[Replay Bug]: Star Citizen ARK Starmap - stuck on loading

[ZheniaZuser]

https://robertsspaceindustries.com/starmap

using Brave

[Shrinks99]

Can replicate, looks like a replay issue? Moving to ReplayWebpage.

[ikreymer]

Took a quick look. This may actually be a capture issue under the hood - there is an empty POST request that is being incorrectly recorded as a GET request. However, there may be also additional issues on top of that.

[Shrinks99]

sigh oops. This is the https://robertsspaceindustries.com/api/starmap/bootup 404? Seems to be within the WACZ I made. Unsure about the request type though.

[ikreymer]

This is fixable but involves not 1 but 2 tricky edge case scenarios:

1. When storing a POST request with no/empty body, ArchiveWeb.page actually just treats it as a GET request, because the body is missing. However, ReplayWeb.page attempts to match it as a POST request. This should be addressed by either changing ArchiveWeb.page, or changing ReplayWeb.page to behave the same way (if no POST data, even though a POST request is made, just treat it as a GET, and not look for &__wb_method=POST query arg).

2. The site uses an <object> tag for SVG rendering, however, <object> tag don't work well with service workers (see: object/embed w3c/ServiceWorker#249). The best option is to actually rewrite an <object> tag to an iframe if the type is image/svg+xml. We also want the same behavior for PDFs, already partially implemented. For server side rewriting, can just replace <object> -> <iframe> if the type attribute matches. However, it becomes a bit more tricky when the element is created dynamically and events are added, eg:

const element = document.createElement("object")
element.type = "image/svg+xml";
element.addEventListener("load", ...)

We need a way to create either an <object> or an <iframe> based on the object type, but it is set later, so can't determine it in createElement. Replacing the element later is also tricky, as calling code will be pointing to a dead element.

In testing, when forcing all object -> iframe, this works, but this may break other things (eg. if is a flash, etc..). A possible workaround may be to create some intermediate proxy object, and actually create an object or iframe when appendChild() is called...

Just forcing the object to iframe does result in a working replay: