DS1815+ (avaton) confirmed working with Club 3D CAC-1420, but unstable #43
Comments
|
Update: I had some weird wonkiness if IPv6 was left on including carrier flapping and worst-case scenario, what seems to be a kernel panic and the system becoming non-responsive requiring a hard reboot. After disabling IPv6 on the dongle, the system remained stable. If an IPv6 address still shows up on the dongle even if you have it set to off in DSM under Network, run as root/sudo in shell:
Going on 24 hours now with heavy traffic and no issues now. |
|
Update 2: Synology finally crashed. It seems related to this issue: https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=198931#c6 But I'm not sure if there's any way to disable LPM or to enable |
|
I investigated Synology's startup script and found that we could set parameters to the kernel module by editing the But Linux kernel 3.10.105 does not have the capability of quirk for LPM unfortunately... |
|
Thanks, same issue here with my DS1815+, was wondering why it kept crashing when transferring files. @bb-qq So does this mean, we can't use with DS1815+? /etc/modules.local.conf does not exist for me. There is however, /etc/modules.conf |
I have no idea what causes it, so for now I can only say that it does not work...
Yes, modules.local.conf should be created manually. modules.conf will be overwritten by Synology programs. |
|
10-4 Thank you. I appreciate you. |
|
Sadly still an issue with version 2.15.0-1 |
|
Hi! Do you have any update on this? There is some avaton based Synology at my partners, and they like some network improvization... |
|
I made a test driver disable LPM to investigate the problem on other platforms, but the symptoms did not improve. Since LPM is also suspected to cause crashes in this Issue, I have also made a driver for avton, but it will probably not improve the symptoms. |
bb-qq
changed the title
|
Thx,
I will try it later, (waiting for new HDD-s), and I will write back with
status.
THX a lot
Gabriel
bb-qq ***@***.***> ezt írta (időpont: 2022. ápr. 23., Szo,
6:51):
… I made a test driver disable LPM to investigate the problem on other
platforms, but the symptoms did not improve.
Since LPM is also suspected to cause crashes in this Issue, I have also
made a driver for avton, but it will probably not improve the symptoms.
https://github.com/bb-qq/r8152/releases/download/2.15.0-6/r8152-avoton-2.15.0-7nolpm2.spk
—
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#43 (comment)>, or
unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AYYUNRRKLZMT5UOVDEGLD2TVGN6WXANCNFSM4QG6U6NA>
.
You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID:
***@***.***>
--
*Keserű Gábor*
***@***.***
|
|
Hi,
A tried it, but no success.:
-Installed the driver
-I can see it in DSM, but didn't get IP with DHCP
-I set manually an IP, but can't ping it/cant reach it. In my Mikrotik
router, I see the IP, but no MAC address on this card.
Any idea? Maybe my Mikrotik router or my mikrotik switch is the problem?
Keserű Gábor ***@***.***> ezt írta (időpont: 2022. ápr. 24., V,
23:34):
… Thx,
I will try it later, (waiting for new HDD-s), and I will write back with
status.
THX a lot
Gabriel
bb-qq ***@***.***> ezt írta (időpont: 2022. ápr. 23., Szo,
6:51):
> I made a test driver disable LPM to investigate the problem on other
> platforms, but the symptoms did not improve.
>
> Since LPM is also suspected to cause crashes in this Issue, I have also
> made a driver for avton, but it will probably not improve the symptoms.
>
> https://github.com/bb-qq/r8152/releases/download/2.15.0-6/r8152-avoton-2.15.0-7nolpm2.spk
>
> —
> Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
> <#43 (comment)>, or
> unsubscribe
> <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AYYUNRRKLZMT5UOVDEGLD2TVGN6WXANCNFSM4QG6U6NA>
> .
> You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID:
> ***@***.***>
>
--
*Keserű Gábor*
***@***.***
--
*Keserű Gábor*
***@***.***
|
|
Try using 169.254.x.x IP addresses so don't need DHCP ? |
|
That could be a problem on the driver side. |
|
Great news to report. Looks like this is for sure a case of DS1815+ USB ports not having enough power. Now using a USB hub with power and it's stable. 🥇 I've gotten it fully stable and seeing as high as 230MB/s transfer speeds. Average closer to 165MB/s, but that is still a good 50MB/s faster, I'll take it.
Zero errors and 0 dropped after 62.4GiB sent and 20.6GiB received. Just messing around and that over a good 15 min period. Do see dmesg showing: But everything seems fine. Running lsusb shows correctly the hardware 🥇 I'll keep testing, for now reporting my findings and hoping others can duplicate and enjoy. Hardware And Software: I have cat 5e cable running from my NAS to my Win10 Computer just for testing. 1.) DS1815+ running DM 6.2.4-25556 Update 6 Then start testing. It's stable for me now, even 30 minutes later. First time ever. I'll get it working properly with DHCP and what not later, have to grab a longer cable first haha. Anyways, hope that helps someone. |
|
So doesn't work great with Jumbo frames, it's slower. Instead just using standard 1,500 MTU. And DHCP is working as expected. Make sure to set Control Panel > Network > Network Interface > Manage > Service Order and make LAN 5 first if you want your 2.5Gbps network to be the default. I recommend keeping the built in LAN 1 still as a backup, just in case. Edit: 24 hours later with Hyper Backup doing it's thing: OK, some send errors and dropped but nothing major. Can live with it, after all this NAS is from 2015 so not surprised it struggles a little bit. It's very much stable, with no corruption, and that's what counts. Edit: Well, 2 hours later and a good bit data later, no errors or drops. So think that was when I switched from Jumbo frame 9k to normal 1,500 MTU. Edit 2: Ok it does drop a little bit sadly. I can live with it. Still good bit faster than standard 1Gbps port(s). Do find it interesting, errors only on TX (send): dmesg: Edit 3: Sadly am seeing in dmesg: Edit 4: It locked up on me during a file transfer. So sadly not super stable even with USB hub. Giving up on this one. |
|
Also tried with Plugable 2.5G USB C and USB to Ethernet Adapter, 2-in-1 Adapter @ https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B084L4JL9K and same problem. :( |
|
NAS: DS1815+ (avaton) with 16GB RAM (2x8GB) DHCP worked just fine, albeit the nic originally was configured in as static, switched in DSM UI and worked. Seeing similar issues per other users with more recent driver. Speeds drop on transfer, but nothing fails and it picks back up soon after, both on iperf and a regular SMB transfer. No transfer or dropped packets at the nic level or switch level seen, just the expected Link down events from the USB reset. No crashes or manual intervention seen thus far with this type of event. iperf3 drop: relevent dmesg logs: ifconfig stats: Otherwise solid performance and thus far no major issues. Not sure if this is the same experience as others or not but I consider this good. |
|
iperf3 dropped because of the So yes same issue. It will become a problem. Files will drop in middle of transfer, if big enough and some times nic will stay down for a good 1 min plus and if you map a network share in windows for example it will randomly drop and explorer will complain about it, and if bad enough will lock up explorer.exe . |
NAS: DS1815+ (avaton) with 16GB RAM (2x8GB) w/two DX513's (Fully Loaded 18 drives).
DSM Version: 6.2.3-25426 Update 2
Driver version: r8152-avoton-2.12.0-3.spk
Switch: Netgear MS510TXPP (port g4, 2.5Gbps)
Notes: Informal SMB transfer speed to a Windows 10 x64 PC with NVMe SSD connected to g9 (10Gbps) QNAP QXG-10G1T (Aquantia AQtion AQC107 Chipset) results in 220MB+/sec speeds.
Since I'm running Open vSwitch for Virtual Machines on the DS1815+, I had to SSH into the box and manually run:
ifconfig eth4 upBefore if would show up in the Control Panel, allowing me to configure.
Relevant dmesg:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: