-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 358
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Allow tagging tactile_paving=incorrect for when only one side of a crossing has it #3813
Comments
See also https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Key:tactile_paving#tactile_paving_only_on_one_side
|
Okay, so add the option "Only one side" and tag that as |
Yes. |
In the past I answered this with 'no' (we have a lot of them here). Do we resurvey them, so a 'no' can be improved to an 'incorrect' over time? |
Resurveying all Or use Vespucci on noticing places like this to retag. |
Tactile paving is resurveyed, for a "no" it's 4 years since last edit by default. If StreetComplete is set to resurvey more often it goes to 2 years. |
Use case
It affects also crossing ques, but is
no
really correct when only one side has paving?Originally posted by @matkoniecz in #3762 (comment)
Probably
incorrect
is the right thing there. The wiki has "or if only one sloped kerb at a crossing has tactile paving" as an example ofincorrect
.Originally posted by @arrival-spring in #3762 (comment)
OT, but I'd appreciate some clarity/a new option for this (I normally just tag no as it's not yes). Also on a crossing with an island, if its only on either side but not on the island which is right?
Originally posted by @peternewman in #3762 (comment)
There was a bit of a discussion here: #2738
I'd support having an other answers button of "Tactile paving only at the top or only at the bottom" and similarly for the crossing quest "Tactile paving only on one side" which would tag
incorrect
after a confirmation.Originally posted by @arrival-spring in #3762 (comment)
See also #2738 .
I appreciate incorrect is low usage currently (0.11%) but I don't know about others but I'd certainly have been tagging no when it's only on one side (given "Does this crosswalk have tactile pavings on both sides?") although I'm not sure how many of those I've had.
As mentioned I've also been tagging no if it's on the kerbs but not on the island as it's not on both sides of the two crossings, but I appreciate that probably needs a more general tagging discussion to find out what is the "correct" answer, or asking a blind person. @matkoniecz do you have contacts/feedback from your tactile maps?
Proposed Solution
Add an other answer for only on one side of the crossing
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: