[TRACKER] BaseMaterial3D (StandardMaterial3D + ORMMaterial3D) issues

[Calinou]

This is a tracker issue for the default 3D material implementation in Godot 4.0 (formerly SpatialMaterial). BaseMaterial3D provides StandardMaterial3D and ORMMaterial3D.

This tracker only tracks issues in the master branch, not 3.x.

Bugs

Preview Give feedback

1. Clearcoat effect on materials is too subtle #14403
   bug confirmed topic:3d topic:rendering +4
2. Vulkan: StandardMaterial3D render_priority has no effect #48123
   bug regression topic:3d topic:rendering +4
3. Vulkan: StandardMaterial3D specular modes are off by one #49841
   bug regression topic:3d topic:rendering +4
4. Vulkan: Depth prepass does not respect cull mode #50124
   bug regression topic:3d topic:rendering +4
5. Vulkan: ORMMaterial3D has a redundant Ambient Occlusion section #50231
   archived bug topic:3d topic:rendering +4
6. Vulkan: ORMMaterial3D has no way to adjust metallic specular (unlike StandardMaterial3D) #50232
   discussion enhancement topic:3d topic:rendering +4
7. Vulkan: Enabling subsurface scattering on BaseMaterial3D spams error in output console #53444
   bug topic:3d topic:rendering +3
8. Vulkan: Light specular lobes can be visible on smooth-shaded surfaces facing away from the light #55161
   archived discussion topic:3d topic:rendering +4
9. Vulkan: BaseMaterial3D Anisotropy does not work and results in a shader compilation error if Normal Map is disabled #55771
   bug topic:3d topic:rendering +3
10. Vulkan: Alpha scissor/test material has pixel Z-order issues #56008
    bug topic:3d topic:rendering +3
11. Vulkan: StandardMaterial3D's Disable Ambient Light property has no effect #56332
    bug confirmed regression topic:3d topic:rendering +5
12. Vulkan: Standard/ORM Material Triplanar breaks with animation #56574
    bug confirmed topic:3d topic:rendering +4
13. Vulkan: Transparency pipeline has z-order issues #63675
    bug regression topic:3d topic:rendering +4
14. Vulkan: StandardMaterial3D with any transparency does not cast shadows #61730
    bug topic:3d topic:rendering +3

Missing features compared to 3.x's SpatialMaterial

Preview Give feedback

1. Vulkan: "Mirrored Repeat" option for BaseMaterial3D missing #51625
   confirmed regression topic:3d topic:rendering +4

Proposals

Preview Give feedback

1. Add rotation of UVs to StandardMaterial3D godot-proposals#1230
   archived topic:3d topic:rendering +3
2. Add a random rotation option to StandardMaterial3D option for tiling textures godot-proposals#1242
   topic:3d topic:rendering +2
3. Add self-shadowing to parallax occlusion mapping in StandardMaterial3D godot-proposals#1843
   topic:3d topic:rendering +2
4. Add a way to combine PBR maps into an ORM texture for use in ORMMaterial3D godot-proposals#2316
   topic:3d topic:editor +2
5. Add a project setting to control BaseMaterial3D parallax mapping quality in a global manner godot-proposals#2455
   performance topic:3d topic:rendering +3
6. Allow StandardMaterial3D Proximity Fade to fade surfaces when they are far away from other solid surfaces godot-proposals#3021
   topic:3d topic:rendering +2
7. Add a Detail Scale property to BaseMaterial3D godot-proposals#3499
   topic:3d topic:rendering +2

[TokisanGames]

Shouldn't these issues be on the GD4 roadmap? Also some of them are out of date, eg #56008 which has been fixed. And here's a new one: #63675