You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The microtonal accidentals don't work correctly if used on a staff of a transposing instrument when switchin between concert pitch off to concert pitch on, or vice versa. By switching between the two modes, the playback remains correct, but the accidental remains unchanged, regardless of the accidental that should instead be used to achieve the transposed note.
Create a score for a transposing instrument (in this example an F horn). Keep the concert pitch option off.
Write a note that will have an accidental when transposed to concert pitch (in this example a written F / sounding Bb).
Apply a microtonal accidental to that note (in this example a half sharp).
Turn the concert pitch option on. The note will be displayed as a B half sharp (instead of the correct B half flat), but the playback will play a B half flat regardless.
The same issuo also happens in reverse:
Create a score for a transposing instrument (in this example an F horn). Keep the concert pitch option on.
Write a note that will have an accidental when transposed to concert pitch (in this example a written B / sounding F#).
Apply a microtonal accidental to that note (in this example a half flat).
Turn the concert pitch option off. The note will be displayed as an F half flat (instead of the correct F half sharp), but the playback will play a (concert pitch) B half flat regardless.
This is not only "transposing instruments" issue, but general transposing issue.
Same happens, for example, if you write quarter tone es, and than transpose score major second up.
Reason is, that MU understands all special accidentals, as "altered natural", but during transposing proces, sometime natural note can became (double) sharp, or flat.
Issue type
UX/Interaction bug (incorrect behaviour)
Bug description
The microtonal accidentals don't work correctly if used on a staff of a transposing instrument when switchin between concert pitch off to concert pitch on, or vice versa. By switching between the two modes, the playback remains correct, but the accidental remains unchanged, regardless of the accidental that should instead be used to achieve the transposed note.
ExampleFile.zip
Steps to reproduce
The same issuo also happens in reverse:
Screenshots/Screen recordings
No response
MuseScore Version
4.2.1-240230937
Regression
I don't know
Operating system
Windows 10
Additional context
Link to the original bug report on the forum
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: