Redefine term "switchyard" and add term "substation" #1975
Labels
[B] restructure
Restructuring existing parts of the ontology
To do
Issues that haven't got discussed yet
Description of the issue
The term OEO_00020009, "switchyard", is incorrectly defined as "an electricity grid component that connects different levels of voltage." This is not a switchyard, but a substation (at least in my experience, and also confirmed with a quick Google search to make sure I'm remembering correctly). The key difference between the two is that a switchyard contains the switchgear necessary for deenergizing some circuits and swapping load over to other circuits, usually in the event of a power outage or for scheduled maintenance. A substation contains some of this sort of switchgear, but it also contains transformers for stepping voltage from a higher level to a lower level, and that voltage transformation is the substation's primary purpose.
Ideas of solution
Redefine "switchyard" and add a new term "substation" with definitions along the lines of:
I'm not sure how much detail should go into the definitions. You could perhaps also expand on this with subclasses for the substation term:
However, all of my experience working with power grids comes from the US. I'm not sure if the "transmission substation" and "distribution substation" definitions I've proposed hold true for Germany's power grid, since Germany defines voltage levels differently than the US does, with a different dividing line between "transmission" voltages and "distribution" voltages:
Germany (source: https://www.smard.de/page/en/wiki-article/5884/214026)
USA (source: https://www.generatorsource.com/Articles/Generator-Info/High-Medium-and-Low-Voltage-Differences.aspx and my personal experience working as a power engineer for US utility companies)
Workflow checklist
I am aware that
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: