Formatter only keeps 1 blank line between functions, but the GDScript style guide mandates 2

[Calinou]

Godot version

4.2.1.stable

VS Code version

1.86.2

Godot Tools VS Code extension version

2.0.0

System information

Fedora 39

Issue description

The GDScript formatter only keeps 1 blank line between functions, but the GDScript style guide mandates 2.

func _on_sdfgi_option_button_item_selected(index: int) -> void:
	# This is a setting that is attached to the environment.
	# If your game requires you to change the environment,
	# then be sure to run this function again to make the setting effective.
	if index == 0: # Disabled (default)
		world_environment.environment.sdfgi_enabled = false
	if index == 1: # Low
		world_environment.environment.sdfgi_enabled = true
		RenderingServer.gi_set_use_half_resolution(true)
	if index == 2: # High
		world_environment.environment.sdfgi_enabled = true
		RenderingServer.gi_set_use_half_resolution(false)


func _on_glow_option_button_item_selected(index: int) -> void:
	# This is a setting that is attached to the environment.
	# If your game requires you to change the environment,
	# then be sure to run this function again to make the setting effective.
	if index == 0: # Disabled (default)
		world_environment.environment.glow_enabled = false
	if index == 1: # Low
		world_environment.environment.glow_enabled = true
	if index == 2: # High
		world_environment.environment.glow_enabled = true

Is turned into:

func _on_sdfgi_option_button_item_selected(index: int) -> void:
	# This is a setting that is attached to the environment.
	# If your game requires you to change the environment,
	# then be sure to run this function again to make the setting effective.
	if index == 0: # Disabled (default)
		world_environment.environment.sdfgi_enabled = false
	if index == 1: # Low
		world_environment.environment.sdfgi_enabled = true
		RenderingServer.gi_set_use_half_resolution(true)
	if index == 2: # High
		world_environment.environment.sdfgi_enabled = true
		RenderingServer.gi_set_use_half_resolution(false)

func _on_glow_option_button_item_selected(index: int) -> void:
	# This is a setting that is attached to the environment.
	# If your game requires you to change the environment,
	# then be sure to run this function again to make the setting effective.
	if index == 0: # Disabled (default)
		world_environment.environment.glow_enabled = false
	if index == 1: # Low
		world_environment.environment.glow_enabled = true
	if index == 2: # High
		world_environment.environment.glow_enabled = true

Note that this only applies between functions/classes, not between top-level member variables and functions/classes.

Steps to reproduce

Format the above code using Ctrl + Shift + I.

[DaelonSuzuka]

Technically this isn't a bug: I think two newlines between functions is bad and the official style guide is wrong.

But... I recognize that I'm the weirdo here, so I'll change the default behavior to do 2 newlines.

[limbonaut]

Wouldn't it be nice to have a configuration option?

[DaelonSuzuka]

I've been trying to avoid adding options for the formatter because that dramatically increases the complexity of both the formatter and the test suite.

This probably will be an option, because I really don't want two newlines in my projects.

[DaelonSuzuka]

Progress. It doesn't handle comments/doc comments yet, and it doesn't insert blanks lines if they're missing. And it breaks half the tests.

[chrisl8]

Technically this isn't a bug: I think two newlines between functions is bad and the official style guide is wrong.

But... I recognize that I'm the weirdo here, so I'll change the default behavior to do 2 newlines.

FWIW, I think Godot is attempting to follow the Python style guide.

https://peps.python.org/pep-0008/#blank-lines

Surround top-level function and class definitions with two blank lines.

[Calinou]

FWIW, I think Godot is attempting to follow the Python style guide.

Indeed, that was the main rationale for using 2 blank lines between functions/classes. There's also the reason that it mimics the effective spacing between functions in languages with brace syntax:

void something() {
	// pass
}

void other_function() {
	// pass
}

def something():
	pass


def other_function():
	pass

In both examples above, there are 2 "blank" lines between functions (even if in the brace-based case, there's a lone brace on the first line).

[rktprof]

Would it be possible to make it add lines but never remove lines? Sometimes I like to separate blocks with more than 1 or 2 lines

[Calinou]

Would it be possible to make it add lines but never remove lines? Sometimes I like to separate blocks with more than 1 or 2 lines

It's possible to design a formatter this way, but I don't think it's a good idea as it goes against the style guide (on top of making the formatter code more complex and bug-prone).

[rktprof]

It's possible to design a formatter this way, but I don't think it's a good idea as it goes against the style guide (on top of making the formatter code more complex and bug-prone).

Understandable, in this specific case it just feels more like a style enforcement rather than a guide =)

[limbonaut]

In defense of two blank lines... I tend to use blank lines to break up longer functions into logical subsections. With a single blank line between functions, it becomes harder to see at a glance where one function ends and another starts.

[DaelonSuzuka]

Closing since this feature was published a while ago.