Merge pull request #168 from paradedb/main

Update ParadeDB Results for v0.5.4

index.html

@@ -406,7 +406,8 @@
 ,{"system":"MySQL (MyISAM)","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":2512,"data_size":121588958061,"result":[[0,0,0],[283.32,276.83,274.52],[276.93,278.29,283.27],[28.83,23.63,21.55],[46.41,40.81,40.93],[467.04,467.39,469.08],[31.02,25.89,24.2],[277.89,275.3,277.3],[329.34,325.8,325.35],[342.86,338.43,336.95],[282.03,279.87,281.22],[277.74,282.68,282],[335.66,334.83,336.44],[305.24,310.39,307.3],[337.41,338.52,342.94],[308.66,307.34,306.27],[738.38,748.44,740.75],[738.75,734.01,738.25],[867.01,872.92,868.84],[25.65,20.61,18.46],[312.39,313.67,306.66],[301.66,305.12,308.01],[298.12,298.44,312.4],[311.34,309.9,311.85],[281.87,278.5,275],[277.46,277.46,277.46],[280.75,278.04,281.76],[263.9,417.39,406.88],[707.21,711.96,705],[668.1,668.33,665.96],[330.31,333.36,331.94],[506.57,506.18,500.53],[2604.49,2681.96,2703.12],[830.65,832.88,831.14],[831.98,830.46,833.41],[608.49,608.51,613.68],[4.56,4.13,4.16],[3.8,3.8,3.7],[1.65,1.45,1.46],[6.33,5.14,6.15],[1.6,1.41,1.41],[1.56,1.42,1.39],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql-myisam/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}
 ,{"system":"MySQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C++","row-oriented","MySQL compatible"],"load_time":9472,"data_size":171953585825,"result":[[339.77,339.88,339.77],[364.91,371.86,367.55],[366.2,368.91,389.66],[364.39,377.53,571.45],[377.69,390.02,384.86],[569.48,576.51,574.68],[367.4,368.23,370.41],[371.29,384.02,613.22],[478.85,683.22,495.68],[489.9,635.96,662.43],[386.07,396.49,640.15],[389.13,412.55,444.12],[447.97,455.54,448.06],[423.22,845.44,813.6],[452.48,460.07,453.98],[577.54,623.21,586.49],[852.07,856.36,862.66],[838.09,848.92,851.12],[1006.37,1011.16,1023.17],[369.76,375.61,415.28],[412.45,419.9,456.62],[411.65,432.88,482.2],[412.73,420.73,429.5],[551.16,577.62,545.45],[382.89,394.76,386.37],[380.9,391.4,385.05],[385.3,394.67,460.32],[388.95,394.7,387.21],[800.33,807.9,807.11],[706.03,745.27,718.9],[450.9,489.59,530.97],[625.5,651.93,647.32],[2721.13,2792.12,2819.26],[945.9,954.94,957.54],[945.42,953.78,965.16],[684.36,716.29,708.75],[10.01,3.79,3.77],[7.48,3.32,3.27],[5.09,0.98,0.96],[8.7,4.77,4.68],[4.82,0.76,0.74],[4.46,0.77,0.75],[7.04,1.17,1.13]],"source":"mysql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}
 ,{"system":"Oxla.com","date":"2024-01-31","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"ingests data only from non-compressed cvs. data should be ingested in chunks < ~5Gb","tags":["C","analytical","somewhat PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":584.88,"data_size":83948840996,"result":[[0.050129,0.022855,0.022903],[0.057503,0.015481,0.015516],[0.094277,0.025541,0.026299],[0.16258,0.024306,0.023829],[0.039942,0.021789,0.02218],[0.1374,0.101147,0.099119],[0.059388,0.025719,0.0264],[0.033712,0.017465,0.0184],[0.135859,0.096702,0.095512],[0.171016,0.155303,0.154772],[0.190669,0.182083,0.183751],[0.22111,0.18886,0.193252],[2.52142,2.55214,2.54007],[2.6807,2.5843,2.63534],[2.75055,2.68715,2.67322],[1.52986,1.47056,1.49706],[8.22161,7.84746,7.57008],[7.06027,7.33078,6.88351],[10.5416,10.2955,10.2149],[0.053765,0.02466,0.023807],[2.67538,2.54948,2.71025],[null,null,null],[null,null,null],[8.75207,8.09075,8.26788],[0.359349,0.31487,0.312975],[0.331405,0.339576,0.332647],[0.351841,0.340408,0.325682],[1.62115,1.67895,1.74872],[null,null,null],[1.58662,1.58356,1.58278],[0.632047,0.553994,0.586148],[1.15181,1.14935,1.10892],[13.1952,13.0677,12.6957],[15.9073,13.0187,12.6488],[12.3274,13.7521,14.7386],[1.27877,1.35705,1.24621],[1.011,0.955655,0.967898],[3.46346,0.841062,0.878294],[0.867865,0.885799,0.812358],[4.55556,1.79754,1.75293],[4.00301,0.064817,0.062893],[0.163954,0.063076,0.060033],[null,null,null]],"source":"oxla/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}
-,{"hide":false,"system":"ParadeDB","date":"2024-01-22","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","row-oriented","column-oriented","search","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":1268,"data_size":15415061091,"result":[[0.163905,0.021898,0.022008],[0.207702,0.09921,0.100067],[0.237625,0.118278,0.118759],[0.442946,0.126447,0.131097],[1.0277,0.904216,0.874925],[1.5306,1.33361,1.35094],[0.136153,0.050723,0.048972],[0.196955,0.097955,0.100465],[1.75463,1.62648,1.6515],[3.27018,3.18922,3.20045],[0.533817,0.369565,0.379801],[0.682929,0.409102,0.419692],[1.54178,1.33929,1.35776],[3.61625,2.76572,2.70619],[1.64899,1.44228,1.44821],[1.17511,1.00967,1.06343],[3.26609,2.8722,2.982],[3.10603,2.75286,2.82727],[7.32941,6.11626,6.0983],[0.544845,0.140834,0.139874],[9.70331,1.6328,1.62837],[11.4209,1.88226,1.84449],[22.8747,4.23374,4.25072],[58.9316,12.5984,12.3467],[3.15828,0.640643,0.636879],[0.835229,0.576707,0.569113],[3.07483,0.725442,0.695266],[9.77006,2.25871,2.28875],[9.48875,5.25401,5.2664],[0.758836,0.596066,0.604683],[2.42823,1.22871,1.22743],[5.7783,1.6789,1.66446],[9.08455,9.12525,9.37842],[12.2218,6.75614,6.71551],[12.6965,7.37193,7.32369],[2.14621,1.95328,1.90366],[0.156902,0.133997,0.134037],[0.22542,0.133992,0.133607],[0.216827,0.134193,0.133826],[0.18494,0.092106,0.092236],[0.217797,0.134427,0.135062],[0.221416,0.135605,0.134971],[0.264453,0.113144,0.113175]],"source":"paradedb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}
+,{"hide":false,"system":"ParadeDB","date":"2024-02-02","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"The results for (c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2) are also submitted here for easy comparison with Elasticsearch","tags":["Rust","row-oriented","column-oriented","search","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":1294,"data_size":15415061091,"result":[[0.170805,0.005724,0.006098],[0.207075,0.09786,0.097367],[0.223766,0.088988,0.083545],[0.428068,0.097471,0.098085],[1.02813,0.842475,0.847983],[1.47076,1.27149,1.24457],[0.079231,0.005903,0.006381],[0.20438,0.102631,0.101062],[1.61474,1.57814,1.57654],[1.34235,1.09032,1.07038],[0.624544,0.350221,0.354308],[0.592603,0.38256,0.382334],[1.5044,1.32063,1.31768],[3.54282,2.67601,2.61359],[1.66994,1.46717,1.4526],[1.16541,0.999982,0.975601],[3.36336,2.90587,2.89977],[3.1358,2.75251,2.71843],[7.57537,5.9709,6.09835],[0.450773,0.136726,0.134937],[9.75662,1.39915,1.44835],[11.2973,1.70324,1.6996],[22.2634,4.01717,3.96894],[57.8901,10.7998,10.8794],[3.10183,0.605149,0.595146],[0.829921,0.542481,0.531427],[3.01411,0.668447,0.680061],[9.88178,2.28414,2.28912],[9.13347,5.15906,5.15358],[0.599997,0.454952,0.463381],[2.34495,1.18331,1.19755],[5.76726,1.62152,1.52735],[8.98009,8.85184,8.65374],[11.9086,6.49934,6.7125],[12.2924,7.10393,7.21253],[2.04731,1.8265,1.84334],[0.274516,0.252795,0.251755],[0.338633,0.253551,0.252828],[0.339914,0.254548,0.253683],[0.244831,0.158776,0.158403],[0.382238,0.253784,0.254412],[0.404016,0.253894,0.253025],[0.358676,0.204648,0.204944]],"source":"paradedb/results/c6a.4xlarge.1500gb.json"}
+,{"hide":false,"system":"ParadeDB","date":"2024-02-02","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["Rust","row-oriented","column-oriented","search","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":1294,"data_size":15415061091,"result":[[0.170805,0.005724,0.006098],[0.207075,0.09786,0.097367],[0.223766,0.088988,0.083545],[0.428068,0.097471,0.098085],[1.02813,0.842475,0.847983],[1.47076,1.27149,1.24457],[0.079231,0.005903,0.006381],[0.20438,0.102631,0.101062],[1.61474,1.57814,1.57654],[1.34235,1.09032,1.07038],[0.624544,0.350221,0.354308],[0.592603,0.38256,0.382334],[1.5044,1.32063,1.31768],[3.54282,2.67601,2.61359],[1.66994,1.46717,1.4526],[1.16541,0.999982,0.975601],[3.36336,2.90587,2.89977],[3.1358,2.75251,2.71843],[7.57537,5.9709,6.09835],[0.450773,0.136726,0.134937],[9.75662,1.39915,1.44835],[11.2973,1.70324,1.6996],[22.2634,4.01717,3.96894],[57.8901,10.7998,10.8794],[3.10183,0.605149,0.595146],[0.829921,0.542481,0.531427],[3.01411,0.668447,0.680061],[9.88178,2.28414,2.28912],[9.13347,5.15906,5.15358],[0.599997,0.454952,0.463381],[2.34495,1.18331,1.19755],[5.76726,1.62152,1.52735],[8.98009,8.85184,8.65374],[11.9086,6.49934,6.7125],[12.2924,7.10393,7.21253],[2.04731,1.8265,1.84334],[0.274516,0.252795,0.251755],[0.338633,0.253551,0.252828],[0.339914,0.254548,0.253683],[0.244831,0.158776,0.158403],[0.382238,0.253784,0.254412],[0.404016,0.253894,0.253025],[0.358676,0.204648,0.204944]],"source":"paradedb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}
 ,{"system":"Pinot","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"It successfully loaded only 94465149 out of 99997497 records. Some queries returned NullPointerException. The loading process is painful - splitting to 100 pieces required. It does not correctly report errors on data loading, the results may be incorrect.","tags":["Java","column-oriented"],"load_time":2032,"data_size":null,"result":[[0.002,0.001,0.001],[0.186,0.186,0.185],[0.251,0.276,0.258],[0.475,0.281,0.238],[3.907,3.655,3.633],[30.471,14.687,14.93],[null,null,null],[0.135,0.134,0.148],[3.039,2.902,2.938],[3.159,3.212,3.225],[4.217,4.197,4.384],[4.145,4.124,4.121],[2.989,3.145,3.18],[6.402,6.886,6.374],[3.245,3.35,3.129],[5.112,5.027,5.141],[5.509,5.279,5.257],[0.865,0.856,0.829],[null,null,null],[0.017,0.015,0.015],[54.348,19.562,19.128],[null,null,null],[76.596,74.719,14.228],[7.441,5.77,5.87],[0.376,0.327,0.286],[7.689,0.395,1.281],[3.434,0.499,0.5],[27.679,2.378,2.393],[null,null,null],[2.221,2.227,2.167],[4.941,4.639,4.565],[5.641,5.37,5.007],[5.295,5.006,5.357],[5.28,5.21,5.105],[6.231,6.238,6.385],[5.918,5.933,5.934],[0.26,0.202,0.21],[0.364,0.072,0.069],[0.042,0.034,0.035],[1.483,0.686,0.651],[0.113,0.071,0.079],[0.042,0.051,0.037],[null,null,null]],"source":"pinot/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}
 ,{"hide":true,"system":"PostgreSQL (tuned)","date":"2022-12-18","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":11800,"data_size":128875248605,"result":[[4.10957,0.687829,0.702019],[3.92694,0.63874,0.636411],[262.331,262.793,262.826],[6.14366,1.16457,1.20297],[26.752,27.4474,27.4878],[50.6555,47.6136,49.2373],[0.035605,0.002266,0.002208],[1.07557,0.599462,0.597673],[18.537,17.4348,17.7942],[309.49,306.831,306.894],[7.78261,2.95749,3.00855],[325.58,315.688,319.237],[4.03189,2.31557,2.21055],[18.8998,10.0497,10.0307],[272.381,271.91,271.87],[5.91906,4.17788,4.21394],[15.6578,15.8794,15.937],[0.025629,0.001484,0.00153],[312.64,312.543,310.582],[0.026206,0.001114,0.001115],[13.1447,0.090463,0.104537],[0.11893,0.093162,0.090471],[18.7775,0.107025,0.110361],[0.131412,0.089608,0.087852],[0.048958,0.00153,0.001405],[0.016134,0.001351,0.001268],[0.021939,0.001781,0.00164],[265.557,260.971,261.025],[277.516,276.053,277.378],[7.56565,6.50964,6.54902],[266.723,266.389,266.231],[269.738,269.255,269.193],[331.115,330.011,330.913],[416.169,421.255,423.724],[408.434,409.538,407.552],[35.5578,18.1707,18.6893],[3.17403,0.652905,0.698142],[0.730699,0.489315,0.465665],[0.563463,0.319131,0.3182],[1.23744,0.989391,1.01963],[0.752814,0.509212,0.511453],[0.677541,0.435178,0.437736],[1.18281,0.688545,0.697523]],"source":"postgresql-tuned/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}
 ,{"system":"PostgreSQL","date":"2022-07-01","machine":"c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2","cluster_size":1,"comment":"","tags":["C","row-oriented","PostgreSQL compatible"],"load_time":2342,"data_size":77797067741,"result":[[439.753,309.785,282.017],[317.874,254.238,254.941],[262.883,263.072,263.09],[32.421,5.31,5.06],[57.134,42.648,42.334],[358.423,356.315,358.342],[31.524,5.35,4.994],[263.145,263.193,263.165],[323.659,322.858,321.918],[327.395,326.17,326.231],[265.983,265.681,265.912],[269.984,265.336,265.379],[284.096,284.56,282.234],[277.25,279.455,280.035],[285.66,286.2,283.611],[66.605,32.023,38.282],[312.452,304.431,305.391],[289.209,290.449,287.578],[331.706,327.485,334.428],[24.646,2.543,2.263],[267.561,267.496,267.524],[267.729,267.69,268.184],[263.074,263.12,267.04],[267.602,267.488,267.494],[263.141,263.859,263.137],[262.923,263.102,263.113],[262.885,263.088,263.114],[267.864,269.127,268.204],[303.376,306.925,308.664],[263.221,263.119,263.148],[270.814,270.575,270.294],[278.342,275.925,276.224],[584.599,576.932,591.502],[462.576,446.962,439.779],[429.93,417.696,416.704],[296.875,297.283,295.14],[3.461,0.842,0.794],[2.179,0.564,0.558],[2.258,0.566,0.416],[2.805,1.311,1.317],[2.936,0.82,0.615],[2.197,0.736,0.535],[1.983,0.32,0.312]],"source":"postgresql/results/c6a.4xlarge.json"}

paradedb/README.md

@@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ ParadeDB is an alternative to Elasticsearch built on Postgres.
 - [GitHub](https://github.com/paradedb/paradedb)
 - [Homepage](https://paradedb.com)
 
-The published benchmarks are based on ParadeDB version `v0.5.1`.
+The published benchmarks are based on ParadeDB version `v0.5.4`.
 
 ## Benchmarks
 

paradedb/benchmark.sh

@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ sudo docker run \
     -p 5432:5432 \
     --name paradedb \
     -d \
-    paradedb/paradedb:0.5.1
+    paradedb/paradedb:0.5.4
 
 echo ""
 echo "Waiting for ParadeDB to start..."

paradedb/results/c6a.4xlarge.1500gb.json

@@ -0,0 +1,65 @@
+{
+  "hide": false,
+  "system": "ParadeDB",
+  "date": "2024-02-02",
+  "machine": "c6a.4xlarge, 1500gb gp2",
+  "cluster_size": 1,
+  "comment": "The results for (c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2) are also submitted here for easy comparison with Elasticsearch",
+
+  "tags": [
+    "Rust",
+    "row-oriented",
+    "column-oriented",
+    "search",
+    "PostgreSQL compatible"
+  ],
+
+  "load_time": 1294,
+  "data_size": 15415061091,
+
+  "result": [
+    [0.170805, 0.005724, 0.006098],
+    [0.207075, 0.09786, 0.097367],
+    [0.223766, 0.088988, 0.083545],
+    [0.428068, 0.097471, 0.098085],
+    [1.02813, 0.842475, 0.847983],
+    [1.47076, 1.27149, 1.24457],
+    [0.079231, 0.005903, 0.006381],
+    [0.20438, 0.102631, 0.101062],
+    [1.61474, 1.57814, 1.57654],
+    [1.34235, 1.09032, 1.07038],
+    [0.624544, 0.350221, 0.354308],
+    [0.592603, 0.38256, 0.382334],
+    [1.5044, 1.32063, 1.31768],
+    [3.54282, 2.67601, 2.61359],
+    [1.66994, 1.46717, 1.4526],
+    [1.16541, 0.999982, 0.975601],
+    [3.36336, 2.90587, 2.89977],
+    [3.1358, 2.75251, 2.71843],
+    [7.57537, 5.9709, 6.09835],
+    [0.450773, 0.136726, 0.134937],
+    [9.75662, 1.39915, 1.44835],
+    [11.2973, 1.70324, 1.6996],
+    [22.2634, 4.01717, 3.96894],
+    [57.8901, 10.7998, 10.8794],
+    [3.10183, 0.605149, 0.595146],
+    [0.829921, 0.542481, 0.531427],
+    [3.01411, 0.668447, 0.680061],
+    [9.88178, 2.28414, 2.28912],
+    [9.13347, 5.15906, 5.15358],
+    [0.599997, 0.454952, 0.463381],
+    [2.34495, 1.18331, 1.19755],
+    [5.76726, 1.62152, 1.52735],
+    [8.98009, 8.85184, 8.65374],
+    [11.9086, 6.49934, 6.7125],
+    [12.2924, 7.10393, 7.21253],
+    [2.04731, 1.8265, 1.84334],
+    [0.274516, 0.252795, 0.251755],
+    [0.338633, 0.253551, 0.252828],
+    [0.339914, 0.254548, 0.253683],
+    [0.244831, 0.158776, 0.158403],
+    [0.382238, 0.253784, 0.254412],
+    [0.404016, 0.253894, 0.253025],
+    [0.358676, 0.204648, 0.204944]
+  ]
+}

paradedb/results/c6a.4xlarge.json

@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 {
   "hide": false,
   "system": "ParadeDB",
-  "date": "2024-01-22",
+  "date": "2024-02-02",
   "machine": "c6a.4xlarge, 500gb gp2",
   "cluster_size": 1,
   "comment": "",
@@ -14,52 +14,52 @@
     "PostgreSQL compatible"
   ],
 
-  "load_time": 1268,
+  "load_time": 1294,
   "data_size": 15415061091,
 
   "result": [
-    [0.163905, 0.021898, 0.022008],
-    [0.207702, 0.09921, 0.100067],
-    [0.237625, 0.118278, 0.118759],
-    [0.442946, 0.126447, 0.131097],
-    [1.0277, 0.904216, 0.874925],
-    [1.5306, 1.33361, 1.35094],
-    [0.136153, 0.050723, 0.048972],
-    [0.196955, 0.097955, 0.100465],
-    [1.75463, 1.62648, 1.6515],
-    [3.27018, 3.18922, 3.20045],
-    [0.533817, 0.369565, 0.379801],
-    [0.682929, 0.409102, 0.419692],
-    [1.54178, 1.33929, 1.35776],
-    [3.61625, 2.76572, 2.70619],
-    [1.64899, 1.44228, 1.44821],
-    [1.17511, 1.00967, 1.06343],
-    [3.26609, 2.8722, 2.982],
-    [3.10603, 2.75286, 2.82727],
-    [7.32941, 6.11626, 6.0983],
-    [0.544845, 0.140834, 0.139874],
-    [9.70331, 1.6328, 1.62837],
-    [11.4209, 1.88226, 1.84449],
-    [22.8747, 4.23374, 4.25072],
-    [58.9316, 12.5984, 12.3467],
-    [3.15828, 0.640643, 0.636879],
-    [0.835229, 0.576707, 0.569113],
-    [3.07483, 0.725442, 0.695266],
-    [9.77006, 2.25871, 2.28875],
-    [9.48875, 5.25401, 5.2664],
-    [0.758836, 0.596066, 0.604683],
-    [2.42823, 1.22871, 1.22743],
-    [5.7783, 1.6789, 1.66446],
-    [9.08455, 9.12525, 9.37842],
-    [12.2218, 6.75614, 6.71551],
-    [12.6965, 7.37193, 7.32369],
-    [2.14621, 1.95328, 1.90366],
-    [0.156902, 0.133997, 0.134037],
-    [0.22542, 0.133992, 0.133607],
-    [0.216827, 0.134193, 0.133826],
-    [0.18494, 0.092106, 0.092236],
-    [0.217797, 0.134427, 0.135062],
-    [0.221416, 0.135605, 0.134971],
-    [0.264453, 0.113144, 0.113175]
+    [0.170805, 0.005724, 0.006098],
+    [0.207075, 0.09786, 0.097367],
+    [0.223766, 0.088988, 0.083545],
+    [0.428068, 0.097471, 0.098085],
+    [1.02813, 0.842475, 0.847983],
+    [1.47076, 1.27149, 1.24457],
+    [0.079231, 0.005903, 0.006381],
+    [0.20438, 0.102631, 0.101062],
+    [1.61474, 1.57814, 1.57654],
+    [1.34235, 1.09032, 1.07038],
+    [0.624544, 0.350221, 0.354308],
+    [0.592603, 0.38256, 0.382334],
+    [1.5044, 1.32063, 1.31768],
+    [3.54282, 2.67601, 2.61359],
+    [1.66994, 1.46717, 1.4526],
+    [1.16541, 0.999982, 0.975601],
+    [3.36336, 2.90587, 2.89977],
+    [3.1358, 2.75251, 2.71843],
+    [7.57537, 5.9709, 6.09835],
+    [0.450773, 0.136726, 0.134937],
+    [9.75662, 1.39915, 1.44835],
+    [11.2973, 1.70324, 1.6996],
+    [22.2634, 4.01717, 3.96894],
+    [57.8901, 10.7998, 10.8794],
+    [3.10183, 0.605149, 0.595146],
+    [0.829921, 0.542481, 0.531427],
+    [3.01411, 0.668447, 0.680061],
+    [9.88178, 2.28414, 2.28912],
+    [9.13347, 5.15906, 5.15358],
+    [0.599997, 0.454952, 0.463381],
+    [2.34495, 1.18331, 1.19755],
+    [5.76726, 1.62152, 1.52735],
+    [8.98009, 8.85184, 8.65374],
+    [11.9086, 6.49934, 6.7125],
+    [12.2924, 7.10393, 7.21253],
+    [2.04731, 1.8265, 1.84334],
+    [0.274516, 0.252795, 0.251755],
+    [0.338633, 0.253551, 0.252828],
+    [0.339914, 0.254548, 0.253683],
+    [0.244831, 0.158776, 0.158403],
+    [0.382238, 0.253784, 0.254412],
+    [0.404016, 0.253894, 0.253025],
+    [0.358676, 0.204648, 0.204944]
   ]
 }