-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.5k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Remove experimental warning on audit mode. #3299
Remove experimental warning on audit mode. #3299
Conversation
Did we solve the issue around audit mode mangling exceptions? |
What do you mean by "mangling exceptions"? |
625373d#diff-c34d08382bb25f61e44ecbd5f50f4166 |
I think the example we got was SystemExit and how this broke people's CI. Not sure if there is anything else that we need to consider. |
My PR doesn't make audit mode the default; I don't know that we need to do that right now. I'm just removing warnings here. |
My bad, I guess this is harmless then. |
@jdmundrawala If audit mode is disabled (the default) we don't wrap any raised exceptions, we just re-raise them - #3090 |
👍 On this change. I could see people being concerned this message gets changed in a patch version. Can we hold off on it until the next major version (12.4)? |
@tyler-ball Sure, that's fine |
Per @tyler-ball's message -- looks like we're on the cusp of releasing 12.4. Can I get this warning removal in there? /cc @chef/client-maintainers |
👍 as long as we're sufficiently confident that the design is fairly stable and we don't need to change it in incompatible ways in the future. |
The main thing off the top of my head is this It's a bug fix but if people did the should syntax in their tests that change would break them. |
@jtimberman I'm going to argue that whether that's a bug or not doesn't generally change the shape of the design of audit mode, and at this point we've got enough usage & published enough articles about it that we should just say it's shipped. |
Well then you shouldn't break any working code. OTOH, that may be a moot point: #3482 (comment) |
…al-warning Remove experimental warning on audit mode.
I'm going to suggest we remove this to avoid freaking out customers since we have been shipping this mode for some time.
/cc @chef/analytics-data-integrations