You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
In simple terms the easiest way to implement crossfade is as follows:
Fade out track volume within the last 2-3 seconds of the song.
Fade in the volume of the next song within the first 2-3 seconds.
Whilst this is not technically "cross" fade (a la' semantics) and should really just be called fade. It achieves almost all of the purpose of having crossfade in the first place. That is, a natural volume transition between tracks. Which personally I argue is far more desirable than typical noise normalisation across all tracks.
Giving the user an audio queue that a song is about to transition is highly beneficial to listening immersion. It allows for mental preparation of the next song for eg. skipping, muting, changing volume without a sudden abrupt need to potentially reverse the first few seconds of the song.
Please consider this feature. Even a simple fade would be greatly appreciated. The overall user experience of Innertune is incredible, however compared to mainstream services like Spotify, a lack of fade is one of the most noticeable missing features in Innertune.
If such a fade option was added, it'd also likely be accepted upstream, even if the source wasn't crossed/overlayed and the volume was simply faded between tracks.
Thanks for considering!
Why do you want this feature?
Crossfade allows for a much more immersing listening experience. It prevents sudden and sharp transitions in different songs by giving the user a passive subconscious notice of song transition.
Additional information
For a quick and painless way on how to do this, please see VolumeShaper: google/ExoPlayer#10702
Checklist
Feature description
Audio should allow for crossfading between tracks.
Despite Exoplayer limitations, this is easier than expected to implement. Please see the below comment:
google/ExoPlayer#3438 (comment)
In simple terms the easiest way to implement crossfade is as follows:
Whilst this is not technically "cross" fade (a la' semantics) and should really just be called fade. It achieves almost all of the purpose of having crossfade in the first place. That is, a natural volume transition between tracks. Which personally I argue is far more desirable than typical noise normalisation across all tracks.
Giving the user an audio queue that a song is about to transition is highly beneficial to listening immersion. It allows for mental preparation of the next song for eg. skipping, muting, changing volume without a sudden abrupt need to potentially reverse the first few seconds of the song.
Please consider this feature. Even a simple fade would be greatly appreciated. The overall user experience of Innertune is incredible, however compared to mainstream services like Spotify, a lack of fade is one of the most noticeable missing features in Innertune.
If such a fade option was added, it'd also likely be accepted upstream, even if the source wasn't crossed/overlayed and the volume was simply faded between tracks.
Thanks for considering!
Why do you want this feature?
Crossfade allows for a much more immersing listening experience. It prevents sudden and sharp transitions in different songs by giving the user a passive subconscious notice of song transition.
Additional information
For a quick and painless way on how to do this, please see VolumeShaper: google/ExoPlayer#10702
https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/media/platform/volumeshaper
In short, it would require an extremely small refactor of the already existing gapless option in Innertune. 🎼
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: