From 28b12ef30330400a315cd9432e360180214d0f18 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: github Date: Mon, 4 Nov 2024 10:56:24 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] [bot] update results for ClickHouse Cloud --- clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json | 6 +++--- clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.192GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.24GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.360GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.48GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.96GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json | 6 +++--- clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json | 8 ++++---- clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json | 8 ++++---- 19 files changed, 74 insertions(+), 74 deletions(-) diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json index 529322754..cd7cd4198 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.192GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (aws)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "192GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "aws"], - "load_time": 260.842, - "data_size": 9946117265, + "load_time": 358.217, + "data_size": 9946566487, "result": [ -[0.002, 0.002, 0.002], [3.631, 0.075, 0.793], [0.035, 0.032, 0.421], [1.303, 0.053, 0.054], [0.239, 0.247, 1.368], [0.619, 0.393, 0.490], [0.017, 0.016, 0.207], [0.017, 0.017, 0.016], [0.470, 1.196, 0.413], [1.176, 0.471, 0.515], [0.175, 0.167, 0.250], [0.204, 0.208, 0.285], [0.438, 0.529, 0.494], [0.744, 0.762, 0.696], [0.691, 0.514, 0.638], [0.277, 0.267, 0.303], [1.132, 1.295, 1.128], [0.798, 0.936, 0.923], [2.759, 2.112, 2.102], [0.019, 0.019, 0.030], [0.743, 0.808, 5.080], [1.652, 0.768, 1.819], [1.107, 3.452, 1.007], [14.392, 2.520, 2.237], [0.238, 0.218, 0.217], [0.166, 0.174, 0.159], [0.216, 0.215, 0.249], [0.628, 0.625, 0.693], [6.564, 6.645, 6.863], [0.044, 0.177, 0.045], [0.810, 0.486, 0.478], [1.202, 0.649, 0.636], [2.300, 1.695, 1.963], [1.863, 1.809, 2.026], [1.895, 1.840, 2.038], [0.248, 0.236, 0.229], [0.164, 0.038, 0.038], [0.026, 0.024, 0.025], [0.108, 0.026, 0.026], [0.068, 0.077, 0.062], [0.021, 0.240, 0.015], [0.014, 0.015, 0.017], [0.018, 0.012, 0.011] +[0.002, 0.002, 0.002], [0.017, 2.010, 0.069], [0.748, 0.045, 0.830], [0.065, 1.330, 0.090], [0.325, 0.226, 0.344], [0.747, 0.605, 0.449], [0.125, 0.019, 0.020], [0.054, 0.017, 0.044], [0.688, 0.378, 0.529], [0.628, 0.573, 0.470], [0.223, 0.218, 0.269], [0.257, 0.924, 0.253], [0.454, 0.752, 0.537], [0.661, 0.596, 0.992], [0.743, 0.503, 0.780], [0.325, 0.268, 0.343], [1.684, 1.092, 1.084], [1.128, 0.781, 1.147], [2.822, 2.455, 2.055], [0.024, 0.018, 0.020], [4.081, 0.652, 1.053], [1.108, 1.106, 1.711], [4.513, 2.207, 0.992], [9.196, 3.530, 2.184], [0.290, 0.237, 0.233], [0.264, 0.253, 0.176], [0.238, 0.329, 0.245], [0.964, 0.626, 0.938], [10.296, 10.232, 6.066], [0.151, 0.045, 0.044], [0.751, 0.443, 0.664], [1.559, 0.893, 0.879], [1.925, 2.407, 2.299], [1.818, 1.844, 1.728], [1.827, 1.843, 2.768], [0.329, 0.311, 0.317], [0.049, 0.039, 0.051], [0.030, 0.030, 0.022], [0.023, 0.024, 0.140], [0.064, 0.094, 0.976], [0.026, 0.021, 0.023], [0.019, 0.278, 0.013], [0.011, 0.012, 0.012] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json index 83d1f4c6f..786a46619 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.24GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (aws)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "24GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "aws"], - "load_time": 900.377, + "load_time": 906.497, "data_size": 9948862978, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.002, 0.002], [2.170, 1.368, 0.027], [0.704, 0.410, 0.238], [2.844, 0.646, 0.310], [1.587, 1.457, 1.480], [3.123, 2.492, 2.471], [0.196, 0.127, 0.081], [0.087, 0.091, 0.042], [1.885, 1.973, 1.748], [2.204, 2.452, 2.257], [0.796, 0.799, 0.906], [1.005, 1.112, 0.987], [2.337, 3.044, 2.753], [3.800, 4.292, 4.437], [4.505, 3.581, 4.030], [1.884, 2.207, 1.995], [9.487, 10.010, 8.924], [6.911, 6.963, 6.356], [32.566, 27.295, 27.984], [0.085, 0.086, 0.084], [5.092, 27.462, 4.966], [5.150, 4.983, 4.998], [33.101, 7.323, 39.269], [73.899, 17.645, 20.681], [1.370, 1.359, 1.592], [0.913, 1.077, 0.923], [1.385, 1.352, 1.350], [5.935, 5.009, 4.503], [62.289, 47.708, 47.638], [0.161, 0.169, 0.158], [4.101, 2.555, 2.871], [3.540, 3.572, 4.338], [39.696, 31.328, 23.060], [21.908, 24.813, 22.449], [21.868, 21.730, 22.083], [1.345, 1.250, 1.318], [0.337, 0.116, 0.133], [0.055, 0.054, 0.054], [0.058, 0.191, 0.055], [0.256, 0.247, 0.236], [0.343, 0.030, 0.027], [0.150, 0.020, 0.021], [0.020, 0.020, 0.020] +[0.003, 0.003, 0.002], [2.762, 0.052, 1.403], [0.412, 0.762, 0.170], [3.003, 0.328, 0.702], [1.539, 1.614, 1.501], [3.260, 2.693, 3.805], [0.144, 0.145, 0.080], [0.452, 0.041, 0.042], [1.723, 2.028, 1.766], [4.202, 2.043, 2.250], [1.229, 0.759, 0.782], [1.126, 1.007, 0.996], [2.490, 3.645, 2.492], [3.860, 5.249, 5.675], [5.180, 4.564, 4.788], [2.612, 2.038, 1.929], [8.778, 9.546, 11.592], [6.878, 6.367, 6.520], [33.338, 38.208, 37.135], [0.118, 0.091, 0.100], [32.580, 4.905, 4.972], [5.082, 25.807, 5.151], [37.858, 7.473, 7.355], [87.145, 17.803, 17.878], [1.575, 1.424, 1.502], [0.997, 1.518, 0.910], [1.850, 1.379, 1.429], [6.779, 4.824, 4.968], [47.658, 97.264, 48.195], [0.230, 0.171, 0.221], [2.642, 2.484, 5.663], [3.527, 3.096, 3.165], [25.300, 33.738, 72.730], [24.609, 21.965, 21.760], [21.674, 25.610, 32.074], [1.537, 2.089, 1.937], [0.356, 0.183, 0.184], [0.626, 0.074, 0.059], [0.057, 0.208, 0.072], [0.261, 0.243, 0.520], [0.025, 0.026, 0.267], [0.193, 0.025, 0.025], [0.027, 0.023, 0.021] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json index b1cc913b9..48be67566 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.360GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (aws)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "360GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "aws"], - "load_time": 350.122, - "data_size": 9948171748, + "load_time": 264.129, + "data_size": 9950573708, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.003, 0.003], [1.832, 0.736, 0.017], [0.534, 0.382, 0.040], [0.048, 1.256, 0.048], [0.244, 0.242, 0.918], [0.874, 0.879, 0.340], [0.528, 0.016, 0.101], [0.052, 0.022, 0.051], [0.428, 0.404, 0.657], [0.516, 0.480, 0.455], [0.253, 0.185, 0.170], [0.376, 0.181, 0.195], [0.410, 0.401, 0.400], [0.560, 0.557, 0.549], [0.422, 0.547, 0.435], [0.311, 0.306, 0.233], [0.989, 0.967, 0.905], [0.694, 0.590, 0.642], [1.895, 1.669, 1.777], [0.019, 0.020, 0.020], [2.436, 1.107, 0.582], [0.614, 0.605, 0.608], [0.884, 2.494, 0.871], [5.039, 1.844, 2.087], [0.203, 0.200, 0.201], [0.175, 0.168, 0.172], [0.218, 0.204, 0.213], [0.576, 0.532, 0.728], [5.453, 5.601, 5.322], [0.051, 0.051, 0.193], [0.500, 0.476, 0.471], [1.365, 0.621, 0.554], [2.181, 2.008, 1.655], [1.828, 1.525, 1.657], [1.597, 1.606, 1.567], [0.231, 0.184, 0.258], [0.071, 0.049, 0.052], [0.030, 0.182, 0.034], [0.142, 0.053, 0.033], [0.082, 0.158, 0.085], [0.030, 0.021, 0.024], [0.146, 0.020, 0.019], [0.015, 0.016, 0.015] +[0.002, 0.002, 0.003], [2.499, 0.019, 0.770], [0.564, 0.328, 0.034], [1.557, 0.687, 0.038], [0.213, 0.174, 0.240], [1.152, 0.437, 0.241], [0.016, 0.261, 0.017], [0.101, 0.015, 0.015], [0.312, 0.760, 0.462], [0.392, 0.361, 0.462], [0.311, 0.280, 0.126], [0.269, 0.139, 0.137], [0.389, 0.268, 0.302], [0.506, 0.394, 0.509], [0.331, 0.320, 0.415], [0.290, 0.231, 0.222], [0.743, 0.781, 1.009], [0.486, 0.500, 0.617], [2.091, 1.741, 1.754], [0.020, 0.016, 0.015], [2.659, 0.441, 0.576], [1.195, 0.414, 0.458], [3.062, 1.408, 0.581], [5.644, 4.152, 1.500], [0.285, 0.163, 0.159], [0.171, 0.124, 0.153], [0.214, 0.209, 0.158], [0.396, 0.560, 0.575], [5.321, 3.473, 5.283], [0.041, 0.039, 0.039], [0.295, 0.287, 0.295], [0.888, 0.363, 0.563], [1.282, 2.156, 1.162], [1.750, 1.191, 1.622], [1.240, 1.191, 1.188], [0.243, 0.161, 0.173], [0.049, 0.037, 0.053], [0.022, 0.024, 0.024], [0.034, 0.025, 0.033], [0.065, 0.069, 0.061], [0.019, 0.017, 0.023], [0.014, 0.014, 0.014], [0.012, 0.012, 0.016] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json index e5302710a..776705063 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.48GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (aws)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "48GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "aws"], - "load_time": 315.064, - "data_size": 9944552213, + "load_time": 308.688, + "data_size": 9943509900, "result": [ -[0.002, 0.004, 0.002], [0.133, 1.855, 0.018], [0.411, 0.106, 1.107], [1.629, 0.311, 0.158], [0.896, 0.879, 0.918], [1.600, 1.323, 1.334], [0.280, 0.067, 0.045], [0.088, 0.029, 0.077], [1.617, 1.156, 1.140], [1.355, 1.543, 1.209], [0.457, 0.407, 0.516], [0.614, 0.604, 0.460], [1.571, 1.268, 1.045], [1.688, 1.733, 2.349], [1.675, 2.047, 1.821], [0.860, 0.864, 1.184], [3.776, 3.788, 3.802], [2.683, 3.329, 2.696], [7.335, 8.090, 9.918], [0.056, 0.039, 0.121], [10.116, 2.890, 2.871], [2.991, 5.392, 2.986], [11.453, 4.351, 4.357], [29.765, 11.192, 6.625], [0.564, 0.590, 0.575], [0.391, 0.386, 0.536], [0.569, 0.561, 0.742], [2.704, 1.913, 1.930], [19.247, 35.388, 19.104], [0.089, 0.175, 0.095], [1.067, 1.028, 1.800], [1.751, 1.405, 1.502], [11.104, 11.501, 23.787], [5.785, 5.539, 5.776], [7.464, 5.692, 7.358], [0.699, 0.860, 0.813], [0.236, 0.085, 0.081], [0.041, 0.050, 0.039], [0.185, 0.050, 0.053], [0.177, 0.162, 0.153], [0.329, 0.026, 0.026], [0.018, 0.016, 0.016], [0.015, 0.014, 0.014] +[0.002, 0.002, 0.002], [1.139, 0.015, 0.038], [0.092, 0.519, 1.037], [1.014, 0.137, 0.734], [0.804, 0.800, 0.653], [1.320, 1.452, 1.296], [0.039, 0.095, 0.149], [0.047, 0.023, 0.023], [0.952, 0.959, 1.103], [0.994, 1.203, 0.915], [0.507, 0.389, 0.402], [0.623, 0.515, 0.449], [1.299, 1.457, 1.407], [1.528, 2.034, 1.826], [1.692, 1.793, 1.722], [0.887, 1.006, 0.777], [4.165, 4.809, 3.437], [2.246, 2.816, 2.615], [8.441, 7.209, 7.408], [0.040, 0.041, 0.040], [11.444, 2.458, 5.282], [2.086, 2.037, 2.599], [14.536, 6.173, 2.942], [33.118, 6.270, 17.011], [0.578, 0.586, 0.568], [0.378, 0.445, 0.381], [0.555, 0.596, 0.565], [2.268, 2.214, 1.794], [23.936, 23.226, 18.992], [0.087, 0.089, 0.091], [1.091, 1.322, 1.295], [1.755, 1.343, 1.683], [11.887, 10.253, 10.792], [6.004, 15.177, 6.008], [7.670, 6.036, 5.691], [0.687, 0.580, 1.264], [0.197, 0.075, 0.086], [0.250, 0.039, 0.112], [0.197, 0.038, 0.041], [0.275, 0.263, 0.156], [0.235, 0.026, 0.022], [0.017, 0.181, 0.016], [0.130, 0.137, 0.015] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json index fe3404d43..595a80c1c 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.720GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (aws)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "720GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "aws"], - "load_time": 224.776, - "data_size": 9943994137, + "load_time": 255.683, + "data_size": 9944364190, "result": [ -[0.004, 0.004, 0.004], [1.269, 0.494, 0.023], [0.035, 0.032, 0.035], [0.568, 0.043, 0.482], [0.244, 0.204, 0.258], [0.893, 0.365, 0.456], [0.021, 0.286, 0.206], [0.027, 0.083, 0.026], [0.458, 0.461, 0.461], [0.506, 0.817, 0.485], [0.288, 0.187, 0.170], [0.279, 0.386, 0.185], [0.397, 0.374, 0.398], [0.565, 0.563, 0.526], [0.900, 0.431, 0.470], [0.219, 0.226, 0.285], [0.697, 0.707, 0.684], [0.496, 0.454, 0.461], [1.540, 1.235, 1.143], [0.019, 0.140, 0.019], [1.211, 0.318, 0.327], [0.821, 0.396, 0.368], [1.192, 0.813, 0.582], [1.327, 1.330, 4.163], [0.211, 0.203, 0.221], [0.160, 0.165, 0.158], [0.184, 0.198, 0.205], [0.368, 0.444, 0.376], [3.163, 3.073, 4.897], [0.102, 0.124, 0.056], [0.400, 0.372, 0.480], [0.515, 0.452, 0.754], [1.843, 1.632, 1.527], [1.194, 1.109, 1.239], [1.032, 1.225, 1.055], [0.162, 0.149, 0.168], [0.054, 0.053, 0.052], [0.035, 0.032, 0.144], [0.035, 0.040, 0.036], [0.082, 0.096, 0.097], [0.021, 0.034, 0.253], [0.262, 0.022, 0.019], [0.014, 0.015, 0.018] +[0.004, 0.004, 0.004], [0.024, 0.024, 0.022], [0.033, 0.034, 1.035], [0.038, 0.538, 0.037], [0.236, 0.743, 0.192], [0.656, 0.286, 0.630], [0.186, 0.022, 0.073], [0.075, 0.027, 0.028], [0.462, 0.456, 0.938], [0.526, 0.640, 0.503], [0.329, 0.291, 0.187], [0.290, 0.273, 0.167], [0.304, 0.311, 0.287], [0.391, 0.366, 0.346], [0.402, 0.796, 0.308], [0.205, 0.201, 0.207], [0.672, 0.621, 0.683], [0.453, 0.415, 0.552], [1.417, 1.380, 1.224], [0.020, 0.020, 0.021], [1.781, 0.883, 0.346], [0.631, 0.385, 0.429], [1.700, 0.857, 0.562], [4.704, 1.254, 1.726], [0.166, 0.204, 0.160], [0.135, 0.134, 0.133], [0.148, 0.154, 0.164], [0.451, 0.373, 0.596], [3.366, 3.354, 2.923], [0.139, 0.213, 0.052], [0.483, 0.352, 0.281], [0.657, 0.386, 0.366], [1.834, 1.821, 1.572], [1.126, 1.215, 1.173], [1.009, 1.119, 1.127], [0.156, 0.163, 0.148], [0.053, 0.054, 0.051], [0.033, 0.033, 0.178], [0.042, 0.040, 0.042], [0.106, 0.117, 0.198], [0.029, 0.027, 0.357], [0.134, 0.019, 0.017], [0.016, 0.015, 0.015] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json index d226da2d0..fe42e8db8 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.96GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (aws)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "96GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "aws"], - "load_time": 271.915, - "data_size": 9948835713, + "load_time": 259.386, + "data_size": 9945836123, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.002, 0.002], [0.017, 0.016, 2.010], [0.662, 0.103, 0.060], [0.116, 1.821, 0.877], [0.593, 0.574, 0.607], [0.883, 0.842, 0.874], [0.264, 0.025, 0.275], [0.711, 0.023, 0.052], [0.821, 0.671, 0.705], [0.984, 0.881, 1.111], [0.388, 0.308, 0.313], [0.772, 0.363, 0.302], [1.214, 0.941, 0.744], [1.212, 1.167, 1.653], [1.318, 1.135, 1.229], [0.656, 0.837, 0.771], [2.976, 2.552, 2.992], [1.808, 1.825, 1.512], [4.112, 3.939, 6.139], [0.205, 0.029, 0.038], [5.702, 3.468, 1.232], [1.876, 1.951, 1.867], [1.901, 1.862, 8.293], [18.863, 5.805, 10.263], [0.491, 0.354, 0.484], [0.345, 0.339, 0.342], [0.473, 0.467, 0.471], [1.625, 1.151, 1.640], [19.167, 18.925, 18.726], [0.093, 0.060, 0.060], [0.685, 0.653, 0.657], [1.840, 0.794, 1.256], [3.191, 3.283, 2.889], [3.593, 3.595, 3.460], [4.714, 3.441, 4.603], [0.474, 0.458, 0.513], [0.061, 0.050, 0.064], [0.028, 0.026, 0.025], [0.043, 0.039, 0.073], [0.149, 0.093, 0.091], [0.021, 0.020, 0.019], [0.017, 0.015, 0.017], [0.012, 0.014, 0.015] +[0.002, 0.002, 0.003], [0.017, 0.015, 1.738], [1.305, 0.054, 0.388], [0.996, 0.089, 0.721], [0.462, 0.489, 0.537], [0.826, 1.262, 0.813], [0.172, 0.025, 0.023], [0.021, 0.075, 0.021], [0.707, 0.570, 0.709], [0.708, 0.651, 0.758], [0.340, 0.249, 0.312], [0.384, 0.407, 0.278], [0.768, 0.688, 0.655], [1.427, 1.148, 1.074], [1.241, 1.017, 1.018], [0.597, 0.660, 0.561], [2.943, 2.246, 2.603], [1.554, 1.892, 1.541], [6.070, 4.587, 5.050], [0.028, 0.029, 0.030], [6.220, 1.181, 1.176], [3.469, 1.491, 1.281], [9.215, 3.845, 1.840], [20.640, 4.313, 11.829], [0.359, 0.359, 0.417], [0.258, 0.243, 0.286], [0.400, 0.387, 0.374], [1.209, 1.389, 1.362], [12.309, 13.622, 11.897], [0.061, 0.058, 0.062], [0.693, 0.657, 0.773], [1.197, 0.958, 1.114], [5.507, 3.346, 4.373], [3.430, 3.897, 4.015], [3.347, 4.213, 3.836], [0.429, 0.467, 0.400], [0.053, 0.049, 0.049], [0.028, 0.029, 0.031], [0.028, 0.028, 0.026], [0.096, 0.086, 0.088], [0.022, 0.017, 0.018], [0.022, 0.014, 0.014], [0.012, 0.013, 0.013] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json index fcc475344..fa4164847 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/aws.dev.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (aws)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "dev", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "aws"], - "load_time": 402.259, - "data_size": 9942153048, + "load_time": 388.379, + "data_size": 9946760097, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.002, 0.002], [0.024, 0.122, 0.036], [0.132, 0.114, 0.089], [0.285, 0.170, 0.159], [0.914, 0.893, 0.763], [1.557, 1.347, 1.631], [0.043, 0.042, 0.051], [0.025, 0.035, 0.023], [0.927, 0.939, 1.316], [1.424, 1.135, 1.452], [0.387, 0.389, 0.485], [0.481, 0.476, 0.563], [1.596, 1.575, 1.262], [2.239, 2.588, 2.088], [1.726, 2.117, 1.727], [0.933, 1.210, 0.884], [4.187, 4.776, 4.176], [3.019, 3.110, 2.990], [12.532, 12.429, 12.602], [0.050, 0.044, 0.048], [2.564, 2.625, 2.514], [2.784, 2.772, 2.774], [3.809, 3.717, 3.789], [8.989, 9.477, 9.474], [0.734, 0.694, 0.694], [0.477, 0.487, 0.479], [0.689, 0.694, 0.700], [2.291, 2.387, 2.429], [23.892, 24.224, 24.447], [0.124, 0.107, 0.096], [1.312, 1.260, 1.259], [2.040, 1.599, 2.069], [12.586, 11.940, 11.964], [12.412, 12.261, 12.105], [12.022, 11.594, 11.791], [0.776, 0.879, 0.687], [0.097, 0.087, 0.077], [0.039, 0.043, 0.042], [0.040, 0.039, 0.041], [0.172, 0.160, 0.189], [0.024, 0.023, 0.023], [0.017, 0.016, 0.017], [0.018, 0.015, 0.017] +[0.003, 0.004, 0.003], [0.118, 0.031, 0.027], [0.142, 0.113, 0.303], [0.228, 0.569, 0.191], [1.135, 1.295, 1.072], [1.947, 1.952, 1.958], [0.057, 0.108, 0.048], [0.068, 0.060, 0.031], [1.256, 1.191, 1.419], [1.679, 1.780, 1.387], [0.550, 0.583, 0.588], [0.675, 0.631, 0.726], [2.111, 1.849, 1.847], [2.753, 2.845, 2.415], [2.145, 2.065, 2.135], [1.204, 1.269, 1.246], [5.694, 5.945, 5.747], [3.794, 3.969, 4.290], [16.415, 20.573, 22.346], [0.092, 0.058, 0.058], [3.336, 3.116, 2.580], [3.080, 3.073, 3.074], [3.747, 4.226, 4.328], [9.231, 12.628, 8.999], [0.739, 0.678, 0.674], [0.615, 0.720, 0.694], [0.933, 0.685, 0.852], [2.280, 2.738, 2.253], [29.948, 24.030, 31.286], [0.155, 0.142, 0.091], [1.270, 1.207, 1.584], [3.197, 2.743, 2.161], [3.813 [16.672, 11.815, 11.579], [15.712, 15.603, 15.153], [1.211, 1.179, 0.855], [0.147, 0.114, 0.111], [0.065, 0.048, 0.047], [0.092, 0.089, 0.053], [0.275, 0.343, 0.289], [0.028, 0.025, 0.025], [0.018, 0.032, 0.019], [0.018, 0.039, 0.034] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.192GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.192GB.json index bdc274af5..5e194e4aa 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.192GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.192GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (azure)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "192GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "azure"], - "load_time": 465.884, - "data_size": 9946229502, + "load_time": 219.207, + "data_size": 9943461277, "result": [ -[0.002, 0.002, 0.002], [0.908, 0.011, 0.011], [0.032, 0.961, 0.044], [0.051, 0.046, 3.584], [2.232, 0.364, 0.236], [8.892, 0.461, 0.463], [0.014, 0.048, 0.012], [0.089, 0.019, 0.043], [0.544, 0.453, 0.700], [0.624, 0.524, 0.654], [0.193, 0.146, 0.234], [1.186, 0.161, 0.260], [0.444, 1.142, 0.431], [0.605, 0.744, 0.947], [0.840, 0.577, 2.595], [0.350, 0.315, 0.330], [1.160, 1.121, 1.776], [0.934, 0.931, 1.042], [3.805, 3.213, 3.325], [0.020, 0.019, 0.018], [12.766, 5.554, 0.593], [0.722, 0.640, 2.976], [0.965, 0.994, 5.830], [5.441, 2.982, 2.339], [2.530, 0.294, 0.295], [0.197, 0.187, 0.182], [0.242, 0.233, 0.328], [1.177, 0.622, 0.646], [8.112, 7.856, 10.843], [0.037, 0.053, 0.553], [0.447, 0.417, 0.688], [0.586, 0.558, 7.466], [3.471, 2.043, 2.084], [1.915, 1.871, 1.838], [1.931, 2.640, 2.583], [0.352, 0.277, 0.283], [0.063, 0.038, 0.039], [0.024, 0.023, 0.034], [0.025, 0.027, 0.037], [0.098, 0.069, 0.065], [0.022, 0.014, 0.014], [0.012, 0.013, 0.021], [0.015, 0.010, 0.010] +[0.003, 0.004, 0.002], [0.013, 0.012, 1.055], [0.276, 2.818, 0.079], [0.044, 0.045, 1.272], [0.277, 0.389, 5.825], [3.559, 2.129, 0.719], [0.017, 0.162, 2.136], [2.047, 0.015, 0.017], [0.771, 0.630, 0.635], [0.503, 0.714, 2.647], [0.171, 0.175, 0.167], [0.239, 0.196, 0.303], [1.524, 1.347, 0.602], [0.732, 0.698, 1.132], [0.976, 0.919, 2.600], [0.366, 0.528, 0.311], [1.904, 8.878, 1.390], [1.189, 1.130, 1.846], [2.877, 5.271, 4.281], [0.018, 0.022, 0.020], [0.617, 14.539, 3.160], [0.838, 0.678, 0.627], [2.144, 1.005, 5.907], [18.044, 3.954, 2.532], [0.283, 0.276, 0.286], [0.286, 0.214, 0.226], [0.347, 0.287, 0.266], [0.605, 0.613, 0.598], [5.506, 5.411, 7.539], [0.047, 0.056, 0.044], [0.719, 0.497, 0.513], [0.995, 0.662, 1.018], [2.259, 3.037, 2.813], [2.788, 1.785, 2.796], [2.639, 2.630, 2.077], [0.283, 0.271, 0.382], [0.045, 0.061, 0.057], [0.036, 0.021, 0.025], [0.028, 0.028, 0.039], [0.095, 0.072, 0.066], [0.014, 0.016, 0.016], [0.022, 0.027, 0.014], [0.012, 0.011, 0.018] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.24GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.24GB.json index 96d82575d..c493af6d6 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.24GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.24GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (azure)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "24GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "azure"], - "load_time": 939.817, - "data_size": 9948885544, + "load_time": 1131.009, + "data_size": 9949446897, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.003, 0.004], [0.025, 0.076, 0.566], [0.187, 0.238, 0.172], [4.671, 0.240, 0.387], [3.261, 2.271, 5.888], [8.456, 8.007, 2.386], [0.048, 0.047, 0.097], [0.031, 0.069, 0.029], [3.598, 1.696, 1.930], [7.479, 2.079, 7.127], [0.636, 0.632, 0.635], [0.990, 1.827, 1.789], [4.694, 2.594, 2.218], [18.939, 3.360, 3.966], [11.822, 12.019, 3.568], [2.455, 7.668, 2.034], [8.161, 35.561, 21.933], [5.624, 10.485, 10.524], [49.190, 23.383, 49.055], [0.078, 0.065, 0.101], [4.543, 4.035, 4.106], [6.690, 4.445, 6.097], [6.551, 6.288, 6.339], [16.961, 26.540, 24.773], [1.277, 1.456, 1.221], [0.877, 0.868, 1.279], [1.240, 1.197, 1.926], [4.063, 4.224, 7.085], [40.899, 68.391, 40.733], [0.141, 0.132, 0.144], [2.377, 2.456, 2.199], [8.091, 3.385, 6.322], [23.414, 24.496, 62.548], [40.483, 39.839, 37.729], [38.631, 19.997, 19.891], [1.306, 3.722, 2.839], [0.206, 0.125, 0.210], [0.048, 0.045, 0.044], [0.058, 0.079, 0.081], [0.242, 0.439, 0.247], [0.045, 0.028, 0.043], [0.030, 0.020, 0.018], [0.027, 0.014, 0.018] +[0.003, 0.004, 0.003], [2.202, 0.037, 0.028], [2.286, 0.257, 0.324], [4.664, 0.334, 4.832], [2.319, 1.928, 2.134], [5.792, 3.260, 3.058], [0.057, 0.056, 0.049], [0.072, 0.045, 0.031], [3.577, 2.742, 2.115], [3.617, 2.933, 3.209], [0.760, 0.786, 0.783], [0.917, 0.995, 0.854], [2.696, 2.985, 3.085], [6.063, 7.886, 4.844], [5.002, 4.533, 3.977], [3.322, 2.923, 2.972], [12.700, 13.273, 11.881], [8.148, 7.719, 7.270], [32.303, 31.987, 33.245], [0.085, 0.077, 0.084], [5.553, 4.704, 4.478], [5.077, 4.948, 5.106], [7.197, 7.416, 7.940], [17.546, 22.501, 22.413], [1.648, 1.524, 1.516], [0.955, 1.060, 1.012], [1.531, 1.488, 1.415], [5.242, 4.862, 4.937], [46.737, 42.944, 46.583], [0.222, 0.163, 0.160], [2.782, 3.593, 2.450], [3.623, 5.489, 3.326], [38.547, 29.987, 37.103], [21.715, 28.725, 20.759], [20.632, 20.927, 29.015], [1.398, 1.530, 1.338], [0.180, 0.117, 0.183], [0.091, 0.049, 0.061], [0.066, 0.057, 0.066], [0.361, 0.258, 0.327], [0.028, 0.034, 0.038], [0.018, 0.025, 0.019], [0.024, 0.017, 0.022] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.360GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.360GB.json index 58aead6b2..965b76cd9 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.360GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.360GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (azure)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "360GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "azure"], - "load_time": 416.963, - "data_size": 9951002674, + "load_time": 378.117, + "data_size": 9946879835, "result": [ -[0.002, 0.005, 0.003], [0.169, 0.020, 0.013], [8.136, 0.101, 0.026], [2.906, 2.331, 0.037], [0.543, 0.224, 0.270], [2.535, 0.303, 0.550], [0.147, 0.014, 0.012], [0.046, 0.024, 0.027], [0.542, 0.368, 0.369], [0.639, 0.413, 0.430], [0.220, 0.172, 0.192], [0.213, 0.147, 0.201], [0.365, 0.366, 0.365], [0.731, 0.666, 0.473], [0.545, 0.550, 0.435], [0.374, 0.291, 0.294], [0.829, 0.753, 0.964], [0.536, 0.537, 0.543], [1.614, 3.437, 1.678], [0.016, 0.017, 0.017], [0.472, 3.407, 9.331], [0.719, 0.595, 0.604], [0.840, 6.253, 0.804], [1.867, 1.744, 10.367], [0.184, 0.186, 0.193], [0.181, 0.177, 0.145], [0.178, 0.169, 0.199], [0.535, 0.558, 0.524], [4.916, 3.882, 4.943], [0.036, 0.048, 0.038], [0.325, 0.342, 0.298], [0.645, 0.596, 0.423], [2.803, 1.814, 1.661], [1.926, 1.526, 1.389], [1.419, 1.294, 1.506], [0.220, 0.330, 0.224], [0.036, 0.039, 0.037], [0.022, 0.039, 0.037], [0.025, 0.037, 0.039], [0.068, 0.064, 0.108], [0.017, 0.015, 0.016], [0.017, 0.014, 0.023], [0.011, 0.010, 0.016] +[0.004, 0.003, 0.004], [2.219, 0.020, 0.013], [1.015, 0.035, 0.288], [3.164, 0.289, 2.408], [0.222, 0.294, 0.303], [4.515, 0.361, 0.324], [0.320, 0.012, 0.019], [0.020, 0.021, 0.042], [2.465, 0.544, 0.400], [0.631, 0.605, 0.620], [0.150, 0.148, 0.138], [0.219, 0.213, 0.204], [0.552, 0.525, 0.368], [0.465, 0.734, 0.485], [0.513, 0.510, 0.526], [0.303, 0.233, 0.222], [1.229, 0.937, 0.818], [0.579, 0.531, 2.291], [1.854, 1.794, 1.485], [0.015, 0.015, 0.015], [5.805, 0.582, 5.318], [0.508, 0.481, 0.685], [5.103, 4.491, 1.106], [2.170, 12.404, 2.153], [0.222, 0.207, 0.160], [0.177, 0.441, 0.143], [0.546, 0.179, 0.183], [7.001, 0.683, 0.670], [5.542, 5.639, 5.592], [0.175, 0.043, 0.035], [0.491, 0.496, 0.362], [0.676, 0.620, 0.578], [2.627, 2.531, 2.145], [2.073, 1.977, 1.404], [1.433, 1.347, 1.286], [0.219, 0.204, 0.177], [0.037, 0.037, 0.042], [0.041, 0.035, 0.023], [0.026, 0.036, 0.040], [0.107, 0.070, 0.079], [0.018, 0.014, 0.026], [0.014, 0.017, 0.019], [0.011, 0.010, 0.012] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.48GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.48GB.json index 3833c5992..cb930dd9b 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.48GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.48GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (azure)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "48GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "azure"], - "load_time": 608.178, - "data_size": 9943430546, + "load_time": 899.373, + "data_size": 9945345170, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.003, 0.003], [1.059, 0.016, 2.114], [0.081, 0.421, 2.410], [3.381, 0.132, 0.117], [0.777, 6.847, 0.858], [7.799, 1.074, 1.019], [0.028, 0.079, 0.028], [0.248, 0.020, 0.018], [1.214, 1.136, 1.912], [1.331, 1.174, 1.016], [0.393, 2.289, 0.400], [0.434, 0.469, 0.446], [5.548, 3.052, 1.079], [2.909, 2.702, 1.835], [3.486, 1.308, 1.292], [0.951, 1.087, 0.925], [4.624, 4.963, 3.799], [2.988, 2.893, 2.870], [8.697, 8.291, 7.396], [0.049, 0.049, 0.039], [2.110, 17.135, 1.948], [2.056, 4.139, 23.975], [11.443, 3.128, 13.549], [18.940, 20.826, 6.743], [0.572, 0.509, 0.500], [0.392, 0.408, 0.411], [0.620, 0.583, 0.509], [1.810, 1.873, 1.702], [18.688, 18.480, 17.014], [0.089, 0.105, 0.077], [1.097, 1.078, 1.031], [1.597, 1.841, 1.366], [13.592, 12.144, 12.520], [5.781, 6.438, 5.308], [6.333, 5.825, 5.793], [0.759, 0.865, 0.638], [0.093, 0.080, 0.075], [0.041, 0.038, 0.038], [0.039, 0.050, 0.042], [0.187, 0.157, 0.176], [0.034, 0.025, 0.023], [0.018, 0.017, 0.015], [0.012, 0.011, 0.010] +[0.002, 0.003, 0.005], [0.015, 0.329, 0.013], [0.127, 0.128, 0.103], [0.658, 0.124, 0.109], [1.217, 1.040, 0.977], [2.571, 1.345, 1.358], [0.081, 0.023, 0.023], [0.028, 0.030, 1.071], [1.305, 1.014, 0.953], [1.198, 1.587, 1.255], [0.379, 0.382, 0.405], [0.436, 0.475, 0.484], [1.554, 1.990, 2.106], [3.246, 2.142, 3.037], [1.773, 1.558, 2.545], [1.755, 1.214, 1.169], [4.412, 7.406, 4.893], [4.076, 3.735, 3.297], [14.945, 8.147, 7.192], [0.038, 0.058, 0.036], [2.221, 2.127, 1.912], [2.847, 2.553, 2.491], [3.130, 2.914, 4.041], [9.195, 10.319, 8.380], [5.845, 0.613, 0.589], [0.422, 0.378, 0.418], [0.529, 0.545, 2.764], [2.232, 22.539, 2.122], [18.890, 29.348, 20.031], [0.084, 0.122, 0.083], [2.254, 1.156, 2.345], [17.381, 1.623, 9.630], [15.241, 25.049, 12.970], [6.169, 5.928, 10.922], [6.088, 5.901, 5.984], [0.995, 0.845, 0.715], [0.116, 0.119, 0.125], [0.053, 0.047, 0.053], [0.052, 0.055, 0.085], [0.390, 0.236, 0.272], [0.030, 0.026, 0.026], [0.024, 0.017, 0.027], [0.026, 0.015, 0.015] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.96GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.96GB.json index eb764f625..84cadab45 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.96GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/azure.96GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (azure)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "96GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "azure"], - "load_time": 299.918, - "data_size": 9948179403, + "load_time": 650.030, + "data_size": 9947200092, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.004, 0.003], [0.976, 2.108, 0.095], [0.060, 0.501, 0.052], [0.102, 4.961, 0.092], [3.845, 0.536, 0.522], [3.406, 7.131, 0.807], [0.360, 0.025, 0.028], [0.044, 0.246, 0.023], [5.331, 0.752, 0.844], [1.041, 2.953, 0.953], [0.332, 0.291, 0.308], [0.489, 0.330, 0.304], [0.848, 0.861, 1.063], [1.282, 1.173, 1.500], [1.350, 1.228, 1.203], [0.840, 1.015, 1.123], [5.077, 4.306, 2.929], [1.960, 2.024, 2.468], [6.819, 6.787, 7.065], [0.031, 0.036, 0.037], [23.602, 1.307, 17.606], [1.545, 1.403, 1.489], [6.870, 2.360, 10.238], [5.580, 16.375, 11.056], [0.397, 0.354, 0.401], [0.361, 0.279, 0.289], [0.367, 0.437, 0.389], [1.180, 1.167, 1.631], [12.318, 12.690, 16.542], [0.065, 0.063, 0.071], [0.855, 0.761, 0.894], [1.513, 1.045, 0.936], [5.711, 8.927, 4.559], [4.259, 5.863, 3.838], [5.329, 3.740, 5.356], [0.487, 0.440, 0.455], [0.056, 0.061, 0.068], [0.039, 0.031, 0.032], [0.029, 0.039, 0.031], [0.132, 0.115, 0.120], [0.018, 0.018, 0.021], [0.014, 0.016, 0.020], [0.013, 0.017, 0.013] +[0.003, 0.002, 0.002], [0.014, 0.137, 0.013], [0.055, 0.125, 0.981], [0.365, 2.199, 0.102], [0.725, 0.642, 2.490], [0.957, 4.531, 0.945], [0.056, 0.023, 0.020], [0.035, 0.026, 0.020], [0.800, 0.845, 0.803], [0.748, 0.925, 0.954], [0.310, 0.298, 0.254], [0.284, 0.354, 0.344], [0.615, 1.034, 0.886], [0.989, 1.427, 1.480], [1.347, 1.223, 1.203], [0.693, 0.986, 0.528], [2.276, 3.567, 3.088], [2.427, 2.139, 1.892], [5.534, 7.405, 5.236], [0.673, 0.038, 0.038], [1.185, 7.991, 20.693], [1.928, 2.647, 1.281], [2.054, 11.383, 6.889], [38.952, 4.747, 4.547], [0.402, 0.322, 0.308], [0.295, 0.230, 0.286], [0.403, 0.346, 0.310], [1.305, 1.030, 1.331], [14.268, 10.128, 14.289], [0.070, 0.057, 0.052], [0.659, 0.752, 0.627], [0.848, 0.743, 0.708], [7.161, 5.365, 3.426], [3.097, 3.113, 3.142], [5.165, 3.126, 3.760], [0.461, 0.422, 0.604], [0.064, 0.081, 0.078], [0.042, 0.030, 0.030], [0.033, 0.029, 0.033], [0.100, 0.140, 0.164], [0.025, 0.016, 0.017], [0.019, 0.014, 0.020], [0.011, 0.017, 0.016] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json index f770019cf..7fe23b53b 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.192GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "192GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "gcp"], - "load_time": 226.800, - "data_size": 9943973486, + "load_time": 228.667, + "data_size": 9944998642, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.003, 0.003], [1.770, 0.020, 0.018], [0.544, 0.045, 1.217], [0.065, 1.652, 0.067], [1.116, 0.352, 0.345], [0.753, 0.961, 0.536], [0.301, 0.020, 0.017], [0.151, 0.084, 0.025], [0.793, 0.629, 0.589], [0.742, 0.778, 0.634], [0.323, 0.297, 0.199], [0.334, 0.244, 0.214], [0.877, 0.681, 0.697], [1.070, 0.992, 1.000], [1.136, 0.938, 0.966], [0.354, 0.312, 0.432], [1.483, 1.282, 1.190], [0.972, 0.968, 0.860], [3.785, 3.184, 3.259], [0.210, 0.174, 0.021], [0.703, 0.711, 2.778], [1.930, 0.801, 0.674], [2.848, 0.954, 0.893], [7.870, 2.412, 2.815], [0.329, 0.334, 0.338], [0.239, 0.263, 0.234], [0.307, 0.332, 0.340], [0.781, 0.725, 0.676], [6.730, 7.005, 7.456], [0.230, 0.045, 0.046], [0.706, 0.882, 0.729], [0.907, 0.953, 0.989], [2.250, 3.287, 2.237], [3.027, 2.617, 2.265], [2.727, 2.389, 2.526], [0.274, 0.281, 0.280], [0.249, 0.059, 0.056], [0.035, 0.034, 0.144], [0.039, 0.037, 0.090], [0.100, 0.096, 0.100], [0.029, 0.022, 0.019], [0.018, 0.019, 0.020], [0.015, 0.016, 0.013] +[0.003, 0.002, 0.003], [1.907, 0.016, 0.015], [0.044, 0.043, 0.043], [1.680, 1.079, 0.051], [0.408, 0.338, 0.343], [0.667, 0.455, 0.598], [0.392, 0.016, 0.015], [0.959, 0.030, 0.023], [0.802, 0.620, 0.635], [1.025, 0.677, 0.721], [0.283, 0.169, 0.167], [0.189, 0.306, 0.347], [0.763, 0.589, 0.596], [0.839, 0.864, 0.862], [0.811, 0.806, 1.067], [0.343, 0.304, 0.295], [1.509, 1.448, 1.318], [0.857, 0.958, 1.008], [3.716, 3.227, 2.607], [0.043, 0.215, 0.022], [0.688, 2.667, 0.593], [1.856, 0.724, 0.765], [3.046, 2.148, 0.936], [2.534, 2.636, 7.535], [0.259, 0.256, 0.230], [0.197, 0.182, 0.206], [0.258, 0.245, 0.241], [0.815, 0.737, 0.650], [6.054, 8.526, 6.155], [0.052, 0.042, 0.190], [0.841, 0.572, 0.539], [1.460, 0.851, 0.898], [3.037, 3.075, 2.508], [2.825, 2.655, 2.468], [2.577, 2.655, 2.575], [0.351, 0.341, 0.298], [0.191, 0.052, 0.051], [0.055, 0.030, 0.031], [0.049, 0.035, 0.032], [0.108, 0.084, 0.256], [0.027, 0.026, 0.267], [0.018, 0.018, 0.199], [0.016, 0.014, 0.013] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json index b269c4306..0a8ff647d 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.24GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "24GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "gcp"], - "load_time": 1090.721, + "load_time": 1084.825, "data_size": 9946973751, "result": [ -[0.002, 0.003, 0.002], [1.747, 1.536, 0.024], [1.044, 0.170, 0.673], [0.528, 1.987, 0.388], [1.837, 1.933, 3.324], [4.835, 4.881, 4.182], [0.043, 0.164, 0.043], [0.071, 0.036, 0.053], [3.540, 2.583, 3.447], [2.458, 2.627, 4.347], [0.873, 0.740, 0.665], [1.109, 0.872, 0.859], [3.141, 3.076, 3.100], [5.283, 5.282, 4.797], [4.481, 4.302, 4.541], [2.692, 2.456, 2.579], [11.985, 10.705, 10.056], [7.481, 7.148, 7.591], [32.080, 29.576, 32.206], [0.074, 0.074, 0.074], [4.842, 19.377, 4.631], [4.777, 4.837, 4.775], [7.558, 22.568, 7.368], [87.719, 20.814, 19.871], [1.671, 1.408, 1.387], [0.990, 1.018, 1.025], [1.425, 1.394, 1.450], [4.521, 4.736, 4.529], [48.410, 49.431, 47.607], [0.172, 0.171, 0.156], [3.181, 2.982, 2.905], [4.649, 4.494, 3.660], [45.040, 35.716, 35.281], [26.633, 27.195, 27.438], [26.061, 29.874, 26.537], [1.720, 1.713, 1.686], [0.169, 0.320, 0.172], [0.055, 0.058, 0.051], [0.076, 0.064, 0.062], [0.383, 0.326, 0.362], [0.041, 0.042, 0.326], [0.022, 0.024, 0.018], [0.019, 0.025, 0.021] +[0.003, 0.003, 0.003], [1.587, 0.029, 0.988], [0.254, 1.112, 0.189], [2.013, 0.476, 0.409], [2.077, 2.208, 2.146], [3.988, 4.915, 4.275], [0.167, 0.058, 0.082], [0.037, 0.036, 0.036], [2.727, 3.597, 2.269], [3.204, 3.015, 2.479], [0.863, 0.807, 0.650], [1.179, 1.047, 0.988], [3.755, 2.933, 3.769], [6.186, 4.970, 5.813], [4.520, 4.903, 4.460], [2.962, 2.337, 2.596], [11.151, 12.580, 12.367], [7.277, 8.297, 7.690], [30.384, 30.745, 40.963], [0.077, 0.075, 0.074], [4.787, 19.307, 20.855], [4.888, 4.867, 4.782], [22.058, 7.047, 7.189], [62.169, 76.400, 24.663], [1.570, 1.394, 1.521], [0.995, 1.205, 1.298], [1.345, 1.821, 1.355], [4.371, 4.341, 5.424], [48.377, 47.768, 47.778], [0.194, 0.178, 0.154], [3.035, 3.011, 2.882], [4.747, 4.719, 3.340], [48.150, 43.123, 35.099], [33.636, 39.365, 27.526], [34.620, 25.561, 26.585], [1.825, 1.743, 1.704], [0.212, 0.162, 0.171], [0.080, 0.059, 0.080], [0.071, 0.064, 0.056], [0.332, 0.369, 0.350], [0.036, 0.036, 0.041], [0.024, 0.021, 0.020], [0.020, 0.018, 0.028] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json index e2a0aab9a..e693b8b35 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.360GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "360GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "gcp"], - "load_time": 223.374, - "data_size": 9943933881, + "load_time": 206.074, + "data_size": 9943970501, "result": [ -[0.004, 0.003, 0.003], [0.042, 0.018, 1.749], [0.040, 1.213, 0.336], [0.048, 1.851, 0.047], [1.160, 0.240, 0.285], [0.383, 0.819, 0.726], [0.385, 0.196, 0.028], [0.118, 0.022, 0.021], [0.476, 0.447, 0.691], [0.511, 0.518, 0.575], [0.362, 0.264, 0.179], [0.415, 0.174, 0.176], [0.439, 0.457, 0.441], [0.617, 0.659, 0.602], [0.638, 0.659, 0.532], [0.359, 0.317, 0.241], [1.066, 1.107, 1.054], [0.575, 0.644, 0.642], [1.691, 2.104, 1.978], [0.264, 0.024, 0.024], [1.613, 0.426, 0.461], [0.478, 0.505, 0.625], [0.693, 2.547, 1.294], [4.654, 1.547, 1.681], [0.208, 0.193, 0.254], [0.152, 0.142, 0.147], [0.191, 0.187, 0.191], [0.587, 0.509, 0.489], [4.734, 5.818, 4.733], [0.039, 0.038, 0.038], [0.476, 0.465, 0.448], [1.115, 0.617, 0.561], [2.620, 2.488, 2.330], [1.973, 2.045, 1.664], [1.657, 1.843, 1.786], [0.302, 0.340, 0.193], [0.069, 0.055, 0.049], [0.151, 0.029, 0.032], [0.031, 0.147, 0.037], [0.276, 0.095, 0.086], [0.019, 0.024, 0.022], [0.019, 0.020, 0.017], [0.013, 0.014, 0.015] +[0.004, 0.004, 0.003], [1.947, 0.019, 0.020], [0.564, 0.038, 0.034], [0.048, 1.857, 0.140], [1.108, 0.320, 0.244], [0.480, 0.400, 1.203], [0.362, 0.021, 0.019], [0.143, 0.024, 0.020], [0.501, 0.689, 0.609], [0.774, 0.594, 0.531], [0.183, 0.322, 0.175], [0.430, 0.192, 0.189], [0.511, 0.514, 0.489], [0.588, 0.587, 0.699], [0.714, 0.501, 0.850], [0.402, 0.288, 0.411], [1.132, 0.780, 1.147], [0.667, 0.561, 0.626], [2.646, 1.967, 2.045], [0.023, 0.019, 0.038], [1.939, 0.965, 0.426], [1.320, 0.504, 0.478], [1.821, 1.237, 0.645], [1.853, 4.677, 3.598], [0.276, 0.205, 0.213], [0.152, 0.163, 0.167], [0.207, 0.204, 0.204], [0.461, 0.538, 0.506], [4.385, 4.234, 4.009], [0.042, 0.042, 0.042], [0.503, 0.469, 0.522], [0.663, 0.616, 0.716], [2.902, 2.012, 2.451], [1.568, 1.987, 1.800], [1.664, 1.566, 1.777], [0.270, 0.340, 0.246], [0.053, 0.047, 0.049], [0.031, 0.033, 0.031], [0.039, 0.036, 0.053], [0.093, 0.094, 0.099], [0.024, 0.023, 0.029], [0.019, 0.023, 0.022], [0.016, 0.016, 0.013] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json index d974376a7..3c6b2edd9 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.48GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "48GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "gcp"], - "load_time": 358.833, - "data_size": 9941624441, + "load_time": 366.423, + "data_size": 9942008100, "result": [ -[0.002, 0.003, 0.003], [3.348, 1.259, 0.136], [0.597, 0.129, 0.116], [0.155, 1.962, 1.224], [0.766, 0.805, 0.681], [1.529, 1.440, 1.682], [0.362, 0.259, 0.029], [0.142, 0.025, 0.025], [1.219, 0.973, 1.421], [1.561, 1.023, 1.762], [0.478, 0.409, 0.343], [0.527, 0.452, 0.517], [1.443, 1.459, 1.324], [2.077, 2.110, 2.035], [1.974, 1.728, 1.925], [1.533, 1.117, 0.931], [4.329, 4.167, 5.879], [2.877, 2.818, 3.447], [9.944, 9.129, 7.739], [0.040, 0.038, 0.040], [7.699, 2.283, 5.918], [2.355, 2.395, 2.364], [9.041, 6.355, 2.935], [22.886, 6.576, 23.234], [0.694, 0.597, 0.711], [0.434, 0.453, 0.477], [0.670, 0.567, 0.576], [2.104, 1.882, 1.826], [19.933, 19.917, 19.342], [0.092, 0.083, 0.089], [1.348, 1.380, 1.652], [2.955, 2.082, 2.133], [15.470, 16.556, 15.377], [7.132, 7.216, 12.883], [7.034, 6.857, 7.033], [1.154, 0.747, 1.011], [0.570, 0.156, 0.273], [0.388, 0.055, 0.064], [0.205, 0.048, 0.053], [0.485, 0.258, 0.249], [0.032, 0.026, 0.350], [0.220, 0.018, 0.017], [0.183, 0.020, 0.165] +[0.003, 0.002, 0.002], [1.979, 0.020, 0.019], [0.540, 0.080, 0.157], [0.203, 1.942, 1.468], [1.092, 0.860, 0.730], [2.226, 1.529, 1.671], [0.027, 0.343, 0.027], [0.142, 0.030, 0.025], [1.432, 1.258, 1.117], [1.548, 1.402, 1.345], [0.417, 0.489, 0.326], [0.436, 0.427, 0.414], [1.640, 1.755, 1.398], [1.976, 2.604, 2.081], [1.985, 1.737, 1.820], [1.196, 0.963, 1.042], [5.974, 5.019, 3.884], [3.189, 2.654, 2.931], [11.319, 10.401, 8.990], [0.043, 0.040, 0.040], [7.645, 1.941, 2.120], [2.065, 6.601, 1.901], [8.511, 3.486, 3.646], [9.020, 26.349, 21.325], [0.653, 0.754, 0.592], [0.407, 0.507, 0.415], [0.563, 0.684, 0.705], [1.803, 1.825, 1.872], [19.498, 19.411, 19.097], [0.090, 0.087, 0.085], [1.426, 1.273, 1.306], [3.172, 2.120, 2.070], [17.030, 15.670, 13.522], [7.466, 9.477, 7.017], [7.559, 7.466, 12.130], [0.896, 1.235, 0.804], [0.313, 0.121, 0.123], [0.388, 0.055, 0.062], [0.238, 0.131, 0.067], [0.503, 0.459, 0.280], [0.315, 0.032, 0.028], [0.213, 0.025, 0.017], [0.198, 0.135, 0.018] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json index 560b6303d..278200332 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.708GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "708GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "gcp"], - "load_time": 196.815, - "data_size": 9943970501, + "load_time": 238.148, + "data_size": 9944483054, "result": [ -[0.004, 0.004, 0.004], [1.107, 0.022, 0.022], [0.423, 0.039, 0.034], [0.847, 0.147, 0.036], [0.222, 0.241, 0.887], [0.255, 0.241, 0.245], [0.020, 0.021, 0.279], [0.577, 0.023, 0.024], [0.597, 0.559, 0.406], [0.539, 0.462, 0.626], [0.350, 0.302, 0.162], [0.151, 0.147, 0.141], [0.315, 0.618, 0.475], [0.413, 0.361, 0.355], [0.513, 0.315, 0.297], [0.188, 0.177, 0.214], [0.825, 0.797, 1.067], [0.603, 0.571, 0.507], [1.827, 1.494, 1.206], [0.182, 0.021, 0.020], [0.329, 1.138, 0.328], [0.376, 0.353, 0.362], [1.109, 1.222, 0.571], [1.309, 4.063, 1.888], [0.434, 0.152, 0.142], [0.119, 0.119, 0.127], [0.124, 0.136, 0.135], [0.423, 0.424, 0.440], [3.700, 3.812, 3.340], [0.046, 0.042, 0.040], [0.520, 0.280, 0.281], [0.388, 0.749, 0.372], [1.895, 1.862, 1.653], [1.725, 1.478, 1.643], [1.398, 1.188, 1.220], [0.152, 0.221, 0.176], [0.048, 0.049, 0.205], [0.030, 0.029, 0.029], [0.031, 0.031, 0.028], [0.088, 0.276, 0.075], [0.361, 0.028, 0.024], [0.194, 0.021, 0.019], [0.014, 0.014, 0.013] +[0.004, 0.004, 0.004], [0.025, 0.023, 1.346], [0.034, 0.956, 0.391], [1.067, 0.178, 0.035], [0.240, 0.223, 0.184], [0.275, 0.572, 0.260], [0.292, 0.589, 0.021], [0.025, 0.162, 0.026], [0.604, 0.440, 0.399], [0.422, 0.421, 0.759], [0.368, 0.288, 0.150], [0.282, 0.325, 0.139], [0.302, 0.762, 0.363], [0.386, 0.364, 0.461], [0.512, 0.306, 0.346], [0.189, 0.206, 0.220], [0.695, 0.829, 0.692], [0.651, 0.538, 0.505], [1.866, 1.100, 1.950], [0.024, 0.053, 0.022], [1.041, 1.009, 0.325], [0.358, 0.369, 0.363], [0.571, 0.530, 1.242], [3.608, 1.543, 2.968], [0.318, 0.137, 0.129], [0.100, 0.114, 0.108], [0.141, 0.137, 0.123], [0.655, 0.420, 0.399], [3.428, 3.226, 3.292], [0.041, 0.040, 0.240], [0.430, 0.287, 0.312], [0.442, 0.352, 0.588], [1.984, 1.886, 1.868], [1.228, 1.172, 1.149], [1.548, 1.224, 1.133], [0.138, 0.171, 0.144], [0.062, 0.050, 0.061], [0.043, 0.028, 0.034], [0.034, 0.034, 0.041], [0.091, 0.076, 0.078], [0.021, 0.024, 0.020], [0.018, 0.021, 0.018], [0.015, 0.015, 0.015] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json index b5fe7d805..c8de9cb5e 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.96GB.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "96GB", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "gcp"], - "load_time": 229.945, - "data_size": 9943970501, + "load_time": 253.568, + "data_size": 9943671346, "result": [ -[0.003, 0.002, 0.003], [0.018, 1.786, 0.953], [0.632, 0.067, 0.338], [1.699, 0.075, 0.171], [0.701, 0.573, 0.475], [1.019, 1.018, 0.732], [0.022, 0.863, 0.273], [0.093, 0.061, 0.020], [1.093, 0.693, 0.746], [0.801, 1.054, 0.999], [0.431, 0.254, 0.344], [0.447, 0.334, 0.382], [0.884, 0.884, 0.838], [1.316, 1.362, 1.346], [1.202, 1.309, 0.986], [0.938, 0.893, 0.677], [2.722, 2.967, 2.666], [1.988, 1.588, 1.641], [5.573, 5.538, 5.260], [0.029, 0.030, 0.025], [1.361, 5.068, 1.134], [1.250, 1.396, 3.721], [5.774, 1.780, 2.015], [15.930, 4.081, 4.931], [0.811, 0.382, 0.421], [0.305, 0.338, 0.326], [0.389, 0.357, 0.368], [1.326, 1.327, 1.319], [13.472, 13.612, 11.754], [0.063, 0.068, 0.061], [0.859, 0.941, 1.197], [2.508, 1.029, 1.169], [5.096, 4.097, 3.730], [4.211, 4.301, 4.474], [4.460, 4.493, 4.276], [0.434, 0.535, 0.406], [0.072, 0.218, 0.123], [0.037, 0.037, 0.039], [0.031, 0.040, 0.185], [0.124, 0.112, 0.116], [0.020, 0.021, 0.018], [0.014, 0.310, 0.016], [0.015, 0.014, 0.014] +[0.003, 0.003, 0.003], [0.024, 0.030, 1.818], [1.349, 0.067, 0.062], [1.837, 0.084, 0.084], [0.566, 0.490, 0.760], [0.999, 1.079, 1.197], [1.129, 0.227, 0.019], [0.099, 0.022, 0.023], [0.987, 0.902, 0.610], [1.173, 1.354, 1.276], [0.396, 0.325, 0.333], [0.457, 0.303, 0.315], [1.036, 0.751, 0.964], [1.388, 1.571, 1.293], [1.393, 1.335, 1.065], [0.923, 0.693, 0.689], [2.709, 3.255, 3.183], [1.854, 1.536, 2.381], [5.716, 6.454, 5.897], [0.031, 0.027, 0.027], [5.080, 3.305, 1.160], [1.261, 1.231, 1.496], [5.606, 1.758, 1.761], [16.383, 5.214, 4.165], [0.463, 0.439, 0.388], [0.277, 0.349, 0.324], [0.382, 0.371, 0.380], [1.263, 1.189, 1.244], [14.048, 14.094, 12.186], [0.267, 0.059, 0.063], [1.308, 1.008, 0.920], [2.284, 1.290, 1.117], [4.947, 3.880, 3.667], [5.421, 4.460, 4.241], [5.451, 5.522, 4.223], [0.593, 0.487, 0.509], [0.076, 0.053, 0.187], [0.030, 0.042, 0.031], [0.136, 0.031, 0.030], [0.107, 0.358, 0.115], [0.023, 0.025, 0.018], [0.261, 0.016, 0.018], [0.014, 0.015, 0.013] ] } diff --git a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json index 16eae977b..7f66232ff 100644 --- a/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json +++ b/clickhouse-cloud/results/gcp.dev.json @@ -1,18 +1,18 @@ { "system": "ClickHouse Cloud (gcp)", - "date": "2024-11-03", + "date": "2024-11-04", "machine": "dev", "cluster_size": "serverless", "comment": "", "tags": ["C++", "column-oriented", "ClickHouse derivative", "managed", "gcp"], - "load_time": 817.182, - "data_size": 9949203591, + "load_time": 616.125, + "data_size": 9945574505, "result": [ -[0.002, 0.008, 0.003], [0.050, 0.032, 0.054], [0.330, 0.131, 0.128], [0.185, 0.145, 0.394], [2.757, 1.195, 2.969], [4.550, 4.390, 1.771], [0.064, 0.042, 0.035], [0.099, 0.029, 0.031], [1.446, 1.315, 4.398], [4.495, 4.300, 1.576], [0.482, 1.249, 1.185], [1.533, 1.212, 1.131], [5.788, 4.545, 3.937], [6.821, 6.445, 3.016], [4.912, 2.191, 2.098], [1.346, 2.834, 2.566], [13.890, 8.586, 33.569], [6.259, 5.703, 4.115], [30.163, 29.405, 19.781], [0.057, 0.072, 0.081], [2.904, 2.867, 4.126], [2.998, 3.185, 3.747], [5.896, 4.355, 5.676], [11.675, 10.343, 14.963], [0.967, 1.165, 1.125], [0.750, 0.818, 0.902], [1.232, 1.158, 1.196], [2.893, 3.352, 3.338], [33.255, 29.373, 32.812], [0.166, 0.123, 0.101], [1.734, 1.589, 1.557], [4.851, 2.921, 3.860], [20.402, 21.615, 18.049], [16.778, 15.914, 28.304], [17.624, 16.310, 16.093], [2.191, 1.563, 1.319], [0.128, 0.243, 0.163], [0.111, 0.140, 0.066], [0.079, 0.062, 0.066], [0.348, 0.317, 0.269], [0.033, 0.069, 0.041], [0.024, 0.033, 0.021], [0.020, 0.021, 0.049] +[0.003, 0.003, 0.003], [0.024, 0.023, 0.017], [0.236, 0.184, 0.218], [0.212, 0.296, 0.241], [1.215, 2.120, 1.854], [3.114, 3.177, 1.454], [0.039, 0.046, 0.340], [0.066, 0.031, 0.031], [1.204, 1.138, 2.630], [1.486, 1.323, 1.303], [0.747, 0.769, 0.445], [0.548, 0.544, 1.043], [1.670, 1.561, 1.555], [2.686, 5.649, 2.692], [3.476, 3.009, 3.071], [1.959, 2.237, 1.275], [8.853, 7.765, 5.452], [3.503, 5.920, 3.477], [27.573, 16.040, 18.008], [0.599, 0.075, 0.055], [8.253, 3.114, 3.958], [4.106, 3.079, 3.242], [3.698, 4.809, 4.502], [10.889, 13.240, 9.464], [1.124, 1.146, 0.808], [0.527, 0.509, 0.621], [0.704, 0.709, 0.892], [2.362, 3.069, 2.503], [30.793, 25.191, 34.295], [0.090, 0.123, 0.121], [1.737, 1.668, 1.390], [2.978, 2.255, 2.055], [19.484, 18.672, 20.285], [14.609, 17.987, 14.919], [14.448, 14.145, 13.941], [1.033, 1.276, 1.017], [0.136, 0.139, 0.146], [0.059, 0.053, 0.068], [0.062, 0.074, 0.049], [0.268, 0.305, 0.317], [0.032, 0.043, 0.025], [0.022, 0.018, 0.024], [0.020, 0.015, 0.017] ] }