[SQA] TC-DL-1.1 Cluster revision, Generated command list, Accepted command and attribute list mismatches from test plan.

[Survensa]

Issue : Cluster revision, Generated command list, Accepted command and attribute list mismatches from test plan. in doorlock.

Expected outcome :

• GeneratedCommandList: 13 entries
• Accepted command list: 32 entries
• Attribute list : 46 entries

Actual outcome :

• GeneratedCommandList: 0 entries
• AccepctedCommand list: 14 entries
• Attribute list : 29 entries (Including global attributes)

Commit used : fa5561c

Log :
Command used for generated command list : ./chip-tool doorlock read generated-command-list 1 1

[1649841171.062560][11886:11891] CHIP:TOO: Endpoint: 1 Cluster: 0x0000_0101 Attribute 0x0000_FFF8 DataVersion: 4187210024
[1649841171.062650][11886:11891] CHIP:TOO: GeneratedCommandList: 0 entries
[1649841171.062758][11886:11891] CHIP:EM: Sending Standalone Ack for MessageCounter:11901987 on exchange 35309i

Command used to read accepted command list : ./chip-tool doorlock read accepted-command-list 1 1

[1649841619.994396][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: AcceptedCommandList: 14 entries
[1649841619.994436][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [1]: 0
[1649841619.994466][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [2]: 1
[1649841619.994495][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [3]: 11
[1649841619.994524][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [4]: 12
[1649841619.994552][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [5]: 13
[1649841619.994580][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [6]: 14
[1649841619.994608][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [7]: 15
[1649841619.994636][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [8]: 16
[1649841619.994664][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [9]: 26
[1649841619.994693][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [10]: 27
[1649841619.994722][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [11]: 29
[1649841619.994750][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [12]: 34
[1649841619.994779][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [13]: 36
[1649841619.994807][11915:11920] CHIP:TOO: [14]: 38
[1649841619.994959][11915:11920] CHIP:EM: Sending Standalone Ack for MessageCounter:1471971 on exchange 10798i

Command used to read attribute list: ./chip-tool doorlock read attribute-list 1 1

[1649841950.210293][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: Endpoint: 1 Cluster: 0x0000_0101 Attribute 0x0000_FFFB DataVersion: 4187210024
[1649841950.210406][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: AttributeList: 29 entries
[1649841950.210440][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [1]: 0
[1649841950.210465][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [2]: 1
[1649841950.210490][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [3]: 2
[1649841950.210515][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [4]: 3
[1649841950.210540][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [5]: 17
[1649841950.210565][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [6]: 18
[1649841950.210589][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [7]: 19
[1649841950.210613][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [8]: 20
[1649841950.210638][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [9]: 21
[1649841950.210662][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [10]: 23
[1649841950.210686][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [11]: 24
[1649841950.210711][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [12]: 25
[1649841950.210735][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [13]: 26
[1649841950.210759][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [14]: 27
[1649841950.210784][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [15]: 33
[1649841950.210808][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [16]: 35
[1649841950.210832][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [17]: 36
[1649841950.210856][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [18]: 37
[1649841950.210881][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [19]: 38
[1649841950.210905][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [20]: 41
[1649841950.210929][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [21]: 43
[1649841950.210953][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [22]: 48
[1649841950.210978][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [23]: 49
[1649841950.211002][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [24]: 51
[1649841950.211026][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [25]: 65528
[1649841950.211051][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [26]: 65529
[1649841950.211076][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [27]: 65531
[1649841950.211100][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [28]: 65532
[1649841950.211125][11938:11943] CHIP:TOO: [29]: 65533
[1649841950.211319][11938:11943] CHIP:EM: Sending Standalone Ack for MessageCounter:10393443 on exchange 49560i

[tehampson]

@Survensa just to confirm this is with the all-clusters app right? I am going to continue investigating with this assumption, but it would be good just to get confirmation. Thanks!

[tehampson]

End of last week I was updating test case spec to reflect the actual values you should be expecting, but someone beat me to it https://github.com/CHIP-Specifications/chip-test-plans/pull/1270. That PR updates the TC to reflect what values you should expect.

Running this on the all cluster app today I see feature map of:

[1653409461.239317][1088162:1088167] CHIP:TOO: Endpoint: 1 Cluster: 0x0000_0101 Attribute 0x0000_FFFC DataVersion: 2331464980
[1653409461.239354][1088162:1088167] CHIP:TOO:   FeatureMap: 275

GeneratedCommandList:

[1653409418.682746][1088102:1088107] CHIP:TOO:   GeneratedCommandList: 5 entries
[1653409418.682827][1088102:1088107] CHIP:TOO:     [1]: 12
[1653409418.682897][1088102:1088107] CHIP:TOO:     [2]: 15
[1653409418.682911][1088102:1088107] CHIP:TOO:     [3]: 28
[1653409418.682924][1088102:1088107] CHIP:TOO:     [4]: 35
[1653409418.682935][1088102:1088107] CHIP:TOO:     [5]: 37

AcceptedCommandList

[1653409447.162688][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:   AcceptedCommandList: 14 entries
[1653409447.162706][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [1]: 0
[1653409447.162718][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [2]: 1
[1653409447.162727][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [3]: 3
[1653409447.162736][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [4]: 11
[1653409447.162745][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [5]: 12
[1653409447.162757][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [6]: 13
[1653409447.162767][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [7]: 14
[1653409447.162778][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [8]: 15
[1653409447.162787][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [9]: 26
[1653409447.162796][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [10]: 27
[1653409447.162806][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [11]: 29
[1653409447.162811][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [12]: 34
[1653409447.162820][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [13]: 36
[1653409447.162829][1088141:1088146] CHIP:TOO:     [14]: 38

---

From accepted command list, seems like 16, 17, 18, 19 are missing

From generated command list, seems like 18 is still missing.

From attribute list, seems 0xFFFA (65530) is missing

[tehampson]

Once #18711 is in. I think all that will need to happen is to update the all-cluster zap file (maybe not even)

[Survensa]

@Survensa just to confirm this is with the all-clusters app right? I am going to continue investigating with this assumption, but it would be good just to get confirmation. Thanks!

We use lock-app for Door lock execution.

[tehampson]

We use lock-app for Door lock execution.

With #18711 now in, this issue should be resolved