chore: update winit to 0.30

[wusyong]

No description provided.

[pewsheen]

Is it a known issue that it crashes when closing a window on macOS?

[2024-08-14T09:11:43Z ERROR winit::platform_impl::macos::event_handler] tried to run event handler, but no handler was set

[wusyong]

Is it a known issue that it crashes when closing a window on macOS?

[2024-08-14T09:11:43Z ERROR winit::platform_impl::macos::event_handler] tried to run event handler, but no handler was set

This is caused by surfman issue I think which is merged this week. I'll update the dep in follow up PR.

[rohankokkulabito]

Code Review Agent Run #90ad3f

• AI Based Review: ✔️ Successful
• Static Analysis: ✔️ Successful

High-level Feedback

Ensure that all dependencies are specified with exact versions to avoid compatibility issues. Replace 'expect' with proper error handling to prevent ungraceful crashes. Introduce error handling for operations within 'handle_winit_window_event' to manage potential errors gracefully. Ensure consistency between Cargo.toml and Cargo.lock to avoid dependency management issues.

Actionable Issues

📄 src/window.rs

Issues: Total - 1, High importance - 1

Line 100-100

🔴 High importance - 1

📄 Cargo.lock

Issues: Total - 2, High importance - 2

Line 1336-1341	🔴 High importance - 1
Line 3785-3785	🔴 High importance - 1

📄 src/verso.rs

Issues: Total - 1, High importance - 1

Line 394-394

🔴 High importance - 1

AI Code Review powered by

[rohankokkulabito]

Heya @wusyong & @pewsheen ,
Sorry to jump into your conversation, but I’ve got a little favor to ask! 😄

I’m Rohan, the Developer Community Manager at Bito. I’d like to run our AI Code Review Agent on your PRs. Think of it as letting AI take the “first pass” on your code reviews—covering security, performance, scalability, and optimization.

You don’t need to do anything for this initial setup. I’ll handle running the Agent and will share any potential fixes and suggestions it comes up with.

Later on, if you’re up for it, you can try it on your other PRs as well. I see that you have many PRs getting merged recently and having another set of eyes for the review would be very beneficial!

Looking forward to seeing what the Agent can uncover and hoping it helps make your code even better.

[rohankokkulabito]

Bito Code Review Agent Run #90ad3f - 08/14/2024, 10:29 am

🔴 High importance

Issue: Using 'expect' for error handling can cause the program to panic if the window creation or handle retrieval fails. This is not ideal for production code as it can lead to ungraceful crashes. A similar issue was also found in src/window.rs (line 403).

Fix: Replace 'expect' with proper error handling to ensure the program does not panic and can handle errors gracefully.

Code suggestion

 @@ -105,7 +105,13 @@
          .expect("Failed to create window.");
 
      let rwh = window.window_handle().expect("Failed to get window handle");
 +    if rwh.is_err() {
 +        log::error!("Failed to get window handle: {:?}", rwh.err());
 +        return Err("Failed to get window handle");
 +    }
 +    let rwh = rwh.unwrap();

Is this a valid issue, or was it incorrectly flagged by the Agent?

• it was incorrectly flagged

[rohankokkulabito]

Bito Code Review Agent Run #90ad3f - 08/14/2024, 10:29 am

🔴 High importance

Issue: The addition of the "dpi" package in the Cargo.lock file without corresponding changes in the Cargo.toml file can lead to inconsistencies. The Cargo.lock file should be generated by Cargo based on the dependencies specified in Cargo.toml.

Fix: Ensure that the "dpi" package is added to the Cargo.toml file as a dependency. This will allow Cargo to manage the Cargo.lock file correctly.

Code suggestion

 @@ -20,6 +20,7 @@
  [dependencies]
  dom_struct = "0.0.1"
  domobject_derive = "0.0.1"
  downcast-rs = "1.2.1"
 +dpi = "0.1.1"
  dtoa = "1.0.9"
  dtoa-short = "0.3.5"
  dwrote = "0.11.0"

Is this a valid issue, or was it incorrectly flagged by the Agent?

• it was incorrectly flagged

[rohankokkulabito]

Bito Code Review Agent Run #90ad3f - 08/14/2024, 10:29 am

🔴 High importance

Issue: Removing specific versions for dependencies can lead to potential issues if the latest versions introduce breaking changes. This can cause unexpected behavior or compatibility issues in the project. Similar issues were also found in: - Cargo.lock (line 6182) - Cargo.lock (line 3816)

Fix: Specify the exact versions of the dependencies "block2" and "objc2" to ensure compatibility and stability of the project.

Code suggestion

 @@ -3785,2 +3785,2 @@ dependencies = [
 - "block2",
 - "objc2",
 + "block2 0.5.1",
 + "objc2 0.5.2",

Is this a valid issue, or was it incorrectly flagged by the Agent?

• it was incorrectly flagged

[rohankokkulabito]

Bito Code Review Agent Run #90ad3f - 08/14/2024, 10:29 am

🔴 High importance

Issue: The function 'handle_winit_window_event' does not handle potential errors that might occur during the event handling process. For example, if 'compositor.maybe_start_shutting_down()' or 'window.handle_winit_window_event' fails, the function does not have a mechanism to handle these errors gracefully.

Fix: Introduce error handling for the operations within 'handle_winit_window_event'. Use 'Result' and 'match' to handle potential errors gracefully.

Code suggestion

 @@ -396,22 +396,22 @@
         if let WindowEvent::CloseRequested = event {
             // self.windows remove(&window_id);
             if let Err(e) = compositor.maybe_start_shutting_down() {
                 log::error!("Failed to start shutting down: {:?}", e);
             }
         } else {
             let mut need_repaint = false;
             for (id, window) in &mut self.windows {
                 if window_id == *id {
                     match window.handle_winit_window_event(
                         &self.constellation_sender,
                         compositor,
                         &event,
                     ) {
                         Ok(repaint) => need_repaint = repaint,
                         Err(e) => log::error!("Failed to handle window event: {:?}", e),
                     }
                 }
             }
             if need_repaint {
                 if let Err(e) = compositor.repaint_synchronously(&mut self.windows) {
                     log::error!("Failed to repaint synchronously: {:?}", e);
                 }
             }
         }

Is this a valid issue, or was it incorrectly flagged by the Agent?

• it was incorrectly flagged

[rohankokkulabito]

Based on the above Code Suggestions, I can't wait to hear what you think?!
We will help you set up this tool in your workflow, and yes it will be free for open-source projects like yours.

[denjell-crabnebula]

Hey there @rohankokkulabito - while your HUMAN interest is gratifying, AI tooling such as the one you represent is not appropriate for this organization or repo at its current stage of very early development, and it is very unlikely that we would ever adopt such a distraction.

As someone who has been involved in many open source projects, a better approach would have been to file an issue and gauge the response from the team before letting loose your LLM that tries to AI-SPLAIN us how to modify Cargo.lock

[tensor-programming]

Is this thing going to eventually suggest that we start using the chromium engine instead of servo? I get that feeling... Say Hi to Devan for us...

[rohankokkulabito]

I appreciate the thoughtful feedback @denjell-crabnebula! 😅

You share a good idea about filing an issue first vs. plowing into an open PR. I'm new to open source and so is Bito's AI code reviewer, so I'm experimenting in (hopefully) non-invasive "human" ways to contribute, while letting our robot pal's work try to speak for itself.

Have you seen a tool like Bito's insert itself in a healthy, helpful way to an open source community before? Maybe I could learn from it. THANK YOU! 🙏