GL_KHR_vulkan_glsl.txt

Name

    KHR_vulkan_glsl

Name Strings

    GL_KHR_vulkan_glsl

Contact

    John Kessenich (johnkessenich 'at' google.com), Google

Contributors

    Jeff Bolz, NVIDIA
    Kerch Holt, NVIDIA
    Kenneth Benzie, Codeplay
    Neil Henning, Codeplay
    Neil Hickey, ARM
    Daniel Koch, NVIDIA
    Timothy Lottes, Epic Games
    David Neto, Google

Notice

    Copyright (c) 2015 The Khronos Group Inc. Copyright terms at
        http://www.khronos.org/registry/speccopyright.html

Status

    Approved by Vulkan working group 03-Dec-2015.
    Ratified by the Khronos Board of Promoters 15-Jan-2016.

Version

    Last Modified Date: 17-Mar-2018
    Revision: 47

Number

    TBD.

Dependencies

    This extension can be applied to OpenGL GLSL versions 1.40
    (#version 140) and higher.

    This extension can be applied to OpenGL ES ESSL versions 3.10
    (#version 310) and higher.

    All these versions map GLSL/ESSL semantics to the same SPIR-V 1.0
    semantics (approximating the most recent versions of GLSL/ESSL).

Overview

    This is version 100 of the GL_KHR_vulkan_glsl extension.

    This extension modifies GLSL to be used as a high-level language for the
    Vulkan API.  GLSL is compiled down to SPIR-V, which the Vulkan API
    consumes.

    The following features are removed:
        * default uniforms (uniform variables not inside a uniform block),
          except for opaque types
        * atomic-counters (those based on atomic_uint)
        * subroutines
        * shared and packed block layouts
        * the already deprecated texturing functions (e.g., texture2D())
        * the already deprecated noise functions (e.g., noise1())
        * compatibility-mode-only features
        * gl_DepthRangeParameters and gl_NumSamples
        * gl_VertexID and gl_InstanceID
        * aliasing of vertex input components
          (see the Vulkan API specification)

    The following features are added:
        * push-constant buffers
        * shader-combining of separate textures and samplers
        * descriptor sets
        * specialization constants
        * gl_VertexIndex and gl_InstanceIndex
        * subpass inputs
        * 'offset' and 'align' layout qualifiers for uniform/buffer blocks for
          versions that did not support them

    The following features are changed:
        * precision qualifiers (mediump and lowp) will be respected for all
          versions, not dropped for desktop versions (default precision for
          desktop versions is highp for all types)
        * gl_FragColor will no longer indicate an implicit broadcast
        * arrays of uniforms and buffer blocks take only one binding number for
          the entire object, not one per array element
        * the default origin is origin_upper_left instead of origin_lower_left

    Each of these is discussed in more detail below.

    Enabling These Features
    -----------------------

    This extension is not enabled with a #extension as other extensions are.
    It is also not enabled through use of a profile or #version.  The intended
    level of GLSL/ESSL features, independent from Vulkan-specific usage, comes
    from the traditional use of #version, profile, and #extension.

    Instead, use of this extension is an effect of using a GLSL front-end in a
    mode that has it generate SPIR-V for Vulkan.  Such tool use is outside the
    scope of using the Vulkan API and outside the definition of GLSL and this
    extension. See the documentation of the compiler to see how to request
    generation of SPIR-V for Vulkan.

    When a front-end is used to accept this extension, it must error check and
    reject shaders not adhering to this specification, and accept those that
    do.  Implementation-dependent maximums and capabilities are supplied to, or
    part of, the front-end, so it can do error checking against them.

    A shader can query the level of Vulkan support available, using the
    predefined

        #define VULKAN 100

    This allows shader code to say, for example,

        #ifdef VULKAN
            layout(set = 1, binding = 0) uniform sampler s;
            layout(set = 1, binding = 1) uniform texture2D t;
            #if VULKAN > 100
                ...
            #endif
        #else
            layout(binding = 0) uniform sampler2D ts;
        #endif

    Specialization Constants
    ------------------------

    SPIR-V specialization constants, which can be set later by the client API,
    can be declared using "layout(constant_id=...)". For example, to make a
    specialization constant with a default value of 12:

        layout(constant_id = 17) const int arraySize = 12;

    Above, "17" is the ID by which the API or other tools can later refer to
    this specific specialization constant.  The API or an intermediate tool can
    then change its value to another constant integer before it is fully
    lowered to executable code.  If it is never changed before final lowering,
    it will retain the value of 12.

    Specialization constants have const semantics, except they don't fold.
    Hence, an array can be declared with 'arraySize' from above:

        vec4 data[arraySize];  // legal, even though arraySize might change

    Specialization constants can be in expressions:

        vec4 data2[arraySize + 2];

    This will make data2 be sized by 2 more than whatever constant value
    'arraySize' has when it is time to lower the shader to executable code.

    An expression formed with specialization constants also behaves in the
    shader like a specialization constant, not a like a constant.

        arraySize + 2       // a specialization constant (with no constant_id)

    Such expressions can be used in the same places as a constant.

    The constant_id can only be applied to a scalar *int*, a scalar *float*
    or a scalar *bool*.

    Only basic operators and constructors can be applied to a specialization
    constant and still result in a specialization constant:

        layout(constant_id = 17) const int arraySize = 12;
        sin(float(arraySize));    // result is not a specialization constant

    While SPIR-V specialization constants are only for scalars, a vector
    can be made by operations on scalars:

        layout(constant_id = 18) const int scX = 1;
        layout(constant_id = 19) const int scZ = 1;
        const vec3 scVec = vec3(scX, 1, scZ);  // partially specialized vector

    A built-in variable can have a 'constant_id' attached to it:

        layout(constant_id = 18) gl_MaxImageUnits;

    This makes it behave as a specialization constant.  It is not a full
    redeclaration; all other characteristics are left intact from the
    original built-in declaration.

    The built-in vector gl_WorkGroupSize can be specialized using special
    layout local_size_{xyz}_id's applied to the "in" qualifier.  For example:

        layout(local_size_x_id = 18, local_size_z_id = 19) in;

    This leaves gl_WorkGroupSize.y as a non-specialization constant, with
    gl_WorkGroupSize being a partially specialized vector.  Its x and z
    components can be later specialized using the ID's 18 and 19.

    Push Constants
    --------------

    Push constants reside in a uniform block declared using the new
    layout-qualifier-id "push_constant" applied to a uniform-block declaration.
    The API writes a set of constants to a push-constant buffer, and the shader
    reads them from a push_constant block:

        layout(push_constant) uniform BlockName {
            int member1;
            float member2;
            ...
        } InstanceName; // optional instance name

        ... = InstanceName.member2; // read a push constant

    The memory accounting used for the push_constant uniform block is different
    than for other uniform blocks:  There is a separate small pool of memory
    it must fit within.  By default, a push_constant buffer follows the std430
    packing rules.

    Descriptor Sets
    ---------------

    Each shader resource in a descriptor set is assigned a tuple of (set
    number, binding number, array element) that defines its location within
    a descriptor set layout.
    In GLSL, the set number and binding number are assigned via the "set"
    and "binding" layout qualifiers respectively, and the array element is
    implicitly assigned consecutively starting with index equal to zero for
    the first element of an array (and array element is zero for non-array
    variables):
    
        // Assign set number = M, binding number = N, array element = 0
        layout (set=M, binding=N) uniform sampler2D variableName;

        // Assign set number = M, binding number = N for all array elements,
        // and array element = i for the ith member of an array of size I.
        layout (set=M, binding=N) uniform sampler2D variableNameArray[I];

    For example, two combined texture/sampler objects can be declared in two
    different descriptor sets as follows

        layout(set = 0, binding = 0) uniform sampler2D ts3;
        layout(set = 1, binding = 0) uniform sampler2D ts4;

    See the API documentation for more detail on the operation model of
    descriptor sets.
    
    Storage Images
    --------------
    
    Storage images are declared in GLSL shader source using uniform image
    variables of the appropriate dimensionality as well as a format layout
    qualifier (if necessary):
    
        layout (set=m, binding=n, r32f) uniform image2D myStorageImage;

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:
    
             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
               OpName %9 "myStorageImage"
             OpDecorate %9 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %9 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeImage %6 2D 0 0 0 2 R32f
        %8 = OpTypePointer UniformConstant %7
        %9 = OpVariable %8 UniformConstant
             ...

    Samplers
    --------
    
    Samplers are declared in GLSL shader source using uniform sampler
    variables, where the sampler type has no associated texture
    dimensionality:

        layout (set=m, binding=n) uniform sampler mySampler;

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:
    
             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %8 "mySampler"
             OpDecorate %8 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %8 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeSampler
        %7 = OpTypePointer UniformConstant %6
        %8 = OpVariable %7 UniformConstant
             ...
    
    Textures (Sampled Images)
    -------------------------

    Textures are declared in GLSL shader source using uniform texture
    variables of the appropriate dimensionality:

        layout (set=m, binding=n) uniform texture2D mySampledImage;

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:

             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %9 "mySampledImage"
             OpDecorate %9 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %9 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeImage %6 2D 0 0 0 1 Unknown
        %8 = OpTypePointer UniformConstant %7
        %9 = OpVariable %8 UniformConstant
             ...

    Combined Texture + Samplers
    ---------------------------
    
    Combined textures and samplers are declared in GLSL shader source using
    uniform sampler variables of the appropriate dimensionality:

        layout (set=m, binding=n) uniform sampler2D myCombinedImageSampler;

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:
    
             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %10 "myCombinedImageSampler"
             OpDecorate %10 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %10 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeImage %6 2D 0 0 0 1 Unknown
        %8 = OpTypeSampledImage %7
        %9 = OpTypePointer UniformConstant %8
        %10 = OpVariable %9 UniformConstant
             ...
    
    Note that a combined image sampler descriptor can be referred to as just
    an image or sampler in the shader as per the above sections.

    Combining separate samplers and textures
    ----------------------------------------

    A sampler, declared with the keyword 'sampler', contains just filtering
    information, containing neither a texture nor an image:

        uniform sampler s;    // a handle to filtering information

    A texture, declared with keywords like 'texture2D', contains just image
    information, not filtering information:

        uniform texture2D t;  // a handle to a texture (an image in SPIR-V)

    Constructors can then be used to combine a sampler and a texture at the
    point of making a texture lookup call:

        texture(sampler2D(t, s), ...);

    Note, layout() information is omitted above for clarity of this feature.
        
    Texture Buffers (Uniform Texel Buffers)
    ---------------------------------------

    Texture buffers are declared in GLSL shader source using uniform
    textureBuffer variables:

        layout (set=m, binding=n) uniform textureBuffer myUniformTexelBuffer;

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:
             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %9 "myUniformTexelBuffer"
             OpDecorate %9 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %9 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeImage %6 Buffer 0 0 0 1 Unknown
        %8 = OpTypePointer UniformConstant %7
        %9 = OpVariable %8 UniformConstant
             ...

    Image Buffers (Storage Texel Buffers)
    -------------------------------------
    
    Image buffers are declared in GLSL shader source using uniform
    imageBuffer variables:

        layout (set=m, binding=n, r32f) uniform imageBuffer myStorageTexelBuffer;

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:

             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %9 "myStorageTexelBuffer"
             OpDecorate %9 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %9 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeImage %6 Buffer 0 0 0 2 R32f
        %8 = OpTypePointer UniformConstant %7
        %9 = OpVariable %8 UniformConstant
             ...

    Storage Buffers
    ---------------
    
    Storage buffers are declared in GLSL shader source using buffer storage
    qualifier and block syntax:

        layout (set=m, binding=n) buffer myStorageBuffer
        {
            vec4 myElement[];
        };

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:
    
             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %9 "myStorageBuffer"
             OpMemberName %9 0 "myElement"
             OpName %11 ""
             OpDecorate %8 ArrayStride 16
             OpMemberDecorate %9 0 Offset 0
             OpDecorate %9 BufferBlock
             OpDecorate %11 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %11 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeVector %6 4
        %8 = OpTypeRuntimeArray %7
        %9 = OpTypeStruct %8
        %10 = OpTypePointer Uniform %9
        %11 = OpVariable %10 Uniform
             ...
             
    Uniform Buffers
    ---------------
    
    Uniform buffers are declared in GLSL shader source using the uniform storage
    qualifier and block syntax:

        layout (set=m, binding=n) uniform myUniformBuffer
        {
            vec4 myElement[32];
        };

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:
             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %11 "myUniformBuffer"
             OpMemberName %11 0 "myElement"
             OpName %13 ""
             OpDecorate %10 ArrayStride 16
             OpMemberDecorate %11 0 Offset 0
             OpDecorate %11 Block
             OpDecorate %13 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %13 Binding n
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeVector %6 4
        %8 = OpTypeInt 32 0
        %9 = OpConstant %8 32
        %10 = OpTypeArray %7 %9
        %11 = OpTypeStruct %10
        %12 = OpTypePointer Uniform %11
        %13 = OpVariable %12 Uniform
             ...
    
    Subpass Inputs
    --------------

    Within a rendering pass, a subpass can write results to an output target
    that can then be read by the next subpass as an input subpass.  The
    "Subpass Input" feature regards the ability to read an output target.

    Subpasses are read through a new set of types, available only
    to fragment shaders:

         subpassInput
         subpassInputMS
        isubpassInput
        isubpassInputMS
        usubpassInput
        usubpassInputMS

    Unlike sampler and image objects, subpass inputs are implicitly addressed
    by the fragment's (x, y, layer) coordinate.
                 
    Input attachments are decorated with their input attachment index in
    addition to descriptor set and binding numbers.

        layout (input_attachment_index=i, set=m, binding=n) uniform subpassInput myInputAttachment;

    Which maps to the following SPIR-V:

             ...
        %1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
             ...
             OpName %9 "myInputAttachment"
             OpDecorate %9 DescriptorSet m
             OpDecorate %9 Binding n
             OpDecorate %9 InputAttachmentIndex i
        %2 = OpTypeVoid
        %3 = OpTypeFunction %2
        %6 = OpTypeFloat 32
        %7 = OpTypeImage %6 SubpassData 0 0 0 2 Unknown
        %8 = OpTypePointer UniformConstant %7
        %9 = OpVariable %8 UniformConstant
             ...

    An input_attachment_index of i selects the ith entry in the input pass
    list. (See API specification for more information.)

    These objects support reading the subpass input through the following
    functions:

        gvec4 subpassLoad(gsubpassInput   subpass);
        gvec4 subpassLoad(gsubpassInputMS subpass, int sample);

    gl_FragColor
    ------------

    The fragment-stage built-in gl_FragColor, which implies a broadcast to all
    outputs, is not present in SPIR-V. Shaders where writing to gl_FragColor
    is allowed can still write to it, but it only means to write to an output:
     - of the same type as gl_FragColor
     - decorated with location 0
     - not decorated as a built-in variable.
    There is no implicit broadcast.

    gl_VertexIndex and gl_InstanceIndex
    -----------------------------------

    Adds two new built-in variables, gl_VertexIndex and gl_InstanceIndex to
    replace the existing built-in variables gl_VertexID and gl_InstanceID.

    In the situations where the indexing is relative to some base offset,
    these built-in variables are defined, for Vulkan, to take on values as
    follows:

        gl_VertexIndex             base, base+1, base+2, ...
        gl_InstanceIndex           base, base+1, base+2, ...

    Where it depends on the situation what the base actually is.
    
    Mapping to SPIR-V
    -----------------

    For informational purposes (non-specification), the following is an
    expected way for an implementation to map GLSL constructs to SPIR-V
    constructs:

    Mapping of storage classes:

      uniform sampler2D...;        -> UniformConstant
      uniform blockN { ... } ...;  -> Uniform, with Block decoration
      in / out variable            -> Input/Output, possibly with block (below)
      in / out block...            -> Input/Output, with Block decoration
      buffer  blockN { ... } ...;  -> Uniform, with BufferBlock decoration, or
                                      StorageBuffer, when requested
      N/A                          -> AtomicCounter
      shared                       -> Workgroup
      <normal global>              -> Private

    Mapping of input/output blocks or variables is the same for all versions
    of GLSL or ESSL. To the extent variables or members are available in a
    version, its location is as follows:

      These are mapped to SPIR-V individual variables, with similarly spelled
      built-in decorations (except as noted):

        Any stage:

            in gl_NumWorkGroups
            in gl_WorkGroupSize
            in gl_WorkGroupID
            in gl_LocalInvocationID
            in gl_GlobalInvocationID
            in gl_LocalInvocationIndex

            in gl_VertexIndex
            in gl_InstanceIndex
            in gl_InvocationID
            in gl_PatchVerticesIn      (PatchVertices)
            in gl_PrimitiveIDIn        (PrimitiveID)
            in/out gl_PrimitiveID      (in/out based only on storage qualifier)
            in gl_TessCoord

            in/out gl_Layer
            in/out gl_ViewportIndex

            patch in/out gl_TessLevelOuter  (uses Patch decoration)
            patch in/out gl_TessLevelInner  (uses Patch decoration)

        Fragment stage only:

            in gl_FragCoord
            in gl_FrontFacing
            in gl_ClipDistance
            in gl_CullDistance
            in gl_PointCoord
            in gl_SampleID
            in gl_SamplePosition
            in gl_HelperInvocation
            out gl_FragDepth
            in gl_SampleMaskIn        (SampleMask)
            out gl_SampleMask         (in/out based only on storage qualifier)

      These are mapped to SPIR-V blocks, as implied by the pseudo code, with
      the members decorated with similarly spelled built-in decorations:

        Non-fragment stage:

            in/out gl_PerVertex {   // some subset of these members will be used
                gl_Position
                gl_PointSize
                gl_ClipDistance
                gl_CullDistance
            }                       // name of block is for debug only

      There is at most one input and one output block per stage in SPIR-V.
      The subset and order of members will match between stages sharing an
      interface.

    Mapping of precision qualifiers:

      lowp     -> RelaxedPrecision, on storage variable and operation
      mediump  -> RelaxedPrecision, on storage variable and operation
      highp    -> 32-bit, same as int or float

      portability tool/mode  -> OpQuantizeToF16

    Mapping of precise:

      precise -> NoContraction

    Mapping of images

      subpassInput  -> OpTypeImage with 'Dim' of SubpassData
      subpassLoad() -> OpImageRead
      imageLoad()   -> OpImageRead
      imageStore()  -> OpImageWrite
      texelFetch()  -> OpImageFetch

      imageAtomicXXX(params, data)  -> %ptr = OpImageTexelPointer params
                                              OpAtomicXXX %ptr, data

      XXXQueryXXX(combined) -> %image = OpImage combined
                                        OpXXXQueryXXX %image

    Mapping of layouts

      std140/std430  ->  explicit offsets/strides on struct
      shared/packed  ->  not allowed
      <default>      ->  not shared, but std140 or std430

      max_vertices   ->  OutputVertices

    Mapping of barriers

      barrier() (compute) -> OpControlBarrier(/*Execution*/Workgroup,
                                              /*Memory*/Workgroup,
                                              /*Semantics*/AcquireRelease |
                                                           WorkgroupMemory)

      barrier() (tess control) -> OpControlBarrier(/*Execution*/Workgroup,
                                                   /*Memory*/Invocation,
                                                   /*Semantics*/None)

      memoryBarrier() -> OpMemoryBarrier(/*Memory*/Device,
                                         /*Semantics*/AcquireRelease |
                                                      UniformMemory |
                                                      WorkgroupMemory |
                                                      ImageMemory)

      memoryBarrierBuffer() -> OpMemoryBarrier(/*Memory*/Device,
                                               /*Semantics*/AcquireRelease |
                                                            UniformMemory)

      memoryBarrierShared() -> OpMemoryBarrier(/*Memory*/Device,
                                               /*Semantics*/AcquireRelease |
                                                            WorkgroupMemory)

      memoryBarrierImage() -> OpMemoryBarrier(/*Memory*/Device,
                                              /*Semantics*/AcquireRelease |
                                                           ImageMemory)

      groupMemoryBarrier() -> OpMemoryBarrier(/*Memory*/Workgroup,
                                              /*Semantics*/AcquireRelease |
                                                           UniformMemory |
                                                           WorkgroupMemory |
                                                           ImageMemory)

    Mapping of atomics

      all atomic builtin functions -> Semantics = None(Relaxed)
      atomicExchange()      -> OpAtomicExchange
      imageAtomicExchange() -> OpAtomicExchange
      atomicCompSwap()      -> OpAtomicCompareExchange
      imageAtomicCompSwap() -> OpAtomicCompareExchange
      N/A                   -> OpAtomicCompareExchangeWeak

    Mapping of other instructions

      %     -> OpUMod/OpSMod
      mod() -> OpFMod
      N/A   -> OpSRem/OpFRem

Changes to Chapter 1 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Change the last paragraph of "1.3 Overview":  "The OpenGL Graphics System
    Specification will specify the OpenGL entry points used to manipulate and
    communicate with GLSL programs and GLSL shaders."

    Add a paragraph: "The Vulkan API will specify the Vulkan entry points used
    to manipulate SPIR-V shaders.  Independent offline tool chains will compile
    GLSL down to the SPIR-V intermediate language. Vulkan use is not enabled
    with a #extension, #version, or a profile.  Instead, use of GLSL for Vulkan
    is determined by offline tool-chain use. See the documentation of such
    tools to see how to request generation of SPIR-V for Vulkan."

    "GLSL -> SPIR-V compilers must be directed as to what SPIR-V *Capabilities*
    are legal at run-time and give errors for GLSL feature use outside those
    capabilities.  This is also true for implementation-dependent limits that
    can be error checked by the front-end against constants present in the
    GLSL source: the front-end can be informed of such limits, and report
    errors when they are exceeded."

Changes to Chapter 2 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Change the name from

    "2 Overview of OpenGL Shading"

    to

    "2 Overview of OpenGL and Vulkan Shading"

    Remove the word "OpenGL" from three introductory paragraphs.

Changes to Chapter 3 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Add a new paragraph at the end of section "3.3 Preprocessor":  "When
    shaders are compiled for Vulkan, the following predefined macro is
    available:

        #define VULKAN 100

    Add the following keywords to section 3.6 Keywords:

        texture1D        texture2D        texture3D
        textureCube      texture2DRect    texture1DArray
        texture2DArray   textureBuffer    texture2DMS
        texture2DMSArray textureCubeArray

        itexture1D        itexture2D       itexture3D
        itextureCube      itexture2DRect   itexture1DArray
        itexture2DArray   itextureBuffer
        itexture2DMS      itexture2DMSArray
        itextureCubeArray

        utexture1D        utexture2D        utexture3D
        utextureCube      utexture2DRect    utexture1DArray
        utexture2DArray   utextureBuffer    utexture2DMS
        utexture2DMSArray utextureCubeArray

        sampler    samplerShadow

        subpassInput      isubpassInput     usubpassInput
        subpassInputMS    isubpassInputMS   usubpassInputMS

    Move the following keywords in section 3.6 Keywords to the reserved
    section:

        atomic_uint
        subroutine

Changes to Chapter 4 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Add into the tables in section 4.1 Basic Types, interleaved with the
    existing types, using the existing descriptions (when not supplied
    below):

        Floating-Point Opaque Types

            texture1D
            texture2D
            texture3D
            textureCube
            texture2DRect
            texture1DArray
            texture2DArray
            textureBuffer
            texture2DMS
            texture2DMSArray
            textureCubeArray
            subpassInput            | a handle for accessing a floating-point
                                    | subpass input
            subpassInputMS          | a handle for accessing a multi-sampled
                                    | floating-point subpass input

        Signed Integer Opaque Types

            itexture1D
            itexture2D
            itexture3D
            itextureCube
            itexture2DRect
            itexture1DArray
            itexture2DArray
            itextureBuffer
            itexture2DMS
            itexture2DMSArray
            itextureCubeArray
            isubpassInput     | a handle for accessing an integer subpass input
            isubpassInputMS   | a handle for accessing a multi-sampled integer
                              | subpass input

        Unsigned Integer Opaque Types

            utexture1D
            utexture2D
            utexture3D
            utextureCube
            utexture2DRect
            utexture1DArray
            utexture2DArray
            utextureBuffer
            utexture2DMS
            utexture2DMSArray
            utextureCubeArray
            usubpassInput     | a handle for accessing an unsigned integer
                              | subpass input
            usubpassInputMS   | a handle for accessing a multi-sampled unsigned
                              | integer subpass input

    Remove the entry from the table in section 4.1 Basic Types:

        atomic_uint

    Add a new category in this section

      "Sampler Opaque Types

          sampler       |    a handle for accessing state describing how to
                        |    sample a texture"
          ---------------------------------------------------------------------
          samplerShadow |    a handle for accessing state describing how to
                        |    sample a depth texture with comparison"

    Remove "structure member selection" from 4.1.7 and instead add a sentence
    "Opaque types cannot be declared or nested in a structure (struct)."

    Modify subsection 4.1.3 Integers, for desktop versions of GLSL, to say:

        "Highp unsigned integers have exactly 32 bits of precision.  Highp
        signed integers use 32 bits, including a sign bit, in two's complement
        form. Mediump and lowp integers are as defined by the RelaxedPrecision
        decoration in SPIR-V."

    Add a subsection to 4.1.7 Opaque Types:

        "4.1.7.x Texture, *sampler*, and *samplerShadow* Types

        "Texture (e.g., *texture2D*), *sampler*, and *samplerShadow* types are opaque
        types, declared and behaving as described above for opaque types.  When
        aggregated into arrays within a shader, these types can only be indexed
        with a dynamically uniform expression, or texture lookup will result in
        undefined values. Texture variables are handles to one-, two-, and
        three-dimensional textures, cube maps, etc., as enumerated in the basic
        types tables. There are distinct
        texture types for each texture target, and for each of float, integer,
        and unsigned integer data types. Textures can be combined with a
        variable of type *sampler* or *samplerShadow* to create a sampler type
        (e.g., sampler2D, or sampler2DShadow). This is done with a constructor,
        e.g., sampler2D(texture2D, sampler),
        sampler2DShadow(texture2D, sampler),
        sampler2DShadow(texture2D, samplerShadow), or
        sampler2D(texture2D, samplerShadow)
        and is described in more detail in section 5.4 "Constructors"."

        "4.1.7.x Subpass Inputs

        "Subpass input types (e.g., subpassInput) are opaque types, declared
        and behaving as described above for opaque types.  When aggregated into
        arrays within a shader, they can only be indexed with a dynamically
        uniform integral expression, otherwise results are undefined.

        "Subpass input types are handles to two-dimensional single sampled or
        multi-sampled images, with distinct types for each of float, integer,
        and unsigned integer data types.

        "Subpass input types are only available in fragment shaders.  It is a
        compile-time error to use them in any other stage."

    Remove the section 4.1.7.3 Atomic Counters

    Change section 4.3.3 Constant Expressions:

      Add a new very first sentence to this section:

        "SPIR-V specialization constants are expressed in GLSL as const, with
        a layout qualifier identifier of constant_id, as described in section
        4.4.x Specialization-Constant Qualifier."

      Add to this sentence:

        "A constant expression is one of...
          * a variable declared with the const qualifier and an initializer,
            where the initializer is a constant expression"

      To make it say:

        "A constant expression is one of...
          * a variable declared with the const qualifier and an initializer,
            where the initializer is a constant expression; this includes both
            const declared with a specialization-constant layout qualifier,
            e.g., 'layout(constant_id = ...)' and those declared without a
            specialization-constant layout qualifier"

      Add to "including getting an element of a constant array," that

        "an array access with a specialization constant as an index does
        not result in a constant expression"

      Add to this sentence:

        "A constant expression is one of...
          * the value returned by a built-in function..."

      To make it say:

        "A constant expression is one of...
          * for non-specialization-constants only: the value returned by a
            built-in function... (when any function is called with an argument
            that is a specialization constant, the result is not a constant
            expression)"

      Rewrite the last half of the last paragraph to be its own paragraph
      saying:

        "Non-specialization constant expressions may be evaluated by the
        compiler's host platform, and are therefore not required ...
        [rest of paragraph stays the same]"

      Add a paragraph

        "Specialization constant expressions are never evaluated by the
        front-end, but instead retain the operations needed to evaluate them
        later on the host."

    Add to the table in section 4.4 Layout Qualifiers:

                             | Individual Variable | Block | Allowed Interface
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------
      constant_id =          |     scalar only     |       |      const
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------
      push_constant          |                     |   X   |      uniform
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------
      set =                  |     opaque only     |   X   |      uniform
      ------------------------------------------------------------------------
      input_attachment_index | subpass types only  |       |      uniform

    (The other columns remain blank.)

    Also add to this table:

                         | Qualifier Only | Allowed Interface
      -------------------------------------------------------
      local_size_x_id =  |        X       |       in
      local_size_y_id =  |        X       |       in
      local_size_z_id =  |        X       |       in

    (The other columns remain blank.)

    Expand this sentence in section 4.4.1 Input Layout Qualifiers:

      "Where integral-constant-expression is defined in section 4.3.3 Constant
      Expressions as 'integral constant expression'"

    To include the following:

      ", with it being a compile-time error for integer-constant-expression to
      be a specialization constant:  The constant used to set a layout
      identifier X in layout(layout-qualifier-name = X) must evaluate to a
      front-end constant containing no specialization constants."

    Change the rules about locations and inputs for doubles, by removing

      "If a vertex shader input is any scalar or vector type, it will consume
      a single location. If a non-vertex shader input is a scalar or vector
      type other than dvec3 or dvec4..."

    Replacing the above with

      "If an input is a scalar or vector type other than dvec3 or dvec4..."

    (Making all stages have the same rule that dvec3 takes two locations...)

    At the end of the paragraphs describing the *location* rules, add this
    paragraph:

      "When generating SPIR-V, all *in* and *out* qualified user-declared
      (non built-in) variables and blocks (or all their members) must have a
      shader-specified *location*. Otherwise, a compile-time error is
      generated."

    [Note that an earlier existing rule just above this says "If a block has
    no block-level *location* layout qualifier, it is required that either all
    or none of its members have a *location* layout qualifier, or a compile-
    time error results."]

    Change section 4.4.1 "Input Layout Qualifiers"

      With one exception, location aliasing is allowed only if it does not
      cause component aliasing

    To

      Location aliasing is allowed only if it does not cause component aliasing

    Remove, from the same paragraph:

      The one exception where component aliasing is permitted is for two input
      variables (not block members) to a vertex shader, which are allowed to
      have component aliasing. This vertex-variable component aliasing is
      intended only to support vertex shaders where each execution path accesses
      at most one input per each aliased component. Implementations are
      permitted, but not required, to generate link-time errors if they detect
      that every path through the vertex shader executable accesses multiple
      inputs aliased to any single component.

    Change section 4.4.1, under "Fragment Shader Inputs" from

      "By default, gl_FragCoord assumes a lower-left origin for window
      coordinates ... For example, the (x, y) location (0.5, 0.5) is
      returned for the lowerleft-most pixel in a window. The origin can be
      changed by redeclaring gl_FragCoord with the
      origin_upper_left identifier."

    To

      "The gl_FragCoord built-in variable assumes an upper-left origin for
      window coordinates ... For example, the (x, y) location (0.5, 0.5) is
      returned for the upper-left-most pixel in a window. The origin can be
      explicitly set by redeclaring gl_FragCoord with the origin_upper_left
      identifier.  It is a compile-time error to change it to
      origin_lower_left."

    Add to the end of section 4.4.3 Uniform Variable Layout Qualifiers:

      "The /push_constant/ identifier is used to declare an entire block, and
      represents a set of "push constants", as defined by the API.  It is a
      compile-time error to apply this to anything other than a uniform block
      declaration.  The values in the block will be initialized through the
      API, as per the Vulkan API specification.  A block declared with
      layout(push_constant) may optionally include an /instance-name/.
      There can be only one push_constant
      block per stage, or a compile-time or link-time error will result. A
      push-constant array can only be indexed with dynamically uniform indexes.
      Uniform blocks declared with push_constant use different resources
      than those without; and are accounted for separately.  See the API
      specification for more detail."

    After the paragraphs about binding ("The binding identifier..."), add

      "The /set/ identifier specifies the descriptor set this object belongs to.
      It is a compile-time error to apply /set/ to a standalone qualifier or to
      a member of a block.  It is a compile-time error to apply /set/ to a block
      qualified as a push_constant.  By default, any non-push_constant uniform
      or shader storage block declared without a /set/ identifier is assigned to
      descriptor set 0.  Similarly, any sampler, texture, or subpass input type
      declared as a uniform, but without a /set/ identifier is also assigned
      to descriptor set 0.

      "If applied to an object declared as an array, all elements of the array
      belong to the specified /set/.

      "It is a compile-time error for either the /set/ or /binding/ value
      to exceed a front-end-configuration supplied maximum value."

    Remove mention of subroutine throughout section 4.4 Layout Qualifiers,
    including removal of section 4.4.4 Subroutine Function Layout Qualifiers.

    Change section 4.4.5 Uniform and Shader Storage Block Layout Qualifiers:

      Change

      "If the binding identifier is used with a uniform or shader storage block
      instanced as an array, the first element of the array takes the specified
      block binding and each subsequent element takes the next consecutive
      uniform block binding point. For an array of arrays, each element (e.g.,
      6 elements for a[2][3]) gets a binding point, and they are ordered per the
      array-of-array ordering described in section 4.1.9 'Arrays.'"
"

      To

      "If the binding identifier is used with a uniform block or buffer block
      instanced as an array, the entire array takes only the provided binding
      number.  The next consecutive binding number is available for a different
      object. For an array of arrays, descriptor set array element numbers used
      in descriptor set accesses are ordered per the array-of-array ordering
      described in section 4.1.9 'Arrays.'"

    Change section 4.4.6 Opaque-Uniform Layout Qualifiers:

      Change

      "If the binding identifier is used with an array, the first element of
      the array takes the specified unit and each subsequent element takes the
      next consecutive unit."

      To

      "If the binding identifier is used with an array, the entire array
      takes only the provided binding number.  The next consecutive binding
      number is available for a different object."

    Remove section 4.4.6.1 Atomic Counter Layout Qualifiers

    Add a new subsection at the end of section 4.4:

      "4.4.x Specialization-Constant Qualifier

      "Specialization constants are declared using "layout(constant_id=...)".
      For example:

        layout(constant_id = 17) const int arraySize = 12;

      "The above makes a specialization constant with a default value of 12.
      17 is the ID by which the API or other tools can later refer to
      this specific specialization constant. If it is never changed before
      final lowering, it will retain the value of 12. It is a compile-time
      error to use the constant_id qualifier on anything but a scalar bool,
      int, uint, float, or double.

      "Built-in constants can be declared to be specialization constants.
      For example,

        layout(constant_id = 31) gl_MaxClipDistances;  // add specialization id

      "The declaration uses just the name of the previously declared built-in
      variable, with a constant_id layout declaration.  It is a compile-time
      error to do this after the constant has been used: Constants are strictly
      either non-specialization constants or specialization constants, not
      both.

      "The built-in constant vector gl_WorkGroupSize can be specialized using
      the local_size_{xyz}_id qualifiers, to individually give the components
      an id. For example:

          layout(local_size_x_id = 18, local_size_z_id = 19) in;

      "This leaves gl_WorkGroupSize.y as a non-specialization constant, with
      gl_WorkGroupSize being a partially specialized vector.  Its x and z
      components can be later specialized using the ids 18 and 19.  These ids
      are declared independently from declaring the work-group size:

        layout(local_size_x = 32, local_size_y = 32) in;   // size is (32,32,1)
        layout(local_size_x_id = 18) in;                   // constant_id for x
        layout(local_size_z_id = 19) in;                   // constant_id for z

      "Existing rules for declaring local_size_x, local_size_y, and
      local_size_z are not changed by this extension. For the local-size ids,
      it is a compile-time error to provide different id values for the same
      local-size id, or to provide them after any use.  Otherwise, order,
      placement, number of statements, and replication do not cause errors.

      "Two arrays sized with specialization constants are the same type only if
      sized with the same symbol, involving no operations.

        layout(constant_id = 51) const int aSize = 20;
        const int pad = 2;
        const int total = aSize + pad; // specialization constant
        int a[total], b[total];        // a and b have the same type
        int c[22];                     // different type than a or b
        int d[aSize + pad];            // different type than a, b, or c
        int e[aSize + 2];              // different type than a, b, c, or d

      "Types containing arrays sized with a specialization constant cannot be
      compared, assigned as aggregates, declared with an initializer, or used
      as an initializer.  They can, however, be passed as arguments to
      functions having formal parameters of the same type.

      "Arrays inside a block may be sized with a specialization constant, but
      the block will have a static layout.  Changing the specialized size will
      not re-layout the block. In the absence of explicit offsets, the layout
      will be based on the default size of the array."

    Add a new subsection at the end of section 4.4:

      "4.4.y Subpass Qualifier

      "Subpasses are declared with the basic 'subpassInput' types.  However,
      they must have the layout qualifier "input_attachment_index" declared
      with them, or a compile-time error results.  For example:

        layout(input_attachment_index = 2, ...) uniform subpassInput t;

      This selects which subpass input is being read from. The value assigned
      to 'input_attachment_index', say i (input_attachment_index = i), selects
      that entry (ith entry) in the input list for the pass.  See the API
      documentation for more detail about passes and the input list.

      "If an array of size N is declared, it consume N consecutive
      input_attachment_index values, starting with the one provided.

      "It is a compile-time or link-time error to have different variables
      declared with the same input_attachment_index.  This includes any overlap
      in the implicit input_attachment_index consumed by array declarations.

      "It is a compile-time error if the value assigned to an
      input_attachment_index is greater than or equal to
      gl_MaxInputAttachments."

    Remove all mention of the 'shared' and 'packed' layout qualifiers.

    Change section 4.4.5 Uniform and Shader Storage Block Layout Qualifiers

      "The initial state of compilation is as if the following were declared:

        layout(std140, column_major) uniform;  // without push_constant
        layout(std430, column_major) buffer;

      "However, when push_constant is declared, the default layout of the
      buffer will be std430. There is no method to globally set this default."

    Add to this statement:

      "The std430 qualifier is supported only for shader storage blocks; using
      std430 on a uniform block will result in a compile-time error"

    the following phrase:

      "unless it is also declared with push_constant"

    Add to section 4.4.5 Uniform and Shader Storage Block Layout Qualifiers,
    for versions not having 'offset' and 'align' description language,
    or replace with the following for versions that do have 'offset' and
    'align' description language:

      "The 'offset' qualifier can only be used on block members of 'uniform' or
      'buffer' blocks. The 'offset' qualifier forces the qualified member to
      start at or after the specified integral-constant-expression, which will
      be its byte offset from the beginning of the buffer. It is a compile-time
      error to have any offset, explicit or assigned, that lies within another
      member of the block. Two blocks linked together in the same program with
      the same block name must have the exact same set of members qualified
      with 'offset' and their integral-constant-expression values must be the
      same, or a link-time error results. The specified 'offset' must be a
      multiple of the base alignment of the type of the block member it
      qualifies, or a compile-time error results.

      "The 'align' qualifier can only be used on block members of 'uniform' or
      'buffer' blocks. The 'align' qualifier makes the start of each block
      buffer have a minimum byte alignment. It does not affect the internal
      layout within each member, which will still follow the std140 or std430
      rules. The specified alignment must be greater than 0 and a power of 2,
      or a compile-time error results.

      "The actual alignment of a member will be the greater of the specified
      'align' alignment and the standard (e.g., std140) base alignment for the
      member's type. The actual offset of a member is computed as follows:
      If 'offset' was declared, start with that offset, otherwise start with
      the offset immediately following the preceding member (in declaration
      order). If the resulting offset is not a multiple of the actual
      alignment, increase it to the first offset that is a multiple of the
      actual alignment. This results in the actual offset the member will have.

      "When 'align' is applied to an array, it affects only the start of the
      array, not the array's internal stride. Both an 'offset' and an 'align'
      qualifier can be specified on a declaration.

      "The 'align' qualifier, when used on a block, has the same effect as
      qualifying each member with the same 'align' value as declared on the
      block, and gets the same compile-time results and errors as if this had
      been done. As described in general earlier, an individual member can
      specify its own 'align', which overrides the block-level 'align', but
      just for that member."

    Remove the following preamble from section 4.7, which exists for desktop
    versions, but not ES versions.  Removal:

      "Precision qualifiers are added for code portability with OpenGL ES, not
      for functionality. They have the same syntax as in OpenGL ES, as
      described below, but they have no semantic meaning, which includes no
      effect on the precision used to store or operate on variables.

      "If an extension adds in the same semantics and functionality in the
      OpenGL ES 2.0 specification for precision qualifiers, then the extension
      is allowed to reuse the keywords below for that purpose.

      "For the purposes of determining if an output from one shader stage
      matches an input of the next stage, the precision qualifier need not
      match."

    Add:

      "For interface matching, uniform variables and uniform and buffer block
      members must have the same precision qualification. For matching *out*
      variables or block members to *in* variables and block members, the
      precision qualification does not have to match.

      "Global variables declared in different compilation units linked into the
      same shader stage must be declared with the same precision qualification."

    More generally, all versions will follow OpenGL ES semantic rules for
    precision qualifiers.

    Section 4.7.2 Precision Qualifiers (desktop only)

      Replace the table saying "none" for all precisions with this statement:

        "Mediump and lowp floating-point values have the precision defined by
        the RelaxedPrecision decoration in SPIR-V."

    Section 4.7.4 Default Precision Qualifiers:

      For desktop versions, replace the last three paragraphs that state the
      default precisions with the following instead:

        "All stages have default precision qualification of highp for all types
        that accept precision qualifiers."

Changes to Chapter 5 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Add a new subsection at the end of section 5.4 "Constructors":

        "5.4.x Sampler Constructors

        "Sampler types, like *sampler2D* can be declared with an initializer
        that is a constructor of the same type, and consuming a texture and a
        sampler.  For example:

          layout(...) uniform sampler s;   // handle to filtering information
          layout(...) uniform texture2D t; // handle to a texture
          layout(...) in vec2 tCoord;
          ...
          texture(sampler2D(t, s), tCoord);

        The result of a sampler constructor cannot be assigned to a variable:

          ... sampler2D sConstruct = sampler2D(t, s);  // ERROR

        Sampler constructors can only be consumed by a function parameter.

        Sampler constructors of arrays are illegal:

          layout(...) uniform texture2D tArray[6];
          ...
          ... sampler2D[](tArray, s) ...  // ERROR

        Formally:
         * every sampler type can be used as a constructor
         * the type of the constructor must match the type of the
           variable being declared
         * the constructor's first argument must be a texture type
         * the constructor's second argument must be a scalar of type
           *sampler* or *samplerShadow*
         * the dimensionality (1D, 2D, 3D, Cube, Rect, Buffer, MS, and Array)
           of the texture type must match that of the constructed sampler type
           (that is, the suffixes of the type of the first argument and the
           type of the constructor will be spelled the same way)
         * there is no control flow construct (e.g., "?:") that consumes any
           sampler type

         Note: Shadow mismatches are allowed between constructors and the
         second argument. Non-shadow samplers can be constructed from
         *samplerShadow* and shadow samplers can be constructed from *sampler*.

    Change section 5.9 Expressions

      Add under "The sequence (,) operator..."

        "Texture and sampler types cannot be used with the sequence (,)
        operator."

      Change under "The ternary selection operator (?:)..."

        "The second and third expressions can be any type, as long their types
        match."

      To

        "The second and third expressions can be any type, as long their types
        match, except for texture and sampler types, which result in a
        compile-time error."

    Add a section at the end of section 5

      "5.x Specialization Constant Operations"

      Only some operations discussed in this section may be applied to a
      specialization constant and still yield a result that is as
      specialization constant.  The operations allowed are listed below.
      When a specialization constant is operated on with one of these
      operators and with another constant or specialization constant, the
      result is implicitly a specialization constant.

       - int(), uint(), and bool() constructors for type conversions
         from any of the following types to any of the following types:
           * int
           * uint
           * bool
       - vector versions of the above conversion constructors
       - allowed implicit conversions of the above
       - swizzles (e.g., foo.yx)
       - The following when applied to integer or unsigned integer types:
           * unary negative ( - )
           * binary operations ( + , - , * , / , % )
           * shift ( <<, >> )
           * bitwise operations ( & , | , ^ )
       - The following when applied to integer or unsigned integer scalar types:
           * comparison ( == , != , > , >= , < , <= )
       - The following when applied to the Boolean scalar type:
           * not ( ! )
           * logical operations ( && , || , ^^ )
           * comparison ( == , != )
       - The ternary operator ( ? : )

Changes to Chapter 6 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Remove mention of subroutine throughout, including removal of
    section 6.1.2 Subroutines.

Changes to Chapter 7 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Changes to section 7.1 Built-In Language Variables

      Replace gl_VertexID and gl_InstanceID, for non-ES with:

        "in int gl_VertexIndex;"
        "in int gl_InstanceIndex;"

      For ES, add:

        "in highp int gl_VertexIndex;"
        "in highp int gl_InstanceIndex;"

      The following definition for gl_VertexIndex should replace the definition
      for gl_VertexID:

        "The variable gl_VertexIndex is a vertex language input variable that
        holds an integer index for the vertex, [See issue 7 regarding which
        name goes with which semantics] relative to a base.  While the
        variable gl_VertexIndex is always present, its value is not always
        defined.  See XXX in the API specification."

      The following definition for gl_InstanceIndex should replace the definition
      for gl_InstanceID:

        "The variable gl_InstanceIndex is a vertex language input variable that
        holds the instance number of the current primitive in an instanced draw
        call, relative to a base. If the current primitive does not come from
        an instanced draw call, the value of gl_InstanceIndex is zero."
        [See issue 7 regarding which name goes with which semantics]

    Changes to section 7.3 Built-In Constants

      Add

        "const int gl_MaxInputAttachments = 1;"

    Remove section 7.4 Built-In Uniform State (there is none in Vulkan).

Changes to Chapter 8 of the OpenGL Shading Language Specification

    Add the following ES language to desktop versions of the specification:

      "The operation of a built-in function can have a different precision
      qualification than the precision qualification of the resulting value.
      These two precision qualifications are established as follows.

      "The precision qualification of the operation of a built-in function is
      based on the precision qualification of its input arguments and formal
      parameters:  When a formal parameter specifies a precision qualifier,
      that is used, otherwise, the precision qualification of the calling
      argument is used.  The highest precision of these will be the precision
      qualification of the operation of the built-in function. Generally,
      this is applied across all arguments to a built-in function, with the
      exceptions being:
        - bitfieldExtract and bitfieldInsert ignore the 'offset' and 'bits'
          arguments.
        - interpolateAt* functions only look at the 'interpolant' argument.

      "The precision qualification of the result of a built-in function is
      determined in one of the following ways:

        - For the texture sampling, image load, and image store functions,
          the precision of the return type matches the precision of the
          sampler type:
             uniform lowp sampler2D sampler;
             highp vec2 coord;
             ...
             lowp vec4 col = texture (sampler, coord); // texture() returns lowp

        Otherwise:

        - For prototypes that do not specify a resulting precision qualifier,
          the precision will be the same as the precision of the operation.
          (As defined earlier.)

        - For prototypes that do specify a resulting precision qualifier,
          the specified precision qualifier is the precision qualification of
          the result."

    Add precision qualifiers to the following in desktop versions:

      genIType floatBitsToInt (highp genFType value)
      genUType floatBitsToUint(highp genFType value)
      genFType intBitsToFloat (highp genIType value)
      genFType uintBitsToFloat(highp genUType value)

      genFType frexp(highp genFType x, out highp genIType exp)
      genFType ldexp(highp genFType x,  in highp genIType exp)

      highp uint packSnorm2x16(vec2 v)
      vec2 unpackSnorm2x16(highp uint p)
      highp uint packUnorm2x16(vec2 v)
      vec2 unpackUnorm2x16(highp uint p)
      vec2 unpackHalf2x16(highp uint v)
      vec4 unpackUnorm4x8(highp uint v)
      vec4 unpackSnorm4x8(highp uint v)

      genIType bitfieldReverse(highp genIType value)
      genUType bitfieldReverse(highp genUType value)
      genIType findMSB(highp genIType value)
      genIType findMSB(highp genUType value)
      genUType uaddCarry(highp genUType x, highp genUType y,
                         out lowp genUType carry)
      genUType usubBorrow(highp genUType x, highp genUType y,
                          out lowp genUType borrow)
      void umulExtended(highp genUType x, highp genUType y,
                        out highp genUType msb, out highp genUType lsb)
      void imulExtended(highp genIType x, highp genIType y,
                        out highp genIType msb, out highp genIType lsb)

    Remove section 8.10 Atomic-Counter Functions

    Remove section 8.14 Noise Functions

    Add a section

      "8.X Subpass Functions

      "Subpass functions are only available in a fragment shader.

      "Subpass inputs are read through the built-in functions below. The gvec...
      and gsubpass... are matched, where they must both be the same floating
      point, integer, or unsigned integer variants.

    Add a table with these two entries (in the same cell):

      "gvec4 subpassLoad(gsubpassInput   subpass)
       gvec4 subpassLoad(gsubpassInputMS subpass, int sample)"

    With the description:

      "Read from a subpass input, from the implicit location (x, y, layer)
      of the current fragment coordinate."

Changes to the grammar

    Arrays can no longer require the size to be a compile-time folded constant
    expression.  Change

      | LEFT_BRACKET constant_expression RIGHT_BRACKET

    to

      | LEFT_BRACKET conditional_expression RIGHT_BRACKET

    and change

      | array_specifier LEFT_BRACKET constant_expression RIGHT_BRACKET

    to

      | array_specifier LEFT_BRACKET conditional_expression RIGHT_BRACKET

    Remove the ATOMIC_UINT type_specifier_nonarray.

    Remove all instances of the SUBROUTINE keyword.

Issues

1. Can we have specialization sizes in an array in a block?  That prevents
   putting known offsets on subsequent members.

   RESOLUTION: Yes, but it does not affect offsets.

2. Can a specialization-sized array be passed by value?

   RESOLUTION: Yes, if they are sized with the same specialization constant.

3. Can a texture array be variably indexed?  Dynamically uniform?

   Resolution (bug 14683): Dynamically uniform indexing.

4. Are arrays of a descriptor set all under the same set number, or does, say,
   an array of size 4 use up 4 descriptor sets?

   RESOLUTION: There is no array of descriptor sets.  Arrays of resources
   are in a single descriptor set and consume a single binding number.

5. Which descriptor set arrays can be variably or non-uniformly indexed?

   RESOLUTION: There is no array of descriptor sets.

6. Do we want an alternate way of doing composite member specialization
   constants?  For example,

       layout(constant_id = 18) gl_WorkGroupSize.y;

   Or

       layout(constant_id = 18, local_size_y = 16) in;

   Or

       layout(constant_id = 18) wgy = 16;
       const ivec3 gl_WorkGroupSize = ivec3(1, wgy, 1);

    RESOLUTION: No. Use local_size_x_id etc. for workgroup size, and
    defer any more generalized way of doing this for composites.

7. What names do we really want to use for
        gl_VertexIndex             base, base+1, base+2, ...
        gl_InstanceIndex           base, base+1, base+2, ...

     RESOLUTION: Use the names above.

     Note that gl_VertexIndex is equivalent to OpenGL's gl_VertexID in that
     it includes the value of the baseVertex parameter. gl_InstanceIndex is
     NOT equivalent to OpenGL's gl_InstanceID because gl_InstanceID does NOT
     include the baseInstance parameter.

8. What should "input subpasses" really be called?

   RESOLVED: subpassInput.

9. The spec currently does not restrict where sampler constructors can go,
   but should it?  E.g., can the user write a shader like the following:

     uniform texture2D t[MAX_TEXTURES];
     uniform sampler s[2];

     uniform int textureCount;
     uniform int sampleCount;
     uniform bool samplerCond;

     float ShadowLookup(bool pcf, vec2 tcBase[MAX_TEXTURES])
     {
         float result = 0;

         for (int textureIndex = 0; textureIndex < textureCount; ++textureIndex)
         {
             for (int sampleIndex = 0; sampleIndex < sampleCount; ++sampleIndex)
             {
                 vec2 tc = tcBase[textureIndex] + offsets[sampleIndex];
                 if (samplerCond)
                     result += texture(sampler2D(t[textureIndex], s[0]), tc).r;
                 else
                     result += texture(sampler2D(t[textureIndex], s[1]), tc).r;
             }

   Or, like this?

     uniform texture2D t[MAX_TEXTURES];
     uniform sampler s[2];

     uniform int textureCount;
     uniform int sampleCount;
     uniform bool samplerCond;

     sampler2D combined0[MAX_TEXTURES] = sampler2D(t, s[0]);
     sampler2D combined1[MAX_TEXTURES] = sampler2D(t, s[1]);

     float ShadowLookup(bool pcf, vec2 tcBase[MAX_TEXTURES])
     {
         for (int textureIndex = 0; textureIndex < textureCount; ++textureIndex) {
             for (int sampleIndex = 0; sampleIndex < sampleCount; ++sampleIndex) {
                 vec2 tc = tcBase[textureIndex] + offsets[sampleIndex];
                 if (samplerCond)
                     result += texture(combined0[textureIndex], tc).r;
                 else
                     result += texture(combined1[textureIndex], tc).r;
             }
         ...

    RESOLUTION (bug 14683): Only constructed at the point of use, where passed
    as an argument to a function parameter.

Revision History

    Rev.    Date         Author    Changes
    ----  -----------    -------  --------------------------------------------
    47    17-Mar-2019    JohnK    Add vertex-input aliasing to list of removed
                                  features
    46    25-Jul-2018    JohnK    No longer require sampler constructors to
                                  check shadow matches: mismatches are allowed
    45    15-Dec-2017    TobiasH  moved resource binding examples in from Vulkan API spec
    44    12-Dec-2017    jbolz    Document mapping of barrier/atomic ops to
                                  SPIR-V
    43    25-Oct-2017    JohnK    remove the already deprecated noise functions
    42    07-Jul-2017    JohnK    arrays of buffers consume only one binding
    41    05-Jul-2017    JohnK    allow std430 on push_constant declarations
    40    21-May-2017    JohnK    Require in/out explicit locations
    39    14-Apr-2017    JohnK    Update overview for StorageBuffer storage
                                  class.
    38    14-Apr-2017    JohnK    Fix Vulkan public issue #466: texture2D typo.
    37    26-Mar-2017    JohnK    Fix glslang issue #369: remove gl_NumSamples.
    36    13-Feb-2017    JohnK    Fix public bug 428: allow anonymous
                                  push_constant blocks.
    35    07-Feb-2017    JohnK    Add 'offset' and 'align' to all versions
    34    26-Jan-2017    JohnK    Allow the ternary operator to result in a
                                  specialization constant
    33    30-Aug-2016    JohnK    Allow out-of-order offsets in a block
    32     1-Aug-2016    JohnK    Remove atomic_uint and more fully subroutine
    31    20-Jul-2016    JohnK    Have desktop versions respect mediump/lowp
    30    12-Apr-2016    JohnK    Restrict spec-const operations to non-float
    29     5-Apr-2016    JohnK    Clarify disallowance of spec-const arrays in
                                  initializers
    28     7-Mar-2016    JohnK    Make push_constants not have sets
    27    28-Feb-2016    JohnK    Make the default by origin_upper_left
    26    17-Feb-2016    JohnK    Expand specialized array semantics
    25    10-Feb-2016    JohnK    Incorporate resolutions from the face to face
    24    28-Jan-2016    JohnK    Update the resolutions from the face to face
    23     6-Jan-2016    Piers    Remove support for gl_VertexID and
                                  gl_InstanceID since they aren't supported by
                                  Vulkan.
    22    29-Dec-2015    JohnK    support old versions and add semantic mapping
    21    09-Dec-2015    JohnK    change spelling *subpass* -> *subpassInput* and
                                  include this and other texture/sample types in
                                  the descriptor-set-0 default scheme
    20    01-Dec-2015    JohnK    push_constant default to std430, opaque types
                                  can only aggregate as arrays
    19    25-Nov-2015    JohnK    Move "Shadow" from texture types to samplerShadow
    18    23-Nov-2015    JohnK    Bug 15206 - Indexing of push constant arrays
    17    18-Nov-2015    JohnK    Bug 15066: std140/std43 defaults
    16    18-Nov-2015    JohnK    Bug 15173: subpass inputs as arrays
    15    07-Nov-2015    JohnK    Bug 14683: new rules for separate texture/sampler
    14    07-Nov-2015    JohnK    Add specialization operators, local_size_*_id
                                  rules, and input dvec3/dvec4 always use two
                                  locations
    13    29-Oct-2015    JohnK    Rules for input att. numbers, constant_id,
                                  and no subpassLoadMS()
    12    29-Oct-2015    JohnK    Explain how gl_FragColor is handled
    11     9-Oct-2015    JohnK    Add issue: where can sampler constructors be
    10     7-Sep-2015    JohnK    Add first draft specification language
     9     5-Sep-2015    JohnK    - make specialization id's scalar only, and
                                    add local_size_x_id... for component-level
                                    workgroup size setting
                                  - address several review comments
     8     2-Sep-2015    JohnK    switch to using the *target* style of target
                                  types (bug 14304)
     7    15-Aug-2015    JohnK    add overview for input targets
     6    12-Aug-2015    JohnK    document gl_VertexIndex and gl_InstanceIndex
     5    16-Jul-2015    JohnK    push_constant is a layout qualifier
                                  VULKAN is the only versioning macro
                                  constantID  -> constant_id
     4    12-Jul-2015    JohnK    Rewrite for clarity, with proper overview,
                                  and prepare to add full semantics
     3    14-May-2015    JohnK    Minor changes from meeting discussion
     2    26-Apr-2015    JohnK    Add controlling features/capabilities
     1    26-Mar-2015    JohnK    Initial revision