Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

DFIP 2112-A Bringing DUSD closer to $1 by allowing DFI for loan repayment & collateral #99

Closed
FxX9920 opened this issue Dec 17, 2021 · 87 comments
Labels
dfip DeFi Improvement Proposal passed Proposal passed round/2112 December 2021 special voting round

Comments

@FxX9920
Copy link

FxX9920 commented Dec 17, 2021

Emergency DFIP bringing dUSD to $1

Overview
Requestor: @BalthasarBecker
Proposal fee: 01db41727f2092148d328b946a3ca0c4eb8faf82d393488ab65466eb81c26976

After a successful launch of the Fort Canning, hard fork incentives for dToken liquidity providers went live on the 6th of December. Every true DeFiChain hodler started earning sweet rewards via minting or buying dTokens providing them as liquidity for the DEXs. Unfortunately, with the demand of dTokens exceeding supply all dTokens trade at a premium ever since. Taking into account that we - the DeFiChain community - rely on accurate prices, especially regarding the dUSD price, I herewith propose the following solution to guarantee the dUSD USD peg. Furthermore, I advocate for a fast and efficient solution, ensuring we can fully focus on getting more people to participate in the amazing features DeFiChain offers.

The proposed idea is a composition out of multiple ideas that were thoroughly discussed, edited and further improved by several community members therefor representing a true community effort:

Every dUSD loan should be repayable with DFI (at oracle price + 1% penalty).
dUSD can be used as collateral at a fixed rate of 0.99 USD for every loan, providing additional utility for dUSD

The proposal is straight forward and easy to implement, but not perfect; it will directly arbitrage the dUSD premium, but many concerns of the community, including myself have been raised whether this proposal will devalue dUSD causing its price to fall below $1. As this risk still persists - there is no free lunch and solving the dUSD premium will always come at a cost - I would like to bring forward a couple of reasons why, at least on the short run, chances are rather low that dUSD will end up trading at a discount causing a default on the USD peg. First, currently we face more demand than supply causing the dUSD premium, hence buying pressure will continuously hold up dUSD prices until liquidity mining incentives reach unattractive levels. Moreover, once buying pressure fades and dUSD starts trading at a discount, people with open dUSD loans will buy back dUSD at a discount to close their loan. Currently, we have 70,000,000 dUSD minted, hence a fairly high buffer to mediate curtain price drops.
Last but not least, I highly want to stress the point that this is a short term solution arising from the need of solving the problem fast and efficiently, and I strongly advocate for several long term changes providing additional support for the dUSD price:
Implementation of a DEX fee for every transaction of about 0,05% for both the taker and maker, resulting in a total of 0.1% burn fee, which reduces any dToken over time
Including additional sources for collateral such as liquidity mining tokens such as BTC-DFI or others to further incentivize minting of dTokens
Introducing decentralized futures (like the road map suggests) to stabilize prices.

Finally, let me say again, that this is not a perfect solution without any risks or any cost. But, as we have all agreed during two Twitter Spaces allowing anyone to voice their opinion and hearing out other proposals, we are all aware that we need a working solution with minimal risk that can be implemented in a fast and efficient way.

@FxX9920 FxX9920 added dfip DeFi Improvement Proposal draft labels Dec 17, 2021
@julianhosp
Copy link

Love it!!

@lordmarkcrypto
Copy link

thanks, Balthasar, let's do it!

@LiorDubov
Copy link

Why do we even need to peg to 1 dollar, why not create a new economy with the reserve currency being DUSD

@ojbcrypto
Copy link

Thank you Balthasar for this pragmatic solution. It‘s very important for the mass adoption that at least 1 DUSD should be 1$ (+/- one cent). Stable has to be stable. As quick as possible. Let‘s go for it.

@10085998
Copy link

what the mere announcement of these proposals does.
1 DUSD = 1.14$

unfortunately the surcharge of the dStocks increases.

How and where can I vote for this proposal?

@muse212
Copy link

muse212 commented Dec 17, 2021

Thanks for your proposal.
Great short term effect. 👍
And keeping to strive for a long term solution.

@dzaengerle
Copy link

I think this solution will just shift the problem to the other dToken: If DUSD value goes down and the value of the other dTokens stays at the same level, their prices will go up and the price difference to swap DFI to a dToken will be the same, like we saw over the past days where DUSD price went down a bit and dToken prices increased. It's only positive for the DFI-DUSD and I think therefore the risk of this solution exceeds its potential benefit.

@DrDrCat
Copy link

DrDrCat commented Dec 17, 2021

i don't quite understand why we need a short term proposal for the long term.
1 USD is 1 USD, you don't can do anymore with this
With 1 DFI you can buy dUSD and get about 34%-101% APR in Crypto LM
With 1 DUSD you can buy dStocks and get about 220-266%

Yes, DUSD is too expensive at this moment ( compared to the Fiat USD ), but with DUSD you have the better Profits like DFI.
So everyone can pay the Premium of 14% to have the possibility to go into the dSTOCK LM with 200%.
And if someone is afraid that they are now buying their dusd at too high a price, they assume that the price will stabilize again. If this is the case, we don't have to change anything in the end, or am I wrong somewhere?
Just a matter of time.

A week ago DEX and oralclae price differed by about 25%, today it is only 14%.
Does the market perhaps simply regulate this itself?


And what I would like to add.
This proposal and this "problem" is indeed a little complex, so that not everyone understands it correctly. ( I probably don't either )

But in the end, what is crucial for DeFiChain and the community is to determine exactly who will benefit from this change.
Is it really everyone?
Is it only the DEX users?
Is it Cake customers, or maybe not?
Does it help the people with 100 masternodes, or those who can't afford one?

This should all be evaluated

@JayMadR
Copy link

JayMadR commented Dec 17, 2021

Nice!

Every dUSD loan should be repayable with DFI (at oracle price + 1% penalty). dUSD can be used as collateral at a fixed rate of 0.99 USD for every loan, providing additional utility for dUSD

I assume the 1% penalty will get burned, right?

and I strongly advocate for several long term changes providing additional support for the dUSD price: Implementation of a DEX fee for every transaction of about 0,05% for both the taker and maker, resulting in a total of 0.1% burn fee, which reduces any dToken over time

I think this idea would lead to a huge problem (at least if you think longterm)!
If dTokens get burned, there are simply too less dTokens available to pay back the open loans (+interests).
In order to pay back the loans, the system would need more dTokens - where do they come from? Correct: they get minted when someone takes a loan. See the problem?
To pay back the loans someone in the system must take out new loans.
The whole system then works in a "death-loop", where there are always too less dTokens available to cover the loan values...
Whats the intention to make this?
Am I understanding anything wrong?
Where are my thinking errors?

@DefiBaconKing
Copy link

DefiBaconKing commented Dec 17, 2021

what the mere announcement of these proposals does. 1 DUSD = 1.14$

unfortunately the surcharge of the dStocks increases.

How and where can I vote for this proposal?

you need a Masternode

@uzyn uzyn changed the title Emergency DFIP bringing dUSD to $1 DFIP 2112-A Bringing DUSD closer to $1 by allowing DFI for loan repayment & collateral Dec 17, 2021
@agentswitters
Copy link

agentswitters commented Dec 17, 2021

As some people including me and don camillo from the telegram group discussed Balthasars well thought proposal in the telegram group and private chats some questions occured

  1. First, everybody agrees as Balthasar analyzed we need a predictable stablecoin dusd that equals its counterparts to attract more people to the defichain ecosystem.

One concern in Balthasars proposal could not be wiped out.

  1. Backed dusd->limited; Unbacked dusd->unlimited, risk of price drop and inflation.

A lot of people appreciate the dusd to be backed with a certain amount of collateral and a certain amount of dfi.
So it might seem a good conclusion to make dusd and dfi interchangeable in paying back the loan in dfi.
On the other hand these dfi wont back the dusd, as they do not become a part of a "big vault". Where do they go? Where do they stay? Will they go to an extra arbitragepool? Will they get burned? Will they circulate as rewards in the future? Will there begin to exist unbacked dusd?
As long as dusd is backed by a certain amount of dfi as collateral there is no chance of an inflation as dfi is limited.
When there starts to establish unbacked dusd this is infinite.

This might be an emergency solution, but there is the inbuild risk in creating an unbacked stablecoin an improve the problem to the worse.
Balthasar and DZ also are aware of this as they discuss this risk of dusd dropping an searching for a solution to that.

  1. Back to the idea of negative interest
    Don Camillo from the german telegram group and me want to elaborate the idea of negative interest brought up by U-Zyn before. We think, that the idea of adjustable interest rates already implemented in defichain could fix the attraction of buying dusd on the dex vs minting dusd. The higher the interest rates, the more expensive it is to mint dusd so it might be cheaper to buy on the dex. Negative interest rates would make it very attractive to mint dusd, as the loan melts away by its own.

The first problem of negative interest would also be the creating of unbacked and therefore infinite dusd, if the loan vanishes via negative interest. Obviously we don't like that idea.
We would like to suggest an idea, that uses the already implementet steering loops of the interest rates of the vaults and tokens. We think there is potential to drive the price up and down.

  1. Conclusio, proposal to discuss

We would like the idea that there might be an selfadjusting system that could rise and lower the attraction of buying or minting dusd via dfi like a pendulum oscillating dusd around 1$ creating a homoeostatic system. A homoeostatic system needs feedback loops and indicators.

The indicator would be the price of the dusd beeing higher than 1 (+Loop) or lower than 1 (-Loop)

a)The Minus-Loop is clear:
To much dusd->cheap->shortage needed->interest rates higher->less attractive to mind/more attractive to buy->buy pressure on the dex->price rises->loop again until price ist 1

Cost of interest is payed by the one who owns the vault/takes the loan. The interest goes to the system to the dusd pool lowering the buying fees to make it more attractive to buy.

b) as U-Zyn proposed a negative interest should initiate the feedback loop to lower the dusd price when it is plus 1. The Plus-Loop.

Problem of unbacked dusd by melting loan could be used as following:
dusd too expensive -> more dusd needed ->interest rates lower/negative interest rates, maybe shortterm high negative interest rates->more attractive to mint/less attractive to buy->lowering buying pressure/selling pressure for arbitrage reasons.

Cost of interest is earned by the one who owns the vault/takes the loan. The interest comes from the system/the selling fees, lowering the price of the dusd.

We'd like you to share your comments and discuss about establishing a kind of these feedback loops so that the chain can keep the homoeostasts on its own. As we are no technicians we are not aware of the coding issues. And maybe we need further research on the system balancing itself and how to modulate fluctuations and prevent escalation. Maybe on the beginning the masternodes vote on these fees to collect data and a research project could be done supported by the community.

  1. Outlook
    As we also liked the idea of Balthasar to be able to pay back loan with dfi, there might be investigation if this could be implemented as long as there is no balance or if there is no balance. Maybe in the background this transaction could run via the dex pool and be part of the balancing mechanism.

@uzyn uzyn pinned this issue Dec 17, 2021
@uzyn uzyn added round/2112 December 2021 special voting round and removed draft labels Dec 17, 2021
@uzyn
Copy link
Contributor

uzyn commented Dec 17, 2021

Voting is opening from Friday, 17 December 2021 23:59:59 UTC.

Please refer to #100 for other key dates.

@Mbeoida
Copy link

Mbeoida commented Dec 17, 2021

Did you guys see what the proposal already caused? dToken are/would be the next asset having 30%+ missmatch. It represents the real value: risk and opportunity.
The current proposal seems to be too narrow (dUSD=USD might not be the "only aim" we should taeget at...), and does not consider a holistic view on the ecosystem.
There needs to be a closed loop arbitrage possibility, ensuring all dtokens still to be backed by crypto.

It's not all about marketing...

@derstrecker
Copy link

As we already can see: To lower the dUSD will lead to an increase of value in the other dToken. There needs to be a valve and it doesn't seem to be the case with this proposal. An open-book unbacked USD-token maybe won't be accepted by exchanges.

It would also be beneficial if you can then buy dToken directly with dUsdc / t, i.e. also add these pools. Of course, with maybe 20% DFI as a third party to be able to enter the Pool for LM, a kind of "gold standard", the lubricating oil in the engine.
Why should I, for example, go to a dTSLA-dUSD pool when I can currently have it 15% cheaper in a dTSLA-dUSDC pool? This depresses dUSD in favor of the other stablecoins, as demand falls. And DFI is still in demand because it is the gold standard. Of course, if both pools have roughly the same APR.

I think that finance professionals who can think in terms of complex equilibrium systems have to work here.
I don't think this should be solved fast, rather than ideal.

@KevinSoell
Copy link

Awesome!
I love the team work & enjoyed the open discussions 🙂

I agree that it's definitely not the ideal solution. But from a marketing perspective, this is more than overdue. In my opinion, if we lose too much momentum, the implications could be much worse than waiting any longer.

I mean, how do you want to promote something by saying: "Hey, this is so cool, but... be aware that you lose ~30% of your money instantly before you can earn any money. Enjoy!"

Let's rather do small & fast steps instead of playing "Mr. perfect" (which doesn't exist anyway).

@muirglacier
Copy link

I think if we trial it with DUSD first, and it all plays out well, we can open up paying other dToken loans with DFI in a blink of an eye - solving the dToken premium as well!

Ayyyyye Sir, let’s go boys!!!

@dDdefi
Copy link

dDdefi commented Dec 18, 2021

signmessage 8K252f95EJCFn7Hv773vHaUwSMxrptm4JS dfip-2112-a-yes
H32RbfKv25RHpc1q36ln9I5CU4feZ7imrOB7x+aM0pGJdaOXXQVWNajblbhs/dtvKqT8KeRAz+QqXTUpfZZTd3Y=

@defiaal
Copy link

defiaal commented Dec 18, 2021

signmessage 8cwPwDzdvKEbuJfwBT3duEtyoRKc1i9zKb dfip-2112-a-yes
IIQAnu2llRLkmuox6bOLf1FJOU04Xh+tFPJI95gNjewtPKMxlW4ZyKIw3z2pynTB11wcfticPfWJOdLe5DlmYYc=
signmessage 8c58cBH6SyhoQrtPC3522JAouAgoLU93x2 dfip-2112-a-yes
IEJ7wt2GhS4dkvVqbRc/Q4GRYI5WTK3xzdHIIPuVEF3QRnleEAXPMFn2fPrU1RJPGDjgUF/WjWzGEHOl+i6zobQ=
signmessage 8X6yRDkrfZk1ndVFtCLw5Es6Xbt9ANnMgg dfip-2112-a-yes
IFCVxjZsYy27r1hhpVyiA3BkfZNkGv5covAsv2Xi5FpOYBpDMwns9kT4CtrQAzkhsuz4t8iswy6WD234gtfImUY=
signmessage 8b4DfwndQM6BEkEgiWCaMgBQh6BwxmhELy dfip-2112-a-yes
H2ar0AuRTPLRX2qu8tUcPkENLjj4yZOBchPDprGOLfXKMgZTNlIXaLWXnNvZfsXYj9a5ljuADYrChziDtRRnObM=

@Matt283
Copy link

Matt283 commented Dec 18, 2021

Explaining to anyone new to the chain that they pay a premium for a stable coin isn't going to work. It's a pity it wasn't predicted. This needs correcting, we don't want to rush, but we don't have months. The proposals have been discussed in length and the whole community has had a chance to openly discuss their concerns. Governance can and should be improved in future - but my view on this change is we do adopt it (but let's document any risks and have a plan if there are unintended consequences). Then move forward and build on! One chain, one community!

@otto1593
Copy link

signmessage 8QCBuwyuQFTMPxgZAaK6kQaVnnpye5nc4C dfip-2112-a-yes
H1VKGVmFA6dQ9OhsIBUScvJTE+RhXjjWwAlvOmIAUvvGH26lYFcKs+ZR82fkiSuU12vx1LNia20tQaFZ8kdx7cw=

@DTenere
Copy link

DTenere commented Dec 18, 2021

"Wisely, and slow. They stumble that run fast.” William Shakespeare

Why introduce a not perfect solution where everyone have concerns. I don't like to be the one pointing out the dangers like a grandpa but I really feel the risks here are under estimated by far. Yes we are in momentum, maybe maybe not. Something unexpected happened with the Fort Canning update, what is preventing it this time?

Are we really in a time critical phase? I highly doubt that and here is why:

(Worse) Case scenarios:

  1. Scenario
    Not perfect emergency update works. DUSD moves, dToken premium shifts what is the gain here? We act like we did something but it didn't fix the system. Would new users come in? I highly doubt that. The system still needs to be updated later again. Maybe remove some functions again which are additional risks.

DFI price goes to 5$ (best case)

  1. Scenario
    Waiting two more weeks for a "perfect" solution where at least no doubts are there before introducing the idea. Intensive debating in the community and so on...

DFI price goes back to 2,50$ (short term worse case)
Long term (two weeks more) I see the potential to 20$-50$ if everything works properly

  1. Scenario
    Emergency update fail. Not all community members where asked. The mood will be so down. A lot of people will be disappointed.

DFI price goes to 1$

You see there is not much to win but much more to lose. Let us give more time. We are not small anymore there is a lot of money on the line for everyone of us...

@muirglacier
Copy link

muirglacier commented Dec 18, 2021

@DTenere i do not see as much of a problem with dToken trading at a premium, after all they are not the real stock, but a USD stable coin should remain stable and pegged in my humble opinion.

@goldi147
Copy link

signmessage 8TQ91Xpu16CXajzbju37tMAvEvGFnw8ryk dfip-2112-a-no
IJ31uvWrVSMSPTBz/S94SzztWex52ak7uk78KRh3oPttUOX2T1yywDa8haU97rYKYLmJmTDv+m7o9VdjJHH449s=
signmessage 8N2B6bjuZGVzq2q629joR28ZjusMfpeey4 dfip-2112-a-no
ILfkWBkII4Rk2diZA2wK0b7gkgtiNU5F8qI4cWkmzP48NhzOhOwrBb8oD3h1Gif4IGhgc1ZjysK58QAPfKYk6ZA=

@Shenzen1982
Copy link

Shenzen1982 commented Dec 19, 2021

What happens if DUSD Price drops under 0.99 because so much people wants to do arbitrag in the same time? Nobody want to buy DUSD for a negative rate any more and a vicious circle begins....

@pamon90
Copy link

pamon90 commented Dec 19, 2021

defi-cli signmessage 8ZAP8vH11pTT47i58GL22GZeW1bX6DCccD "dfip-1-yes"
IE1J62TYuvnztYY08a/F4HqcHqxToiJuoR1ZXTRyvHltXBoDu/R0L+sMl9IzPKR+pdgi1Sis9XTGwzr8+hxblJA=

@defiuser2
Copy link

$ defi-cli signmessage 8eKVok98Qod4nCruNZL8ZLTZMG9LRm3V7t dfip-2112-a-yes
H41QipCbu37VDvTmOV76L1zvULZbT2EVeZyTPmCsFrkrSWoOnfBy4gNkV4V3SVER74xp9nvJtgr2SwOW4YbweP8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Jyov8rftj4tJZ8Pfb8UWVpGcENvc54Bbv dfip-2112-a-yes
IPdXJfbomwKpf18f47utuuunwA6yiJ/IMmekEX1hpHUAMIXmojvwBM5dt41uXHBJX5f2owrZsZj9rmbp7ykfnfc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8NU1UrckihBcfkKzaQ3j1WXqyhphWGPRd4 dfip-2112-a-yes
H+SMSWyWCgqeXH+XNEVOhOejJNhl4bFhYEWTzMr0XtrZG499L/6s6Z7tcAlQQI730N/CVH11OVzQIknZmHSNaeg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Fk9Tppih3a6UJE2xSJnuYPu7Bswxv4ELa dfip-2112-a-yes
IGnyi3HxEhQzuugDYAA1khF7H1KVCEc+kbPFKX4yn0svCPy07g+c+GhoX/Syd3UFl1FXpShMT0nlhMWSukhuz1A=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VZARaBZdA1wnykw92mdWcQKW7wVA8qADB dfip-2112-a-yes
IMOZpUnM9RmcBFytf1b7cEs0oYZ2wOrHzsjsnKAPEfiOWL/X0huDBvkz40xZrlf+F0lumgKaQea+z8etf38vyL8=

@Jonthreesixteen
Copy link

I vote yes to the proposal, please make it happen asap for the ultimate good of the project.

@John-Gee
Copy link

I vote yes to the proposal, please make it happen asap for the ultimate good of the project.

You need a masternode to sign your vote.

@Jonthreesixteen
Copy link

Jonthreesixteen commented Dec 20, 2021 via email

@John-Gee
Copy link

Hi, John How do I get masternode to do that? I'm a newbie to GitHub and voting here. Best regards.

All is explained here: https://github.com/DeFiCh/dfips

If you have further questions, please ask on reddit or TG, this is not the best place for support, but we'd be more than happy to help you on either of these communities.

@ilfalconft
Copy link

$ defi-cli signmessage 8YBcHsAMiQkVSdmRutroDJYzhmk7XfPrme "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IETEpBswWwd0TbJJdVpYpFPpKNw5MWdk+QzgBV1YTWSgXetfWKjvV/CZ9SiKDnF+b5InfGrZgwcU+XHdl0m6mV0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YdkHP43284yWT9DRJnMkVpoSgBsi3Cc1b "dfip-2112-a-yes"
INNCYn6l+kx9c6J0AyXVL1V30v+BvVFknLgK8y4FVDOiH0bGtL09XqgiVAqlr687aBVN4ZR7ys22fqcFS13DQV8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Wioij5SWdiSynTQwgjWoBsLu6ycQoDL1w "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJQfuZpdYVBoPrUjD9m1bUsEVx4F3SFBiA0gSenDMpCLPKmsFrbBp/M1H7uxMRbVRNjULAS+rbGXDZbhmeTPs7k=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8J3NCvQ3STd33V25NFfHgiEaUkpvNWqehv "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IHKmyL7dXu8YcFjf3CTUnX50Cu2W+lA2aPTBSws/5XxQPDyD6ihmUzAwoXI9OXUPTMTP6L8lj5XsVpM1mQES9/Y=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Tx4GCWFMT6TWGtVFa8yKDrTqSf9rGDS5Q "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H1/ZzdUkHHEKtuFIHp234U1TN6bSSNgKq24BG3KKVWU0G/dqjXP6q33RyYKDJFvEOIY+RlUyBMS9vPmrae7a4oY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8H3bUfNCQunSDrELfqrSoFPKBJZpqLnz9e "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IIjGwXU8oCzb+ZLF4iipSwisZ/LYT+PJF1da6Kl+9QLMTV3w+ToeSLf09MhCL4Uhl9WbowlMC6AUwdMTX3S0mvY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8M5heVSsMmvLe9YfzkgvyhesvVoFfcdbSF "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJt0Nl3jGYLoxyLFa4XdDFlG9oXCKD41a4paYA6GlrCIWqd38tdMNvKmAs9FJb+NOQ9Y2Ut93kdFL8sIjvNYPKI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Uatd1BAYCWYbrZ2gyMsJCzB354Mxe5ZBr "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H84LkWdu25H0bNGIL0mnWahTeFaUJMDhJiPrFcfSAjpqBpGgHTN8cO+tb5DCGs9Dl22wIS9QO9vb9N0i7U4awXI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bGdLtHj3F9btgxVBwY2283XgYwMvn9H4j "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H4+IySCgvt8k7erNorbtV5wx0s41kSmC/QoRzw63tjrHaQ5RWDshOvYCL7exWXEh+BbYfXutV1PKvogjxvHmSa0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8eDuLQs11rsj9NzShptTDYyPgo9LygzGKT "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IIGPW79E6YCbkRFGvpErM5c4yoIRoGpBrvGznjTZQcvEDdeEtN5R3u/9AbFJ1H9k/WZeuHMu6JRBpJmQdpVRMbI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8G1TuJ41MaNfcPrbUDVn1dd36a9tmhwHTd "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9TrbQfKyOBdNLV3VyUQYsPxapSZ0P/jj8J7KsfnJv9vWomEVx90WNuFEKbQBpe98bvPJipq4uc/albZIKVEwSk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RecfWRC5ZsP8sqfogzb2oQpetU8y2rtbC "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IL4zlIf5FG9/qXBayFD0J0Nc9Y/0pX4xncU9hdtM5EBRVd7d/UryYpR3lgFb8eVZj7jdqp0KJ8BHkIXEIKrqMzo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8K5Hek5BTXjfL8Ar6Qh6oCP3gCCvN3YnMV "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9BFnVsgLCW0ld1UUm2kQugL6GSMzeZsb/Cr7nwPHG+ASpI2vSBmyf41E5yYxFFneVrVeYGpe8h7J9mpfdGjr6w=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8eJG5Dqz6jfFF761tuzEcTP44nU6jpAbCP "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICpynFMRlXlSto77LPm0L6o8Y3INyG6nb8F6JfOUdRlcD169Vbwq74q3uHaPexejCjmoHyyDV1l5bJ6uHdBhAHA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8NRjq6wdAJgztXQetGimGJy9fuaY5Z9hd7 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H6zCQOzeNEkRnuOhwsEYKOEJptfgNWVY8qZyIk9BxB3yTqj4iEEbk0WneLGrYtg5SAzqWobQsmynqWsbaZc/WNY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TuMmN236DmQMeRRbPFbRgrbuDsVtBg2Yn "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H1w0e+rAlMHeuvTzFiHDhOJH4oMac8k6IJ2R2tB37pRlHsNttTYPCRR1lLssAVfpaOLedO/fJK7g3IQoJT4tiB8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Mo5WU823ZLikdEG7i3bBcDRSbkoMi31kC "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJcQcdv2QD0ipSVXL52HZluGVD7asxkiCLBGAUmcMwD0AlzHcEJtBzky3848kR9d6lodhL300dIY2Nv7wLTdpMg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GwU7sSKxoYkziCfdcDf7dEZgxov6T5MvN "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ILgDhdzb6LKn4P2+Ife4dRgOVEZINS0teYt7Sz/q4AaHd4UamQQXeGbiQ7w5/O64F+JMmcdNkFTvBZMl2ezzDkM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TbLbus2F6vdpDejVjimjymGsd6u7oKAnx "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H1xJa4rCY6Wf4WAp4jaDmMs6YQirM+lAJa4+ChDkRVUQV1YOfXab1Zf0vrzHZ6C1Os1zhN3oeIvRnEc7b2lYNdA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Gb9Gv41MWxKuRjzGRSmkiHBXEURYgvmnB "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HyaSqepobGCEnAUg8+n1UgcwI1JJsUec12v9I6AMtNjTXI+dYBqF/ZtgX+VrwfFVtuysiMZhDpHXOJRewwKu8Cc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8XHyGBw9bNS42uTDLvdsRxX4w9w6YWP4n3 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IH66UVSHk/neUYSONUqppRb9cVIu9lwBpSJYs0BZx8pgfZkvVRmI2TqCbxgnfdFMtaEMhhckw7rnvMMoZenEAFI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Wtnqp66Ayv6nMRz5eFvwhdAey9hASNRzg "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IHQ1hhvqcg4XBJBc5ySGfbCXC67xvddBlmGucvEon+RfQx9LkEJp/I/FT9SKmu3fPSYkL0WocjnVu9Z3tpt93/0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VHvfufV3Dgyd4QuhpUpkxYymfrxXdZXxp "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9opV8BuPznKMuwS/HBjz6b3Htm51YyQ0BAID/rSNUukDLOyFUvEA06u7tWxSjYeayQuJme/J9FyN7gH8QlkBzc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8dCvHbMD8gvmWXCX5GxyfJuYNo51b9E9Cf "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ILlQRmBEg4rGY3LyeK/auF/3kc8A4PZOMzwB3em82A9DALHe19UMdYTtb2d1MC8H0hD2RmGnh7r2xs9ykvDIJk0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GKmgaxWxNMX7jdpPzZ46h9q25Ke9RFqh6 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IMNtrkjMJyLEz7f32R7qkEqdGI09Kb5eUN58+ns9kQTCZ9VZkpM1Ay5nZrAELHHXpz+E1rZl/pLy1Tqy5g7H5uI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8XctLWjNsRJByMrYCgNxqyw9F1JhGYoDNb "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IFB4Dn08/vdTA/snEDdhKpvObYoDc5R0ykhh0oRcm+CqCHCMOQy9zNXPlobIDzJeMKyUC0Qx1lbnUucDvFsg7dc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8PqDHZgJFVdv6yhBybVJJXgyZJ6yV9X98z "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H4sFSrEITZWEXM/bs3gg0Z0Mr3Oszf/4H2Pd6ArbUDhNCrLwB5tcpGAc9SrP7gjwxxUpuGPPTZgktjizf7FkMqw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JKyjTntV6gjheb8hfqmwbpzygZAS8zH9f "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/22AKVu7Rghw/cDraGzU4SHadeXIB84iQxHZABWZnU6Qlo7atSBhV48ymZhpQBqqB/axAOPxSXN6WjfMD3xU34=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8KQgqEh9Y7yGNoRFPALkrFy38KQ3eM3eLD "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IKNq8zX1wmMPGQZeakabdKv9+2lqxz7TZt7taZepmIr+NEV5n1nygDxcihIvLpzaPmGnSXXD2iigCKZFhzJ3hY4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8SYnYXHnZks3EhFQXKpWjCn9vfYBYWTgNa "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HwTPQf3l3kgtYg2DFQT8ON+uS6POo2BDeLBKZWI015epa15yybj8heEgDMUamVS58NEaw4Y/vxt+QtnDKuKnEiY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YFaw9FuEW4mGxH8HYfGwpVPtQRGoeaWsZ "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H39zUZicZJ4qnmo+D3xFJxfhf1xjWofmoKapMpZuLJMZOXag4j5lGh7oy+cMaZ9dAzE7mCRC1mLkXnNfd0wcBI8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8QAVD49TQ8yb79cZuNj2MQi2R5N7Sy6Lsz "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IEKORf2uEsGIabgyN3L1gg0oe1yy/xwZr0k5IhtO4/1uBBZvzV5d8gEHqIgaU5g3ITP2+WTp6Hvksb8hH6qW2BQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YhPXshjNHV5Cks1vVdJLZhUetvTtsJRXH "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPgfxwa9dseRBGR59mqUzccAmO8gNj/Ma84omDaYihssU3kE96gSFjVYkSvQxH1jiYr8IATS1e++J+JFNAuhyQU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Proq458GqiGXgpchDUCsnzwvEZUkcvYe6 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HylcoSlLrmgRAMWVXZwSU3N6mYA1XvpvvcJY3fYgXi52VlCdVflRDaCCe6T2zemThjxTvhXROCxH6a1yG3GoEW0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZUou87SmD92yeFSY11WNNJ34VwgpVVLEp "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hx7GiElykqg9q7ijKYVXutbvhhnQAo3Jati/Lwx/nsKMbqWLAbWet8xyk9NKierdZIgAU+Ks71Y77vw/l9zLQEw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8XnU3V2VtmD3WmNKApJGwVWfy5R4TpDtqw "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IEjkg2TPboBggOmbALd7BEWOObnpwS121jGwgbLpJse+ZGX168fStj/AmgWeJTdzZo8dkg7VyWjivB4i50jPTz0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UcEPAG2vwthvaBuN4DuwTx6ToghHpdFTf "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPy5keST3wjzbSZgAUVddOEe9D6PaYcNEQDTyX4oFxY/di7YX+Ze7+Z3oLmgGON5N8YqU7hSjkQRle66yZCtKJ4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GTKxhcLR5NnbURuPTAs7hyDnhFDnwgvPF "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ID0x9Wci2CHGdNXhVW2/jqwK19KU3ZmSVWv/VQnIoEr6MFYUSRHwUr4sKVrbeL8C7kIB9Ve5XcA6Yte4XSlYy8U=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JAY3WkuSbf2oPysqyB5bQFrVWeNMvEur3 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/nC1jBBnWIchzpXwd57UzSgAmTsc6DLTgzzYRaApxPDes8BZeiFPkmSQfMi2qXQWylQ9wn7dB+Z8J/AITky9Dg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8S2ChaGtGZhVefZNxxGpPKcex4oQX6JZfF "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H3/RqnAM5e9H50sfmvY08zUHlOK94Qu7x4qafrOfj/KvLALODB6eV6j57uZ++9L2CAzWWt65REh376Q9q1oTpT8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8P9k32yuLnRPxuR3RcgWMvRNNymvtYZZUA "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IK1588rIgkwQHgpzAen1vuLLtTXTvb918WF1C8vlLcdRa7MeF23xMrIq5MYD0EU2XQD+DT+qZ0EqPWLNVY76YIQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8cPdmzanux26wCkH4VLTzLkYbvP4HNbcv6 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IOZfWSwB2LE5qa8XVECt9Nrv7Vt2bZ3v3NusWvSAaf0DZtgErwCBlNQKHF2pYM9ky6PQBBMBzBeqrA9Y3QIbV1Q=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8FP87pxSXXWiWtBsWErbk6BwgwNHrPxABg "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+dECQttILYlNlLqK06FgYNCQ02AgvE0wU2s80PZ0BR8bUQ0/vufpBH5dhEGWlBS1faJAWcPImwyRXbJ6YZz708=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8d8BexiivTmCnzhdexyRKArU4RUHWg2B1T "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hyp6k++hArfjz8tQR5sAaZTniASSVQtcbbjEDvinuBbOFyCEozXY+epwtqljsIKqm+IQ1HRLyt9WysHRCre1meY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Z83D4Y5Dyua9LUJg73vEQBdYr7m3qwfbY "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HxuiyGHdFUU0lL+js5kSHx+61uCe4U7UmBpaOzU46p+Ubyjw8Lr9Dg0FowtV4tW1g1HoOxm6DL0BIOZcFcgj2kQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8KpgshJKBDaJ3zD8xDCPz2BSG7faiUhv91 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IIHtsq0fPSBvK3B3A665vqVOeCkrHWZc9EXk7/Si/XxSN+w4ZgBPwN3xBdFgFH7+4mRnTbMcqWjeyYH11ZBVcP4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8J1cRrojqowJAsmwE1HWvSJevCo5LuHvzi "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IP5HL/zab8d15D4EmlBICYtcLlQiIGFfG238mCpHMSCDEgi5YH3kd6MwMUXZnBNSUOC9SrcIhWibRjmj+lrGvUE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZdW61jiokJM7YTFcP38dPT29f1YWgLbxj "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H868BaXYrjth2bdjaH62TTW5quRqB6sNPzvhYMd4OKVlR1YBmIFLa7dElesrkkVpvfr4jD6aKaaBwjWZvgF4N+Q=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UC4dh9zE53K8XWSQg4oUy7YfRtm1QayKH "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/WinAHfVTr96bjoAtfMgaezHWSH79y6n+ObGCbAwTPuIFZFqSgrXLCliAOgKjEF0B1OYCMBsYLhSH3wbOXb0M0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8NW2ijCUHKYdAS2auMMV3GuscHaAFwaB9o "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H3VZVstDR3sllP8P60ojMX74qV/2y8UF7B7fiPSTRu95EgCANZmpoyLDXuh40tV5F98wKUUyxO+lJhrIYupoJIs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8FJvnsaKGmiAPwz23CSBi6p88yoaW3Tcqb "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H5YpQhhZ2ZOmQQ8F5ld8KBpqJFxvmoZutOTiGkmFJN/db307x5Cp52z3zxOBC3zSdApFnDZCjOkwYAsmK3l5LKY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GCrGgCTYhQT1c2gMkvFgTFEc2yVridibf "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ILRAjKSZESyImfZ6z0kLtI5a7UJLhM4iMBMkhYsV/0wWUjFnxWnDCnTTvFo4d8Lyj+ei5ryTs3Hm7sIoWGn+rlo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TNzT6pRw3Gwif3AmUfnHZrahEVggGScke "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hw8T1HmERx5k6NEWry+hsYTS+PprbhjKs8JAkf6ph8ZmdcivzCgKkpfODLT5bf2OjlL2Zi1N/phFMaDO6h2TkgQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JuHowYTsowci3fRjxSEtzhRogvx4ra8C2 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICf4Yv8RTXgdAFLrKhMRtsXa90FUF8vnLpraBZS5UxZ6ClsQ0xC8LGfu3L00k19tADPLfK+31pLdmpH/uq1qKjE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8NvgGPa8qHyRPxhe6nGFnS7CDkjgEWv1zM "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IDxhXGq1Eynwn0o9PGM8qEOpbRqp8LHccIWpLEU7+PZlbDOGO25sKPUGaLH9oOF7XGo0QOMm45LsPNvoiRfqm1k=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TH7ghvNFyfndAcAjVi5TKABtqTc5pKi5S "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IGLou1oE9w8Ca6D5iwm9CRuuMhB3zxTbJWeTRG3A+8g+RV9n3pLRy396rhtsFjvtKVDdBs5ql/weNz3O2w6IMes=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WHmcoPxhY8UWiMsPjYUHiBusAh5KjLs3j "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H3Hj8NFh7bJzAOkP8uaUKKMVuZSf+bUYW5WhkZvAUcoLX9Tx3MZd350Idxm2y5FSYH25+Ggj0qf0ylkXCxH7sM0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8K91J7hzygNGuLD4V98bqppatnaSuMYgCw "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ILl4w2A2JjGj9E2kKFdscMXpPIFNxjp+qpEpJ66nx3jRLQmxMHu9rdh06bkibJWTlHGK6xX+K88wJdtm7nSjS+c=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8QGdTUH6TBxdGtAPfP4esEx6ZpbgonxJwT "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H8jA79iu/fX4hxlyM1ppzrKPcidkvXjvdr9JghunS12kAIM8Fozn4fw6JhVC2Xf7gjOCdmldeFwNe4NUMqpovsU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8byb2vU6MBGFSa5pTrsVVB4iEbxrAW1EMY "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJHx6qA9C5wNmp6VYfYbffSl9tA2VVqxKPGgLQnkDbvGThHNY4nfsBbbUDvH/Avx0UfQORYujAbJ+rW9TuGFVTU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RVc8DhYkkBm1kEMxz54rNTk5aXV4oWQEs "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IG/y7tbsqLGKdJa8e45nMa+lcTZ1ZcQwis3sXbt8cih+QEAaKsdEAwCR3zuPXFgkXOjs3upQ4XjEsZfs93FKDLA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WqmeJQVQtae3AG3zYwoB5tDToUva3RU5p "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H58sEucej+XV4UhQOuBPD1q5zwGnGuuCiavWd15UsrwvCTx0PLl7Z2eSvkt4oa3pQ7+qy3aoeya2JZiHxPrxvLw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WSQoSH6YuX4F3cJAB9HB1vGx6Jg578Fkp "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H7qJwj2amArai/ZG8ygqLMdbGxAlDcxv1S4KKXBcY4niGEqxDrE6/+RjstzHzayv/5jUDq1ehfSzVljNXWwQKxU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JDSk74uqQHVajdtpx9AkBijMDzG1FGB3L "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IAcVXmfvPfDsInbzoFql3W9h1Phu0cpDVWNd0V2iNA4vbsPz8WGOg7VDr0mvy6QOt/ikz/dIBArp7pWlIYLm3pM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Wwciq63ydo5z4MT6BhHGJ4EC19AqJfwjb "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IEt9yegzondOlaYl/5KUo7NwBXnaSE/EDTRnWtLEgUU3fxWZcZwD9i6lR5TePbJ824VELHds69ptPcjBskKzZTM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GqVpTHTSkfz7SovgQ1b5WLNNnwyPMEzY8 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9qexpeKyGlueoccQvTc3vLa4AU5P56BzpzXs8m1krXWHVVW5uTumIVXTsCOISXwGsgo7mw4vyJYxLxid2GGJ7U=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JXbWMY4RoQGsU6QSR2bfdCgBRBTtpTaET "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hw27Q+Zeid0mXZv99M2IvpnRenn8vTbJkmzZxdEOaIVJaPw6D+0IkVeqCRDLLse4ehoqNhZPFAtuXeKLVqmQANs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZiTcgUw1zAU5cqC8NwBNY2oiWmj6yTkkJ "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPECxBzilRSGUs6NX9ZtxrVZpBkDqprxujkPhXzsgexAAU0WoKcKB2icCh3g0U28QQj3U+kc5ZiF9bCMpQPH7eg=

@Nahdonnis
Copy link

defi-cli signmessage 8Wk9Yfeyd7C4Nh6FTs6tmGobhBmPzmhmFM "dfip-2112-a-yes"
II/I9gmRIxuU1c+E4novwrXbITL6xGcJKSUexfa1WTEuYNaRE6fZGXz2TQFMYinCo8jLRFfmge68yM/UGWasZx4=

@DuBeRo
Copy link

DuBeRo commented Dec 20, 2021

$ defi-cli signmessage 8JBngbGW3R3m5GXzRCp45wPJLP8KWLDfXP "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/NMV9QGsVMD25EKBf5x9wCFCfs1sORJ+LGjGOKQ107+ENx7pOYZ6WYImeQF5dAE+gA2p3zSUKjB+72kI+4ZQpk=

@sandstumpen
Copy link

signmessage 8XjGQuumUBGyevsG8Jn4yZQ6QBpkA4ukgM dfip-2112-a-yes
H7k8D+SMOWTBksob0c+AMH1nVtlJSG6CfENqZhAfe6DoZn/NNG10AHYxA1Ntu8B3caXBMDg6Lc+BPI8ThTMagcY=

@uzyn
Copy link
Contributor

uzyn commented Dec 20, 2021

Summary of votes from eligible https://cakedefi.com users after survey:

  • 130 yes
  • 12 no
  • 5 neutral

130 yes

$ defi-cli signmessage 8LQE1MbVTd2NLyUmxQVdjAc7A3qcpnjbFB "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IK/5cr04nOsuzPoHZhVgoRz1fIKeMPbEOiyoF6IUO4BoT2pmczz8xD7qRiiWLO6w86py4yDSbT2QI1jJTDWArAk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LoksVmGmeCFBEziUhPM25T8vnWXjTY8hG "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICZ3odv+3gNV5D6gxkkFql+OGwE+b0FPXu5MhIfYJ8DgXAAjvuQQqO7tdD8sStNxjtFTOoEkhHs0iY7dPMi4sRE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8QupBjGKw69RTUCvXmjsSfUbsJHoRctqC4 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H4Bnci97uVIwwpYIvz+RNXxWw3Hsc/uGJoEMXpxIz4fEfi1yzklsjxB9IqTH8nhSnQQajexTaoDO66VlvnxFe/k=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8H1ULdCAEdpEAX6a7vG9tHceWRBWjWWFWb "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H3GK+AiIpl2mQ/NfzmFB9U+CLmHB9ppJZiYQ3Y0cnIOxYhLMXWuch+Oz7UZzeTA+YKvM46esZeNqt65ykYaZ8hM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8W6CSGt2AQnb9VaVRkdqfVkAWiCYHWPULN "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IDspdBfzodszHoB8evAezMrWsIV3OyLlfDBJ1HGXv8GZPXh8NhOKxOOi1qjURFBBs5kZUR/1C2usB+tKU6GIIeM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VBLzNi1TdHwQHWg7HbZcR9ZSkequXs6Up "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IBkKcS+RsuZDW2cOsYAPFoxIa+iMlnUUSGRZ25vP35rfLKeAElixaMjMC1dYV+YdbhbM23VQC8h44fbHRrwUd9o=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8U94KePNHgnQj9Tdh3nCrgVD3jrYqSiZeM "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ILqA5YehKT7PlHgUJ/0oyv5tYDU06eENF1nuy4L9BwKdEklq+ijKXqhf9nCBTvKQ6aXhWVphNlq2X6Fw3lfyTFg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UQJQ5KZPojS1DdhLuFwU2uyDUxeggAuzJ "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H2WyAptGGMmc8RE9KIZNldz97aWd4Cu6TFcgsq5Jz4F0Jvsv0P0nVPN5We0LnpYASe8j4AeERgAoqFJMAzlEK3w=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8FvmrHART1vUvRC7yMqHE7Yfaq4M9TxvCZ "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H6Qkdu0Z8sg1df11hq7XK/A2erbSpDkXNNInh9JYFsJXSAu35RYigetvD1WsrjoVXLpIUcInwNfxFM99lIsgcJk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YpwhLonjsz4K28UksHtcEkduW9y2Z1AkC "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HwFP8wFnI9fa4LI75dRg+qyEBr2Gr/xoX+6f77xbVeQYBj/rXs81doV2EghvbJGjGdnojIqlhWYC9zwEInf5uGg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8V8VFKY9QsHFjqPZ7TZUw4gJWbPaH6kDPU "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H7OaZgCd61Ud1sQomy1r0A73ZE+b0C9V0xd9mEqIV1UZbg6HfJlWA8NUGpj7eFjx8PG+3ArxaF532OYqy1fTxag=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Fd7s8dSxXAJ9GJgRLW99yvKkWMwT6JdiQ "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hwq35YjVBb6UcOG4k41iKqiAVxTqXzOilOYPR6g4HwcgD0G8ciOm3G/IgoA42jW0Zxm6QwZ9jIC4g+MVJshXS7E=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8H6fv2NtJQ9Q559rXjkzdZkMceQzdKgyTo "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IImjqXvM8CLLNmeyiv1Yemwia0m1iSqCzGzvmIeDls7CcGy432TMzpqXpht2S8sMsF4Y1DHavQHj94BsGaKoGvg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LLNJSfspvTQ4ygY9vMYyhuuph5ifzchJy "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H6ffB4YR8icQU6PPt+N1K32z1QeLjSL22YCN8WrISn7LdzrjZJkWwPpokY5APr8H/9XTGatj4jn9UWQnpQ9HLys=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WhqJyDLXLiJgePFTVkUHpRZ9CfFaoQNLL "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+ZZ9rKmgTPCDbhjeKDtocKYHfMP0tEWqpyu2R2o7ASBQihfP41+xfMpHsZkhkD0t5prc58S0jgKLMQO2POq2ZY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LhSrRi4mpVtjY7R7reGT3Uv5embLfRYLt "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJgnMm/hBo9c/jSPdlMLcl10M4g/eTtFyLWuifFOHfYXQ9TtKNTACSt1/TJeX2+0fMZCHpbZZTL9kHXK21fG7+I=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JNF4s8E6awasceNvFVwfDwkVtMx8CD6yE "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPM1NfpYM4KAxmvbRufdyD2U5DwaWVnMDxneA+JZSWRDetZ21LdbtOfdovFZ7lMTofW4UwA78wfBkr8ZMlXaLto=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8XcZSNv2ge8uKCmdzTtY2TbLcUf3xsUMfs "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICy4r0T87OV3g5pKWfQqU0aU8/hkL3GukxEgkg7IUvtuTDBGhXtDSVRvV57p50kyOdc2vzqAPfc2LSlcygS4U9M=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Xoypn2whNw6ATknayiHXyTurRMkR9AF58 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IHfAwZ3uV7r3xLkavw1WCkdCJCIWU0fYPXuwNyBs7p0/arwo9sYsuWYSFPTKQyDBfjBC6DrHnK7FaDMrppYl1D8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YcEwJqHTKWLYSVGHp3w2knkhyCzNXSqmS "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICSieg1E3rgO7FrJxogIG/yWZQWhaGF4hZCz5TLDRhFTBE2rMK/B8S7MQbQIVy9T2SCJQqQffF8DtupBKpkM1bo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UoBUAVDxrhxuzvgnt5Rtm6cEpmNamjcZE "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+iKJ8MGycxWxcdeiSASmXNu63lwwrXGSkbCVyZyoTvDauwtnxxBUFAZqyEce56KAi54mcKmxbsg4O7ztfDVa5s=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8J9cKafkM4wtjEVFUZs84jEhnEQE3sYier "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H67CaKDvMAzpJpnjUUrUvo4HDh2MxxiFsvE3/LX4Sg4GVl+USZtIGUf7KDwmPxQsqPELVatde52az69I6pGQKdI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8KKK92SVGqesUxr3txVdgprgEv8cCZ3EEt "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/obiORUfeee6cWwMdZhOQQEXNJ3MfnyXnxKWe1DgGLCZqraazHwbo9cwhwDsvDAT9CIGQb4vjDCgMNUlCcAInA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Mv7Kg2ZEfC6oPBcoWPa1V9DfGYmJraDuX "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H6sXhVZqELV8qIhxj5nvHDcHd7XbFcsjWUkUQoqpU06XBA1PeL1/dcgTZpFyNuEyWNzN6ycayhnt/OZSUbY28TY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8d8N1PBFFvG6fsDq72bP6PXC2JZZHWoNKe "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9cFe0k1VXgPtq1MTRh/nyDNHrFA/3nXfk3GGAVWIDKcKiqrXgGU4DQBOpU+qaDvB9ELPcbS3QpBWv5hVAvMNS8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JQgeF5rCqLkEoiSsW7f5Eb7z6CgucY7Nj "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9suEBia66sLP5AND7HvRRsm4HDSFUrJBqFoUhRr9pMvfClagf3CMYAn65i6bnp8l3S9SKhyVKywv0VEDx/QZt4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VxohuNsyCDRCxTA7so5ar2jUFGXVdmU7Q "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H7tGpIDVuPU4Im61IN9hwzAkbob+VXqO7XOHQzvGnRX2KBWta2eyP39a0bwlIL8Z7FJ3NGAIzAb6Bp2nfiH4qS4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8HbdJdcMG9ZgdA3e5KDU7eQQb52je3gt15 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IMByNZm0QxeSjNsgmma1+XYtoWZ/pubucIm1usWIkg0XVbjOXZd4mkyEQPDP9tNjqekg+d4LNTuy8R6zAT4NY20=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Wed9aMxrB6cdXrphCze6JaL8RszH8GURm "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IOfVdTIjjsGeXZR6E2x8suMc+F5nzpojXGBQt4uaixb+BfdWC9CUqtVPjKWPtHnY2bao59/8En6gt2szmLrRAik=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8X3KaUcjjwUFoZSRCTGEHe4SfW3eQYdhaF "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IINNYDtotS6HHHwKdR4novIWiBBQBGPqua72OvlYvmEXcax71JGj3gjwgn9FjEYD5PhGB57Cwzz3wgaX8n8SQFY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Rt2wuBuWM3q8UVZJDb1EvRvbEswFthhYY "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IHQrHYLxnQ1gwyaakvIu1CNqn5w6c1anz6TgWyWDuZQhQibAegAG6ua82wAcrctCJqbEmLyWsI1RZC0Ts+OjiRg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8cWBMKZ114bMEfU1D4cEhPLcJNQCLboJ7W "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HxOxWD6K6pys3GjA9S4dKwy9Ck71Dw39yln/Tsr1F9sPL3Qg08g+cAzGGHHeZ86GA26eFkFYoBYpO8ze13CL41s=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WwSDFBLcdf3onf1khvmNUTi2rArwQsh6Y "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H3I1tvu/IYE8ZYvtC4hl3F+eibdlSsXAjHpxuLDQExcXAK4IojRDk2eKLSmc90LyOKn/Xya9xewew15S26Kruq4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Waw4AquJbY2yboLjgQhSjV5MJyneC4bvR "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IEENx1JtIRfoBpNWvXxH9FWCsTtiVd8R4nRrySF3Qj2McLdfipfbfA3GZurSqmtKU4P0BI4AZ6hN19Nj+qNzB28=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8SxytTDhbwr4TdywMnKDr98hfnKieNmM1i "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IAMIoGSKlnKmp8p+lKJG5l7oiuwqz4d8GMxXYwpsziseflywlw6QyEFsg3yXGuoIgCdKhLa2pw2TeBggqEct2nk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8H9uoNTVa4DxfURmpjfZhRKmyi5uT2PTzJ "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H7fyGoQxmaHb9pt1pFno7FEPiuOMP0cwBdTu5iY/y2pbQ+z26LNY/oKaHPeaS82GN4Cu1e3U14kgOYBwxPvaVMk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8KGnZ74yjaTvBtqh3mSXpq72LZqgYu1rGh "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICF6MZaEI5JpDQk73tLZqDJROISX+kVwW/YBWsBGfGTQWk/8WewNyo2vI9c68lYzkukM6lhKqj/d/drZEVVvTwA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZzzKLdXTLA55d1gSp6SFWcFneAG4SCfcA "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IB9AA5CVXuDtVIIUNfQJhasjvGH+Qpxe70JLXg/DkPKPafefcHqfl+V57aqVvvwCx26lWjCG7dyKdnwu3OuTJn4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WvZMpGeVoH41fRLh5rrFXFnFqxWs9wb4A "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPMv7jE6ewZFQZqaTrnHuLy/F6uYRlOY6fkVhZNgc2/KVaR5WgOZTpnASXAqekx16HobeddM2TIxfrhYDI2eQUg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WVqN8QfWsCPUyYqgDAkbSSPad998ZsJ7K "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPEu7GCr4BX2Of/bBs8YN8ib9fG4mafHbFBrer8nfBDYTyO/M7Dm9fKR9kYh+snV2/uiP/ESmcySE+DTsJymQWQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bXUUW3jT3DnG9ZviSpSvxSBKcWpmDFEAH "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H0r2629GBLP+0bfKeyoz0ab8S9f7hVsOZrz61ISLg3E5GB7a0DirhuAYvrL4GQzlRyL+ruX3tyO3AWCn5kwCq4o=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aofKcKDwW3ZAQ9nS1XZmGk7c2j6YM6m3p "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IIXLZ2lrbQwhUJm+D9TGE4Zgn0V0L5NkPy3Qo0g59It1J/xEMBPbWR7M+YvCx8qB1Eczhw/+0Wv5NASbj06BTT0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8eETFGSUdWmCYCp8SKCiewBUc27Hi5La2b "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+HAYfKgralZt6tR3oesEALWPKnpcOVfCPJOe2jVJX1gDDYKtzLu37G+eP9LrZWYsXe2MAruuoXyhAjugN+LrIw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8c2Bknr6QkpJz4uVGVVEirXrmUnVkQ8BnD "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9q8grBbaN1dKV2Bp3z+TBPkJXYOOpdajYP6EZNHthpMEhm/exvdY8Xjx1vA78YSUYmHlL1cT7FEub98KiBiiLo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RLuJNRzNyyYCVUK4rSKTz4jE5eogJuS9m "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IDPRMOvnrCdyoDvsI2vTSRAMVsJadzbTfgAir+3lffi1ZVFgEfFn7rF6/FKPeTQ4mAqijOpsAmLlENBP94SNNzI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YEq2h9xorBSJVoUmpeyYxdX49MRy1rTam "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HytR9vYo+DTCYXegrfVErNSLWmp+XoIPFJLreYOUwQlTFjULH0Wnh6zSOVkp00WkMBKPfPTLHayDnfRKwjXY2sU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Tu2oETx9Ud87dw9NxU1JgfPbC7NT9KUf6 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H7SJu1x9Kn8w9M0LuWTabUoq7Q/z+Ix2OoNOVWtIcO0GCWHXrC7zT8CGc+k9jX4/cGt9BH2EfAf5Byo07fFXPIc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WFKC51GoXu9FjF2J1u7LfsAPk8MUAWMkT "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H45zwHgRrEUBua344n9SHIjpxje9gqcdtCljUkWrYBmIFYHJ9Cinc1619GBwN26ivRqxYVBPqmeMM/HKmQAoaC8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8FCti735amK34nybQkQKVGMA4K398oBENx "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H4UIDxNS8MvF5fI/rL++hSGRsqKSPHazy2Vmb1o0c7oPD5btvEOG2/qpwveAiry3fvm2Uw39cdJ3TuVoArEsn08=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bi6KMY12BqfB1XRPe7eYd1HftqFWZBjs9 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H5IzJQCK/d6UbnXx3AzlVuV5uhhRpyRZamICKocpoiiDcPg4W8vbFC8lKifMZqfQlMYsURo4RR/bej9nQsNHI7A=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8W5ZBh1FmseZU2SvJRGuqvibb3AF7nKXQb "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IEV7SoVrfgQls773gxOtIF032WOFSK+IjQYISH+iD+eHZeYMHEDoBL0l3NopDpIl2hmY7U7qYVfUClR4V2RfdbQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZzZPPLjoPSh6uQD8FKpk8jB5riwpryE3n "dfip-2112-a-yes"
INFD2ImoE5h62vXRNLfegFn3J7Ru/ia0EdqkSJ0bO8utBt6FRP1s0p0nyXI/GkOs/hLWr5agWpEMjcvTcYclo6U=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aaQDgwZTKxxYiSH4jVz1KEeDuYwqjU2g5 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IMMfoaHXPOh0RUHPzW+VqMMTiO3VbwFRkNAyXSUnls4YE9xv1nBYCwaqB+0LZWmlLKDsUfNDeQkr1ea67Z7C4eA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZcArjPhpid7pudPpXLYSABGcoyr3LCUBj "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IA1Fl7KZqiWMhbfrFfS7spBv2R/tAFrJ80GUQTihxxWuQxd6pjgA+rYb3F39XVAgU09jObk9yJ3yvvwQgDDJrPw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UnBhtUgDT2r82iTxw37o1YQUkonCSC5Fc "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJBSErc/Rk2pYv38Y2B3WWfr0YbW07cnZ9QQez29v1eFWnSSFk/lV22ttMRdaXQG6yXH7Q68hIf6Nc4IeCsoRjw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8MDRLvoJhekqCLFDpfX8h4SkAnLj1tVQA4 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IDnkj0Ma8ffuQDa6xTmEe1Vo9KC8qh8AuIo8XVipsKZZbezSgmFp+CA7/Rux5on76PjBAzMzsg8nNBJTxwGV/vw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VSVVu5mC1pF9H4FHqiBmMKqEPEcCVpkXA "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H7pbBQs9zXOVswcsEMOsLLFuGTTVZZ+Cyy8SktpUq1JNLgHERrorwWNK9S7EynqCpFNaxfXDWqntlVcXPkMdBSg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8P6E2H9hW7vVyJYqru6TmUr4tSmQuTLDRH "dfip-2112-a-yes"
INmuLMY+ghchqKS9Vk1H7H+OB96AdqnJW5FLhGst7+9CY0svTqmrqO3KsMcp3tDCxG9WXtlg/sVlftnNiTyY4/s=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8K7MbCnCb7ApTTUT1VXTnd4EfeJamcKShi "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IAmjppMd5zpnhZNPZ0P2yEvs8tkLQUWsZa/+rH1Ky5+vSn35V+7xpiHeUP9bdiZ0rUTHP1M60321K2TsfHVM4VA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8NvxFoM2Jszp9bcbG68nfswimeFuWbdJG3 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hw7BRbRd3snotlOI5T4fQUDZdMlFWk9pCFdcYR7njCVoKrKyyvgzEe2RV1vgcHTUnGZYNyGhB5RuIRFp4eHCMiQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8MrckRinMEmJqDwdQJEK9UVRsoTz5N9yoS "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H2UEb4x9m03KthZUCopgFvh4OSXQid34yU2TjL9h/EWJRKQeosG8RKrsF0Ed21mq+2KM6rwvUZML/5k+RO8oXoE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TZkvfzssMJh5LQFqeAdnveS6aZ92RRLJ3 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HwGy59170mrQCLo8c7okla2SISfRtLbf2M4r+5UiT9WjcrIICHpBBjI1Rqnc6xp4JmlgkPTXy+OEE7omqTJxXVw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aYgbVpbc6PFDLbVFZwDZdsvzbvHab49dG "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H2ZXSXZ7ik8soks63NL3OVH9xqtz2jWEwXdY37xtGjE0Nyx971SC953qDLXh1oL0GYfLhn0QVYBxWxcPe4aoSUw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8NED5fequ6k2it7k9mZN54qpDdwDNwSsU7 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9gRV1fLnTVusVMKnq4kugXpW5P/ZoMlOQA3Lzuj8G1sRGz7TBGNJPYs3kn00PJlLu4VwErB51ZAfZKKXzhvyAE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8PQGqdFDFKBXB1pcBzHJpanDnuutYaih8q "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H6S/NiZI0XBGr1ElfjnMIYYQul7RFiyvYpjU3SSFIrP5VAqWPD5NRnRSvCFS4s/ibg0KuO47kk/Qo0Mc1Y9eDYE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GoBZyUjQdZZjWaUms1TxmSx8D8vydW5Up "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H0MalRR5hWrqA43zRwJtIHlVj15odTVskXUzkAq4N7cJUhyfpK0fLhaZmE79wfgWfAB6YsRxeYdbT2pCSrRIloY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8dSpZVxisBr9UfG8HbyUU86hydVJL7Ef5J "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+GGN6i9f/Ar2ajRwufOpF4bTcfHc2t/CLT5cBc2rVzbOvMzqz1K8jp5BSqg3o6mjPlCsYDy+ch4eVWA/wAAHms=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8cppa8jZb23eDcds6S5ox7XaKKg699r9JT "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IE0qERMcr0wxSX2zTbXIAQ+fOr3P+H5+g3lMTunrPL9jZEzxzOf/9V7bdFvnXRt3Sc3VELr7b8qm33VncG2h5LU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8JDFoSmyX5VEhntveK9HrcoHZS2tuj2quM "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HxbmNcaqHRdYxiM44EUo2jqKxVyMPtEKrXXbbWuUqWNkJZ57mHoUrzoXQvxoubg0EuNXQ/zSXNizZRYZIjzAtVs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8M767wCwdvtFwYDm8hpeVAQxBk6rTNUcdD "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJOkvQ8aoYdjbZWd+dxC1bsVFl03FyZ2k7l5fgqM01qLABBoyAS+l1NscQyKiOs3K36a9pX3nB1QqzkGJnMdcm8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TqoNqksKuUY641vMMhf42tSSSdTKx8R4q "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HxIauSzeICUP+QLZqFC21l/acR3zqceIloGbaB90FA3vFV2biNi+0ADL8XAPHjjjCKdhcK1Kmeecyj7q9bE6qNs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aYtzUtcPJ9ReAqCRvNGeDHKohgLYcR6Ft "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IFMO5rPs0GdVFiGNUBcUUx36a1AFHPwZfg8JakF7FcvQYNTajW/8ni9DRND3vSgmnt2RTnKPG4v4Rta3AznzvfY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LosoHS25r49vAkVsMcQsFggPeH177Vjhd "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IE/orcgQpfo8VtpLYkbpZ+Qr1cN0WD5mUs0/v61kWBKXGOfDTO/7S5lr3SjU4tRL1He43FKlBuWbXb5HmBVHL9k=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8K4QbLmm7rh6yrHoDitNMNhjJJpvVYzKvM "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IAknABdabEKKrCGkcIOfBRUWCuRa8gvfzBVNxjR8Aiz2UYvue+HRYujddwg6eVuu85pKfnJzxiyi04Gm4B95GvY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aTDHMVuwCaEjycYzCjHYWBmCymhbFKsbR "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IBrqXz34KqgC1CvVHH03MqZaNm4ZTEEIWSbxYE99UJ4Rf+j2BPNeXFiO7x3aL5lmbOcDfahvDDkFIHxB56REMLc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8SQkqxhvE4EUfQXbUQskqKAZvE6mMVLnTm "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+Y43v42TRnt8/fevAUv3asEZbBTT2/CJFhTYqENBxRfbjfjdpODpR2VT2vwe565LpzksxIIhZV2r+IXo7dEAIE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8HyegERjH7BmYuQDzZ4zKiDZP8PRtvLsfN "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H8grnF4jhcWgo4747jESQUuQLhCI0bOmowNFnCMbI+g4V/xxmQWOtOLcIlYfPQr+7Wa8Bn/77gmxXDI4Vcb0e6g=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8R86SnY3sNUUXGpy2ToLYJqBGqaTTHarcE "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H95HLCJE5wxSsMmwGmD8iAQCHyb+KO8c6Yg+85KtpQ6qTpz+8p88zHiblsWy9gpho4/pQBthfOYBwlcLherQy3U=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bYruVHN57QMEAbMPJdRabaKQ7j2CuJtXN "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICIex8NVsDJ7bnaawwnQP6BEu2Fy9wb1m+4JAGvlXyzmAYYuN/3g9bzhNZYbTul0c9bXlaZLZLmo0U9enpvGIWs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WqFQc9C4ujoFAzt7fitKGPUZ88Usr8qbn "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+d7mlNBs2ibYdtIM9qhBgSXv/n94FKT+PyuZHQsQ5e7VnvwDcwWuJ5ujylAo9Fliql3gLW2xbitDmqeuk1Ru10=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LQUyr8ztGa7tvNjRZZreu4R3yuwDuVG2N "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H6ShxIH7H99zw8CNDCy5BAr9jTjN5KhGc68VyHJMb89vJtfQb6C76L2lDsUN2BCO9Y7M95+XT+tpwF1JcVgVi1U=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RZJwYj5fYPNLGkcB1KgiDhUUCVD8NzB7o "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICS6fUPHywFYGKpMINslPbM/2Jh5+8K5X0H0fppOL7nUXcJDKpImFWZXQR6tfSfyAF1bkm0lS+W1Meg+xQqS1Dc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bpvFXHTCC9jPBvKeC6dLVab9k8LnmuzoD "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICZd+iSu5C/+hrPtRF7Kj79SM/TLAq9eOUft0TLCF+cjNHT93bYluO62QgroKayno2YlPwmd2yGNSFLVRx/fQ9k=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8abBgv8y8G1aCV5hwkfWQVG2h7JJKXHk3P "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPEznAjdugzNUN4qtqLz8FRR3srGcxfI/0utgL9G7WHiO18/7RnQTg1gpBhXJ+lsx8jjDsR3glJ0dCDu8CFzXCU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZAF9MJjecV3m15HZpubNe1kq9ro4qPa66 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
INkV4T9n6az/DveARHVjk56ifm8GZuzfNLl1Dvo/5z5uYpr3v9YnL1jl8kDz8wWvGvGWQu/Avv9TDFdDylsN66Q=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8bpw4qKZDH228tn4iHqKnwQc7oeDaGmMHz "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IMrJL6q5bpgCLqSO7GIEZc7xTadt1XUCpTATO94svO/+BKkA6368NiAOUWKFr/0SlvQQ7i9Nu++qgo5JgOZAtXg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Rs2AehJ1uDgNBagFJbNU55BUixmYwVmAB "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hxn0/WyXUO4E+NBTMEZNfHKBvN+SQZngpYckRoMo+4ryK4zya9AOMzOCbvqTNZeXHWwXrgRw9BrcE3gRl9ebQkw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WDwASHC2Gygqbh2wQ6dbPRcMToE5NqT63 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hy8JngN8f9cUD+W3M2/yK/UeyOpxvtn6CYoXxgXCEFYUIlhZgdwitvCpbgdmNS9yrPyvIQHgsHiyawG5LoMPjD0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8FN6cGRAPMTwiBLRzHAh39BkZokFCkcJRe "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IBlm9h6MaKOwbUB9leoXAwBMyPwtNI1miyLsxNgKW1ixBQpBNweeo3hW7+zab7tZ4jSFXuXXBfuZMyv6qGYcDSE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Y11b9QrRfS2ZDwQBkPBxF1ehhdvi4kTV7 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/TiCmzar4q+X+hS4e59mi0z6goMWQN4wOHuz9twuKS2Y5xBjL8M7TZr4KkFVx6J7EXXu30ttSo8oDVfan/HH8U=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8QDoF2PTapJVkL7Sj7G6yKwoQn6KMq3mEq "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HxXEIWhNXusFnBGUlohFchQg4oOaVuA+FR5CgSmciSfOWssMEl4uvoCk5C3hRgGV8BGF5DtT/pmDHTg45PFBjzY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LGrb7TpdV8atZ2fzXizpvkLitPvsApvJ6 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HxIjICczPERGqnCp82fOSGM6GTnJims5uu/ZP790v5UvRGQqggRQtQQ5F8jWUvEQx7ZmEZFF6ssjY7dD4sQgUO4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8M4SFdQgv6mV3zFTMbH3Mv8EsRPWGXXJg3 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H1TImw3YTQsRLeMWOhaCF1tkbv/WvAXMy8i6B7hUYmpIXuFoYsFCvKoLVQWXrLnOlDt91GgfNSmtHgHZeTh/oEA=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aLNtWKd3gGYVfhdbRNjA2qbkLkTSmzj7k "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IHx9XJIbzepRACCu1QIjy1turJ14M+oHOkLgUpAKU+kPFXE0/99zVXaHh9t2VXJ3yCBjajIMcNjtKKOvpG3eU5E=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8dzgrtVJ1KMigZs8WS5n4R6biE2jdsbLu6 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H8kNJ9fecbSJ9tl9TitLeqzT/sbVzZ1VC0Phjl5XL5z5JYPkgq4k2+nwWdOzWUkSC4Yj57i9idyE1bo+PM4wFvs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GuL9RvCPD9crWfBnbbvSDdAw98dxLj8VL "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hxcb0SquMRxYUcmWttuwebr8x03rxMQFYk+EmhCYrSaAMqFguobdV9qyfNdkea1E7G0aOO05GNel1DHhgo+b9AQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TYxiK2t9iQaamFJwQ1Bjn7g7GndMXrmUP "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H+OHz8mpbA48XMaNeBZyn5vZIjYsIjRcLBlGBJKkhnG+DZb5RZIOPFlM9EN8lQIx9ZSGStD0WHwTEzvPmMFZo64=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8dGAhWVcqicKtzybjxekEcRuLXDqcXpe3D "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H5zy9R3L2WzARIuNFiMjPknqOC/FyD9odGHXD1G/05F6BTWUN9SIf32VBiPt4B+sW76DtgnKi1uN6dxZSUiXZmY=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8cXB6mkaYvz7V9asNpzjdQu9mtiVWjVZNH "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H0/fCmvsQPwEG3rehpjTEqkcGgaruzAF5YiANMZdo0VGW9ZwPPUolO3TpPLL88JKPHcsTY/1t0EwS5xPTqxoVCk=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8SkLGGTaAMcqfKsREz7TxkyQB981YVMdsE "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IJ1xyBzHk90x7tDzu7+GGczy8LvUyFRzbJQDkVNIchche/BLyehs2HcgKDYMwKb2Kxk15YnHa0pGsELplbrsWOM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8MA9xthKGSQjKDFCHA8D4xsGQNJEC8phUM "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IMXWYi5r/lHc++KHJy8Df8FXnPEJAqpCqH45jPV9z7sQNz2pPY72yFT8WMzXj8I7kprKZN2+C8PLTLH5kefJ1Vo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8ZfZsC1HiSf55GivvEdvR2JXJU1G4N7fpe "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IMzG6qYCRtzk8U9i2HlfxYrjdajdwWS97OP2JNIPypbVZfrVSjE/FhCzbj8kjkf2tmHsgkW+OzLrjSYDNS6BYJI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Uzfy7TMByLMtexDsGdVjesDKqCWzo7tLn "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IBl/wSyoSIXiKacadM45f+DX7QkTZWS63C5nhxnbQAf9WLgHslZu0tkrM6Bc/EFx84JFp/VX17+S3AJ/nrpcAi4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8MX8bUDFdLiU9KBt46DFLWF5pd67pcAv7m "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IH2p98Ahxd4/+wA1iIcN0N250cUBvZjlJX3qIUIhOThOetz8dWL3pxFzL6civ7/41GwkdIBTajp0APfmCZOP6lo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Q1ZDLjw4Vd8F6US74S1M394BwnCcVPj3Q "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ICl0xV/A6uwrlsHkNPiXW4SjXPsFaTNOmKgTYg/uG+O7DvBK7I1Cj4VtrYwx4DecgoIAhKzASMnyaER/gQgLSh0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8R2qzMjdNr1qVRFv7PJoNh2YBQqHj5UnEY "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9cxObXuQxRt2+3T+ILjLzUFTvogTydc0/8A5dIslHRdTAqr19lw/sHaaoQZyLeaL0YNxmqwhrUjlJvC7pPcLTM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aJdgaPNPibHLZ53DDuixHaGJPu9FZpo6H "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/KzPf3E4SCvuiL5KcIdF0yk+v1ip5O1lMzOFyy3gitQJGVuVtkx+UGOk7YmByyVLwp6kGWPc8r+RyiZJVp621Y=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8TmWwUooCSj6qK5C6tzAK8fX4Fq87JKTee "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HxSgnOz2uT/PqjsKLqZSJT6zMAbKJKXhdM+wf6qk8zIXC3EURwCXabdBlffftvrfSpN5WVZxU/8loFvncmcMsp8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8P8khzQAZXwANwKkopYRABebRfu8hNWmVm "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IGjmBNtbDWDF2bIETn+TE/aHLO2NPwLlRpNCcOiV2w/mO5wduPM2ObETi/YWCrB0vO19Gc+bPNZmeF60hxRaZ0A=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LQU2tXseU8gi3gGvHpNZA7a9oAKmr8hLn "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IPwjhPddsdmLhfgB6YV6rT3DlL8rvz0BOoYQXS2IaD22bTUF8puIGxj1uR15cX+bJKBCfl9pYpDbYIZ+8UVHZm8=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8e9wzU8xskNfdXZ5dvfsKsKPPmMFRxSA3D "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H8LGxnboHyB1CEiNJNK3CFZG2O57Jexuu06FWF6zz2yBed1P9FL0QV5BXJ15D7HwzelHrWuvTA3ITA0EmCUz13c=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8SZvmaPSu4cWW7Q18A4vAvCKxX5m5p2D5L "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H3dP6lxX6TRxulTeVKyFW7kNeojt9XyVOZdl0c8dMixkDYsg3ifPfrC1n9463Bsg6Xc/J1njkJXhPUjtVjgMOpw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UzgK9stQbcEsLo89CfaRZK3FYJse5DeiA "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H8+LYoJ9T7OPAwORYc7kuvOXLvvANjLY8dE3UTX8UJU9eidO5ZacHV2DaajEyGIBYRnDS+7lY1AopjxSTnbSV0g=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8W3C2XR4j9CgvmvSciZVh8jtfrwiqJKkV7 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IA607726ASrRfXoZhTMgVsmjOinHmG385p7N58HYdKyWT4WfDimoyJOM/ukXhQWwhpmyj+WzBI1MVQyZN5GZDD0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Sgx8t7CmD1bsKhRzcZSFxxu6tPU6XUGfW "dfip-2112-a-yes"
Hy+TYC2Jwz3sHLmAwBRU3WsVPG2/cbb0fU3CM1xRQeEvKGH2/ZGaJFKGHuNIL4AB/NZ99YzrFW3sKiMB62kQ+rU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8PToJuBXQmB8GyPcRUszA7sFKEzbe9CjLu "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H8imqiaUo3x9bGx5EsKJ/3EtdL5nWjlL3WsT17oUpSb+KKUhx3c6TcYTDT/bKbh8SqEG0uKm40wzfxyrQEz8+xM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RoFKAh6M3rbWw2Twf1KY2C5bmfihxb8YY "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H9smlMm8tW6iAyDIJhgi73yZnHQVo63NE61a8bPnDj/9M8nwRzOOb5nH1NfLti1esUUH1ClZrjv2NCE9aYKgUSQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Zgjtp5UfoRhyF4X7cMUPHUw462wJLRQ7k "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H1jZyxcWBkW4KAff2U89wuGQLEGixX8TcLLYf2OIxXapMNpslIU32hvntO3HUF4n2iUCPpT+l+g/wNKHGpEfF3Y=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YVzv1NBcseNh4mt9JDqu6ZvegHCW6hdYA "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H2xwWRnSmvdpsIyrQQFaphtLbBlcMDeNeMLBfDA4lWLaO2n2ml0lmQeO9NvRe516zSQ/aZ5GmZpTOASvK0vR+Qg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8GWfMTnJdPcfjRsdTVErFoZseqArUZsZ2k "dfip-2112-a-yes"
HwLUjUbW8lR7jaHIfTF4ATZu92QgCOwB6bpS0vttKujNBTyCczarGscTkeJxX0ydDlwYunI3c2EPaowx3V5DcuM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aEsz3dsd5Z21zfqA3Dw7jgy3QWpHsYz72 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H1tVrXo4bFf8RP8Q23L9bNWEkjgmCNJK+pR3+lRFnO5rU5J9Bq5/kqtvdw3Ncl3rIVI/BgU9QkdIr/1gCTKAync=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8aqXetSP2XNF8M5G3uY6ab22yEBaWLBVA2 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
ILt8VZMu0tsJGsbj/K3KvzCXBEiO/asJtjU07liPqnhFTNZqOLEtT6SgXC1t5sjjRxbb2ibuQ8CJiXkcCO64phs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Q4nwQHE4G7Gvdu69AStvrspeDeLjHypsP "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IBfXhmJCwRRsJ/fIBftOqkz3VvntMGFL50PucJOCLTXgYngvyv/y6UaBKZJAQBwsfnMMp7eO5Xk+vMXUg2N1Fbc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8WYDhsWfkuhVHYCVug145gsFtNFEJbjMaM "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H6Jz2sa4IppYzxiLA7fOMxJ+gnu48QBouOgBk5Tdva+hBjuq7d6ry8cW2/UjwVPWgTZizhWQs3YNcK3wqOPMHFs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8e7hbrMLxpXir6YmFsTaj2eDttueXUspmu "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H4u1KW7YZbl/qj3WZt3XVWenqi668cy4EsfGzKaWRaPCfbHx6ly/hcND36KuLtfWFRCx/RnfTd2S7RYnElsCj4c=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LLjsSXV2zi5FpnJ9EkHktYRNyJ46aEPqF "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H7Q3ER/eQECt88iXOaJpNxvNQtoatGjs2S8HcchWmWr0NZ+ISu5h0un0/VkUbWOVa1TE+kU2Kx9igjyWerDg3BM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8eJ9GWk27MEZwsS3kUZiSJH4Dw4u56omTQ "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IG5W9hTL8Y6v0z8TT8br2YGpWOZqTXASEhm7JapjhK7+FP2rPnsNggiZzvYESMR6WQhxgQ1GiFEHADzh+A3k1/c=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VVDJvdp9gGtkF5oq5sD2NP9CGswEqAE6B "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IAr8Z2WwAXpg/ihgU+d7xyM1hdnE2jkpT0HAvng+VBwCAhBXgUrpVd0w0XIdXkjScJMwKNvVMpVu1zg0nhmfxHs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8RavqBjD3uQY6gEETRdmg3q8oxUiuSpZXj "dfip-2112-a-yes"
INStlNz7BnvZ7+ZIXZ5Hap7zssRAIoJ/zoR3mBv8BJjmSYOUgwiNMNTQpgy3B5SrB0c6dQTCrKwyc4ZtYPXwYBs=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8NvY8HviSG1VfCV2kdPzKZyW6yscp63pjx "dfip-2112-a-yes"
IBPIUPgx97HVLQ4lmVYti//RooUFGKjovg3kLplW5bamCzxRKsn0axZEqwg3T8OJnbfz7/DQnGktepbSlXFMQxw=

12 no

$ defi-cli signmessage 8LQE1MbVTd2NLyUmxQVdjAc7A3qcpnjbFB "dfip-2112-a-no"
IOZxgpYGAlNflZWKYriGEQc93mBCFI3jrrIPYNUBmZTaJnMw96gFwyEP0RquuJl+KzEvYZj3QSU20sN75FGP4LQ=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LoksVmGmeCFBEziUhPM25T8vnWXjTY8hG "dfip-2112-a-no"
Hyo7Vy3k2XUYebutl500GthVVgU1PYqeBb9Qy1NCaMdKA5RK7hRI2+/QSAIhyQUoD5xtk20KXEJnWib7cJfqKgo=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8QupBjGKw69RTUCvXmjsSfUbsJHoRctqC4 "dfip-2112-a-no"
IAzqGQbpfcqnIpRbCHmdW8eciWF6AhHTBGpVbgUc0uPSRh89mD55co/lxm0AKPVBrhM3Hw+dk+0cUReNjRN3F4g=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8H1ULdCAEdpEAX6a7vG9tHceWRBWjWWFWb "dfip-2112-a-no"
H3DM1/fc6t64s1w4rOS7ydPt/uZvTPvfL0VQJN5lk8bsMpQOfFFF6E663jw1uUXO2j0lxvXd+ha6WNB1yr4ZHf0=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8W6CSGt2AQnb9VaVRkdqfVkAWiCYHWPULN "dfip-2112-a-no"
IPkeRPVHRO+XlTutVuFpygjHyf9l+QUmpk/Xz93kFLMyfv9ouMxbW9YpFgHMrruNh2r35Xon4cHN6x6ip9maU3c=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8VBLzNi1TdHwQHWg7HbZcR9ZSkequXs6Up "dfip-2112-a-no"
H6rH31b76RYleQ6cg5jwocgV4xqGtt1eL9fcoseRuTvwVNr8bfzm0/Qqj4Fkr7xGz08RdiDtB7ukqGLKMzrh1Cw=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8U94KePNHgnQj9Tdh3nCrgVD3jrYqSiZeM "dfip-2112-a-no"
Hyo9OktNtiXsKqEb9lQcnkn1RUojCRhGvoheqJD5xUPwcXkguL+CSDaJz7kjmELWnm+MLv+lZ3EWLZ6S2qIY7KU=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8UQJQ5KZPojS1DdhLuFwU2uyDUxeggAuzJ "dfip-2112-a-no"
IDmBwGNYY3fHKApZd34lQfh/3kRp5DmheTrMH/MzNcBpH+eWol/FHtY1tTrz0tlIqK46jGOsZsYbcJNxDdFYzBE=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8FvmrHART1vUvRC7yMqHE7Yfaq4M9TxvCZ "dfip-2112-a-no"
IIPMgRV5AXMkcsDInzFfn1JMRYZFBwiYU9l8bZhGa6WaaCeq8PO6nwd3U6BoSKSJSQYlXYsMHPDkOjTG8B8mnPI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8YpwhLonjsz4K28UksHtcEkduW9y2Z1AkC "dfip-2112-a-no"
Hxr27e6xN1n/XyIwoOdjXk+jnKOmIDZV8pewaY9xCkWPXKHekihuBWO2Uvl5oC5O/M4I/qxAsVZuCv79HuqnVi4=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8V8VFKY9QsHFjqPZ7TZUw4gJWbPaH6kDPU "dfip-2112-a-no"
H9WUKrmRr0U2167zn5HOeldZVyS9PDJIpTEYeswabgZ4Gv/ovzSZSTyMTKZVbbmbVjOXzY7V3Va7aJUJrqPTsAg=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8Fd7s8dSxXAJ9GJgRLW99yvKkWMwT6JdiQ "dfip-2112-a-no"
HwNhO2xPL8P/ge+fMhEt86UThnO3K2jlNDyD1VCQJ8TqYKmg4p5mixlCWSAIY97BMkSsG2ZvDUIrx9yJQN0ENCY=

5 neutral

$ defi-cli signmessage 8LQE1MbVTd2NLyUmxQVdjAc7A3qcpnjbFB "dfip-2112-a-neutral"
HwCoe+MR9Xg05ipUl+zcuDzRL4LwRszE0/8hUMwsnJ4wPQpJb2AhgVhiIIthBgMtUNcv+eX7cJcv3gelb85F9VI=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8LoksVmGmeCFBEziUhPM25T8vnWXjTY8hG "dfip-2112-a-neutral"
IG82ZoWDQCr5vsJE722E/HSOD0IfviAaeZw9CWud9qNJGDu/qH66Sant8CRDAQP033d5/KLyo4Dp+tiyl0hSoRM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8QupBjGKw69RTUCvXmjsSfUbsJHoRctqC4 "dfip-2112-a-neutral"
IJt2D3yEhUZkUxNmEcMSMA59JxRJteamSo85vBx+0YYaJ6ILvL4ezosvWFgh1uh+NNgHmx/eq4PKKL1MjJExklM=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8H1ULdCAEdpEAX6a7vG9tHceWRBWjWWFWb "dfip-2112-a-neutral"
IDRzA8mSty9jhNgZMi/xSuY3y0lfWn2kuwa6EhJWTqbERnccKlEIbFKj97GdGKyAyMvDKu4g9krgjQmhg4NWVOc=
$ defi-cli signmessage 8W6CSGt2AQnb9VaVRkdqfVkAWiCYHWPULN "dfip-2112-a-neutral"
IPUtHU/bs9OusBWV7UifAuOBVB+v3X6St48LMNgD3ZKPdYQDs3I8h/wQsuF6emklhKBBnmGHBbSMK+Z7M1hUeZ0=

@SilverSurfer2000
Copy link

signmessage 8daGYPTDTzMRtUx61uWRjg7p9GECMjuip8 "dfip-2112-a-yes"
H/Or5kc3d2xJHlUTHhBiEnypOCFqM7E9vgs8uvr2EMzIXrbPMdlasuUI+xY54TmJGWsqkQG1/sDgoU6LyhjJQU0=

@KunoWA
Copy link

KunoWA commented Dec 20, 2021

signmessage 8J9ChjB3QuUGqTUJ3tdHiix2pAoyknYx2g "dfip-2112-a-no"
ID53PxUMpKJtvSKBfUnHmBPoeVbcO5TtR7Z9ngMWdQxNIRP/7Fq6lQRK/hbS4Gk3H0wwQMO/4m/bmciZlpZQI2I=

@DeFiChain-Masternode-Owner

signmessage 8N5iyTHbJNQc1nTfF74khJ9rndj6kG9FzN "dfip-2112-a-no"
H0B9PT5APAWNTlfge74ox92LGH1Ozr8BhIHIcjymXVCvARlU9lRUN1S5neV18ReegU2ESBLkiJFYBywh9sCcr+I=

signmessage 8Ht3oDDj2uHeoae3mKALM6kVmsuJaj3SSm "dfip-2112-a-no"
HwKIMudICZ0ToXUsWo69IvmrQfcxkxU0la2EyyIjs8AHQdZsTL3C3gy7IH7lg1/efM635w9wCCxGMnaKLRZsQ3o=

signmessage 8YsdyhGMoJfjfujfQox1D2S8d4JTzGQivj "dfip-2112-a-no"
H5jGSPXm3VRVJzjVtejwI8IiwF9Is65dVT3dakR1RRKKezHqkTvkNZa4vZAI31pLVWx37MU64y2suwNyVYO8odo=

@surangap
Copy link
Contributor

RESULTS for dfip-2112-a
===========================
dfip-2112-a is approved by 289 votes majority
YES: 318
NO: 29
Neutral: 7
Total valid votes: 354
Total rejected votes: 3
===========================

mnstate_validate.log
validate_dfip-2112-a_failed.log
validate_dfip.log

@Swayyo
Copy link

Swayyo commented Dec 21, 2021

What about being able to pay back all loans with dfi? Why should this be limited to the Dusd loans? This would align all pool ratios an the end customer would be able to take part without a loss.

@defiprop
Copy link

Uhh, that was close. This was a real "emergency" that justified an emergency update. At least the whole thing was well thought through, wasn't it? And who cares about the doubts some people had (like just shifting the premium to dStocks by printing un-backed DUSD)? "Whatever it takes!"

@arah1
Copy link

arah1 commented Dec 22, 2021

Uhh, that was close. This was a real "emergency" that justified an emergency update. At least the whole thing was well thought through, wasn't it? And who cares about the doubts some people had (like just shifting the premium to dStocks by printing un-backed DUSD)? "Whatever it takes!"

this has went through a majority vote, stop whining about it in nearly every topic, i dont see you giving any positive suggestion that works permanently.
if you think any of your suggestion is good, you can pay the deposit and get it into voting.

@KunoWA
Copy link

KunoWA commented Dec 23, 2021

@arah1 It is not that easy.
This emergency procedure was invented by @julianhosp and @uzyn. There is no way to add another DFIP fast enough!
You need positive suggestions: I would reduce the costs to supply DUSD as much as possible using the currently available switches we have
a) DUSD-Loan interest 0% (as long as no negative interest is possible)
b) DUSD-only vault schema with 100% collateral minimum
c) Zero DEX commission for DUSD seller, 2x the commission for the buyer
d) allow 100% USDC or USDT collateral in the vaults for DUSD credits (this will reduce the price risk to mint DUSD)

There should have been alternatives for the voting and not just 1 possible solution. It was too easy to push and support this change not giving any other alternative the way to the fast track - I do not understand the motivation from the Defichain-side - maybe there is some pressure from the Cake-side?

@arah1
Copy link

arah1 commented Dec 24, 2021

Thanks, good info.

@defiprop
Copy link

@KunoWA Well I understand now that this was a real emergency as Julian promoted shorting DUSD which only made sense in case you'd manipulate DUSD artificially afterwards. Imagine he would not have pushed this accordingly (as an emergency): People who followed his advice (to "arbitrage" DUSD) would have been mad at him (and he most probably even might have been sued in Singapore or elsewhere for knowingly giving more than questionable investment advice...). He needed to find a fast solution and needed to push it even faster. So now it seems that he has solved his legal risk issue, thus for now there is no need for any further emergency update. The only way to not accept that Julian can decide whether or not an issue is an emergency would be chain-split into CeFi-Chain and DeFi-Chain after the hard fork, however this seems not very realistic as there are very few master-nodes that are not operated by Cake-CeFi.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
dfip DeFi Improvement Proposal passed Proposal passed round/2112 December 2021 special voting round
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests