[Bugfix] fix props first logic

* for exceptions input.form, input.list, button.type always use setAttributes
* for form.action always escape
* always assign handlers to props, even if the case appears strange
* refactor normalizeProperty to return an object that clearly indicates type: & normalized:

package.json

@@ -45,4 +45,4 @@
     "qunit": "^0.7.2",
     "rsvp": "~3.0.6"
   }
-}
+}

packages/dom-helper/lib/main.js

@@ -294,8 +294,8 @@ prototype.setProperty = function(element, name, value, namespace) {
       }
     }
   } else {
-    var normalized = normalizeProperty(element, name);
-    if (normalized) {
+    var { normalized , type } = normalizeProperty(element, name);
+    if (type === 'prop') {
       element[normalized] = value;
     } else {
       if (isAttrRemovalValue(value)) {

packages/dom-helper/lib/prop.js

@@ -1,63 +1,71 @@
 export function isAttrRemovalValue(value) {
   return value === null || value === undefined;
 }
+/*
+ *
+ * @method normalizeProperty
+ * @param element {HTMLElement}
+ * @param slotName {String}
+ * @returns {Object} { name, type }
+ */
+export function normalizeProperty(element, slotName) {
+  var type, normalized;
 
-function UNDEFINED() {}
-
-// TODO should this be an o_create kind of thing?
-export var propertyCaches = {};
-
-export function normalizeProperty(element, attrName) {
-  var tagName = element.tagName;
-  var key, cachedAttrName;
-  var cache = propertyCaches[tagName];
-  if (!cache) {
-    // TODO should this be an o_create kind of thing?
-    cache = {};
-    for (cachedAttrName in element) {
-      key = cachedAttrName.toLowerCase();
-      if (isSettable(element, cachedAttrName)) {
-        cache[key] = cachedAttrName;
-      } else {
-        cache[key] = UNDEFINED;
-      }
+  if (slotName in element) {
+    normalized = slotName;
+    type = 'prop';
+  } else {
+    var lower = slotName.toLowerCase();
+    if (lower in element) {
+      type = 'prop';
+      normalized = lower;
+    } else {
+      type = 'attr';
+      normalized = slotName;
     }
-    propertyCaches[tagName] = cache;
   }
 
-  // presumes that the attrName has been lowercased.
-  var value = cache[attrName];
-  return value === UNDEFINED ? undefined : value;
+  if (type === 'prop' && preferAttr(element.tagName, normalized)) {
+    type = 'attr';
+  }
+
+  return { normalized, type };
 }
 
-// elements with a property that does not conform to the spec in certain
-// browsers. In these cases, we'll end up using setAttribute instead
-var badPairs = [{
+// properties that MUST be set as attributes, due to:
+// * browser bug
+// * strange spec outlier
+var ATTR_OVERRIDES = {
+
   // phantomjs < 2.0 lets you set it as a prop but won't reflect it
   // back to the attribute. button.getAttribute('type') === null
-  tagName: 'BUTTON',
-  propName: 'type'
-}, {
-  // Some version of IE (like IE9) actually throw an exception
-  // if you set input.type = 'something-unknown'
-  tagName: 'INPUT',
-  propName: 'type'
-}, {
-  // Some versions of IE (IE8) throw an exception when setting
-  // `input.list = 'somestring'`:
-  // https://github.com/emberjs/ember.js/issues/10908
-  // https://github.com/emberjs/ember.js/issues/11364
-  tagName: 'INPUT',
-  propName: 'list'
-}];
-
-function isSettable(element, attrName) {
-  for (let i = 0, l = badPairs.length; i < l; i++) {
-    let pair = badPairs[i];
-    if (pair.tagName === element.tagName && pair.propName === attrName) {
-      return false;
-    }
-  }
+  BUTTON: { type: true, form: true },
+
+  INPUT: {
+    // TODO: remove when IE8 is droped
+    // Some versions of IE (IE8) throw an exception when setting
+    // `input.list = 'somestring'`:
+    // https://github.com/emberjs/ember.js/issues/10908
+    // https://github.com/emberjs/ember.js/issues/11364
+    list: true,
+    // Some version of IE (like IE9) actually throw an exception
+    // if you set input.type = 'something-unknown'
+    type: true,
+    form: true
+  },
+
+  // element.form is actually a legitimate readOnly property, that is to be
+  // mutated, but must be mutated by setAttribute...
+  SELECT:   { form: true },
+  OPTION:   { form: true },
+  TEXTAREA: { form: true },
+  LABEL:    { form: true },
+  FIELDSET: { form: true },
+  LEGEND:   { form: true },
+  OBJECT:   { form: true }
+};
 
-  return true;
+function preferAttr(tagName, propName) {
+  var tag = ATTR_OVERRIDES[tagName.toUpperCase()];
+  return tag && tag[propName.toLowerCase()] || false;
 }

packages/dom-helper/tests/dom-helper-test.js

@@ -196,14 +196,14 @@ test('#setProperty removes attr with undefined', function(){
 
 test('#setProperty uses setAttribute for special non-compliant element props', function() {
   expect(6);
-  
+
   var badPairs = [
     { tagName: 'button', key: 'type', value: 'submit', selfClosing: false },
     { tagName: 'input', key: 'type', value: 'x-not-supported', selfClosing: true }
   ];
 
   badPairs.forEach(function(pair) {
-    var node = dom.createElement(pair.tagName);   
+    var node = dom.createElement(pair.tagName);
     var setAttribute = node.setAttribute;
 
     node.setAttribute = function(attrName, value) {

packages/dom-helper/tests/prop-test.js

@@ -2,27 +2,88 @@ import { normalizeProperty } from 'dom-helper/prop';
 
 QUnit.module('dom-helper prop');
 
-test('returns `undefined` for special element properties that are non-compliant in certain browsers', function() {
-  expect(3);
+test('type.attr, for element props that for one reason or another need to be treated as attrs', function() {
+  expect(12);
 
-  var badPairs = [
-    { tagName: 'BUTTON', key: 'type' },
-    { tagName: 'INPUT', key: 'type' },
-    { tagName: 'INPUT', key: 'list' }
-  ];
+  [
+    { tagName: 'TEXTAREA', key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'BUTTON',   key: 'type' },
+    { tagName: 'INPUT',    key: 'type' },
+    { tagName: 'INPUT',    key: 'list' },
+    { tagName: 'INPUT',    key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'OPTION',   key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'INPUT',    key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'BUTTON',   key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'LABEL',    key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'FIELDSET', key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'LEGEND',   key: 'form' },
+    { tagName: 'OBJECT',   key: 'form' }
+  ].forEach((pair) => {
+    var element = {
+      tagName: pair.tagName
+    };
+
+    Object.defineProperty(element, pair.key, {
+      set() { throw new Error('I am a bad browser!'); }
+    });
 
-  badPairs.forEach(function(pair) {
+    deepEqual(normalizeProperty(element, pair.key), {
+      normalized: pair.key,
+      type: 'attr'
+    }, ` ${pair.tagName}.${pair.key}`);
+  });
+});
+
+var TAG_EVENT_PAIRS = [
+  { tagName: 'form', key: 'onsubmit' },
+  { tagName: 'form', key: 'onSubmit' },
+  { tagName: 'form', key: 'ONSUBMIT' },
+  { tagName: 'video', key: 'canplay' },
+  { tagName: 'video', key: 'canPlay' },
+  { tagName: 'video', key: 'CANPLAY' }
+];
+
+test('type.eventHandlers should all be props: Chrome', function() {
+  expect(6);
+  TAG_EVENT_PAIRS.forEach((pair) => {
     var element = {
       tagName: pair.tagName
     };
 
     Object.defineProperty(element, pair.key, {
-      set: function() {
-        throw new Error('I am a bad browser!');
-      }
+      set() { },
+      get() { }
     });
 
-    var actual = normalizeProperty(element, pair.key);
-    equal(actual, undefined);
+    deepEqual(normalizeProperty(element, pair.key), {
+      normalized: pair.key,
+      type: 'prop'
+    }, ` ${pair.tagName}.${pair.key}`);
+  });
+});
+
+
+test('type.eventHandlers should all be props: Safari style (which has screwed up stuff)', function() {
+  expect(24);
+
+  TAG_EVENT_PAIRS.forEach((pair) => {
+    var parent = {
+      tagName: pair.tagName
+    };
+
+    Object.defineProperty(parent, pair.key, {
+      set: undefined,
+      get: undefined
+    });
+
+    var element = Object.create(parent);
+
+    ok(Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(element, pair.key) === undefined, 'ensure we mimic silly safari');
+    ok(Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(parent, pair.key).set === undefined, 'ensure we mimic silly safari');
+
+    var { normalized, type } = normalizeProperty(element, pair.key);
+
+    equal(normalized, pair.key, `normalized: ${pair.tagName}.${pair.key}`);
+    equal(type, 'prop', `type: ${pair.tagName}.${pair.key}`);
   });
 });

packages/htmlbars-compiler/tests/dirtying-test.js

@@ -311,6 +311,7 @@ test("helper calls follow the normal dirtying rules", function() {
 test("attribute nodes follow the normal dirtying rules", function() {
   var template = compile("<div class={{value}}>hello</div>");
   var object = { value: "world" };
+
   var result = template.render(object, env);
 
   equalTokens(result.fragment, "<div class='world'>hello</div>", "Initial render");

packages/morph-attr/lib/main.js

@@ -63,20 +63,22 @@ function AttrMorph(element, attrName, domHelper, namespace) {
   this.rendered = false;
   this._renderedInitially = false;
 
-  var normalizedAttrName = normalizeProperty(this.element, attrName);
+
   if (this.namespace) {
     this._update = updateAttributeNS;
     this._get = getAttributeNS;
     this.attrName = attrName;
   } else {
-    if (element.namespaceURI === svgNamespace || attrName === 'style' || !normalizedAttrName) {
+    var { normalized, type } = normalizeProperty(this.element, attrName);
+
+    if (element.namespaceURI === svgNamespace || attrName === 'style' || type === 'attr') {
       this._update = updateAttribute;
       this._get = getAttribute;
-      this.attrName = attrName;
+      this.attrName = normalized ;
     } else {
       this._update = updateProperty;
       this._get = getProperty;
-      this.attrName = normalizedAttrName;
+      this.attrName = normalized ;
     }
   }
 }

packages/morph-attr/lib/sanitize-attribute-value.js

@@ -11,7 +11,8 @@ var badTags = {
   'LINK': true,
   'IMG': true,
   'IFRAME': true,
-  'BASE': true
+  'BASE': true,
+  'FORM': true
 };
 
 var badTagsForDataURI = {
@@ -21,7 +22,8 @@ var badTagsForDataURI = {
 export var badAttributes = {
   'href': true,
   'src': true,
-  'background': true
+  'background': true,
+  'action': true
 };
 
 var badAttributesForDataURI = {

packages/morph-attr/tests/attr-morph/sanitize-attribute-value-test.js

@@ -86,13 +86,15 @@ var badTags = [
   'LINK',
   'IMG',
   'IFRAME',
-  'BASE'
+  'BASE',
+  'FORM',
 ];
 
 var badAttributes = [
   'href',
   'src',
-  'background'
+  'background',
+  'action'
 ];
 
 var someIllegalProtocols = [