Not finding Private IP During Bootstrap

[elbandito]

I have a private cloud, and I'm trying to bootstrap an instance with its private IP address, but I keep getting the same "No IP address available for bootstrapping." error. I'm passing the --openstack-private-network and --bootstrap-network options. Maybe I've just been staring at it too long and need an extra set of eyes to point out the obvious. Here's the output in verbose mode:

> ko server create --node-name image --ssh-user ubuntu --openstack-ssh-key-id dev-test -i ~/Downloads/dev-test.pem --flavor 2 --image bb90d9fb-a73a-4631-945d-5f9b1ae4e657 -r "role[base]" --network-ids 718ef283-f9bf-48c2-83b4-11d94e14f6aa --openstack-private-network --bootstrap-network internal -E development -VV
DEBUG: openstack_username dev
DEBUG: openstack_auth_url https://myhost.com:5001/v2.0/tokens
DEBUG: openstack_tenant development
DEBUG: openstack_endpoint_type publicURL
DEBUG: openstack_insecure
DEBUG: Using fog version: 1.24.0
DEBUG: Create server params - server_def = {:name=>"image", :image_ref=>"bb90d9fb-a73a-4631-945d-5f9b1ae4e657", :flavor_ref=>"2", :security_groups=>["default"], :availability_zone=>nil, :metadata=>nil, :key_name=>"dev-test", :nics=>[{"net_id"=>"718ef283-f9bf-48c2-83b4-11d94e14f6aa"}]}

Waiting for server [wait time = 600]............
Instance ID        14d4befe-e4df-488a-850e-df95d3b61657
Name               image
Flavor             2
Image              bb90d9fb-a73a-4631-945d-5f9b1ae4e657
Keypair            dev-test
State              ACTIVE
Availability Zone  nova
DEBUG: Addresses {"internal"=>[{"OS-EXT-IPS-MAC:mac_addr"=>"fa:16:3e:0a:27:30", "version"=>4, "addr"=>"10.250.2.22", "OS-EXT-IPS:type"=>"fixed"}]}
DEBUG: Floating IP Address requested -1
DEBUG: Addresses {"internal"=>[{"OS-EXT-IPS-MAC:mac_addr"=>"fa:16:3e:0a:27:30", "version"=>4, "addr"=>"10.250.2.22", "OS-EXT-IPS:type"=>"fixed"}]}
DEBUG: Bootstrap Network: private
DEBUG: Bootstrap IP Address:
ERROR: No IP address available for bootstrapping.
FATAL: No IP address available for bootstrapping.
DEBUG: No IP address available for bootstrapping.

[jjasghar]

Do you have a VPN or is that 10.x Addy route-able?

[elbandito]

@jjasghar There's a VPN

[jjasghar]

Ah OK, just starting from the ground up. Are you you using neutron or nova networking?

[elbandito]

I believe our OpenStack service is setup to use Neutron. Don't know if this is a datapoint, but bootstrapping does work fine if I use floating IPs.

[jjasghar]

Ah yeah that's a perfect data point. When I get to my laptop I'll write out the issue, you found a bug.

[elbandito]

Sounds good! Let me know if can help out with anything!

There's one thing I'd like to verify the correct usage of. I'm using the same network for both the --network-ids and --bootstrap-network. The only difference is that for the --bootstrap-network, I'm specifying the name instead of the id. Is this ok?

Name      ID                                    Tenant                            Shared
internal  718ef283-f9bf-48c2-83b4-11d94e14f6aa  ee491d66b636499aa534afcc37d767fb  true

[elbandito]

@jjasghar The issue appears to be here. We're not even considering the user defined network name, we're just setting it to private for all cases of network private being true.

[jjasghar]

is this still an issue? If so, I can pick up attempting to repo and resolve this.

[elbandito]

I believe it is. I made a local change, which I've been testing, and it seems to be working fine. Just need to write a test case.

[jjasghar]

Any chance you can push this upstream? I'm getting another issue with floating ips reported so it's very possible we'll have another knife-openstack release sooner then later.

[elbandito]

Ok, let me take a look at it.

[elbandito]

@jjasghar I'm about to take a look. Is this still needed?

[elbandito]

@jjasghar just submitted a PR