-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.4k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
[kdump] Fix OOM events in crashkernel #6447
Conversation
retest vsimage please |
files/Aboot/boot0.j2
Outdated
write_cmdline() { | ||
# use extra parameters from kernel-params hook if the file exists | ||
if [ -f "$target_path/$kernel_params" ]; then | ||
if $secureboot && $debug; then |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
if $secureboot && $debug; then [](start = 8, length = 30)
if $secureboot && $debug; then [](start = 8, length = 30)
If secureboot and not debug, you will not use extra parameter. This is surprising different than the case of secureboot and debug. #Closed
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
That's correct.
The $target_path/$kernel_params
file which is /host/kernel-params
allows the user to inject more kernel parameters on the cmdline. It's especially useful during development to figure out which set of parameters should be used on a platform. But it can also be used to change some runtime behavior. Unfortunately some could have unfortunate behavior and end up compromising a system. To remove the risk of an attacker injecting harmful parameter we disable this feature in secureboot and print a message. It is still possible to boot the box in debug mode and inject parameters but that will show at runtime.
If you prefer I can disable this mechanism for secureboot entirely, including secureboot && debug
.
9a45b98
to
299e82c
Compare
retest vsimage please |
is this needed for 202012? |
Yes it's needed for 202012 |
A few issues where discovered with crashkernel on Arista platforms. 1) platforms using `docker_inram=on` would end up OOM in kdump environment. This happens because the same initramfs is used by SONiC and the crashkernel. With `docker_inram=on` the `dockerfs.tar.gz` is extracted in a `tmpfs` created for the occasion. Since `dockerfs.tar.gz` weights more than 1.5G, it doesn't fit into the kdump environment and ends up OOM. This OOM event can in turn trigger a panic. 2) Arista platforms with `secureboot` enabled would fail to load the crashkernel because the kernel parameter would be discarded on boot. This happens because the `boot0` in secureboot mode is strict about kernel parameter injection. 3) The secureboot path allowlist would remove kernel crash reports. 4) The kdump service would fail on Arista products since `/boot/` is empty in `secureboot` **- How I did it** 1) To prevent an OOM event in the crashkernel the fix is to avoid the codepaths in `union-mount` that create tmpfs and populate them. Some more codepath specific to Arista devices are also skipped to make the kdump process faster. This relies on detecting that the initramfs is starting in a kdump environment and skipping some initialization. The `/usr/sbin/kdump-config` tool appends a few kernel cmdline arguments when loading the crashkernel. The most unique one is `systemd.unit=kdump-tools.service` which is used in a few initramfs hooks to set `in_kdump`. 2) To allow `kdump` to work in `secureboot` environment the cmdline generation in boot0 was slightly modified. The codepath to load kernel parameters changed by SONiC is now running for booting in secure mode. It was altered to prevent an append only behavior which would grow the `kernel-cmdline` at every reboot. This ever growing behavior would lead `kexec` to fail to load the kernel due to a too long cmdline. 3) To get the kernel crash under /var/crash this path has to be added to `allowlist_paths` 4) The `/host/image-XXX/boot` folder is now populated in `secureboot` mode but not used. **- How to verify it** Regular boot: - enable kdump - enable docker_inram=on via kernel-params - reboot - generate a crash `echo c > /proc/sysrq-trigger` - before: witness OOM events on the console - after: crash kernel works and crash available under /var/crash Secure boot: - enable kdump - reboot - generate a crash `echo c > /proc/sysrq-trigger` - before: witness no kdump - after: crash kernel works and crash available under /var/crash Co-authored-by: Boyang Yu <[email protected]>
- Why I did it
A few issues where discovered with crashkernel on Arista platforms.
platforms using
docker_inram=on
would end up OOM in kdump environment.This happens because the same initramfs is used by SONiC and the crashkernel.
With
docker_inram=on
thedockerfs.tar.gz
is extracted in atmpfs
created for the occasion.Since
dockerfs.tar.gz
weights more than 1.5G, it doesn't fit into the kdump environment and ends up OOM.This OOM event can in turn trigger a panic.
Arista platforms with
secureboot
enabled would fail to load the crashkernel because the kernel parameter would be discarded on boot.This happens because the
boot0
in secureboot mode is strict about kernel parameter injection.The secureboot path allowlist would remove kernel crash reports.
The kdump service would fail on Arista products since
/boot/
is empty insecureboot
- How I did it
To prevent an OOM event in the crashkernel the fix is to avoid the codepaths in
union-mount
that create tmpfs and populate them. Some more codepath specific to Arista devices are also skipped to make the kdump process faster.This relies on detecting that the initramfs is starting in a kdump environment and skipping some initialization.
The
/usr/sbin/kdump-config
tool appends a few kernel cmdline arguments when loading the crashkernel.The most unique one is
systemd.unit=kdump-tools.service
which is used in a few initramfs hooks to setin_kdump
.To allow
kdump
to work insecureboot
environment the cmdline generation in boot0 was slightly modified.The codepath to load kernel parameters changed by SONiC is now running for booting in secure mode.
It was altered to prevent an append only behavior which would grow the
kernel-cmdline
at every reboot.This ever growing behavior would lead
kexec
to fail to load the kernel due to a too long cmdline.To get the kernel crash under /var/crash this path has to be added to
allowlist_paths
The
/host/image-XXX/boot
folder is now populated insecureboot
mode but not used.- How to verify it
Regular boot:
echo c > /proc/sysrq-trigger
Secure boot:
echo c > /proc/sysrq-trigger
- Which release branch to backport (provide reason below if selected)
This bug is present in 202012 and needs to be addressed.
- Description for the changelog
Fix kdump crashkernel errors seen on Arista devices