ([ba1e9a8](ba1e9a8))
* syntax and formatting for literal types ([#529](#529)) ([32aca34](32aca34)), closes [#80](#80)
* syntax highlighting in documentation comments ([#690](#690)) ([83364d3](83364d3)), closes [#669](#669)
* unique names withing declarations ([#575](#575)) ([47ce782](47ce782)), closes [#543](#543)
* validate package of imports ([#627](#627)) ([18641de](18641de)), closes [#543](#543)
* validation for annotation target ([#670](#670)) ([fa7631d](fa7631d)), closes [#543](#543)
* validation for results of segments ([#613](#613)) ([bf20c7c](bf20c7c)), closes [#543](#543)
* validation for type arguments of named types ([#632](#632)) ([b72768c](b72768c)), closes [#543](#543)
* value converter for strings & ints ([#655](#655)) ([aafa2e3](aafa2e3))
* various checks for annotations on parameters and results ([#625](#625)) ([e77037e](e77037e)), closes [#543](#543)
* various checks for argument lists ([#648](#648)) ([d76e597](d76e597)), closes [#543](#543)
* various checks for calls ([#638](#638)) ([e0fa032](e0fa032)), closes [#543](#543)
* various checks related to inheritance ([#633](#633)) ([7ec746a](7ec746a)), closes [#543](#543)
* various features related to literal types ([#657](#657)) ([1775705](1775705)), closes [#80](#80)
* very basic type computer ([#596](#596)) ([b3d786c](b3d786c)), closes [#541](#541)
* warn if deprecated/experimental declarations are used ([#608](#608)) ([9b5287c](9b5287c)), closes [#543](#543) [#540](#540)
* warn if experimental language features are used ([#624](#624)) ([090fcc3](090fcc3)), closes [#108](#108)
* warn if parameters or placeholders are unused ([#612](#612)) ([3a2e9cc](3a2e9cc)), closes [#543](#543)
* warning if literal types or union types have duplicate entries ([#658](#658)) ([9ba9d20](9ba9d20))

### Bug Fixes

* CLI startup ([#560](#560)) ([4bde898](4bde898))
* duplicate error if annotation call has no argument list and lacks required parameters ([#650](#650)) ([4ba2c2c](4ba2c2c))
* mark map literals as experimental ([#656](#656)) ([ca47870](ca47870))
* resolution of references to declarations of wrong node type ([#599](#599)) ([6ae387a](6ae387a))
@lars-reimann
Copy link
Member Author

🎉 This issue has been resolved in version 0.2.0 🎉

The release is available on:

Your semantic-release bot 📦🚀

@lars-reimann lars-reimann added the released Included in a release label Oct 25, 2023
@lars-reimann lars-reimann self-assigned this Nov 22, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@lars-reimann lars-reimann

Labels
enhancement 💡 New feature or request released Included in a release validation ✔️ Improved or new static checks
Projects
DSL
Archived in project
Milestone
No milestone
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

feat: error if function pointers are used Safe-DS/DSL
1 participant
@lars-reimann