Nesting of [[ ... ]] should produce error

[thoj]

NeoLua Version: 13.11

Example to reproduce:

local longstr = [[Show me this
yes!
]]

--[[

local unused_string = [[Line1
Line2]]

local longstr = [[
Do not show me this
Multiline string]]

--]]

print(longstr)

Hi i ran into this when i used

--[[
Some code
something = [[ long string ]]
Some Code <-- this executed
--]]
Some more code

I got really confused until i tried with normal lua interpeter where i got:
lua: [string ""]:5: nesting of [[...]] is deprecated near '['

I think NeoLua also should make nesting [[...]] an error.

Note for others: You should enclose long strings in [=[...]=], [==[...]==], [===[...]===], etc to avoid this.

[neolithos]

I always test with:
Lua Live Demo
And it produces the same result as NeoLua.

The reason is you commented the last closing string out. For the neolua the whole line is a comment.

What lua-interpreter did you use? Version?

[thoj]

Weird. I tried with Lua 5.1.5 and got the above deprecated message.

tj@ami:~$ lua test.lua
lua: test.lua:7: nesting of [[...]] is deprecated near '['
tj@ami:~$ lua -v
Lua 5.1.5  Copyright (C) 1994-2012 Lua.org, PUC-Rio
tj@ami:~$ lua5.3 test.lua
Do not show me this
Multiline string

Strange that lua would let you shoot yourself in the foot like that without even a warning.

[neolithos]

Interesting...

I have no idea, which way is the best?

[thoj]

Hmm yeah this is a quite interesting issue. The best in my opinion would be a warning.