diff --git a/packages/edit-site/src/components/dataviews/view-list.js b/packages/edit-site/src/components/dataviews/view-list.js
index fa4d143b4ee1ad..e48f3078714ae5 100644
--- a/packages/edit-site/src/components/dataviews/view-list.js
+++ b/packages/edit-site/src/components/dataviews/view-list.js
@@ -43,7 +43,6 @@ const {
 	DropdownMenuV2: DropdownMenu,
 	DropdownMenuGroupV2: DropdownMenuGroup,
 	DropdownMenuItemV2: DropdownMenuItem,
-	DropdownMenuCheckboxItemV2: DropdownMenuCheckboxItem,
 	DropdownMenuSeparatorV2: DropdownMenuSeparator,
 	DropdownSubMenuV2: DropdownSubMenu,
 	DropdownSubMenuTriggerV2: DropdownSubMenuTrigger,
@@ -202,12 +201,12 @@ function HeaderMenu( { dataView, header } ) {
 										return (
 											<DropdownMenuItem
 												key={ element.value }
+												role="menuitemradio"
 												prefix={
 													isActive && (
 														<Icon icon={ check } />
 													)
 												}
-												role="menuitemradio"
 												onSelect={ () => {
 													dataView.setColumnFilters( [
 														...otherFilters,
@@ -235,12 +234,14 @@ function HeaderMenu( { dataView, header } ) {
 											</DropdownSubMenuTrigger>
 										}
 									>
-										<DropdownMenuCheckboxItem
+										<DropdownMenuItem
 											key="in-filter"
-											value={ OPERATOR_IN }
-											checked={
+											role="menuitemradio"
+											prefix={
 												filterInView?.operator ===
-												OPERATOR_IN
+													OPERATOR_IN && (
+													<Icon icon={ check } />
+												)
 											}
 											onSelect={ () =>
 												dataView.setColumnFilters( [
@@ -255,13 +256,15 @@ function HeaderMenu( { dataView, header } ) {
 											}
 										>
 											{ __( 'Show matches' ) }
-										</DropdownMenuCheckboxItem>
-										<DropdownMenuCheckboxItem
+										</DropdownMenuItem>
+										<DropdownMenuItem
 											key="not-in-filter"
-											value={ OPERATOR_NOT_IN }
-											checked={
+											role="menuitemradio"
+											prefix={
 												filterInView?.operator ===
-												OPERATOR_NOT_IN
+													OPERATOR_NOT_IN && (
+													<Icon icon={ check } />
+												)
 											}
 											onSelect={ () =>
 												dataView.setColumnFilters( [
@@ -276,7 +279,7 @@ function HeaderMenu( { dataView, header } ) {
 											}
 										>
 											{ __( 'Hide matches' ) }
-										</DropdownMenuCheckboxItem>
+										</DropdownMenuItem>
 									</DropdownSubMenu>
 								) }
 							</WithSeparators>