-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.3k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Update .JO section #2264
Update .JO section #2264
Conversation
Really appreciate you going through these steps more transparently this time around. Thank you @groundcat! Without being too paranoid, but can you forward the full email with headers such that we can verify the DKIM signature? :D |
@mozfreddyb Sure! I just sent it over to you via email in |
The email did not contain any DKIM signature... We will need to figure out how else to verify this. I think we should have a maintainers email group or some other solution? |
Indeed... Unfortunately, this email did not include a DKIM signature, so there is no reliable way to confirm that it has not been tampered with. However, for this specific TLD, the registry contact directed me to this URL: https://www.dns.jo/JoFamily.aspx. In the meantime, if we trace the path via the IANA page: https://www.iana.org/domains/root/db/jo.html and identified the registry website for registration services: https://www.dns.jo/. This site is indeed the authentic registry website. For this specific case, by following the path (with the IANA database as the root of the evidence chain), the page at https://www.dns.jo/JoFamily.aspx can be considered an authoritative source, even in the absence of an email confirmation. That said, I do understand your point regarding the importance of a validation chain for email-based evidence in other cases. |
I'm not sure I completely trust the translation of that site. @groundcat could you clarify if second level domains are registrable? It would be nice if we could just add |
The .JO registry website does have its own English version, which can be considered an official translation. Therefore, in this case, there is no need to rely on third-party translations, such as Google Translate, which can often provide questionable results. You can click the menu icon in the top right corner and select "English" to view the English version of the list of all suffixes. Since this page is provided directly by the registry, it should be considered authoritative as well. https://www.dns.jo/JoFamily.aspx
I do not think we can use |
I am creating this pull request to update the .JO block in the ICANN section.
Steps taken to verify information from the authoritative source:
Domain .jo/الاردن. <[email protected]>
), confirming the requested information.Excerpt from the email confirmation:
A copy of the email confirmation along with the email headers is available to be forwarded to a maintainer for review upon request.