Unable to run barebones NestJS app with yarn pnp

[fabiog27]

Current Behavior

If you try to run a NestJS app with nx in combination with yarn v3 in pnp mode, you get a bunch of errors during build about incorrect dependency resolution. This does not happen when running a NestJS app with yarn v3 without nx.

Expected Behavior

I expect the NestJS app to build successfully with this combination of tools. Yarn v3 with pnp as the nodeLinker is giving us great benefits during local & CI builds.

GitHub Repo

https://github.com/fabiog27/nx-nestjs-yarn-example

Steps to Reproduce

1. Clone the repo
2. yarn install
3. yarn nx serve experiment

Nx Report

Node : 18.14.2
   OS   : darwin x64
   yarn : 3.4.1

   nx                      : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/js                : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/jest              : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/linter            : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/workspace         : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/eslint-plugin-nx  : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/nest              : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/node              : 15.8.2
   @nrwl/webpack           : 15.8.2
   typescript              : 4.9.5

Failure Logs

hunk (runtime: main) main.js (main) 1.9 MiB (javascript) 793 bytes (runtime) [entry] [rendered]

WARNING in ../../.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/utils/load-package.util.js 9:39-59
Critical dependency: the request of a dependency is an expression

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/express-npm-4.18.2-bb15ff679a-3c4b9b0768.zip/node_modules/express/lib/view.js 81:13-25
Critical dependency: the request of a dependency is an expression

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/concat.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/concat.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/concat.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/filter.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/filter.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/filter.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/flatten.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/flatten.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/flatten.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/index.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/index.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/index.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/iterate.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/iterate.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/iterate.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/map.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/map.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/map.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/slice.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/slice.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/slice.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/utils.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/utils.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/utils.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/lib/zip.js
Module Warning (from ../../.yarn/__virtual__/source-map-loader-virtual-ffe0e71b95/0/cache/source-map-loader-npm-3.0.2-6e868d7f08-d5a4e2ab19.zip/node_modules/source-map-loader/dist/cjs.js):
Failed to parse source map from '/Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/cache/iterare-npm-1.2.1-b666309be8-70bc80038e.zip/node_modules/iterare/src/zip.ts' file: Error: ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '/node_modules/iterare/src/zip.ts'

WARNING in ../../.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/helpers/load-adapter.js 9:39-63
Critical dependency: the request of a dependency is an expression

WARNING in ../../.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/helpers/optional-require.js 6:39-59
Critical dependency: the request of a dependency is an expression

ERROR in ../../.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/cache/cache.providers.js 17:108-132
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/common tried to access cache-manager (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: cache-manager
Required by: @nestjs/common@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/cache/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/testing@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



ERROR in ../../.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/pipes/validation.pipe.js 38:174-200
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/common tried to access class-validator (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: class-validator
Required by: @nestjs/common@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/pipes/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/testing@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



ERROR in ../../.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/pipes/validation.pipe.js 41:182-210
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/common tried to access class-transformer (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: class-transformer
Required by: @nestjs/common@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/pipes/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/testing@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



ERROR in ../../.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/serializer/class-serializer.interceptor.js 25:244-272
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/common tried to access class-transformer (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: class-transformer
Required by: @nestjs/common@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/__virtual__/@nestjs-common-virtual-5682bc52e1/0/cache/@nestjs-common-npm-9.3.9-aa8dde60a2-48fde36bef.zip/node_modules/@nestjs/common/serializer/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/testing@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



ERROR in ../../.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/nest-application.js 19:107-150
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/core tried to access @nestjs/websockets (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: @nestjs/websockets
Required by: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/testing@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



ERROR in ../../.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/nest-application.js 20:124-177
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/core tried to access @nestjs/microservices (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: @nestjs/microservices
Required by: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



ERROR in ../../.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/nest-application.js 122:120-152
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/core tried to access @nestjs/microservices (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: @nestjs/microservices
Required by: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



ERROR in ../../.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/nest-factory.js 57:120-152
Module not found: Error: @nestjs/core tried to access @nestjs/microservices (a peer dependency) but it isn't provided by its ancestors; this makes the require call ambiguous and unsound.

Required package: @nestjs/microservices
Required by: @nestjs/core@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9 (via /Users/fabio/projects/test/nx-nestjs-yarn-example/.yarn/unplugged/@nestjs-core-virtual-e8ebea8e3e/node_modules/@nestjs/core/)

Ancestor breaking the chain: @nestjs/platform-express@virtual:97b59d416a009439fa8dbc23c5107e61f2df4eeb4d52731c32ca239deaeb6407a49d416ea32b9198a31d27f9142fe2b91a03d92e3f0ad8d911021b64e723395a#npm:9.3.9
Ancestor breaking the chain: experiment@workspace:.



webpack compiled with 8 errors and 13 warnings (2bb0c791ddacc81d)
There was an error with the build. See above.

Additional Information

No response

[AgentEnder]

NX doesn't currently support yarn PnP, the request is tracked by #2386. I'm going to close this as a duplicate, since it is tracked elsewhere.

We would like to move forward with PnP support at some point, but its not a small effort and we are currently prioritizing other tasks.

[github-actions]

This issue has been closed for more than 30 days. If this issue is still occuring, please open a new issue with more recent context.