[FEATURE REQUEST] Add diff_attr to pkg.upgrade() (At least for Yum, Zypper, Apt)
#62031
Labels
Comments
agraul
added
Feature
Merged
3 tasks
agraul
added a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Jun 14, 2022
diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
tiltingpenguin
added a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Jul 6, 2022
diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031
tiltingpenguin
added a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Jul 6, 2022
diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031
meaksh
pushed a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Jul 7, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3004 (#538) * Migrate zypper.upgrade tests to pytest (cherry picked from commit ecce005b543f66198c7ac118966254dd3d60682f) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade Fixes saltstack/salt#62030 (cherry picked from commit 19ebb40dc4538c983721a8746a201b7f1300c2f7) * Don't turn attr="all" into a list pkg_resource.format_pkg_list expects its `attr` argument to be either a list of attributes or the string "all" to indicate all available attributes should be used for formatting. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62032 (cherry picked from commit 05482da89b91442235d3cc2889e59ac3722a7fae) * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
tiltingpenguin
added a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Jul 7, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3000 (#545) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade * Don't turn attr="all" into a list * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031
tiltingpenguin
added a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Jul 7, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3000.3 (#544) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade * Don't turn attr="all" into a list * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031
agraul
added a commit
to agraul/salt
that referenced
this issue
Oct 6, 2022
diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack#62031
Ch3LL
pushed a commit
that referenced
this issue
Oct 6, 2022
diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: #62031
meaksh
pushed a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Dec 28, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3004 (#538) * Migrate zypper.upgrade tests to pytest (cherry picked from commit ecce005b543f66198c7ac118966254dd3d60682f) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade Fixes saltstack/salt#62030 (cherry picked from commit 19ebb40dc4538c983721a8746a201b7f1300c2f7) * Don't turn attr="all" into a list pkg_resource.format_pkg_list expects its `attr` argument to be either a list of attributes or the string "all" to indicate all available attributes should be used for formatting. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62032 (cherry picked from commit 05482da89b91442235d3cc2889e59ac3722a7fae) * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
meaksh
pushed a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Dec 28, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3004 (#538) * Migrate zypper.upgrade tests to pytest (cherry picked from commit ecce005b543f66198c7ac118966254dd3d60682f) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade Fixes saltstack/salt#62030 (cherry picked from commit 19ebb40dc4538c983721a8746a201b7f1300c2f7) * Don't turn attr="all" into a list pkg_resource.format_pkg_list expects its `attr` argument to be either a list of attributes or the string "all" to indicate all available attributes should be used for formatting. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62032 (cherry picked from commit 05482da89b91442235d3cc2889e59ac3722a7fae) * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
meaksh
pushed a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Dec 29, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3004 (#538) * Migrate zypper.upgrade tests to pytest (cherry picked from commit ecce005b543f66198c7ac118966254dd3d60682f) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade Fixes saltstack/salt#62030 (cherry picked from commit 19ebb40dc4538c983721a8746a201b7f1300c2f7) * Don't turn attr="all" into a list pkg_resource.format_pkg_list expects its `attr` argument to be either a list of attributes or the string "all" to indicate all available attributes should be used for formatting. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62032 (cherry picked from commit 05482da89b91442235d3cc2889e59ac3722a7fae) * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
meaksh
pushed a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Dec 29, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3004 (#538) * Migrate zypper.upgrade tests to pytest (cherry picked from commit ecce005b543f66198c7ac118966254dd3d60682f) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade Fixes saltstack/salt#62030 (cherry picked from commit 19ebb40dc4538c983721a8746a201b7f1300c2f7) * Don't turn attr="all" into a list pkg_resource.format_pkg_list expects its `attr` argument to be either a list of attributes or the string "all" to indicate all available attributes should be used for formatting. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62032 (cherry picked from commit 05482da89b91442235d3cc2889e59ac3722a7fae) * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
meaksh
pushed a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Dec 29, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3004 (#538) * Migrate zypper.upgrade tests to pytest (cherry picked from commit ecce005b543f66198c7ac118966254dd3d60682f) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade Fixes saltstack/salt#62030 (cherry picked from commit 19ebb40dc4538c983721a8746a201b7f1300c2f7) * Don't turn attr="all" into a list pkg_resource.format_pkg_list expects its `attr` argument to be either a list of attributes or the string "all" to indicate all available attributes should be used for formatting. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62032 (cherry picked from commit 05482da89b91442235d3cc2889e59ac3722a7fae) * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
meaksh
pushed a commit
to openSUSE/salt
that referenced
this issue
Dec 29, 2022
…ade()/yumpkg.upgrade() - backport 3004 (#538) * Migrate zypper.upgrade tests to pytest (cherry picked from commit ecce005b543f66198c7ac118966254dd3d60682f) * Add names and pkgs parameters to zypper.upgrade Fixes saltstack/salt#62030 (cherry picked from commit 19ebb40dc4538c983721a8746a201b7f1300c2f7) * Don't turn attr="all" into a list pkg_resource.format_pkg_list expects its `attr` argument to be either a list of attributes or the string "all" to indicate all available attributes should be used for formatting. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62032 (cherry picked from commit 05482da89b91442235d3cc2889e59ac3722a7fae) * Add diff_attr parameter to zypper/yum upgrade diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031 (cherry picked from commit 20ffffe3be6c7d94e9cc3338a57bbf5014f33d93)
blu-base
pushed a commit
to blu-base/saltext-zypper
that referenced
this issue
Nov 2, 2024
diff_attr works just like it does for pkg.install. Having the option to return additional attributes can remove the need for a follow-up list_pkgs call. Fixes: saltstack/salt#62031
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.
pkg.upgrade()only provides limited information of packages that changed, whilepkg.install()can, optionally, provide more information. The additional information can also be gathered bypkg.list_pkgs(attr=X)whereXis a list of attributes or the string "all", but that requires an additional function call.Describe the solution you'd like
Just like
pkg.install(..., diff_attr=X),pkg.upgrade(..., diff_attr=X)returns the specified attributes in addition to the name and the version.Describe alternatives you've considered
Since this addition is very small and already exists in
pkg.install(), I haven't considered alternatives to addingdiff_attrtopkg.upgrade(). I'm not aware of any downside except for having another parameter inpkg.upgrade().The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: