HTML Standard (Jul 2019): review tracker

[LJWatson]

Requested

• APA WG requested 30 Aug
• HTML WG requested 30 Aug
• I18n WG requested on 30 Aug
• Privacy IG requested on 20 Aug
• TAG
• W3C Chairs (member only) requested 30 Aug
• WebApps WG requested on 30 Aug
• Web Security IG requested on 30 Aug

Responses

TBC.

[LJWatson]

@siusin did you ask the TAG and Privacy IG for review?

[siusin]

@LJWatson yes we did :)

[matatk]

APA Review Results

We reported the following two potential concerns/minor comments (with follow-up to happen on both), but neither are significant issues, certainly not showstoppers. They both turned out to be minor things, so APA has no official concerns.

• Concern: focusability of <audio> and <video>
• Comment (with minor issue to follow): question about the accessibility of navigation occuring in the opener of a pop-up window.

Background info

• Background info on my review and process suggestions.
• Other things we may like to follow in future (item 1 in that post became the "concern" issue above)

Updates

2019-11-07: As per the latest conversation on the HTML PR thread linked above, I'll be filing a new issue on the behaviour of pop-ups in due course, but as the accessibility concern we have was not introduced by the latest changes to HTML and is somewhat esoteric, I don't think it should hold up the CR process.

2019-11-13: On the APA call today we discussed one of the potential issues I'd raised and decided that it was a concern as it appears to leave a gap in the spec; I will file an issue about this tomorrow and update this comment to point to it.

2019-11-15: Added the "concern" issue mentioned above.

2019-12-04: Updated to state we have no concerns as per today's APA meeting.