Comments counter per reviewer

[ceci]

In order to... incentivise reviewers to ask for more information and suggest improvements to authors using the comments feature already available
As a... reviewer
I want... a comment counter per reviewer per year during the submission period, very similar to the reviews counter

(by @ericabriones)

[hugocorbucci]

Can you provide some more details on the UI on this one?
Is it just another menu where I can see all sessions I have comments on in the menu on the left? Or is it something public that anyone can see?

[ceci]

It turns out we probably don't need this anymore. :-) Reviewers are actively commenting on proposals now.

[ceci]

Just added the information we want the counter per year

And...@hugocorbucci and I were talking on Telegram, and I told him I guess it is too late for this year's submissions.

[hugocorbucci]

Wait.. we want this one? Or #170?

[ceci]

We wanted both: the ranking shows the top commenters. This one shows how many comments you have added. But, then again, I don't think we need it anymore.

It feels like reviewers understood their job includes commenting before submissions close. :-)

[hugocorbucci]

So close this and say won't fix?

Or any wireframe for a UI for next year?

Hugo Corbucci
Skype user: hugo.corbucci
Twitter: hugocorbucci

On Mon, Jun 29, 2015 at 12:04 PM, Cecilia Fernandes <
[email protected]> wrote:

We wanted both: the ranking shows the top commenters. This one shows how
many comments you have added. But, then again, I don't think we need it
anymore.

It feels like reviewers understood their job includes commenting before
submissions close. :-)

—
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#165 (comment)
.

[ceci]

I'll wait for @ericabriones' decision on this.

[ericabriones]

My opinion is that we still need it, the reviewers made comments on the
submissions but we had one person appointed each week to talk to them and
get them going, I think something like this could make our comment rate
even higher. We most certainly don't need this for now, but for next year I
think it would help.

On Mon, Jun 29, 2015 at 4:11 PM Cecilia Fernandes [email protected]
wrote:

I'll wait for @ericabriones https://github.com/ericabriones' decision
on this.

—
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#165 (comment)
.

[celsoMartins]

Where it will appear? Under "Minhas avaliações"?

Something like "Meus comentários (2)" with an action to list the comments?

/cc @ericabriones @ceci