host_with_path with dynamic page.

[mesiarm]

I want create sites for diferent locales (example.com/page, example.com/en/page) so I am using host_with_path multisite option. But dynamic page (example.com/project/{slug}) stopped working and when visiting example.com/project/example it redirects back to example.com. When I added dynamic page to ignore_uri_patterns, it works, but blocks in global page doesn´t work.

[mesiarm]

When I try debug method matchRequest in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\BaseSiteSelector $site->getRelativePath() returns "/" sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath()) returns "@^(/)(/.*|$)@", and $requestPathInfo contains "/project/example/". Preg_match doesn´t match anything. Is regex correct?

protected function matchRequest(SiteInterface $site, Request $request)
    {
        $results = [];

        // we read the value from the attribute to handle fragment support
        $requestPathInfo = $request->get('pathInfo', $request->getPathInfo());

        if (!preg_match(sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath()), $requestPathInfo, $results)) {
            return false;
        }

        return $results[2];
    }

[eerison]

Hey @mesiarm I use multi site in my project too, but for dynamically routes, I create an action in a controller (a normal symfony's action) to manager this route!
But I guess it's not the best approach, later I found that is possible to use Hybrid or Dynamic pages, look here: https://docs.sonata-project.org/projects/SonataPageBundle/en/3.x/reference/introduction/#a-page

But there isn't too much doc about this, I guess you need to check in the code how it works, But if it works for you provide some Pull request improving the documentation about this please, maybe it can help others.

[eerison]

When I try debug method matchRequest in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\BaseSiteSelector $site->getRelativePath() returns "/" sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath()) returns "@^(/)(/.*|$)@", and $requestPathInfo contains "/project/example/". Preg_match doesn´t match anything. Is regex correct?

protected function matchRequest(SiteInterface $site, Request $request)
    {
        $results = [];

        // we read the value from the attribute to handle fragment support
        $requestPathInfo = $request->get('pathInfo', $request->getPathInfo());

        if (!preg_match(sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath()), $requestPathInfo, $results)) {
            return false;
        }

        return $results[2];
    }

have you tried to use Hybrid or Dynamic routes?

[mesiarm]

When I try debug method matchRequest in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\BaseSiteSelector $site->getRelativePath() returns "/" sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath()) returns "@^(/)(/.*|$)@", and $requestPathInfo contains "/project/example/". Preg_match doesn´t match anything. Is regex correct?

protected function matchRequest(SiteInterface $site, Request $request)
    {
        $results = [];

        // we read the value from the attribute to handle fragment support
        $requestPathInfo = $request->get('pathInfo', $request->getPathInfo());

        if (!preg_match(sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath()), $requestPathInfo, $results)) {
            return false;
        }

        return $results[2];
    }

have you tried to use Hybrid or Dynamic routes?

I created App Project Detail page with /project/{slug} page and then created ProjectController with detail action and route setting:

<?php

namespace App\Controller;

use App\Entity\Project;
use Sensio\Bundle\FrameworkExtraBundle\Configuration\ParamConverter;
use Symfony\Bundle\FrameworkBundle\Controller\AbstractController;
use Symfony\Component\HttpFoundation\Response;
use Symfony\Component\Routing\Annotation\Route;

class ProjectController extends AbstractController
{
    /**
     * @Route("/project/{slug}", name="app_project_detail")
     * @ParamConverter("project", options={"mapping": {"slug": "slug"}})
     */
    public function detail(Project $project): Response
    {
        return $this->render('project/detail.html.twig', [
            'test' => 'test',
            'project' => $project,
        ]);
    }
}

[haivala]

Just to mention that I have done something like this: #1368

[eerison]

Just to mention that I have done something like this: #1368

Hi @haivala thanks for share your issue here :)

But definitely we need more documentation about this, should be really good if someone that used this can provide some doc, unfortunately I didn't test this functionality yet.

But @mesiarm if you want to test this solution and add some doc, it will be really good :)

[mesiarm]

#752 - simmilar issue. Dynamic page should be definitely better documented, how to use it, maybe someone, who used this functionality in his/her projects could provide more information. I will try to look at source code to understand it better.

[mesiarm]

"@^(/)(/.*|$)@" regex in matchRequest in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\BaseSiteSelector causes / as default site relative path is not supported.

[mesiarm]

So if default site relative path cannot be / - is it bug or is it intended?

[eerison]

So if default site relative path cannot be / - is it bug or is it intended?

Can't it be "/" or "/-"? If you mean it can't be "/-" then I would say it's intend, Because this slug/url is more or less wrong?🤔

Or is it missing the locale like "/de-en"?

[mesiarm]

I mean only / (without dash). I wanted to use / for default site and /en for English site.

[eerison]

I mean only / (without dash). I wanted to use / for default site and /en for English site.

Well if you can't use with / and /en ,I would say it's a bug 🤔, what do you think?

I use this functionality but with multisite

[mesiarm]

Just to clarify: /en works, /anything works, but / doesn´t. Regex is sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath())

[eerison]

Just to clarify: /en works, /anything works, but / doesn´t. Regex is sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath())

I guess you can create a site with relativePath = null

[mesiarm]

Just to clarify: /en works, /anything works, but / doesn´t. Regex is sprintf('@^(%s)(/.*|$)@', $site->getRelativePath())

I guess you can create a site with relativePath = null

I think it wouldn´t match mentioned regex which is in method matchRequest in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\BaseSiteSelector

[mesiarm]

correction - I tried it with null and it works (probably due $request->setPathInfo($pathInfo ?: '/'); in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector) . It should be corrected in documentation https://docs.sonata-project.org/projects/SonataPageBundle/en/3.x/reference/getting_started/ because there is stated default site /, but in CreateSiteCommand it is converted to empty string ($site->setRelativePath('/' === $values['relativePath'] ? '' : $values['relativePath']);) It works, because Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector accepts falsy values, but it is confusing, when creating sites manually.

[eerison]

correction - I tried it with null and it works (probably due $request->setPathInfo($pathInfo ?: '/'); in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector) . It should be corrected in documentation https://docs.sonata-project.org/projects/SonataPageBundle/en/3.x/reference/getting_started/ because there is stated default site /, but in CreateSiteCommand it is converted to empty string ($site->setRelativePath('/' === $values['relativePath'] ? '' : $values['relativePath']);) It works, because Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector accepts falsy values, but it is confusing, when creating sites manually.

But the question is, is it the correct way 👀 , I don't know why the doc says that the default value is /, it's strange :/

[mesiarm]

correction - I tried it with null and it works (probably due $request->setPathInfo($pathInfo ?: '/'); in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector) . It should be corrected in documentation https://docs.sonata-project.org/projects/SonataPageBundle/en/3.x/reference/getting_started/ because there is stated default site /, but in CreateSiteCommand it is converted to empty string ($site->setRelativePath('/' === $values['relativePath'] ? '' : $values['relativePath']);) It works, because Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector accepts falsy values, but it is confusing, when creating sites manually.

But the question is, is it the correct way 👀 , I don't know why the doc says that the default value is /, it's strange :/

Yes, any falsy value in relativePath works, / doesn´t work.

[eerison]

correction - I tried it with null and it works (probably due $request->setPathInfo($pathInfo ?: '/'); in Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector) . It should be corrected in documentation https://docs.sonata-project.org/projects/SonataPageBundle/en/3.x/reference/getting_started/ because there is stated default site /, but in CreateSiteCommand it is converted to empty string ($site->setRelativePath('/' === $values['relativePath'] ? '' : $values['relativePath']);) It works, because Sonata\PageBundle\Site\HostPathSiteSelector accepts falsy values, but it is confusing, when creating sites manually.

But the question is, is it the correct way 👀 , I don't know why the doc says that the default value is /, it's strange :/

Yes, any falsy value in relativePath works, / doesn´t work.

well in this case we should provide a fix for this! like doesn't accept "/" in relativePath we could use symfony assert for this

[eerison]

Yeah I checked now and in the project that I'm working it's null

[jordisala1991]

Does #1606 fix this issue?