Skip to content

2024‐08‐02

Bruce Bailey edited this page Aug 2, 2024 · 4 revisions

DRAFT Minutes for meeting 2 August 2024

Attendance (8): Bruce, Giacomo, Francis , Ken

Avon Kuo, Bruce Bailey, Dan Bjorge, Giacomo Petri, Francis Storr, Ken Franqueiro, Mike Gower, Lori Oakley, Patrick Lauke, Scott O'Hara

Regrets: Gundula

Announcements

  • Usual Agenda
  • Reminder on ErratumRaised label -- namely batching up for CFC and republication (i.e., date)
  • Ken updating ReadMe, Mike and Bruce updating wiki (including process) to match
  • Ken working on changing Understanding (etc.) to use PR date rather than most recent build date.
  • Still not getting as much feed back (4 thumbs up) as we would like -- We agree folks have enough time.
  • OT, but W3C Public mailing list archives has a nice facelift!

Following standard agenda:

  • Review ‘For discussion’ items
  • Review ‘Drafted’ items (30 min), either:
    • i. move back to In progress, with more work to do
    • ii. move to Ready for approval, if there is general agreement the issue is sufficiently resolved
    • iii. leave in Drafted, if discussion was not concluded satisfactorily
  • Review issues closed and project items closed
  • Review ‘To do’.
  • Time permitting, items of interest to participants, including open discussions.

For discussion

Added "Duplicated text" as guidance to fulfil the 1.4.5 Images of Text success criterion in the Understanding Document #3773 Mike continuing to iterate with Patrick and other. Discussion between SC being met versus not applicable. Everyone on call comfortable with either approach, and canonical wording is "does not fail" so end result is the same. Mike also note that WCAG definition for text allows that alt attribute value is text.

Scott would rather not allow:

click me

Where the image is just raster text which could easily be CSS styled text. Folks on call agree it is terrible, but not prohibited by the literal wording of SC. Concurrence that visually unpleasant approach will discourage this poor-but-passing use case.

1777

Drafted

Ready for approval

Drafted column

Open Discussion

Reflow

Process