You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Describe the bug
Looking at a test run, I can see the following:
Testing wcs2:get-scal-req3-kvp type Mandatory in Test Mode with defaultResult Pass (s0001/d14820e89_1/d4566e24999_1)...
Assertion: Req3:Test GridCoverage,RectifiedGridCoverage.
[FAILURE] The service should offer at least one GridCoverage.
[MESSAGE] The server does not support the gml coverage.
Test wcs2:get-scal-req3-kvp Failed
Now, the server in question only has RectifiedGridCoverage, it does not support general GridCoverage.
The test is however written to fail if at least one is not found:
I don't think this is what the ATS requires... requirement 3 states:
The coverage identifier in a GetCoverage request shall address a coverage which is a GridCoverage, RectifiedGridCoverage, ReferenceableGridCoverage, or a subtype of one of these."
ReferenceableGridCoverage is commented out through the tests, but I think in order to pass the test a server should offer at least a GridCoverage or a RectifiedGridCoverage, but not both?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
@aaime yes, you are right: the intention of the test was that at least one coverage of whatever type, dimension, range type must be provided for executing a test. So indeed it is an "or".
BTW, GridCoverage is a deprecated initial attempt dating back 20+ years and known to be flawed. CIS 1.1 adds a GeneralGridCoverage which unifies it all, and to add this into the game WCS 2.1 has been issued (no further technical change).
aaime
changed the title
Scaling test requires at least one GridCoverage
Scaling test should allow having one GridCoverage or one RectifiedGridCoverage
Dec 8, 2024
aaime
added a commit
to geoserver/ets-wcs20
that referenced
this issue
Dec 8, 2024
Describe the bug
Looking at a test run, I can see the following:
Now, the server in question only has RectifiedGridCoverage, it does not support general GridCoverage.
The test is however written to fail if at least one is not found:
https://github.com/opengeospatial/ets-wcs20/blob/master/src/main/scripts/ctl/ext_get-scal.xml#L357
I don't think this is what the ATS requires... requirement 3 states:
ReferenceableGridCoverage is commented out through the tests, but I think in order to pass the test a server should offer at least a GridCoverage or a RectifiedGridCoverage, but not both?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: