Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

MU-Nachrichten werden z.T. als MC erkannt, z.B. Siro und andere #72

Open
HomeAutoUser opened this issue Nov 6, 2017 · 10 comments
Open

MU-Nachrichten werden z.T. als MC erkannt, z.B. Siro und andere #72

HomeAutoUser opened this issue Nov 6, 2017 · 10 comments
Labels
bug incorrect detection MU MS MC

Comments

@HomeAutoUser
Copy link
Contributor

Für die Übersicht, lieber ein neuer Faden.
Immer noch sporadische fälschliche Erkennung nach cfb3738 Anpassung (signalDecoder.cpp).

Zum Teil FHTTK oder FHT80b. da besteht noch Potential ;-)

2017.11.06 18:21:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: decoded matched MU Protocol id 60 dmsg K11222250 length 32 RSSI = -55
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MS;P1=396;P2=-9756;P3=-393;P4=607;P5=-610;D=012131313451345451345131313451345454513131313131313131313451345131345451313131313131313131313454513454545454545;CP=1;SP=2;R=5;m=2;
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:13]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:31]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:51]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:10]
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P1=396;P3=-393;P4=607;P5=-610;D=10;�
2017.11.06 18:21:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-610;LH=607;SL=-393;SH=396;D=FFFBDADED5FFDBAFFF5AAA8;C=334;L=89;R=5;�
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:43]
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=377;P2=-412;P3=584;P4=-607;D=012121212121212121212121234341212121212123412123412121234341234121212123434341234121212121212123434343434121212341212;CP=1;R=3;
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: FHT80TF - door/window switch protolength 45
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: decoded matched MU Protocol id 70 dmsg T81460E01 length 32 RSSI = -72.5
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:22:04 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate

2017.11.06 18:20:30 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:10]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:103]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:54]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:41]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:16]
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P1=586;P4=-406;P5=383;P6=-613;D=5;�
2017.11.06 18:20:31 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-613;LH=586;SL=-406;SH=383;D=576FDD55D8;C=331;L=37;R=22;�
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:41]
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:15]
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=391;P2=-400;P3=610;P4=-614;D=0121212121212121212121212341212341212121212341212341234341212341212121212121212123412341212343412121212341212343412341212341212341212121512121212121212121212121234121234121212121234121234123434121234121212121212121212341234121234341212121234121234341234;CP=1;R=33;O;
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: FHT80 - roomthermostat protolength 54
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: decoded matched MU Protocol id 73 dmsg 810c04xx0909a001202C0000A626 length 48 RSSI = -57.5
2017.11.06 18:20:42 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate

2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=414;P3=-608;P5=-413;P7=591;D=01023434315151515151573157315157315737315157373731573737315151515731545731515151573734573737373;CP=1;R=67;
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:13]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:43]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:35]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P3=-607;P4=612;P5=384;P6=-402;D=5;�
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-607;LH=612;SL=-402;SH=384;D=55EBAAF77B5B8;C=334;L=49;R=8;�
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:32]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:25]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=414;P2=-418;P5=566;P6=-644;D=012121232121212321212121256121212561256565612125612121212121256125656565656561212125656563256565612321212561212561212325656125612563212;CP=1;R=67;
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:18:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate

2017.11.06 18:13:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:32]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:25]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:17]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P1=399;P2=-396;P5=610;P6=-612;D=17121212121212121212121212561212125612565612561212125612565656121212121212121212125612561212565612121212121212121212125;O;�
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-612;LH=610;SL=-396;SH=399;D=FDED6F6AFFEDD7FFAD554;C=336;L=82;R=5;�
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:17]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:71]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:25]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:61]
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=390;P2=-396;P5=613;P6=-612;D=171212121212121212121212125612121256125656125612121256125656561212121212121212121256125612125656121212121212121212121256561256565656565610;CP=1;R=5;
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:13:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: FHT80 - roomthermostat protolength 54

2017.11.06 18:05:16 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:05:16 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:32]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:24]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=405;P2=-389;P4=605;P5=-618;D=012321212121212121212121245126232153245454512124512121212121245124545454545124512124545121245454545121212451212451212124512454512124512;CP=1;R=14;
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P0=-29766;P1=406;P2=-420;P3=574;P4=-592;D=010123434343434123412123434341234343412121212341212341212123434123412123412;CP=1;R=62;
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:52]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:43]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:62]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P2=-412;P3=617;P4=-605;P5=386;D=5;�
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-605;LH=617;SL=-412;SH=386;D=DFDADDD755EEF7B5;C=336;L=64;R=9;�
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:32]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:24]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=400;P2=-431;P4=574;P5=-603;D=012121212321212321212121245123212451245454512124512121212121245124545124512124512124545451245454532121212451212451212124532451245124512;CP=1;R=62;
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.06 18:05:17 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate

...
@sidey79
Copy link
Contributor

sidey79 commented Nov 7, 2017 •
edited
Loading

Ich habe mal was versucht: 4ed6c3b

Problem ist vermutlich, dass ich den Takt erst später errechne und erstmal annehme, dass einer der Pulse = Takt ist. Ich habe das ganze jetzt mal auf einen langen Puls geändert. Ob das so wirklich besser ist weiss ich nicht.
Sorry, wir sind jetzt im try & error Mode

Diese Signalfolge wird nun als MU gewertet:
MC;P1=399;P2=-396;P5=610;P6=-612;D=17121212121212121212121212561212125612565612561212125612565656121212121212121212125612561212565612121212121212121212125;O;

@HomeAutoUser
Copy link
Contributor Author

HomeAutoUser commented Nov 7, 2017 •
edited
Loading

Hallo @sidey79,
mit deiner aktuellen Änderung.

2017.11.07 20:31:38 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/keepalive ok, retry = 0
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:10]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:32]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:24]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:40]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:103]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P0=-597;P2=-378;P3=409;P4=623;D=35323232323232323232323232403232324032404032403232324032404040323232323232323232324032403232404032323232323232323232324040324040404040403;�
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-597;LH=623;SL=-378;SH=409;D=DBAFFF5AAA8;C=334;L=41;R=243;�
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:35]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:53]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:32]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:24]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:40]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:103]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:36]
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P0=-597;P2=-378;P3=409;P4=623;D=36;�
2017.11.07 20:31:39 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-597;LH=623;SL=-378;SH=409;D=FFFBDADED5FFDBAFFF5AAA8;C=334;L=89;R=243;�

2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MS;P1=395;P2=-10090;P3=264;P4=-390;P5=605;P6=-609;D=0123456341414141456141456145656141456141414141414141414561456141456561414141456141414145614141414565656565656;CP=1;SP=2;R=29;m=2;
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:14]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:41]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:61]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:10]
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P1=395;P4=-390;P5=605;P6=-609;D=10;�
2017.11.07 20:34:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-609;LH=605;SL=-390;SH=395;D=FFFBBF76BBFF6EBEFBEAAA;C=333;L=87;R=29;�
2017.11.07 20:34:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.07 20:34:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.07 20:34:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.07 20:34:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.07 20:34:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.07 20:34:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:41]
2017.11.07 20:34:33 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=397;P2=-399;P3=612;P4=-603;D=012121212121212121212121234121234121212121234121234123434121234123434343434123412123434121234343434121212341212341212123412123434341212;CP=1;R=29;

2017.11.07 20:35:22 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:21]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:13]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:63]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P3=-408;P4=599;P5=-623;P6=379;D=67636363636363636363636363456363634563454563456363634563454545636363636363636363634563456363454563636363636363636363634545634545454545456;�
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-623;LH=599;SL=-408;SH=379;D=BAFFF5AAA8;C=334;L=37;R=245;�
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:67]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:76]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:63]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:36]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:60]
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P3=-408;P4=599;P5=-623;P6=379;D=60;�
2017.11.07 20:35:36 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-623;LH=599;SL=-408;SH=379;D=FFFBDADED5FFDBAFFF5AAA8;C=334;L=89;R=245;�
2017.11.07 20:35:38 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/keepalive ok, retry = 0
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:101]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:12]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:23]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:34]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:41]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:14]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;P1=391;P4=-413;P5=596;P6=-614;D=17141414141414141414141414561414145614565656141456141414141414561414141414141414145614561414565614141456141414561414141456141456561;O;�
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: �MC;LL=-614;LH=596;SL=-413;SH=391;D=FBDABBFBFF6EBDEFBAD8;C=335;L=77;R=7;�
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:17]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:71]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:14]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:41]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:45]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:56]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READ: +seq[:61]
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz/msg READredu: MU;P1=393;P4=-399;P5=610;P6=-613;D=171414141414141414141414145614141456145656561414561414141414145614141414141414141456145614145656141414561414145614141414561414565614561410;CP=1;R=7;
2017.11.07 20:35:40 4: Arduino_Nano_868Mhz: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 70 -> FHT80TF matches, trying to demodulate

@sidey79
Copy link
Contributor

sidey79 commented Feb 18, 2018

Ist das Problem noch vorhanden oder zwischenzeitlich gelöst?

@elektron-bbs
Copy link
Contributor

Dieses Problem besteht immer noch. Hier eine FS20- und eine FHT-Nachricht:

2018.02.18 17:38:08 4: sduino868IP/msg READ: �Mc;LL=-610;LH=579;SL=-402;SH=366;D=FFF5D5F5DDFFF7BED58;C=326;L=73;R=245;�
2018.02.18 17:38:08 4: sduino868IP/msg READ: �MU;P0=387;P1=-404;P2=569;P3=-621;D=01012301012301010101010101010101010123010101230;CP=0;R=234;�
2018.02.18 17:38:08 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:38:08 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP/msg READ: �MU;P0=-160;P1=128;P2=-2464;P3=372;P4=-421;P5=578;P6=-605;P7=-9312;D=01234343434343434343434343456563434565656343434345656343456343456343434343434343434343434563434345634343434563456565634373434343434343434343434345656343456565634343434565634345634345634343434343434343434343456343434563434343456345656563437343434343434343;CP=3;R=243;O;�
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: FS20 - remote control post demodulation 9C64000011 length 45
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: decoded matched MU Protocol id 74 dmsg 810b04f70101a0019C64000011 length 40 RSSI = -80.5
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: FS20 - remote control post demodulation 9C64000011 length 45
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: decoded matched MU Protocol id 74 dmsg 810b04f70101a0019C64000011 length 40 RSSI = -80.5
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP Dispatch: 810b04f70101a0019C64000011, Dropped due to short time or equal msg
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP/msg READ: �MU;P0=-401;P1=399;P2=580;P3=-597;D=0101010101023101023232310101010232310102310102310101010101010;CP=1;R=217;�
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:38:10 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:38:11 4: sduino868IP/keepalive ok, retry = 0
2018.02.18 17:38:22 4: sduino868IP/msg READ: �Mc;LL=-597;LH=585;SL=-395;SH=387;D=FFFB6EDEBAFFDAD6FFF6B6;C=327;L=87;R=33;�
2018.02.18 17:38:22 4: sduino868IP/msg READ: �MU;P1=583;P2=-401;P5=392;P6=-600;D=525252525252525252525252165216521652521652165252521616525216165252525252525252521652161652161652165252525252525252525252165216165216525;CP=5;R=33;�
2018.02.18 17:38:22 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 73 -> FHT80 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:38:22 4: sduino868IP: FHT80 - roomthermostat post demodulation 52190000B600
2018.02.18 17:38:22 4: sduino868IP: decoded matched MU Protocol id 73 dmsg 810c04xx0909a00152190000B600 length 48 RSSI = -57.5
2018.02.18 17:38:22 4: sduino868IP: Fingerprint for MU Protocol id 74 -> FS20 matches, trying to demodulate
2018.02.18 17:39:11 4: sduino868IP/keepalive ok, retry = 0

@sidey79
Copy link
Contributor

sidey79 commented Feb 18, 2018

@elektron-bbs

Ok verstehe. Das Problem ist nur, wenn ich die MU Nachrichten aus deinem Log teste, kommen die natürlich als MU raus.
Die MC Nachricht brauche ich erst nicht testen, die muss leider immer als MC erkannt werden, wenn sie einmal so gespeichert wurde. :(

@HomeAutoUser
Copy link
Contributor Author

HomeAutoUser commented Feb 18, 2018 •
edited
Loading

@elektron-bbs
Generiere bitte noch einmal deine Ausgabe mit aktivem DMC. Deine Zeiten bei MC sind DEFINITIV dem FS20 und co. zuzuordnen. (bei mir leider noch nicht der Prestigefall)

Hier siehst du wie man DMC aktivieren kann in der Firmware. (signalDecoder.cpp)

@elektron-bbs
Copy link
Contributor

Das ist doch auch das Thema hier: "MU-Nachrichten werden z.T. als MC erkannt"
Deshalb habe ich eine FS20- und eine FHT-Nachricht gepostet, die fälschlicherweise auch als MC dekodiert werden.

@sidey79
Copy link
Contributor

sidey79 commented Feb 18, 2018

@elektron-bbs

Vielleicht stehe ich auf dem Schlauch... Ich habe diverse Signale gegen die aktuelle Lib getestet und konnte den Fehler nicht mehr nachstellen. Habe aber jetzt eine Signalfolge, mit der sich der Fehler nachstellen lässt.
#76 (comment)

@sidey79
Copy link
Contributor

sidey79 commented Feb 23, 2018

Ich habe leider noch nichts finden können, wie ich dieses Fehlverhalten unterbinden, bin aber dran was zu suchen.

sidey79 added a commit that referenced this issue Feb 24, 2018
@sidey79
signalDecoder.cpp
93243a4 
In ManchesterpatternDecoder isManchester wird geprüft, ob longlow + longhigh und longhigh+longlow als Sequenz vorkommen.
Dies ist notwendig, um eine bessere MC Erkennung zu erreichen. In der Regel, sollten MC Signale auch beide Sequenzen enthalten. Auch wenn dies nicht 100% garantiert werden kann. z.B bei FFFF ist dies nicht der Fall. Dieser Fall wird aber auch heute bereits nicht erkannt.

fixes #76, #72
@sidey79
Copy link
Contributor

sidey79 commented Feb 24, 2018

@elektron-bbs

Ich denke ich habe einen Weg gefunden, diese Signale nicht mehr als MC zu erkennen.

sidey79 added a commit that referenced this issue Feb 25, 2018
@sidey79
signalDecoder.cpp
990e50f 
In ManchesterpatternDecoder isManchester wird geprüft, ob longlow + longhigh und longhigh+longlow als Sequenz vorkommen.
Dies ist notwendig, um eine bessere MC Erkennung zu erreichen. In der Regel, sollten MC Signale auch beide Sequenzen enthalten. Auch wenn dies nicht 100% garantiert werden kann. z.B bei FFFF ist dies nicht der Fall. Dieser Fall wird aber auch heute bereits nicht erkannt.

fixes #76, #72
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
bug incorrect detection MU MS MC
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
3 participants
@sidey79 @HomeAutoUser @elektron-bbs