Ikea Styrbar E2002 - 1002 ans 2002 block after long press left or right #5516
Comments
|
Hi, Hope that helps, regards |
|
As there has not been any response in 21 days, this issue has been automatically marked as stale. At OP: Please either close this issue or keep it active It will be closed in 7 days if no further activity occurs. |
|
Same Issue here - Conbee II with firmware 26660700. The up down buttons of the styrbar suddenly stopped working. |
|
Can confirm that long-pressing the left/right buttons unblocks the on/off buttons for me. |
|
I confirm that the long-pressing the left/right buttons blocks and unblocks the on/off buttons for me as well. I am also prety sure that it is not just about the left/right buttons because I was a few days out of my house. When left my home, all worked perfectly. When I came back the On/Off buttons were blocked on all Styrbar controllers in the house. |
|
I can semi-reliably trigger the hanging by pressing the left or right buttons multiple times in fast succession. |
|
Same here. Sometimes cannot turn off the associated light group after the scenes or brightness has been long-pressed or in succession. |
|
I can also confirm the staleness, but seems to not affect the API. |
|
After reading the suggestion here, i tried holding the left and right buttons and it been working for a day now. |
Okay it seems as if I was only lucky. Ran into this very same issue with OpenHAB today. A restart ofdeCONZ was required to get it back working. A reboot of the USB device did not help. |
|
Same here, long-pressed left/right blocks and unblocks up/down AND left/right long/release events |
|
I am using FHEM and deCOnz on a Raspi 3 and I am so glad I found this thread, because I am having the same problem and searching for the error for hours. Dresden Elektronik. can you please investigate this issue? This is my first Styrbar remote, and I immediately slipped into this issue :-( |
|
Asked manup to check. |
|
If I remember correctly the switch was a bit strange in what it sends for left/right buttons, not sure if it supports long press/hold at all for these buttons. Need to make some tests with the sniffer on. |
|
Pi4 with Raspberry Pi OS light I've got the problem that all telegrams are not really reliable. For me it looks like that the order in which I press the buttons has an impact. |
|
Just got a Styrbar too and experiencing the same issue, overall it's a very unreliable remote at the moment. Is there any way I can help with this? |
|
I got this Styrbar too, now but I'm expecting the simmilar issues mentioned up. I also can't fix this with rebooting my system pressing one of the button very often. The only way to solve, is delete it from deConz and reconnect it. But when the side buttons get pressed again, none of the other buttons work either. Thats very annoying and I hope it get fixed soon. |
|
I have the same issues. I logged an issue because i could not find any other logged issue. |
|
I am also having some issues with Styrbar. It seems to work for the most part, but "long press for colder" seems to be broken. Using "toggle warm/cold" appears to be a workaround. |
|
I have the same issue. Here is the debug line I get when the press on the on button doesn't work: [INFO] No button handler for: Remote Control N2, unicast to: 0x0000, endpoint: 0x01, cluster: ONOFF (Ox0006), command: ON(0x01), payload: None, zclSec: 24 |
|
Is there any chance that somebody from Dresden-Elektronik will fix this annoying issue please? :-) |
|
Already forwarded and it's on the list. Nothing more I can do atm. |
|
The switch sits already on the table for testing - before the next release :) |
|
Hmm the device is pretty strange for the side buttons. The 300x and 400x commands do actually work, but compared to the top/bottom buttons you need to press them longer until long press starts, like 2–3 seconds. After This the top/down buttons work again. If the side buttons are released before long press starts I can confirm the top/down buttons no longer work until long press again for > 2–3 seconds, at least this part seems to be a hickup in the plugin code, not sure yet what it is. The side button long press sends surprisingly a lot of commands during until long release: Next I'd like to check if the Ikea gateway applies some different configuration to make this useable. |
|
I made a few tests with the Ikea gateway and think we misunderstood how the "long press" and "long release" actually works. But more importantly the long press of the side buttons is completely symmetric, meaning left + right can't be distinguished. The long press command sequence is always: 0x09 → 0x07 → 0x08 → 0x09 Only the short press commands are different for left and right. Basically this means we need to change the implementation, for example we could add another virtual button which only has 5001 and 5003 and remove 3001, 3003 and 4001, 4003. Currently we also detect the long press too late at the stage of the 0x08 command, this needs to be changed to handle the 0x09 start properly. |
|
Ah now I see why we use 0x08, this actually does contain the info for left / right in the first payload byte. But this command comes 5 seconds after the initial 0x09 command, way too late to be usable. |
|
AS there's still issues with it, Re-opening. |
|
Copy from the merge: @De-k Behaviour: Healing: |
|
Notified @manup |
|
I can confirm this is still an issue on the HA version of Deconz 2.13.4 with a just unboxed STYRBAR. |
|
Same here. Using Deconz 2.13.4 and bought the styrbar 2 hours ago.. |
|
Adding my comments, same for me - |
|
The issue is (supposed to be) fixed in v2.14.0-beta, so reporting it doesn't work in older versions like v2.13.4 is rather superfluous. |
No clue as to how I(/we) should know that to be honest? The post in #5713 indicates its not fixed in the 2.14, that made me post in this original one. It was not intended to be rude or harsh comment, just wanted to point out that the issue was still there on current release and new hardware. @ALL that are working on the issue, thanks for all the efforts. |
I found out by reading the comments for the PR, and also the release notes of the v2.14.0-beta 😊 |
and others
Describe the bug
Hello, i have 2 Styrbar E2002 connected with my Home Assistant v2021.11.5 and deCONZ v6.10.0
1001, UP shoort
1002, UP long press
1003, UP long press release
2001, Down shoort
2002, Down long press
2003, Down long press release
3002, Shoort Left
4002 Shoort Right
all work but i don't have long press left and right
If i press long left or right, the 1002 and 2002 will no longer work
I listen the message with Node Red pelette deCONZ
Steps to reproduce the behavior
Push long on left or right button
Expected behavior
Screenshots
Environment
deCONZ Logs
Additional context
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: