Wrong focus on preset search

[bussed]

On OSX / Safari

I create a new area.
I leave draw mode (clicking on area mode again).
I select the drawn area.
"Ribbon" shows up with Del / Q / O / etc options (this is really cool btw)

But the focus is now in the preset search text field. So q/o/.. shortcuts dont work.
I have to select an preset first to get the keyboard shortcuts working.

This behaviour confused me a bit. I would have expected the keyboard shortcuts "to work" in this situation.

[tmcw]

This doesn't seem wrong to me: iD focuses on getting users to enter a preset first and thus focuses the preset search area until they have enough tags to be valid features - even if you leave the feature selection and return to it. Once a feature has enough tags to be valid, or a preset selected, clicking on it will not focus the preset search area.

[bussed]

Hmm, i think it is not uncommon that you first want to get the geometry correct (with the help of pressing o or q) and then - as a last step - add a preset. Often i draw several buildings geom and then apply a preset to them at last.
But this is just how i use to map.

[jfirebaugh]

Yes, I think we should auto-focus the search field only right after finishing drawing. At that point, the radial menu isn't shown anyway. So then the flow for correcting geometry before assigning a preset would be:

1. Draw
2. Finish drawing (either by esc or return key, or clicking the starting/ending node)
3. Now search field is focused, no radial menu is open
4. Click again to reselect the feature and show menu
5. Now the search field should be blurred (this is what should change from current behavior)

In other words: when the menu is shown, search should not be focused. When search is focused, the menu should not be shown.