OAuth: server response missing access token

[samox73]

Unluckily, #18 did not help me. 2FA is disabled, I triple checked my username/password/ID/secret but I still get the error

Get "https://oauth.reddit.com/r/itookapicture/top?limit=1&t=today": oauth2: server response missing access_token

click me to see the request that is sent

{
   "Method":"GET",
   "URL":"*net/url.URL"{
      "Scheme":"https",
      "Opaque":"",
      "User":"*net/url.Userinfo nil",
      "Host":"oauth.reddit.com",
      "Path":"/r/itookapicture/top",
      "RawPath":"",
      "ForceQuery":false,
      "RawQuery":"limit=1&t=today",
      "Fragment":"",
      "RawFragment":""
   },
   "Proto":"HTTP/1.1",
   "ProtoMajor":1,
   "ProtoMinor":1,
   "Header":"net/http.Header"[
      "Content-Type":[
         "application/x-www-form-urlencoded"
      ],
      "Accept":[
         "application/json"
      ]
   ],
   "Body":"io.ReadCloser nil",
   "GetBody":"nil",
   "ContentLength":0,
   "TransferEncoding":[]"string len":0,
   "cap":0,
   "nil",
   "Close":false,
   "Host":"oauth.reddit.com",
   "Form":"net/url.Values nil",
   "PostForm":"net/url.Values nil",
   "MultipartForm":"*mime/multipart.Form nil",
   "Trailer":"net/http.Header nil",
   "RemoteAddr":"",
   "RequestURI":"",
   "TLS":"*crypto/tls.ConnectionState nil",
   "Cancel":"<-chan struct"{
      
   }"nil",
   "Response":"*net/http.Response nil",
   "ctx":context.Context(*context.emptyCtx) *0
}

I noticed that the User field is nil. Is that the intended behavior? I'm initializing the client like this:

id := "xxxxxxxxxxxx"
secret := "xxxxxxxxxxxx"
user := "xxxxxxxxxxxx"
password := "xxxxxxxxxxxx"
credentials := reddit.Credentials{ID: id, Secret: secret, Username: user, Password: password}
client, err := reddit.NewClient(credentials)
if err != nil {
	panic(err)
}
posts, _, err := client.Subreddit.TopPosts(context.Background(), "itookapicture", &reddit.ListPostOptions{
	ListOptions: reddit.ListOptions{
		Limit: 1,
	},
	Time: "today",
})
if err != nil {
	panic(err)
}

I tried to track down where this error comes from and the call stack seems to be:

reddit#Do:348
reddit#DoRequestWithClient:437
client#Do:593
client#do:???

but I have no clue where inside client#do the error happens (set breakpoints at every return but they don't trigger). Thus, I am not quite sure if this is caused by misuse on my end, an error in go-reddit or (rather unlikely) in client.go.

[samox73]

@vartanbeno has this project been abandoned? I am also getting the

<p>reddit's awesome and all, but you may have a bit of a
problem. we've seen far too many requests come from your ip address
recently.</p>

error when running the examples, no matter which machine I run it from.

[caner-cetin]

Also getting OAuth error and this issue is from April. Code is long abandoned.

[dutchdata]

I just got to this page. I have been using graw and its subpackage, graw/reddit (https://github.com/turnage/graw & https://github.com/turnage/graw/reddit). The repo seems to be maintained actively and by many contributors.

I noticed a couple major differences between this repo and the aforementioned ones:

1. The config does not require a user-agent -- does it automatically create one?
2. So far, I have not read anything about this package regarding "waiting between requests" -- graw/reddit waits 1 second between requests to avoid hitting Reddit's 60-requests-per-minute limit.

To all above, I have gotten the same error only when exceeding Reddit's API limits. I am wondering if this package puts the onus on the user to time requests appropriately.

Hope this helps. And, if I have overlooked something in this repo's docs regarding the above assertions, please let me know.

Additionally, I only came to this repo because I am having trouble setting up event streams with graw and graw/reddit. Has anyone else had this issue?

[jgibat]

Hi, got the same issue so I dug into this a bit. You can see in reddit-oauth.go that it uses password auth, so I tested grant_type=password manually w/curl and got the following error:

{"error_description": "Only script apps may use password auth", "error": "unauthorized_client"}

I created a new app of type 'script' and can successfully authenticate and use go-reddit now. hope this helps.

[dutchdata]

Good find! Thank you for posting this. Also glad it wasn't just me.

…

On Sun, Jan 22, 2023 at 08:53 jgibat ***@***.***> wrote: Hi, got the same issue so I dug into this a bit. You can see in reddit-oauth.go that it uses password auth, so I tested grant_type=password manually w/curl and got the following error: {"error_description": "Only script apps may use password auth", "error": "unauthorized_client"} I created a new app of type 'script' and can successfully authenticate and use go-reddit now. hope this helps. — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#31 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AUWVMO6NDQQO7TRNEHXVM5DWTVJZFANCNFSM5QVOHPYA> . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[ashaller2017]

to anyone here I think most likely you guys are using a webapp or mobile app for the reddit api.. request a script app and it helps ease the oauth problem without having to go pull down the git and fix the reddit-auth file