Unsorted list of secrets in UI for Generic/KV version 1

[Garath620]

Describe the bug
Vault UI displays an unsorted list of secrets for Generic/KV V1 secret store.

Expected behavior
The list of secret should be sorted alphabetically like in KV V2 secret store.

Environment:

• Vault Server Version 0.10.4

[briankassouf]

Which storage backend are you using?

[Garath620]

I use Filesystem Storage Backend.
I try with vault server in dev mode and the list of secret is sorted correctly.

[jefferai]

Just to be clear, "sorted correctly" implies that there is a sorting order. There's not. It just so happens that most storage implementations, when listing, will return a sorted set of strings.

At this point, it's unclear whether you're describing a desired improvement to the file storage engine, or if you are raising some kind of issue with the UI. I don't know of any reason that V1/V2 would behave differently.

[Garath620]

Hello @jefferai

I create a kv secrets engine v1 and an other in v2.
vault secrets enable -path=testsort -version=1 kv
vault secrets enable -path=testsort2 -version=2 kv
I put same data into and in UI I see this :

[Garath620]

Thank you!