You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
In my opinion, the language of the robot convert docs does not entirely make it clear that all of the formats listed are both valid input formats and output formats, though I think that is the case. Although probably intuitive, it is also unclear that the --format option applies to output and not input, so some clarity on that would be helpful. Finally, I think it would be good to allow flags for both --output-format and --input-format. In my experience in the ontology world, I find files with extensions that aren't canonical / aren't reflective of the actual serialization. As a non-expert in many of these formats, it's sometimes not clear for me what file extension to use myself, but if I have an enumeration of --input-format and --output-format to choose from, this gives me confidence that the tool is interpreting things correctly.
Propositions
1. Update the robot convert docs to make it clear that the serialization formats listed are acceptable as both inputs and outputs.
@joeflack4 we have an open PR for --input-format: #1056 This feature does have some complications stemming from automatic loading of ontology imports (discussed in the PR).
I should also note: the input and output formats are not exactly the same. JSON input (JSON-LD) and JSON output (OBO Graphs) are different, for example.
Overview
In my opinion, the language of the
robot convert docs
does not entirely make it clear that all of the formats listed are both valid input formats and output formats, though I think that is the case. Although probably intuitive, it is also unclear that the--format
option applies to output and not input, so some clarity on that would be helpful. Finally, I think it would be good to allow flags for both--output-format
and--input-format
. In my experience in the ontology world, I find files with extensions that aren't canonical / aren't reflective of the actual serialization. As a non-expert in many of these formats, it's sometimes not clear for me what file extension to use myself, but if I have an enumeration of--input-format
and--output-format
to choose from, this gives me confidence that the tool is interpreting things correctly.Propositions
robot convert docs
to make it clear that the serialization formats listed are acceptable as both inputs and outputs.--format
-->--output-format
--input-format
Related
--input-format
option #1056The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: