diff --git a/src/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCast.php b/src/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCast.php
index 4003d01e..ac71df9e 100644
--- a/src/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCast.php
+++ b/src/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCast.php
@@ -42,7 +42,7 @@ protected function castValue(
         $datetime = $formats
             ->map(fn (string $format) => rescue(fn () => $type::createFromFormat(
                 $format,
-                (string) $value,
+                $value instanceof DateTimeInterface ? $value->format($format) : (string) $value,
                 isset($this->timeZone) ? new DateTimeZone($this->timeZone) : null
             ), report: false))
             ->first(fn ($value) => (bool) $value);
diff --git a/tests/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCastTest.php b/tests/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCastTest.php
index 2742f157..46054ec1 100644
--- a/tests/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCastTest.php
+++ b/tests/Casts/DateTimeInterfaceCastTest.php
@@ -59,6 +59,78 @@
             CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
         )
     )->toEqual(new DateTimeImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'carbon'),
+            new Carbon('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new Carbon('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'carbonImmutable'),
+            new CarbonImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new CarbonImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'dateTime'),
+            new DateTime('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new DateTime('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'dateTimeImmutable'),
+            new DateTimeImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new DateTimeImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'carbon'),
+            new DateTime('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new Carbon('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'carbonImmutable'),
+            new DateTimeImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new CarbonImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'dateTime'),
+            new Carbon('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new DateTime('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
+
+    expect(
+        $caster->cast(
+            FakeDataStructureFactory::property($class, 'dateTimeImmutable'),
+            new CarbonImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'),
+            [],
+            CreationContextFactory::createFromConfig($class::class)->get()
+        )
+    )->toEqual(new DateTimeImmutable('19-05-1994 00:00:00'));
 });
 
 it('fails when it cannot cast a date into the correct format', function () {