Swiping a notification to dismiss should not dismiss all notifications

[jblz]

Expected behavior

Only the item swiped to be dismissed

Actual behavior

The item disappears & then all app notifications disappear

Steps to reproduce the behavior

Have more than one notification items, swipe one away

Tested on [device], Android [version]

Pixel, Android versions 8 & 9

[hypest]

Tried app version 11.4 on a Pixel 2 XL running Android 9 and couldn't reproduce it when dismissing one of two notifications. I tried with one comment and one "Like" notification and been able to dismiss the "Like" only. Are there perhaps more specific steps to reproduce? Thanks!

[jblz]

@hypest I'll keep an eye out for how to reproduce. Perhaps, the issue only surfaces if there are multiple of the same type (e.g. all comments)

[jblz]

I'm still seeing this from time to time.

Here's what my notification drawer looked like when it occurred recently:

...when I swiped away the bottom note, all three were dismissed.

[designsimply]

Moving to the Prioritized list because even though we can always open the Notifications tab to see what’s up, it's annoying as the feeling is something may have just been missed. Thank you for raising the issue @jblz !

[jblz]

Thanks, @designsimply!

I think I've noticed this happening more frequently when there are "non-standard" notification types in the list. For example X-post notifications. Perhaps that's related.

[malinajirka]

I've looked into this issue, but it's difficult to fix since we are not able to reproduce it. I've tested different scenarios and everything worked as expected for me.

I have two guesses what might be causing the issue

1. The app crashes in the background when the notification is dismissed.
2. We create a PendingIntent which is processed when the notification is dismissed and this line doesn't work as expected (from an unknown reason). We invoke notificationManager.cancel(GCMMessageService.GROUP_NOTIFICATION_ID); and all notifications are dismissed

@jblz I'd be great if you could post the application log when this issue happens again. (Click on "Me" -> "Help & Support" -> "Application log". Thank you 🙇

Note: I'll keep testing this issue on the production version of the app. Hopefully, I'll encounter it sooner or later.

[antonis]

I'm closing the issue since I wasn't able to reproduce in the latest version of the app

Screen_recording_20240304_181916.mp4