Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Feed Attributes or Properties #173

Closed
cookeac opened this issue Oct 22, 2020 · 5 comments
Closed

Feed Attributes or Properties #173

cookeac opened this issue Oct 22, 2020 · 5 comments
Labels
this-release Scheduled to be implemented for this release in development

Comments

@cookeac
Copy link
Collaborator

cookeac commented Oct 22, 2020

Suggesting work in this area to provide an initial, extensible code list in support of #93.
An alternative would be to allow for a Scheme + ID method of defining codes.

Common attributes seem to be:

Analysis Units Meaning
Dry Matter (DM) % (of feed)
Crude protein % (of DM) in NL/BE : RE (ruw eiwitgehalte)
Crude fibre % (of DM)
NDF % (of DM) Neutral detergent fibre
ADF % (of DM) Acid detergent fibre
Lignin % (of DM)
Ether extract % (of DM)
Ash % (of DM)
Starch % (of DM) in NL/BE : ZET (zetmeel)
Total Sugars % (of DM)
Gross Energy MJ/kg DM
Digestable Energy (DE) MJ/kg DM Ruminants, same name but different values for monogastrics
Metabolisable Energy (ME) MJ/kg DM Ruminants, same name but different values for monogastrics
Minerals Units Meaning
Calcium g/kg DM
Phosphorus g/kg DM
Potassium g/kg DM
Sodium g/kg DM
Magnesium g/kg DM
Manganese mg/kg DM
Zinc mg/kg DM
Copper mg/kg DM
Iron mg/kg DM
Aluminium mg/kg DM

There are a bunch more around amino acids, tannins, nitrogen degradability.

@erwinspeybroeck
Copy link
Collaborator

erwinspeybroeck commented Oct 23, 2020

There are formula's used to calculate a number of the feed properties out of feed properties that are analysed:

GE (gross energy) (kJ/kg) = 24,14 x RE + 36,57 x RVET + 20,92 x RC + 16,99 x OK - 0,63 x SUI*

  • correction for sugar only when more than 80 g sugar per kg dry matter
    RE = crude protein, RVET = crude fat, RC = crude fibre, SUI = sugar, OK(h) = 1000 – (liquid+ RAS (crude ashes) + RE + RVET(h) +RC) = other carbohydrates

ME (MJ/kg DM) = 14,94 VOS + 18,98 RVET –1,478 RC – 0,97 SUI (VOS=Digestible organic matter)
q = 100 ME /GE

NElac = 0,6 x (1 + 0,004 x (q-57)) x 0,9752 x ME (in kJ/kg)
This is the net energy value for milk production

VEM = NElac / 6900 x 1000
VEM is a relative energy measure, using barley as a reference raw material.
One kg of air-dried barley with a certain (standardized) composition has an average net energy value for milk production (NElac) of 6900 kJ.
VEM = 0,6 x (1+0,004 x (q-57)) x 0,9752 x ME / 6,90 = (0,0003392 x q + 0,0654656) x ME with ME the above metabolizing energy and q
VEM is used for milk production - there is also a VEVI for meat production

Regarding the analysis there are mostly regulations or ISO specifications , e.g. for crude fibre : EC Regulation 152/2009;
ISO 6865, 2000

In NL/BE a system called DVE/OEB is used.
DVE = digestible protein (is also calculated from a number of properties)
OEB = Unstable Protein Balance = OEB = {RE x (1 - 1,11 x %BRE/100)} - {FOS x 0,150}
%BRE = rumen resistance of crude protein , FOS = rumen fermentable organic matter

My conclusion is that we need to have the possibility to add "local" feed properties. A number of feed properties will be common, I guess

@erwinspeybroeck
Copy link
Collaborator

add a field : calculated/measured to each attribute

schemes would be helpful, but might become complex for processing it --> use an icar scheme and try to pose it as a standard

@cookeac cookeac added the this-release Scheduled to be implemented for this release in development label Nov 5, 2020
@SvenSchierenbeck
Copy link

SvenSchierenbeck commented Nov 18, 2020

some more minerals:

minerals units
sulphur g/kg DM
chlorine g/kg DM
cobalt mg/kg DM
selenium mg/kg DM
iodine mg/kg DM
molybdenum mg/kg GM

As Andrew mentioned there are several vitamins and amino acids which could be added later.
There are also some parameters of the German system and several parameters of the US CNCPS system missing. I will add some of them in the next days. I agree with Erwin that we should have the possibility to add some national feed properties.

@erwinspeybroeck
Copy link
Collaborator

This issue is solved in the next release, definitions are added to develop

@erwinspeybroeck
Copy link
Collaborator

This issue is solved in the next release, definitions are added to develop

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
this-release Scheduled to be implemented for this release in development
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants