CNCF gitdm

This is the Cloud Native Computing Foundation's fork of Jon Corbet and Greg KH's gitdm tool for calculating contributions based on developers and their companies. Companies and developers can check if they are correctly attributed at the following links:

Company Developers list: co1, co2, co3, co4.

Developers affiliations list: dev1, dev2, dev3.

New affiliations are imported into DevStats about 1-2 times/month.

DevStats

This repository is used as a source of affiliations for all DevStats projects. The final affiliations JSON is periodically imported by the DevStats project.

Adding/Updating affiliation

If you find any errors or missing affiliations in those lists, please submit a pull request with edits to developers affiliations files: dev1, dev2, dev3.

Only the Developers affiliations list dev1, dev2, dev3 should be edited manually.

Company Developers lists co1, co2, co3, co4 are computed derivatives of the first list.

Other files used for affiliations are email map file and github users file.

Please note that cncf/gitdm affiliations are imported into DevStats (cncf/devstats) weekly.

Removing affiliations

If you do not want to have your email listed here please read how to remove your email.

Testing changes

You can test any changes locally by cloning this repository and regenerating all data by running ./rerun_data.sh.

Then generate config files by running: ./import_affs.sh.

If those two files are out of sync, the tool will notify you about this.

This tool will generate a new email-map file.

Check if your changes processed properly and move the file to cncf-config/email-map (replace)

Sync workflow

Please follow the instructions from SYNC.md.

Running

Use *.sh scripts to run analytics (all*.sh for full analysis and rels*.sh for per release stats)

This program assumes that gitdm resides in: ~/dev/cncf/gitdm/ and that kubernetes is in ~/dev/go/src/k8s.io/kubernetes/

Output files are placed in the kubernetes directory.

To regenerate all statistics just run: ./rerun_data.sh

This is an iterative process: Run any of scripts. Review its output in the kubernetes directory. Iteratively adjust mappings to handle more authors.

You can also run via ./debug.sh to halt in debugger and review the hackers structure and those who were not found. See cncfdm.py:DebugUnknowns

Final report:

Data

Report

Contributing

Pull requests are welcome.

Our mapping is never complete, please see config files in Config files.

File email-map is a direct email to the employer mapping.

There is also a long list of unknown emails. For that, scroll to the section called Developers with unknown affiliation: in all.txt

All of those were searched for in various sources but we were not able to find their affiliation.

Detailed Description

Regenerating all data with ./rerun_data.sh means:

• Data for kubernetes/kubernetes repository (all time) with 3 mappings of Unknown developers: no mapping (list them with their email & name), map them to their email domain ([email protected] --> 'Gmail *'), map all of them to '(Unknown)'. This is done via running: (./all.sh, ./all_no_map.sh, ./all_with_map.sh). Output goes to kubernetes/all_time/ directory
• Data for kubernetes/kubernetes repository divided into releases v1.0.0, v1.1.0, ..., v1.7.0 (with 3 types of mappings described above). This is done via (./rels.sh, ./rels_strict.sh, ./rels_no_map.sh). Output goes to kubernetes/v1.X.0-v1.Y.0/ directory: X=0,1,2,3,4,5,6 Y=1,2,3,4,5,6,7)

After performing those two steps, cncfdm.py output neds to be analysed. It is done by calling: ./analysis_all.sh (analyses all time results) and then ./analysis_rels.sh (for per-release data)

Data for all 68 repos (currently) which makes the entire Kubernetes project with ./kubernetes_repos.sh script.

Final files generated by first 2 calls (for single repo kubernetes/kubernetes) are in kubernetes/all_time/*.txt and ./kubernetes/v1.X.0-v1.Y.0/*.txt

All scripts are configured to ignore commits related to files from vendor and Godeps directories. This is because external sources are placed here and many commits are just adding external libraries. Accounting for them would make the results less accurate

All of them use a git log call with specific args piped to cncfdm.py call with specific parameters.

See ./run.sh for an example. All other calls use the same commands git log and cncfdm.py with other parameters.

To get a list of parameters for cncfdm.py, see comments inside of the cncfdm.py file describing all possible options.

For more details about how cncfdm.py tool works refer to its sources and other *.py files.

Those files are analysed by ./analysis_all.sh and ./analysis_rels.sh.

The first one calls: ruby analysis.rb all kubernetes/all_time/first_run_patch.txt kubernetes/all_time/run_no_map_patch.txt kubernetes/all_time/run_with_map_patch.txt

The second calls: ruby analysis.rb v1.0_v1.1 kubernetes/*/output_strict_patch.txt kubernetes/*/output_patch.txt kubernetes/*/output_no_map_patch.txt

This ruby tool expects to get 3 files (one with no unknown developers mapping, 2nd with mapping to a domain name and 3rd with mapping to (Unknown).

The output of this analysis.rb tool goes to project/<prefix>_<key>_<type>.csv files. : can be all or v1.X.0-v1.Y.0 - it means that thefile is for all time data or for specific release of kubernetes/kubernetes : can be changeset, employers, lines, signoffs - it means that the file contains data sorted by this desc. : can be sum, top, all:

• all means that the file contains all data for given sorted by desc (header is: idx,company,n,percent which means n-th, company name, n developers, % all developers) All known is sum of all detected developers
• top means that there will be top 10 data from all but also must contain data for: '(Unknown)', 'Gmail *', 'Qq *', 'Outlook *', 'Yahoo *', 'Hotmail *', '(Independent)', '(Not Found)'. The header is the same as in all.
• sum contains a summary value for all found developers. It has a different header: N companies,sum,percent numer of developer's companies found, the sum of for all found developers, % of sum as a part of sum for all developers.
• Special names: All known (sum all known developers), (Independent) (developers working on their own), (Not Found) (developers for whom an employer was not found even though the search was done in multiple sources), (Unknown) (developers not mapped (yet?)), Some name * (sum of developers having emails on Some name domain). Asterisk * added to indicate this.

This data is directly used for "Who writes Kubernetes" report.

./kubernetes_repos.sh script is used to generate all time data for all kubernetes repos.

To use it, you must have all of kubernetes repositories (68 from 3 different organizations) cloned in ~/dev/go/src/k8s/.

Orgs are: kubernetes, kubernetes-incubator, kubernetes-client.

It generates statistics for each single repo via: ./anyrepo.sh ~/dev/go/src/k8s.io/<repo-name> <repo-name>

See details in ./kubernetes_repos.sh. is a directory where a given kubernetes repository is cloned.

To clone a repository, do: cd ~/dev/go/src/k8s/ git clone https://github.com/<one-of-3-kubernetes-orgs>/<kubernetes-repo-name>.git.

one-of-3-kubernetes-orgs: kubernetes, kubernetes-incubator and kubernetes-client

kubernetes-repo-name: please look up all repo names in all kubernetes orgs on GitHub.

./anyrepo.sh just calls cncfdm.py with appropriate args (like exclude vendor dir numstat etc).

There is also ./anyreporange.sh that allows querying a repo for a specific time range (cncfdm.py supports that as well).

Output of this goes to repos/<repo-name>.<ext> : repository name ./anyrepo.sh was called with. : txt, csv, html, out: txt: main data file, csv: dumps list of employers in given repo, html: the same as txt but in HTML format, out: cncfdm.py verbose output messages (for debugging)

Finally, ./kubernetes_repos.sh calls: ./multirepo.sh with all 68 repository directories listed.

It gathers git log on each of them and concatenates all those files and then run cncfdm.py on the concatenated result (see ./multirepo.sh)

Results are saved to repos/combined.<ext> is the same as for anyrepo.sh.

Typical work flow is re-runing ./kubernetes_repos.sh and examining repos/combined.txt for unknown developers.

Research on google, Clearbit, FullContact, github, LinkedIn, Facebook, any other source -> update cncf-config/<filename> and re-run ./kubernetes_repos.sh : usually in this order: email-map, domain-map, a in very rare cases: aliases, gitdm.config-cncf or group mappings in groups/

Also, when running data for a single kubernetes/kubernetes for example with ./all.sh examining developers found in ./kubernetes/all_time/first_run_patch.txt.

After all this data is generated, ./kubernetes_repos.sh concatenates all single repo data into a single output file: repos/merged.out to allow browsing all the data in a single file.

It also generates developers and companies statistics via a ./topdevs.sh call.

It calls a ruby tool on the combined output of all 68 kubernetes repos (saved as CSV) like so: ruby topdevs.rb repos/combined.csv

That tool generates files as follows:

• companies_by_name.csv - this is a list of companies found, sorted by their names (not case sensitive) to allow manual examination for duplicates which came about from different names such as "Google" vs "Googe Corporation" vs "Google Corp." or "google"
• companies_by_count.csv - list of companies found, sorted (desc) by the number of employers. This serves a similar purpose but from a different perspective.
• unknown_devs.txt, unknown_devs.csv, unknown_emails.csv - list of developers for whom there isn't a mapping. Used to prioritize searching for devs, and unknown_emails.csv is in the format fitting a clearbit batch.

There are clearbit tools in clearbit_tools/ directory.

Look for any files with .rb extension. 3 rounds of commercial Clearbit requests were performed. And they returned quite a lot of data.

But those files are not checked in and are listed in ./.gitignore because we have to pay for that data.

Those tools are used to enrich of cncf-config/email-map mapping. google_other.txt - contains a list of Google developers with email on a domain different than @google.com. ./changesets.csv, ./added.csv, ./removed.csv files contain developers sorted by changesets, added lines, removed lines desc.

A new set of tools to get Clearbit and FullContact data is located in affiliation_finder/ directory. The two tools are described inthe 'Tools to help find unknown affiliations' section of this document.

This is used to generate Top N developers in given criteria.

./new_devs.sh (also used by ./rerun_data.sh) is used to generate statistics about new developers between kubernetes/kubernetes releases.

It calls: ruby new_devs.rb kubernetes/v1.X.0-v1.Y.0/output_strict_patch.csv for all X and Y. new_devs.rb simply generates information about developers who were new between each release and file new_devs.csv, which contains a list of companies who introduced most new developers overall (sorted by # of new developers desc).

That covers a typical usage and data for "Who writes Kubernetes report"

Other tools

Other tools include:

• see_parser.sh - display data feed as used by cncfdm.py tool
• range.sh - generate stats for Linux kernel for given data range (1st and 2nd command line argument like 2016-01-01 2017-01-01), assumes Linux repo (torvalds/linux) is cloned in ~/dev/linux/
• range_<period>.sh - used to generate monthly, quarterly, yearly stats using above ./range.sh, for example ./range_monthly.sh.

To work on Prometheus contributors before and after joining CNCF:

Prometheus joined CNCF on 2016-05-09.

You need to clone all Prometheus repos into ~/dev/prometheus using ./clone_prometheus.sh

Then you need to get a number of distinct Prometheus contributors before joining CNCF: ./prometheus_repos.sh 2015-05-09 2016-05-08 ~/dev/prometheus/

Result is:

Processed 2721 csets from 230 developers
252 employers found
A total of 1558445 lines added, 353900 removed (delta 1204545)

Now check the number of distinct contributors after 2016-05-09: ./prometheus_repos.sh 2016-05-09 2017-06-01 ~/dev/prometheus/

Processed 2817 csets from 346 developers
365 employers found
A total of 2696196 lines added, 771502 removed (delta 1924694)

We have a change from 230 to 365 which is a 59% increase.

Report

Links to data and generated report are here: ./res/links.txt

CNCF Projects join statistics

• CNCF Projects join dates are: https://github.com/cncf/toc#projects

• To generate statistics for Prometheus 90 days before joining CNCF and 90 days after joining try this:

• Run ./clone_prometheus.sh

• Run ./cncf_join_analysis.sh prometheus 2016-05-09 90 ~/dev/prometheus/

• Results go to prometheus_repos/result.txt

• Create a directory where you want to put links to kubernetes repos, like this: mkdir ~/dev/kubernetes_repos_links

• Copy kubernetes_repos.sh to link_kubernetes_repos.sh: cp kubernetes_repos.sh link_kubernetes_repos.sh

• Open the copy and add 1st line: cd ~/dev/kubernetes_repos_links

• Replace lines like ./anyrepo.sh ~/dev/go/src/k8s.io/test-infra/ test-infra with ln -s ~/dev/go/src/k8s.io/test-infra/ test-infra; run it; done. k8s repos links are now in ~/dev/kubernetes_repos_links

• The command that takes on Kubernetes repos should be: ./cncf_join_analysis.sh kubernetes 2016-03-10 90 ~/dev/kubernetes_repos_links

• Results go to kubernetes_repos/result.txt

• To generate statistics for OpenTracing 90 days before joining CNCF and 90 days after joining try this:

• Run ./clone_opentracing.sh

• Run ./cncf_join_analysis.sh opentracing 2016-08-17 90 ~/dev/opentracing/

• Results go to opentracing_repos/result.txt

• There is also an All-in-one script to regenerate all CNCF Projects joint statistics, run ./join_stats.sh

Typical update of "Who writes Kubernetes report"

• Run ./pull_kubernetes.sh to get all Kubernetes repos updated.
• Change directory to dev/go/src/k8s.io/kubernetes/ and update this repository as well.
• New release since the last run (1.7) so many scripts needs to be updated. Also, all repos from 3 kubernetes orgs are now in ~/dev/kubernetes/repos so ./kubernetes_repos.sh script needs an update as well
• Updated kubernetes_repos.sh script to get repos from ~/dev/kubernetes_repos/
• Script to regenerate all data is ./rerun_data.sh, it needs to be updated to support v1.7.0
• Now report is: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RKtRamlu4D_OpTDFTKNpMsmV51obdZlPWbXVj-LrDuw/edit?usp=sharing
• Report data sheet/draft is: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/15otmXVx8Gd6JzfiGP_OSjP8M9zyLeLof5-IGQKEb0UQ/edit#gid=0
• Now report sections:

Since the kubernetes project started in June 2014, 2623 Developers from 789 Companies worked on it (counting Kubernetes and all its projects 68 repos from 3 orgs).
A total of 28.4 million lines of code were added, 16.3 million lines removed.

Taken from: ./repos/combined.txt

Processed 59041 csets from 2623 developers
789 employers found
A total of 28440262 lines added, 16342872 removed (delta 12097390)

For a single kubernetes/kubernetes repo, the data is in: kubernetes/all_time/first_run_numstat.txt

Processed 28225 csets from 1338 developers
400 employers found
A total of 6667288 lines added, 4132224 removed (delta 2535064)

• About how to fill data sheet/chart:
• Sheet "all time data":
• analysis_all_repos.sh, generates files starting with: report/all_repos_rest
• report/prefix_key_type (prefix: all - for kubernetes/kubernetes, all_repos - for all repos, v1.x for releases), project/
• Commits info is in other_repos/all_kubernetes_dtfrom_dtto and other_repos/kubernetes_dtfrom_dtto (for all k8s repos and kubernetes/kubernetes alone)
• To see commits for all kubernetes repos combined for last year & for last 12 months (each) separately: grep -HIn "csets from" other_repos/all_kubernetes_range_unknown_201*
• The same for kubernetes/kubernetes repo: grep -HIn "csets from" other_repos/kubernetes_range_unknown_201*
• Update report and report data sheet with those results
• Number of github events etc - from cncf/velocity:projects/unlimited.csv (this is for 201606-201705)
• Values for May 2017 are in: cncf/velocity:projects/cncf_projects_201705.csv

activity,comments,prs,commits,issues,authors
Last year: 308313,217684,46351,16000,28278,1728
Last month: 30227,21371,4645,1741,2470,451

• Analyses of kubernetes/kubernetes (main repo) are in this format: report/all_{key}_top.csv, import them to the 2nd sheet
• Big summaries like all developers etc are in ./repos/combined.txt, for the main k8s repo: kubernetes/all_time/first_run_numstat.txt
• Top developer stats are here: stats/all_key.csv (for all repos), stats/kubernetes_key.csv (for the main repo) and stats/v1.x_key.csv per versions.
• Import those to the last 3 sheets in data set
• Per verion data: report/v1.x_v1.y_key_top.csv, key: changesets, lines, developers, import to data sheet for all versions: 7 x 3 = 21 imports

Affiliations of some developers are uncertain despite best effort. These developers are listed in uncertain.csv file.

GitHub users can be pulled using Octokit GiHub API.

To do this, call: ruby ghusers.rb or ./ghusers.sh

Required are:

• Standard GitHub OAuth token: https://github.com/settings/tokens --> Personal access tokens, put it in /etc/github/oauth file.
• A GitHub Application to increase rate limit from 60 to 5000 (60 is not enough to process kubernetes, 5000 is enough).
• See: https://github.com/settings/ --> OAuth application, put your client_id and client_secret in /ect/github/client_id, /etc/github/client_secret files.
• This tool will cache all GitHub calls (save them as JSON files in ./ghusers/)
• Final JSON will be saved in ./github_users.json (subsequent calls will use data from this file, so to reset cache, just remove this file and all files from ghusers/ directory
• To generate the actual mapping, manually process this JSON (and do some mapping of company names - GitHub users sometimes put strange values there)
• I've done that by iteratively using a new tool: import_from_github_users.sh, import_from_github_users.rb with a mapping file (that tries to map a GiHub user company name into something more accurate): company-names-mapping

Tools to help find unknown affiliations

To enhance this json with pre-existing affiliations, call: ./enchance_json.sh

• To generate JSON with some filtered data (like all unknown devs with location or LinkedIn profile link or just a blog entry) call: ./lookup_json.sh (see script for details, also lookup_json.rb have a lot of comments on how to use it).

• To generate a progress report (report about how many Not Found, Unknowns, and Independent devs are defined in our affiliation, call: ./progress_report.sh).

• To generate aliases for emails that are already known (are using the same GitHub user name) try ./aliaser.sh, the output is aliaser.txt that can be analyzed and manually added to cncf-config/aliases if needed.

• To generate a correlations map for company name (to avoid mapping typos etc) run ./correlations.sh script. Result is in correlations.txt file that can be used to update cncf-config/email-map with corrected employer names.

• To generate per-files/directories statistics, use: ./per_dirs.sh, this is a part of a standard workflow, results are in csv files in per_dirs directory

• To generate affiliation files (developers_affiliations.txt, company_developers.txt), use ./gen_aff_files.sh

• To generate data for the stacked chart, run ./stacked_chart_<months|rels>_<csets|perc>.sh. It generates a csv file: stacked_chart_<months|rels>_<csets|perc>.csv, to generate all stacked charts: ./stacked_charts.sh

• To import data from pretty-formatted files use import_affs.sh, this is not a part of the standard workflow

All those tools are automatically called when running the full data regeneration script: ./rerun_data.sh

• To automatically find affiliations (email to company) using Clearbit, run two scripts from affiliation_finder folder in order:
  • clearbit_affiliation_lookup.rb
  • ruby clearbit_affiliation_merge.rb

The first one works with one argument and generates a file clearbit_affiliation_lookup.csv. The argument can be skipped or have a value of 'true' or 'false' - default. Invocation would be clearbit_affiliation_lookup.rb or clearbit_affiliation_lookup.rb false or clearbit_affiliation_lookup.rb true. The argument is used to whether the script's output data should be overwriten (normally data would be appended to the file) and at the same time it will allow previously looked-up email addresses to be checked again.
The execution environment needs to have a proper value for this: Clearbit.key = ENV['CLEARBIT_KEY'] It is a secret API key on a Clearbit account which has been set up for subscription. When the file is generated, open it in a csv editor, sort by the 'chance' field. Visually check and correct data in the 'affiliation_suggestion' column. Replace values such as 'http://www.ghostcloud.cn/' with 'Ghostcloud'. If you find affiliations for other developers manually, just change the 'none' value in the 'chance' column to 'high' and provide a value in the 'affiliation_suggestion' column. Columns to the right of 'affiliation_suggestion' are not required.

The second script reads the 'clearbit_affiliation_lookup.csv' file. Data is processed against the cncf-config/email-map file. When done, the 'email-map' file will have new and updated affiliations. The file will be sorted as well. The lookup file will not be altered.

• To automatically find affiliations (email to company) using FullContact, run two scripts from affiliation_finder folder in order:
  • ruby fullcontact_affiliation_lookup.rb
  • ruby fullcontact_affiliation_merge.rb

The first one works with one argument and generates a file fullcontact_affiliation_lookup.csv. The argument can be skipped or have a value of 'true' or 'false' - default. Invocation would be fullcontact_affiliation_lookup.rb or fullcontact_affiliation_lookup.rb false or fullcontact_affiliation_lookup.rb true. The argument is used to whether the script's output data should be overwriten (normally data would be appended to the file) and at the same time it will allow previously looked-up email addresses to be checked again.
The execution environment needs to have a proper value for this: config.api_key = ENV['FULLCONTACT_KEY'] It is a secret API key on a FullContact account which has been set up for subscription. The columns differ in this file compared to that of Clearbit. If you find affiliations for other developers manually, just change the value in the 'org_1' column. The column by default should have 5 pipe-delimited values. If you do not have the values for the other 4, just type 4 pipes. Columns to the right of 'org_1' are not required.

The second script reads the 'clearbit_affiliation_lookup.csv' file. Data is processed against the cncf-config/email-map file. When done, the 'email-map' file will have new and updated affiliations. The file will be sorted as well. The lookup file will not be altered. The merge scripts export developer work history to fullcontact_developer_historical_irganizations.csv.

Add new project ( cncf or non-cncf) to get affiliation for it.

Please follow the instructions from ADD_PROJECT.md.

Authors

• Łukasz Gryglicki [email protected] - developement.
• Justyna Gryglicka [email protected] - researching affiliations data.