diff --git a/PoGo.NecroBot.Logic/Tasks/UseIncubatorsTask.cs b/PoGo.NecroBot.Logic/Tasks/UseIncubatorsTask.cs
index e8c299d6e..08e3282e1 100644
--- a/PoGo.NecroBot.Logic/Tasks/UseIncubatorsTask.cs
+++ b/PoGo.NecroBot.Logic/Tasks/UseIncubatorsTask.cs
@@ -73,7 +73,8 @@ public static async Task Execute(ISession session, CancellationToken cancellatio
                 if (incubator.PokemonId == 0)
                 {
                     // Unlimited incubators prefer short eggs, limited incubators prefer long eggs
-                    var egg = incubator.ItemId == ItemId.ItemIncubatorBasicUnlimited
+                    // Special case: If only one incubator is available at all, it will prefer long eggs
+                    var egg = (incubator.ItemId == ItemId.ItemIncubatorBasicUnlimited && incubators.Count > 1)
                         ? unusedEggs.FirstOrDefault()
                         : unusedEggs.LastOrDefault();