-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 350
feat(plugins): add butternut plugin #69
base: master
Are you sure you want to change the base?
Conversation
Balthazar Gronon seems not to be a GitHub user. You need a GitHub account to be able to sign the CLA. If you have already a GitHub account, please add the email address used for this commit to your account. |
@evilebottnawi not a duplicate, the other one is a different one that was made after for strange reasons |
@evilebottnawi You are free to choose which plugin would be in this repo. And I closed Rich-Harris/butternut#124. So we won't collide |
@apercu i reopen this issue, but you seriously should come to one solution, several solutions |
In my opinion the competition on the contrary improves the ecosystem, the choice is always welcome. For example there is the npm and we also have yarn. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages |
@MaxGraey Not in all cases, competition should be manifested when one product does not want to meet the goals that community wait, in your case your do the same thing, it's not a competition but a repetition. It is just my opinion. |
@MaxGraey I do not think you want to see |
@evilebottnawi So, we have different opinions and that great. But what if one solution better in some aspects or has completely different implementation? Anyway what is the solution to leave it up to you as maintainer. |
I will accept any your decision if it will be useful to the community |
@MaxGraey I'll leave it here until someone else has seen it. In fact, the main problem is that when you two or more you can make the product better. Also, if one of you is absent for some reason, the other will be able to solve problems and publish new versions. Many repositories are abandoned for this reason. But I have no right to tell you how it do right, just my advice, no more. |
44a1d2b
to
7b590cc
Compare
7b590cc
to
ee6d02e
Compare
There isn't a problem with having more than one loader / plugin covering the same functionality as far as the list goes though personally I try to avoid duplicating libs whenever possible when publishing them. That said and this is applicable to both butternut plugins, part of the guidelines for the parent awesome-list from sindresorhus is libs need to have a certain amount of maturity before they are added. The generally accepted minimum based on age is 4-6 weeks and normally a few releases as proper maintenance is definitely a part of So, all that said there doesn't need to be a choice between one plugin or the other as @MaxGraey said, a certain amount of competition drives innovation but in both cases here the libs need to mature a bit more before they are added. Both pull request can remain open and we will revisit this topic in the future based on the above criteria. |
@ballercat please accept CLA |
Please rebase |
No description provided.