diff --git a/resources/lib/youtube_plugin/kodion/monitors/player_monitor.py b/resources/lib/youtube_plugin/kodion/monitors/player_monitor.py
index 41f906552..1ad502aee 100644
--- a/resources/lib/youtube_plugin/kodion/monitors/player_monitor.py
+++ b/resources/lib/youtube_plugin/kodion/monitors/player_monitor.py
@@ -218,8 +218,8 @@ def run(self):
                 status=(segment_end, segment_end, segment_end, 'stopped'),
             )
         if use_local_history:
-            self._context.get_playback_history().update_item(self.video_id,
-                                                             play_data)
+            self._context.get_playback_history().set_item(self.video_id,
+                                                          play_data)
 
         self._context.send_notification(PLAYBACK_STOPPED, self.playback_data)
         self._context.log_debug('Playback stopped [{video_id}]:'