Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Feature suggestion: Transmit PWR profile separately #79

Closed
tobekas opened this issue May 9, 2020 · 11 comments
Closed

Feature suggestion: Transmit PWR profile separately #79

tobekas opened this issue May 9, 2020 · 11 comments

Comments

@tobekas
Copy link

tobekas commented May 9, 2020

Hi Wouter,
is it possible to transmit Ant+ Device Profile PWR (and maybe S&C) in addition to FE-C?
I tested FortiusANT in simulation mode and tried to pair it with my Edge 800. It could find the HRM channel but unfortunately no power sensor. I think this is because the edge 800 does not support FE-C. However it would be great, if it could be used to track the workout with power information.

@WouterJD
Copy link
Owner

WouterJD commented May 9, 2020

Will do after current developments

@WouterJD WouterJD changed the title Transmit PWR profile separately Feature suggestion: Transmit PWR profile separately May 9, 2020
@WouterJD
Copy link
Owner

Check in on #87

@tobekas
Copy link
Author

tobekas commented May 20, 2020

Do you mean, this feature suggestion will be tracked in #87 or that is should already be implemented in the latest version?
With Version 3.0 a cannot find a separate "ANT+ PWR" channel with my Edge 800 by now. At least not in simulation mode (-s flag).
My original feature suggestion was to additionally broadcast a plain power channel (ANT+ PWR profile) in addition to the FE-E channel, which already includes power. Or even beyond that to additionally broadcast the S&C channel (speed and cadence), if possible.

@WouterJD
Copy link
Owner

Hi @tobekas Thanks for responding.

I sure understood your request and from #87 I understand that Edge pairs with FE-C channel.
First step please check what's going on in #87.
I have no edge so cannot test that.

If edge does not pair, I'm happy to create PWR profile; in that case please reopen this issue.

@tobekas
Copy link
Author

tobekas commented May 20, 2020

Edge 820 does pair with FE-C but Edge 800 and some other old generation devices don’t. In #87 it’s about pairing with an Edge 820. He also mentions an 800, but this is used as a reference measurement paired with an independent power meter and speed sensor for comparison.

My suggestion is to add PWR profile, to enable pairing with older devices. As far as I know, new generation Smart Trainers also provide PWR in addition to FE-C.

In addition to using Swift..., this would also make it possible to simply record power data with the Edge (for workout history in garminConnect, Strava...) during boring training only with the head unit, in case you don't have a power meter on your bike.

@WouterJD
Copy link
Owner

ok

@WouterJD
Copy link
Owner

@tobekas SCS and PWR profile are ready for test; refer to #95.

@tobekas
Copy link
Author

tobekas commented Jun 13, 2020

Hi. Just tested your branch (in simulation mode) and it works like a charm. SCS and PWR Sensors now appear and can be paired with my Edge 800. Great!

@WouterJD
Copy link
Owner

Great, thanks for testing👍👍

@WouterJD
Copy link
Owner

WouterJD commented Jun 14, 2020

Implemented and released

@BikeBeppe64
Copy link

Hi. Just tested your branch (in simulation mode) and it works like a charm. SCS and PWR Sensors now appear and can be paired with my Edge 800. Great!

I did It in a simulation mode too but had problem in normal mode.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants