shortsf_analysis

stories overview

• x-axis = story mean rating rank
• y-axis = story std rank
• color = chooser
• size = number of raters

author ratings

mean story ratings by author

sowing dissension

story rating standard deviation by chooser

self-bias

for each person, deviation from group mean, split into cases where person is chooser versus not chooser

individual rater distributions

violin plot showing distribution of scores per person

rater correlations

regularized estimate of correlations between pairs of reviewers (10 observations minimum)