Group control

[measwel]

Hi,

Would it be possible to control a group of devices like with the smartlife app? The app controls the devices in a group practically simultanously. When I try the same with tinytuya, I need to send commands to each device separately and I get a delay for each device. Sorry if the question has been asked before.

[uzlonewolf]

Not easily. You basically have to pre-open persistent connections to every device in the group and then send the commands as needed. If no data is received in ~29 seconds the devices close the connection, so a keep-alive/heartbeat must be implemented as well. The quick-n-dirty way of doing this uses a thread for each device, though I personally don't like doing that and instead use non-blocking sockets and dump them all into select() with a timeout.

[measwel]

Thanks @uzlonewolf.

My usecase. I use 5 RGB LED bulbs in my darkroom app (https://github.com/measwel/darkroom). I switch these off, before I switch on the enlarger (via smart outlet). They go out one by one and sometimes not all are off when the enlarger switches on. It would be useful to:

(1) switch them all off in one go.
(2) have a light weight way to know if they are all off.

As to (1) could you perhaps show some example code?
As to (2) is polling the status the only way to find out if the bulb is off? It introduces another delay.
The turn_off() command does not return the status of the bulb.
What would be a smart way to find out if the bulb is off?

[uzlonewolf]

Unfortunately I don't have any simple code to demonstrate it, the best I got is the "multiserver" I was working on https://github.com/uzlonewolf/tinytuya/blob/socket-server/multiserver/multiserver.py#L777 . It still has some rough edges such as lag when it's attempting to (re-)connect devices, but it otherwise works.

As long as the connections are persistent the devices should send async status updates whenever their state changes, so it shouldn't be too hard to just track the last state received.

[mariustt]

Hi,

I’m experiencing the same issue using Tuya Local, which is based on TinyTuya. When trying to turn off 14 lights simultaneously, I see a similar result as the one shown make-all/tuya-local#1323 (comment).

Any advice or solutions for this problem would be absolutely amazing!